Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E12TheHighGround

Go To

OR

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The episode deals with the "you say terrorists, we say freedom fighters" issue. The Ansata separatists are trying to overthrow their Rutian oppressors "by any means necessary," including suicide bombers (while the government they're fighting makes use of indefinite detention, and in the past simply killed people). During this episode, Data notes the "historical fact" that Ireland was reunified in 2024 after a successful terrorist campaign ([[BannedInChina which is why this episode wasn't broadcast in its entirety in either Britain or the Republic of Ireland until years after]]).

to:

** The episode deals with the "you say terrorists, we say freedom fighters" issue. The Ansata separatists are trying to overthrow their Rutian oppressors "by any means necessary," including suicide bombers (while the government they're fighting makes use of indefinite detention, and in the past simply killed people). During this episode, Data notes the "historical fact" that Ireland was reunified in 2024 after a successful terrorist campaign ([[BannedInChina ([[invoked]][[BannedInChina which is why this episode wasn't broadcast in its entirety in either Britain or the Republic of Ireland until years after]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EurekaMoment: {{Downplayed}}. When Geordi notices a nuclear vibration, Data believes its a subspace rebound. This causes Wesley to remember something he studied. However, Wesley can't think of the name of it and Geordi and Data help him remember it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguated Stockholm Syndrome link


* StockholmSyndrome: Beverly shows signs of this towards Finn. When Picard is captured by the separatists, he's quick to point this out to her.

to:

* StockholmSyndrome: UsefulNotes/StockholmSyndrome: Beverly shows signs of this towards Finn. When Picard is captured by the separatists, he's quick to point this out to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CuffsOffRubWrists: Crusher rubs her wrists after Finn unlocks her shackles so she can start treating his followers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil is pushing ot for Finn? Come on.


* EvilIsPetty: Evil is pushing it, but Finn's final act after his cell is raided is to run back and try to murder Picard, even though there is nothing to gain from doing so. He may have figured his plan would play out posthumously.

to:

* EvilIsPetty: Evil is pushing it, but As if attempting to blow up the Enterprise and kill over a thousand innocent people wasn't evil enough, Finn's final act after his cell is raided is to run back and try to murder Picard, even though there is nothing to gain from doing so. He may have figured his plan would play out posthumously.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]]. Though that may justified by Finn not being from earth and using example from his own planet history.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]]. Though that may justified by Finn not being from earth and using example from his own planet history.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]]. Though that may justified by Finn not being from earth and only knows a finite amount from word of mouth.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]]. Though that may justified by Finn not being from earth and only knows a finite amount using example from word of mouth.his own planet history.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]]. Though that may justified by Finn not being from earth and only knows a finite amount from word of mouth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FailedFutureForecast: The reference to the unification of Ireland in 2024, thanks to a successful terrorist campaign not only instantly dates the episode back to before the Good Friday Agreement, which saw the end of The Troubles and which made it very unlikely to result in the unification of Ireland by 2024, but is also indicative of the sympathetic views that a not-insubstantial portion of the American population had towards the IRA at the time, before events later in the decade (including the Oklahoma City bombing in America, and the Omagh bombing in Northern Ireland) eroded that sympathy.

to:

* FailedFutureForecast: The reference to the unification of Ireland in 2024, thanks to a successful terrorist campaign not only instantly dates the episode back to before the Good Friday Agreement, which saw the end of The Troubles and which made it very unlikely to result in the unification of Ireland by 2024, 2024,[[note]]There ''would'', ironically, be questions over Northern Ireland's place in the United Kingdom during the late 2010s and early 2020s, but because of Brexit rather than The Troubles -- and even then, while polls showed a large majority of Brexit supporters were in favor of handing Northern Ireland over to the Republic of Ireland if it made it easier for the rest of the UK to extricate itself from UsefulNotes/TheEuropeanUnion, this was in general never considered likely or politically tenable.[[/note]] but is also indicative of the sympathetic views that a not-insubstantial portion of the American population had towards the IRA at the time, before events later in the decade (including the Oklahoma City bombing in America, and the Omagh bombing in Northern Ireland) eroded that sympathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoTimeToExplain: Once Geordi gets the bomb off, he calls for the transporter room to lock on to his communicator and prepare to transport into space. Troi, horrified, starts to question it but Picard holds up his hand to stop her.

