Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SomewhereAnEquestrianIsCrying

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Probably the most blatant example is in ''Eragon''. Paolini seems to be under the impression that horses can gallop for hundreds of leagues for days on end on nothing but a few crops of desert grass and sips dirty water.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** They can, however, get ''crippled'' when injured badly enough. (Lamed horses may recover after a few months but will not regain any quality modifiers like "heavy" or "spirited" when they do.)

Changed: 225

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Neatly averted in SheWoreAYellowRibbon, where the love interest character teases a cavalry officer about all the time they spend walking, and he pedantically explains that they have to do this so that the horses don't die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
better translation, I hope


** It's a joke about the german phrase: "Ich hab' auch schon Pferde kotzen gesehen." ("I've seen also horses puking.") meaning: "[[SarcasmMode Very likely.]]" or "I have some doubts about the things you tell me, but I'm too polite to say you that so offendingly."

to:

** It's a joke about the german phrase: "Ich hab' auch schon Pferde kotzen gesehen." ("I've seen also horses puking.puke as well.") meaning: "[[SarcasmMode Very likely.]]" or "I have some doubts about the things you tell me, but I'm too polite to say you that so offendingly."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the second ''Last Herald-Mage'' book she even comes out and says when the Companions have to run all night the Heralds are keeping them going by magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** It is entirely possible to guide a horse with legs alone, including [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAqPfjEjaYM riding completely bridleless]]. Stacy Westfall, a world-renowned [[EquestrianSports freestyle reiner]], has done it repeatedly and consistently. It's only a matter of training and balance. ''Years'' of training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DidYouHearAboutTheMorgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on.

to:

* ''DidYouHearAboutTheMorgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on. The saddle and breastplate being on a stalled horse is plausible, but avoided if possible; the bridle being on is a ''definite'' no.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Random outburst of pedantic equestrianism.

Added DiffLines:

****This troper is feeling pedantic, and wants to clarify that you don't usually steer a horse with your knees--but you do normally direct them with heels, calves, thighs, hips, seat and posture--reins are only one aid. Any decently-skilled rider on a moderately trained horse should be able to guide them about a ring at a walk without reins. Speed and more complex manoeuvres are much more difficult, but possible, although it's worth pointing out it's really nice to have reins available for safety purposes. (This leads me to point out another common misconception about equestrianism--riding is not just a matter of jumping on a horse and letting the horse do the work. It's actually a complicated skill that's a bit like patting your head and rubbing your belly at the same time, with an understanding of basic physics and geometry along with a zen-like mastery of your own emotions being quite useful. Really. I'm not making this up.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the Christian fairy tales ''The Princess and the Three Knights'' by Karen Kingsbury and ''The Squire and the Scroll'' by Jennie Bishop, horses are treated like medieval versions of motorcycles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted and lampshaded in C. S. Lewis' ''[[TheChroniclesOfNarnia The Horse and His Boy]]'', in which the talking horse himself insists that "galloping for a night and a day" is nonsense and they will have to alternately walk and trot.

to:

* Averted and lampshaded in C. S. Lewis' CSLewis' ''[[TheChroniclesOfNarnia The Horse and His Boy]]'', in which the talking horse himself insists that "galloping for a night and a day" is nonsense and they will have to alternately walk and trot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While falling over cliffs is something no horse would survive (especially when one broken leg can spell death), a horse flopping over on it's back is frankly spot-on, if not entirely accurately animated in the movie, as anyone who's had a horse decide to lay down while being ridden will tell you. Most horses are actually quite fond of rolling around on their back with all four legs flailing in the air, preferably in a nice patch of mud for you to have to scrub off before they can be ridden again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Did You Hear About the Morgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on.
* ''Something To Talk About'' co-starred Robert Duvall, who actually knew how to ride, and so insisted on doing his own stunts. The problem here lies with the end competition. Identified as a Grand Prix event, that means the fences he'd be jumping would be approximately 5' high. They actually look about that height when some of the stunt riders are jumping. But it takes considerable training and skill to jump one fence of that height, let alone 8 to 12 of them. So all the fences were obviously lowered to about 2'6" for Duvall's turn.

to:

