Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E17MadeInManehattan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NamesTheSame: Charity Kindheart shares her first name with Charity Sweetmint, Rarity's apprentice from the book ''Literature/RarityAndTheCuriousCaseOfCharity''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Jossed is a YMMV Definition Only Page now. Deleting examples, fan theories that are in objective pages - they need to go on YMMV pages - and moving these about a specific fan work to Outdated By Canon


* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as the Season 4 episode "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E17SomeponyToWatchOverMe Somepony to Watch Over Me]]" shows that Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet stocked with replacement hats and bows. Until [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS7E13ThePerfectPear "The Perfect Pear"]] came around and showed that her father in fact had an identical hat, putting the theory into ShrugOfGod territory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutOfOrder: It's scheduled to be the 16th episode of season 5, despite being 17th in the production order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as the Season 4 episode "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E17SomeponyToWatchOverMe Somepony to Watch Over Me]]" shows that Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet stocked with replacement hats and bows.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as the Season 4 episode "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E17SomeponyToWatchOverMe Somepony to Watch Over Me]]" shows that Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet stocked with replacement hats and bows. Until [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS7E13ThePerfectPear "The Perfect Pear"]] came around and showed that her father in fact had an identical hat, putting the theory into ShrugOfGod territory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NamesTheSame: Charity Kindheart shares her first name with Charity Sweetmint, Rarity's apprentice from the book ''Literature/RarityAndTheCuriousCaseOfCharity''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as the Season 4 episode "Somepony to Watch Over Me" shows that Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet stocked with replacement hats and bows.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as the Season 4 episode "Somepony "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E17SomeponyToWatchOverMe Somepony to Watch Over Me" Me]]" shows that Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet stocked with replacement hats and bows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as there was an episode that showed a whole closet filled with hats and bows.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as there was an the Season 4 episode "Somepony to Watch Over Me" shows that showed Applejack and Apple Bloom have a whole closet filled stocked with replacement hats and bows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that. Funny enough this isn't even the first episode to Joss the theory, as there was an episode that showed a whole closet filled with hats and bows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


{{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that.

to:

{{Jossed}}: *{{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

{{Jossed}}: You wouldn't think this episode had much ''to'' Joss, but the abuse and subsequent replacement of Applejack's hat kills the idea seen in many fanworks that it's of great sentimental value. She sure doesn't respond to its damage, or to Rarity throwing it away and getting her an identical one, in the way she would if it were the last thing given to her by her late father or anything like that.
----

Top