Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheSimpsonsS2E15OhBrotherWhereArtThou

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.

to:

* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't doesn't seem to care about the other two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouGetMeCoffee: After Herb puts him in charge of designing a car, Homer (innocently) bugs the technicians with a few questions about the car's blueprints. The head technician responds by calmly-but-condescendingly asking Homer to go get everyone coffee.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArsonMurderJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.

to:

* ArsonMurderJaywalking: ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArsonMuderJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.

to:

* ArsonMuderJaywalking: ArsonMurderJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArsonMuderJaywalking: Abe and Jasper's complaints to the movie theater manager involve a small screen, a sticky floor, and a tacked-on romantic subplot. Obviously, the theater manager can't do anything about that third item and he don't seem to care about the other two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ViewersAreMorons: Also, another InUniverse example regarding the Powell Motors executives. When Homer makes requests for a car (after Herb offers him a free one) the executives shoot him down by saying things like "Americans don't want X" or "Americans want Y, not X". Once again, Herb [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech sternly calls out]] the executives.
-->'''Herb:''' Homer, tell the nice man what country you come from.
-->'''Homer:''' (indignant) America!
-->'''Herb:''' (to the executies) [[SuddenlyShouting DO YOU HEAR THAT, YA MORONS?!]] This is why we're getting killed in the marketplace! Instead of listening to what they want; you're telling them what they want!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObliviousToHints: Homer fails to pick up on the orphanage manager’s hints that his brother is in Detroit and only picks up the answer straight after paying the man 20 bucks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ViewersAreGeniuses: An InUniverse example occurs when Herb's design team suggests the name [[Myth/ClassicalMythology "Persephone"]] for a new car. A reference to a rather obscure Greek Mythology character ''might'' go over the heads of a typical, ordinary person who isn't familiar with the said mythology (and even for those who ''are'' familiar, Persephone is a bit of a stretch). Herb understandably and not-so-subtly calls them out on this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverMyFault: Herb blames Homer for ruining his company despite putting him in charge, shelving all other projects and outright ignoring his employees' warnings, who despite being 'Havard dead-heads' as he put it still know enough about business to be on the board of a car company.

to:

* NeverMyFault: Herb blames Homer for ruining his company despite putting him in charge, shelving all other projects and projects, outright ignoring his employees' warnings, who despite being 'Havard dead-heads' as he put it still know enough about business to be on the board of a car company.company, and apparently living so far outside his means that the moment his company flops he becomes destitute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CouldSayItBut: The orphanage director tries to tell Homer where his brother is in this way. Unfortunately Homer is too dumb to realise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlatantLies: When Herb disowns Homer at the end, Marge tries to comfort him by saying "I'm sure he said it to make conversation".

to:

* BlatantLies: When Herb disowns Homer at the end, Marge tries to comfort him by saying "I'm sure "maybe he just said it that to make conversation".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CassandraTruth: The engineers try to warn Herb that Homer's decisions are counter productive and even harmful to company's well-being, though due to their own ineffectiveness at making good designs themselves, their earlier petty unwillingness to work with Homer, and [[NotHelpingYourCase generally rude way of consulting Herb]], he ignores them.
-->'''Herb:''' Well you know what, I'm ''glad'' you're nervous, [[AntiAdvise cause that means we're on the right track!]]

to:

* CassandraTruth: The engineers try to warn Herb that Homer's decisions are counter productive and even harmful to company's well-being, though due to their own ineffectiveness at making good designs themselves, profitable designs, their earlier petty unwillingness to work with Homer, and [[NotHelpingYourCase generally rude way of consulting Herb]], he ignores them.
-->'''Herb:''' Well you know what, I'm ''glad'' you're nervous, [[AntiAdvise [[AntiAdvice cause that means we're on the right track!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CassandraTruth: The engineers try to warn Herb that Homer's decisions are counter productive and even harmful to company's well-being, though due to their own ineffectiveness at making good designs themselves, their earlier petty unwillingness to work with Homer, and [[NotHelpingYourCase generally rude way of consulting Herb]], he ignores them.
-->'''Herb:''' Well you know what, I'm ''glad'' you're nervous, [[AntiAdvise cause that means we're on the right track!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AreWeThereYet: The TropeNamer. Bart and Lisa annoy Homer with that question during the car ride to Detroit. Marge tells them they'll turn around if they don't stop, Homer complains that he wants to see his brother, an annoyed Marge tells him it was an idle threat.