* ''Did You Hear About the Morgans?'' ''DidYouHearAboutTheMorgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on.
* ''Something To Talk About'' ''SomethingToTalkAbout'' co-starred Robert Duvall, who actually knew how to ride, and so insisted on doing his own stunts. The problem here lies with the end competition. Identified as a Grand Prix event, that means the fences he'd be jumping would be approximately 5' high. They actually look about that height when some of the stunt riders are jumping. But it takes considerable training and skill to jump one fence of that height, let alone 8 to 12 of them. So all the fences were obviously lowered to about 2'6" for Duvall's turn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Let's try to keep the examples here to fictional ones. While there are definite cases of real life abuse and neglect due to their owners' ignorance, most of these tend to have consequences. In fictionland, however, the ill-treatment never produces bad results. Super trope of AutomatonHorses. See HorsingAround for when the horses ''do'' protest their treatment.

to:

Let's try to keep the examples here to fictional ones. While there are definite cases of real life abuse and neglect due to their owners' ignorance, most of these tend to have consequences. In fictionland, however, the ill-treatment never produces bad results. Super trope of AutomatonHorses. See HorsingAround for when the horses ''do'' protest their treatment.
treatment. For Somewhere An Equestrian Is Smiling, see InvulnerableHorses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It's a joke about the german phrase: "Ich hab' auch schon Pferde kotzen gesehen." ("I've seen also horses puking.") meaning: "[[SarcasmMode Very likely.]]" or "I have some doubts about the things you tell me, but I'm too polite to say you that so offendingly."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** SomewhereAnEquestrianIsCrying because of the above. While horses can't exist solely on a diet of the mentioned treats (ideally, they eat roughage like hay more or less constantly throughout the day), go on a horse forum and you can and will find horses who will eat any and all of the above, not to mention soda, hamburgers, granola bars, bananas, potato chips, snack cakes, and marshmallow Peeps. While giving a horse a bucketfull of any of these would do them no good, small amounts are unlikely to do a healthy horse any harm. And as with dogs, the type and amount of chocolate is key to toxicity, and a chocolate bar is highly unlikely to actually poison a full-size horse. The only real worry would be screwing up a drug test if they were competing. The tying up with the saddle on does stand as a fail (especially if he had someone offering a free stall and groom!)

Added: 412

Changed: 236

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Averted and lampshaded in C. S. Lewis' ''[[TheChroniclesOfNarnia The Horse and His Boy]]'', in which the talking horse himself insists that "galloping for a night and a day" is nonsense and they will have to alternately walk and trot.
* Similarly averted in MercedesLackey's [[HeraldsOfValdemar Valdemar]] novels, where the horselike Companions can indeed run for a night and a day -- which proves that they are magical creatures and merely horse''like''. In one instance an experienced horseman Herald rides a mare and notes all the ways she differs from his Companion, including balking at close paths and grazing at every possible opportunity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* In the Western "Rattler" by Barry Andrew Chambers his horse is generally treated like a dog that you put a saddle on. This initially looks like a simple case of [[AllAnimalsAreDogs All Animals are Dogs]] but veers off into into potential animal abuse when the horse is fed CHOCOLATE. Chocolate is toxic to horses as well as dogs. He also feeds, or allows others to feed, his horse pancakes, a blueberry pie, and beef jerky at various points. No one finds anything wrong with this. Additionally, when offered the chance to stable his horse and have it properly groomed and fed, he declines and ties it up outside still saddled for at least a day, possibly longer.

to:

* In the Western "Rattler" ''Rattler'' by Barry Andrew Chambers his horse is generally treated like a dog that you put a saddle on. This initially looks like a simple case of [[AllAnimalsAreDogs All Animals are Dogs]] but veers off into into potential animal abuse when the horse is fed CHOCOLATE. Chocolate is toxic to horses as well as dogs. He also feeds, or allows others to feed, his horse pancakes, a blueberry pie, and beef jerky at various points. No one finds anything wrong with this. Additionally, when offered the chance to stable his horse and have it properly groomed and fed, he declines and ties it up outside still saddled for at least a day, possibly longer.



* MountAndBlade gives you horses with infinite stamina and lets you control them perfectly in combat even if they're just 'average' horses and not highly trained warhorses.

to:

* MountAndBlade ''MountAndBlade'' gives you horses with infinite stamina and lets you control them perfectly in combat even if they're just 'average' horses and not highly trained warhorses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This is not inaccurate. Contrary to popular belief, reins should ''not'' be used as the only way to direct a horse--instead, you use your legs and seat posture in tandem with the reins to direct a horse. Many riding instructors actually take the reins away from inexperienced riders so they get used to using their knees instead of the reins. And as for firing from horseback, that's not inaccurate either. While it's not exactly ''easy'' to fire a bow while your horse is moving, it's still possible. The Mongols in particular were renowned for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There's no reason to list aversions here


* Averted and {{Lampshaded}} in ''SheWoreAYellowRibbon'', when Olivia Dandridge complains about having to walk instead of riding, saying she might as well be with the Infantry; Lt. Cohill tartly replies, "We soon would be, if we didn't ease these horses."