to:

* NoTimeToExplain: Once Geordi gets the bomb off, he calls for the transporter room to lock on to his communicator and prepare to transport into space. Troi, horrified, starts to question it but Picard holds up his hand to stop her.her, trusting that Geordi made the request for good reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffablyEvil: Finn, a terrorist willing to sacrifice innocent lives to serve his cause, is polite and personable to Beverly Crusher. He even provides her food when she is in his custody.

to:

* AffablyEvil: Finn, a terrorist willing to sacrifice innocent lives to serve his cause, is polite and personable to Beverly Crusher. He even provides her food After kidnapping her, the first thing he does when she is in his custody.custody is offer her some food.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AffablyEvil: Finn, a terrorist willing to sacrifice innocent lives to serve his cause, is polite and personable to Beverly Crusher. He even provides her food when she is in his custody.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cut trope


* MoralDissonance: While the Prime Directive is invoked to justify not providing support to the Rutian government, there is still the open question of why the Federation has any dealings at all with a planet experiencing such violent social conflict as opposed to simply avoiding them entirely the way they would less advanced civilizations. Even if Rutia IV meets the technological threshold for allowing the Federation to have contact with them, their civil strife is a clear demonstration that technology is an inadequate yardstick for measuring a culture's behavior.
-->'''Finn:''' Captain, there's a lot to admire in the Federation, but there's a hint of moral cowardice in your dealings with non-aligned planets. [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech You do business with a government that's crushing us. And then you say you aren't involved? You're very much involved. You just don't want to get dirty]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the war.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: When Crusher insists that Washington was a general and not a terrorist, Finn claims that Washington would have been considered a terrorist if he'd lost the war. But while rebel generals may be considered ''traitors'', they are not considered terrorists in the annals of history unless they actually used terrorist tactics. For example, Robert E. Lee has never been considered a terrorist even though he lost the war.[[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar American Civil War]].

Added: 907

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Crusher has been taken to the Ansatan separatists' underground hideout, where their leader Finn tells her that they need her medical skills. Many of the terrorists are dying because their DNA has been warped. The Ansatans' use of an Inverter to jump through dimensions to teleport without a trace is slowly killing them, but it is a sacrifice they're willing to make for their cause. Though Crusher scorns his tactics, Finn argues that he's using the only means he has at his disposal to achieve freedom. Finn proves to be a talented artist and begins sketching Crusher in his off time.

to:

Crusher has been taken to the Ansatan separatists' underground hideout, where their leader Kyril Finn tells her that they need her medical skills. Many of the terrorists are dying because their DNA has been warped. The Ansatans' use of an Inverter to jump through dimensions to teleport without a trace is slowly killing them, but it is a sacrifice they're willing to make for their cause. Though Crusher scorns his tactics, Finn argues that he's using the only means he has at his disposal to achieve freedom. Finn proves to be a talented artist and begins sketching Crusher in his off time.


Added DiffLines:

-->'''Finn:''' Captain, there's a lot to admire in the Federation, but there's a hint of moral cowardice in your dealings with non-aligned planets. [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech You do business with a government that's crushing us. And then you say you aren't involved? You're very much involved. You just don't want to get dirty]].


Added DiffLines:

* ShutUpKirk: When Beverly denounces Finn as a mass murderer with the blood of countless innocents on his hands, he bites back with this:
-->"How much innocent blood has been spilled for the cause of freedom in the history of your Federation, Doctor? How many good and noble societies have bombed civilians in war? Wiped out whole cities. And now that you enjoy the comfort that has come from their battles, their killing, you frown on my immorality? I am willing to die for my freedom. And, in the finest tradition of your own great civilization, I'm willing to kill for it, too."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Skunk Stripe is no longer a trope. Zero Context Examples and examples that do fit existing tropes will be deleted.


* SkunkStripe: All the Rutians have one.

Top