to:

* AreWeThereYet: The TropeNamer. Bart and Lisa annoy Homer with that question during the car ride to Detroit. Marge tells them they'll turn around if they don't stop, Homer complains that he wants to see his brother, an annoyed Marge tells him it was an idle threat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicFail: Herb asks Homer to help his company design a car for the "average American man". Homer instead designs an '''$82,000''' [[note]]equal to about ''$168,000'' in 2021![[/note]] HummerDinger that gets Herb laughed straight into bankruptcy. Herb didn't really make things easy on himself by 1) believing '''Homer''', with his immense stupidity, could actually represent an "average American" and 2) Herb decided not to listen when the rest of the research team tried to warn him.

to:

* EpicFail: Herb asks Homer to help his company design a car for the "average American man". Homer instead designs an '''$82,000''' [[note]]equal to about ''$168,000'' ''$184,000'' in 2021![[/note]] 2023![[/note]] HummerDinger that gets Herb laughed straight into bankruptcy. Herb didn't really make things easy on himself by 1) believing '''Homer''', with his immense stupidity, could actually represent an "average American" and 2) Herb decided not to listen when the rest of the research team tried to warn him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2022 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75,000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

to:

As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 $184,000 in 2022 2023 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75,000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

Added: 543

Changed: 807

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerEnding: Homer is left heartbroken after a bankrupt Herb disowns him. Some fans were so upset by Herb's downfall that the producers would ultimately do [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS3E24BrotherCanYouSpareTwoDimes "Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes"]] to give Herb a happy ending again (though a much later episode ["Changing of the Guardian"] reveals that Herb went broke again, and viewers don't get any information as to what happened).

to:

* DisappointingHeritageReveal: The self-made car magnate Herbert Powell was given away at birth and grew up wanting to know who his birth family was. As such, he is delighted to learn that he has a half-brother and, in fact, an entire family, to the point that he readily puts his half-brother to work designing his company's new car. Unfortunately for him, that half-brother is Homer Simpson, and the resulting car is an unmarketable disaster that bankrupts his company.
-->'''Lisa Simpson:''' Poor Herbert. His life was an unbridled success until he discovered that he was a Simpson.
* DownerEnding: Homer is left heartbroken after a bankrupt Herb disowns him. Some fans were so upset by Herb's downfall that the producers would ultimately do [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS3E24BrotherCanYouSpareTwoDimes "Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes"]] to give Herb a happy ending again (though (although a much later episode ["Changing of the Guardian"] reveals that Herb went broke again, and viewers don't get any information as to what happened).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2022 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

to:

As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2022 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000).$70-75,000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IgnoredExpert: Herb's automotive engineers try and warn him Homer's ideas are no good but he disregards them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IncompetenceInc: Powell Motors is shown to be this. The company's products don't appeal to consumers and are implied to be cheap and low quality, their marketing is so idiotic that they name new cars after Myth/ClassicalMythology references, the board of directors are a bunch of clueless {{Upper Class Twit}}s and Herb has an extremely bad relationship with them and with his lead engineers, especially due to being a SelfMadeMan who loathes people born into success. Things are so bad that Powell Motors is losing more and more ground to its Japanese competitors every day. Homer's car is just the final nail in the company's coffin - Herb put all his hopes on Homer's new miracle product, and he ignored his engineers' and executives' warnings about the lemon Homer was designing, since he believed anything they hated ''must'' be an improvement.

to:

* IncompetenceInc: Powell Motors is shown to be this. The company's products don't appeal to consumers and are implied to be cheap and low quality, their marketing is so idiotic that they name new cars after very obscure (to the common man) Myth/ClassicalMythology references, the board of directors are a bunch of clueless {{Upper Class Twit}}s and Herb has an extremely bad relationship with them and with his lead engineers, especially due to being a SelfMadeMan who loathes people born into success. Things are so bad that Powell Motors is losing more and more ground to its Japanese competitors every day. Homer's car is just the final nail in the company's coffin - Herb put all his hopes on Homer's new miracle product, and he ignored his engineers' and executives' warnings about the lemon Homer was designing, since he believed anything they hated ''must'' be an improvement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV tropes may not appear outside YMMV pages.