* Deliberately averted in ''{{The Horse and His Boy}}'', where Bree (a talking horse) makes it clear to Shasta that the "galloping all day and all night" thing ''does not happen''.



* Averted as much as possible in the ''{{Belgariad}}'' - at one point, after being forced to ride all night and through a freezing river, the horses ''collapse'' and must be rubbed down. They're far too fragile to ride for some time, slowing the group down considerably. There's also mention of one character having to ride several horses to death to stay in front of the heroes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Epona, your horse in OcarinaOfTime is similarly invincible (as are you when riding) and while she has a stamina system, it runs on carrots... She also won't object if you shoot her in the head with arrows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the Western "Rattler" by Barry Andrew Chambers his horse is generally treated like a dog that you put a saddle on. This initially looks like a simple case of [[AllAnimalsAreDogs All Animals are Dogs]] but veers off into into potential animal abuse when the horse is fed CHOCOLATE. Chocolate is toxic to horses as well as dogs. He also feeds, or allows others to feed, his horse pancakes, a blueberry pie, and beef jerky at various points. No one finds anything wrong with this. Additionally, when offered the chance to stable his horse and have it properly groomed and fed, he declines and ties it up outside still saddled for at least a day, possibly longer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Red Dead Redemption is almost certainly not the Ur Example of anything, and especially not Automaton Horses


** RDR gives us the ur-example of AutomatonHorses.

to:

** RDR gives us the ur-example of AutomatonHorses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Have You Heard About the Morgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on.

to:

* ''Have ''Did You Heard Hear About the Morgans?'' features a scene in which Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker flee from a hitman on horseback. Here's the problem: they had no time to tack the horse up from when they spotted the hitman to when they had to make their escape. Which means the horse was standing in its stall with a saddle, breastplate, and bridle on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** RDR gives us the ur-example of AutomatonHorses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''DerSchuhDesManitu'', Winnetouch's horse Jacqueline has to vomit after walking too fast. This movie being a comedy, this may be deliberate PlayingWithTheTrope, though.

to:

* In ''DerSchuhDesManitu'', Winnetouch's horse Jacqueline has to vomit after walking too fast. This movie being a comedy, this may be deliberate PlayingWithTheTrope, [[PlayingWithATrope deliberate]], though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''DerSchuhDesManitu'', Winnetouch's horse Jacqueline has to vomit after walking too fast. This movie being a comedy, this may be deliberate PlayingWithTheTrope, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Averted as much as possible in the ''{{Belgariad}}'' - at one point, after being forced to ride all night and through a freezing river, the horses ''collapse'' and must be rubbed down. They're far too fragile to ride for some time, slowing the group down considerably. There's also mention of one character having to ride several horses to death to stay in front of the heroes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MountAndBlade gives you horses with infinite stamina and lets you control them perfectly in combat even if they're just 'average' horses and not highly trained warhorses.
** You can steer them with your knees as well, it seems... horseback archery doesn't involve you holding the reins, but they still manoeuvre as normal.
** They're immortal too; if yours gets impaled on a lance by a charging knight it'll get better for the next battle.
** They do at least run away if their rider is unhorsed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->You cannot gallop them for hours. They’ll collapse. The best way to make time in the saddle is to alternate paces, and have a remount or two trailing behind, and allow the animals reasonable rest. Don’t let your steed eat or drink indiscriminately; it’s likely to bloat and become helpless. In fact, it’s a rather fragile creature, requiring close attention — for example, rubdowns after hard exertion — if it isn’t to fall sick and perhaps die on you. It’s also lazy, stupid, and sometimes malicious.
---> PoulAnderson, [[http://www.sfwa.org/2005/01/on-thud-and-blunder/ On Thud and Blunder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Robert Jordan did at least some research for TheWheelOfTime books (especially as the series went on and on and on). Characters are shown to and talk about caring for horses at least to a decent degree. Most is shown from the perspective of Perrin (A blacksmith) perspective, and Mat (son of a horse trader).

Top