History YMMV / LlamasWithHats

* ArchiveBinge: Thanks to the episodes' short length (3-4 minutes on average), [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJOwdrTA8Gw watching all twelve will take you less than twenty minutes]].

* HilariousInHindsight

* DarthWiki/MostAnnoyingSound: The Mask's yelling grinds your ears.

* MostAnnoyingSound: The Mask's yelling grinds your ears.

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Many people, including ''Carl himself'', thought Paul was a woman. Mostly the hat.

* SignatureScene
** The very first episode.
** [[spoiler:Carl jumping off of the bridge at the very end of the series.]]

* MemeticMutation: Second only to ''WebAnimation/CharlieTheUnicorn'', this is easily Creator/FilmCow's most quoted show.
** "Caaaaaarrrrlllll, that kills people!"
** "My stomach was makin' the rumblies, that only hands would satisfy."
** "I will not apologize for art."
** "That is what forgiveness sounds like: screaming and then silence."
** "Probably because I'm a dangerous sociopath with a long history of violence. I ''don't'' understand how you keep forgetting that."
** "Whitey's gotta pay. And the payment is baby hands."
** "I'm the Henry Ford of human meat."
** "Bad idea, Nikolai!"
** "That's probably the basilisk. It won't bother us. The stupid thing only eats ''Chipotle''!"
** "You remember the Blood Vortex, in Paris? Yeah. That was my favorite..."
** It's a popular practice to have characters from other media reenacting scenes from the series in their own varied ways.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: From episode 2: "That is what forgiveness sounds like. Screaming and then silence." At the end of the series, Carl, having [[ApocalypseHow killed everyone on earth, including Paul at some point,]] [[DrivenToSuicide jumps from an overpass,]] screaming like Paul used to to his death, leaving behind silence...

* FunnyAneurysmMoment:
** From episode 2: "That is what forgiveness sounds like. Screaming and then silence." At the end of the series, Carl, having [[ApocalypseHow killed everyone on earth, including Paul at some point,]] [[DrivenToSuicide jumps from an overpass,]] screaming like Paul used to to his death, leaving behind silence...

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Does Carl actually ''enjoy'' the atrocities he commits, or does he just do them to [[AttentionWhore make Paul keep paying attention to him]]? The second half of the series strongly implies that the latter is true, especially considering that Carl "finishing his work" may have been [[spoiler:blowing up the Earth (which would have ended his life too, while not contradicting the WordOfGod, and guaranteed that no aquatic or underground life survived). Seeing Paul dead could have ended his desire to truly finish his work, causing him to just take his own life.]]

** Carl isn't the only unhinged violent psychopathic llama out there. Season 3 of ''Anime/{{Aggretsuko}}'' introduces one who, unlike Carl, is most definitely '''[[KnightOfCerebus not]]''' played for laughs.

* ArchiveBinge: Thanks to the episodes' short length (3-4 minutes on average), [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJOwdrTA8Gw watching all twelves will take you less than twenty minutes]].

* CreepyAwesome: Carl is a dangerous sociopath with a long history of violence, but how many villains have successfully managed to [[spoiler:[[OmnicidalManiac destroy all life on Earth.]]]] ''On purpose,'' no less! Plus, while [[CardCarryingVillain it just further illustrates Carl's horribleness]], you've got to admit: [[spoiler:[[CallBack the Meat Dragon]]]] is actually pretty cool.

* FirstInstallmentWins: The first four episodes are some of the most quoted videos in the entire history of web-based entertainment. The post-revival one, while loved in their own right for their sharp dramatic turn, are nowhere near as popular.

* TheWoobie: Poor Paul. His best friend turns out to be a violent, unstoppable sociopath and he bears witness to all of the traumatizing horrors Carl enacts. You just can't help but feel like he needs a hug for all he's been through.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: From episode 2: "That is what forgiveness sounds like. Screaming and then silence." At the end of the series, Carl, having [[ApocalypseHow killed everyone on earth, including Paul at some point,]] [[DrivenToSuicide jumps from an overpass,]] screaming like Paul used to to his death, leaving behind silence...

* ArchiveBinge: Thanks to the episodes' short length (3-4 minutes on average), [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJOwdrTA8Gw watching the entire series takes less than twenty minutes]].

* [[CrossesTheLineTwice Crosses The Line So Many Times It Pretty Much Doesn't Exist Any More]]: ''Everything'' Carl does, at least until he draws a new line purely for the sake of crossing it again. The series ''itself'' crosses it a third time by the halfway point, going from BlackComedy to straight psychodrama.
* FanNickname: Some fans of the series took the liberty to name the Meat Dragon that Carl made in episode 6 "Paulina".

* FanNickname: Fans of the series took the liberty to name the Meat Dragon that Carl made in episode 6 "Paulina".

* MostAnnoyingSound: Paul's constant whining of [[SayMyName "Carl!"]] can get irritating very quickly, especially after everyone started [[MemeticMutation quoting it in real life]].