* IncompetenceInc: Powell Motors is shown to be this. The company's products don't appeal to consumers and are implied to be cheap and low quality, their marketing is so idiotic that they name new cars after GeniusBonus Myth/ClassicalMythology references, the board of directors are a bunch of clueless {{Upper Class Twit}}s and Herb has an extremely bad relationship with them and with his lead engineers, especially due to being a SelfMadeMan who loathes people born into success. Things are so bad that Powell Motors is losing more and more ground to its Japanese competitors every day. Homer's car is just the final nail in the company's coffin - Herb put all his hopes on Homer's new miracle product, and he ignored his engineers' and executives' warnings about the lemon Homer was designing, since he believed anything they hated ''must'' be an improvement.

to:

* IncompetenceInc: Powell Motors is shown to be this. The company's products don't appeal to consumers and are implied to be cheap and low quality, their marketing is so idiotic that they name new cars after GeniusBonus Myth/ClassicalMythology references, the board of directors are a bunch of clueless {{Upper Class Twit}}s and Herb has an extremely bad relationship with them and with his lead engineers, especially due to being a SelfMadeMan who loathes people born into success. Things are so bad that Powell Motors is losing more and more ground to its Japanese competitors every day. Homer's car is just the final nail in the company's coffin - Herb put all his hopes on Homer's new miracle product, and he ignored his engineers' and executives' warnings about the lemon Homer was designing, since he believed anything they hated ''must'' be an improvement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Homer:''' Since I'm the one you kept, that must mean you really love me.\\

to:

-->'''Homer:''' ->'''Homer:''' Since I'm the one you kept, that must mean you really love me.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Homer:''' Since I'm the one you kept, that must mean you really love me.\\
'''Abe:''' Hmm. Interesting theory...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: The design team makes some valid points about fuel efficiency and automobile designs, but how they express them ultimately demeans everything.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: The design team makes some valid points about fuel efficiency and automobile designs, but how they express them ultimately demeans everything. The lead designer also correctly warns Herb that Homer's ideas will harm the company, though in what is heavily implied to be a pompous tirade full of cheap knocks at Homer's intelligence and personal hygene, leading him to get ignored until it is too late.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IHaveNoSon: Or in Herb's case, "I Have No Brother" It took the next season for Herb to forgive Homer.

to:

* IHaveNoSon: Or in Herb's case, "I Have No Brother" Brother". It took the next season for Herb to forgive Homer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LateArrivalSpoiler: The episode spends some time building up the StrongFamilyResemblance between Homer and Herb, implying it through the way strangers react to Homer as they enter Detroit and only revealing Herb's face when he and Homer meet for the first time. Naturally, that moment is the thumbnail for the episode on Disney+.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Bart:''' So any idea where this bastard lives?
-->'''Homer:''' (angrily) BART!!
-->'''Bart:''' His parents aren't married, are they? It's a correct word, isn't it?
-->'''Homer:''' (reluctantly) I guess he got us there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2020 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

to:

As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2020 2022 dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2020 dollars price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

to:

As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' (nearly $176,000 in 2020 dollars dollars) price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' *nearly $176,000 in 2020 dollars price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75,000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

to:

As the company expresses little support for Homer's crazy ideas, Herb gives him complete creative control over the product, which ends up becoming "The Homer", an extremely ugly and expensive car, with an '''''$82,000''''' *nearly (nearly $176,000 in 2020 dollars price tag (consider that, in 1991, few if any luxury cars sold for over $70-75,000).$70-75),000). The ensuing PR chaos ends up with Powell Motors in bankruptcy (its assets being taken over by Komatsu Motors) and with Herbert losing everything he had, angrily telling Homer that his life was good until he knew he was a Simpson, an opinion shared by Lisa. Immediately after, Abe arrives in a taxi to see Herb, only to make a hasty retreat. On the way home, Bart compliments Homer for his car.

Top