History YMMV / ALoudHouseChristmas

* UncannyValley: Mr. Coconuts, big time. It retains its cartoonish design from the original series, which looks completely distanced from the now live-action cast.

* IdiotPlot: Everyone legitimately thought the sharkodile was an actual living thing, even though it looked clearly plastic.

* UncannyValley: Luan's puppet, Mr. Coconuts, was already a bit off-putting to most fans in the cartoon, but seeing him in live-action turned this feeling UpToEleven. It doesn't help that Luan's carrying him through a majority of the movie.

** Lucy's BlindingBangs don't look very convincing. While it's obviously a wig the actress is wearing, it's a bit hard to think of it as her real hair for the character she's playing, feeling more like a cosplay prop.

''YMMV/TheCasagrandes'' | ''YMMV/TheLoudHouseMovie'' | ''YMMV/ALoudHouseChristmas''-]]]]]

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that this is a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] movie already turned off a large portion of the ''The Loud House'' fandom from the start, with some believing that Creator/{{Nickelodeon}} didn't learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy, but it has mainly received this treatment due to the way it portrays how Lincoln is more than willing to sabotage his Family's plans on Christmas so they can keep the traditions he likes. The methods he goes to sabotage his family include...

* FanficFuel: Luna and Sam's [[spoiler:breakup and getting back together]] is not shown, so there have been some fanfics already depicting what could have happened off-screen. Some also write about their skiing trip as well.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that this is a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Creator/{{Nickelodeon}} didn't learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy, but it has mainly received this treatment due to the way it portrays how Lincoln is more than willing to sabotage his Family's plans on Christmas so they can keep the traditions he likes. The methods he goes to sabotage his family include...

* FanficFuel: Luna and Sam's breakup and getting back together is not shown, so there have been some fanfics already depicting what could have happened off-screen. Some also write about their skiing trip as well.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that this is a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Creator/{{Nickelodeon}} didn't learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy, but it has mainly received this treatment due to the way it portrays how Lincoln is more than willing to sabotage his Family's plans on Christmas so they can keep the traditions he likes. The methods he goes to sabotage his family include...

** Tricking Luna into thinking she won a recording session with Mick Swagger to draw her away from a skiing trip with Sam, which in turn causes Sam to break up with her (though they do get back together at the end and still go skiing);
** And stealing Tanya to film the Sharkodile attack video, which gets Leni fired.
** Then Scoots spots the Sharkodile and reports it to the news, causing the town to go on curfew and cancelling the Christmas tree lighting at the mall, which was the event Lincoln wanted his family to be at in the first place...
** ...Followed up by him causing massive property damage when bringing the Sharkodile to the mall to explain it is fake.
** And to top it off, despite having 300 hours of community service, Lincoln is instantly forgiven and gets to have Christmas with his family.

** Then Scoots spots the Sharkodile and reports it to the news, causing the town to go on curfew and cancelling the Christmas tree lighting at the mall, which was the event he wanted his family to be at in the first place...

** And to top it off, despite having 300 hours of community service, he is instantly forgiven and gets to have Christmas with his family.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: While Leni and Luan got screwed over by situations beyond their control, and Lori just got sentimental, Luna still had a choice in the matter when she was duped into thinking that Mick Swagger was coming to town (i.e. she still could’ve chosen Sam over Mick). She comes off as completely oblivious, almost insensitively so, when she calls off the trip with Sam, who is clearly hurt by her decision. ''And'' she’s met Mick Swagger before. As such, it’s not hard to side with Sam when she’s angry with Luna and breaks up with her (though they get back together at the end).

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that this is a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Creator/{{Nickelodeon}} didn't learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy, but it has mainly received this treatment from fans due to the way the movie portrays how Lincoln is more than willing to sabotage his Family's plans on Christmas so they can keep the traditions he likes. The methods he goes to sabotage his family include: setting up mean pranks at Sunset Canyon to get them to cancel Luan's comedy gig, tricking Luna into thinking she won a recording session with Mick Swagger to draw her away from a skiing trip with Sam, which in turn causes Sam to break up with her (though they do get back together at the end and still go skiing), and stealing Tanya to film the Sharkodile attack video, which gets Leni fired. Then Scoots spots the Sharkodile and reports it to the news causing the town to go on curfew and cancelling the Christmas tree lighting at the mall, which was the event he wanted his family to be at in the first place. Followed up by him causing massive property damage when bringing the Sharkodile to the mall to explain it is fake. And to top it off, despite having 300 hours of community service, he is instantly forgiven and gets to have Christmas with his family.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] ''Loud House'' movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy, but it has mainly received this treatment from fans due to the way the movie portrays how Lincoln is more than willing to sabotage his Family's plans on Christmas so they can keep the traditions he likes. The methods he goes to sabotage his family include: setting up mean pranks at Sunset Canyon to get them to cancel Luan's comedy gig, tricking Luna into thinking she won a recording session with Mick Swagger to draw her away from a skiing trip with Sam, which in turn causes Sam to break up with her (though they do get back together at the end and still go skiing), and stealing Tanya to film the Sharkodile attack video, which gets Leni fired. Then Scoots spots the Sharkodile and reports it to the news causing the town to go on curfew and cancelling the Christmas tree lighting at the mall, which was the event he wanted his family to be at in the first place. Followed up by him causing massive property damage when bringing the Sharkodile to the mall to explain it is fake. And to top it off, despite having 300 hours of community service, he is instantly forgiven and gets to have Christmas with his family.

* FanficFuel: Luna and Sam's breakup and getting back together is not shown, so there have been some fanfics already depicting what could have happened off screen. Some also write about their skiing trip as well.
* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] ''Loud House'' movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk, and it's clear to see why many ''Loud House'' fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: One of the criticism of the movie is that, while it stick close to the cartoon by focusing on a scheme of Lincoln's, most fans were disappointed that the Loud sisters feel a little lacking in this one and there isn't much focus to them other then having their plans ruined and their reaction to Lincoln's deceit as well as the usual forgiveness. Especially since this is the series first live action movie.

* FanFicFuel: Luna and Sam's breakup and getting back together is not shown, so there have been some fanfics already depicting what could have happened off screen. Some also write about their skiing trip as well.

* ContinuityLockout: Slightly, the film tries to be accessible to newcomers but it does seem to assume you've watched the show and know of the, at the time, status quo such as Luna dating Sam and Lori away from home at college.

** Lucy's BlindingBangs don't look very convincing. While it's obviously a wig the actress is wearing, it's a bit hard to think of it as her real hair for the character she's playing, feeling more like a cos-play prop.

* UncannyValley: Luan's puppet, Mr. Coconuts, was already a bit off-putting to most fans in the cartoon, but seeing him in live-action turned this feeling UpToEleven. It doesn't help that Luann's carrying him through a majority of the movie.

* ContinuityLockout: Slightly, the film tries to be accessible to newcomers bu it does seem to assume you've watched the show and know of the, at the time, status quo such as Luna dating Sam and Lori away from home at college.

* ContinuityLockout: Slightly, the film tries to accessible to newcomers but the it does seem to assume you've watched the show and know of the, at the time, status quo such as Luna dating Sam and Lori away from home at college.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: One of the criticism of the movie is that, while it stick close to the cartoon by focusing on a scheme of Lincoln's, most fans were disapointed that the Loud sisters feel a little lacking in this one and there isn't much focus to them other then having their plans ruined and their reaction to Lincoln's deceit as well as the usual forgiveness. Especially since this is the series first live action movie.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Most fans even feel the plot would've worked better in the cartoon where the continuity is stronger rather then live action and rather a plot that would've been more stand-alone to get new fans onboard.

* UncannyValley: Luan's puppet, Mr. Coconuts, was already a bit off-putting to most fans in the cartoon, but seeing him in live-action turned this feeling UpToEleven.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] ''Loud House'' movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk, and it's clear to see why many ''Loud House'' fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

* UncannyValley: Luan's puppet, Mr. Coconut, was already a bit off-putting to most fans in the cartoon, but seeing it recreated and being used by her for live-action turned this feeling UpToEleven.

* BrokenBase: The fact that it's a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] ''Loud House'' movie already caused controversy among the fandom from the start, with its detractors believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as a WellIntentionedExtremist, and it's clear to see why many ''Loud House'' fans [[FanonDiscontinuity would rather pretend this special never existed]].