Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / CaptainSmoothAndSergeantRough

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yet it's still an effective chemistry, sometimes invoked a bit, but always Lampshaded.

Added: 134

Changed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Sharpe and Harper in ''{{Sharpe}}'', though Sharpe is somewhat less refined than most officers.


Added DiffLines:

* Inverted in DragonAge2, Meredith is a lot more hard-line and brutal than her more diplomatic and practical second-in-command Cullen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*At the end of the new StarTrek movie, the roles are flipped.[[TheKirk Kirk]], a former JerkWithAHeartofGold and MilitaryMaverick,is in the command chair with cool, collected[[TheSpock Spock]] as his first officer. Note the original Kirk was not rough around the edges in any sense, but was an OfficerAndAGentleman despite sharing certain traits (such as womanizing and hubris) with his AU counterpart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A non-military example occurs in ''TheShawshankRedemption'', with Warden Norton filling the role of Captain Smooth and Captain Hadley being the Sergeant Rough. These roles are apparent in the dressing-down of the new meat.

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CaptainAmerica occasionally features this during his WWII adventures, with the Sergeant usually being Sgt. NickFury, but his first mission featured Bucky as the Sergeant Rough as seen in WolverineOrigins.
* The comic version of {{300}} had a '''King Smooth and Captain Rough'''. Leonidas was usually very calm and stoic while his Captain was brutish and violent.

to:

* CaptainAmerica occasionally features this during his WWII adventures, with the Sergeant usually being Sgt. NickFury, but his first mission featured Bucky as the Sergeant Rough as seen in WolverineOrigins.
[[{{Wolverine}} ''Wolverine Origins'']].
* The comic version of {{300}} [[ThreeHundred 300]] had a '''King Smooth and Captain Rough'''. Leonidas was usually very calm and stoic while his Captain was brutish and violent.

Changed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The comic version of {{300}} had a '''King Smooth and Captain Rough'''. Leonidas was usually very calm and stoic while his Captain was brutish and violent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[EnsignNewbie Shiro Amada]] and [[SergeantRock Karen Joshua]] of ''[[{{Ptitled636c0z1}} Mobile Suit Gundam: The 08th MS Team]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Inverted in the remake of Hawaii Five-0. Despite being in charge, Steve is the biggest wildcard on the team and is known for his inventive interrogation techniques, while Danny is much more by-the-book and civilised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the ''HarryPotter'' series, headmaster Albus Dumbledore and deputy headmistress Minerva [=McGonagall=] fit this pretty well. Dumbledore is, well, [[TheDumbledore the trope he named]] and generally doesn't seem to care much about school rules being enforced. [=McGonagall=] is a serious SternTeacher, although she is occasionally NotSoStoic. In the first book, Dumbledore catches Harry out of bed after curfew and his response is to have a nice mentorly talk with him. Later on in the same book, [=McGonagall=] catches Harry and friends out after curfew and her response is to dock a shitload of points and give them all detentions.

Changed: 441

Removed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misleading real-life examples: if you have to select C Os from the ranks, your recruitment process is broken


* As noted above, this trope is largely a holdover from the days before professional armies with an officer corps chosen from merit. In those days, most of the officers were from aristocratic families, while [=NCOs=] were generally low-born grunts who had survived previous campaigns long enough to learn the "tricks of the trade" through personal experience.
** Most officers are still specifically trained for command rather than promoted from the ranks, so this is in no way dead in real life.

to:

* As noted above, this trope is largely a holdover originates from the days before professional armies with an officer corps chosen from merit. In those days, time when most of the officers were from aristocratic families, while [=NCOs=] were generally low-born grunts who had survived previous campaigns long enough to learn the "tricks of the trade" through personal experience.
** Most
experience. Today, officers are still specifically trained for command rather and [=NCOs=] go through completely separate training programmes and promotion from one group to the other is rare (as they do different jobs, it's more of a career change than promoted from a promotion). In the ranks, so modern era, it's also fairly common for sergeants to have a higher pay grade than their commanding officer, for this is in no way dead in real life.reason.



* The [=US Army=] [[InvokedTrope intentionally selects COs and retains NCOs and trains them to uphold their respective images]]. If there's ever an inversion, it's rare and intentional.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes direct to the point of using their fists which no higher-up should do. This is to some degree TruthInTelevision. Not only is it a holdover from class differences, but it reflects the fundamental role between the two roles: The officer must concern himself with the big picture, providing direction to his unit in the form of plans and orders, while the NCO's business is in the details, enforcing discipline, maintaining the unit's proficiency, and personally directing his soldiers in battle. It can also be a useful psychological trick that bears relations with GoodCopBadCop.

to:

Sometimes direct to the point of using their fists which no higher-up should do. This is to some degree TruthInTelevision. Not only is it a holdover from class differences, but it reflects the fundamental role difference between the two roles: The officer must concern himself with the big picture, providing direction to his unit in the form of plans and orders, while the NCO's business is in the details, enforcing discipline, maintaining the unit's proficiency, and personally directing his soldiers in battle. It can also be a useful psychological trick that bears relations with GoodCopBadCop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes direct to the point of using their fists which no higher-up should do. This is to some degree TruthInTelevision. Not only is it a holdover from class differences, it can be a useful psychological trick that bears relations with GoodCopBadCop.

to:

Sometimes direct to the point of using their fists which no higher-up should do. This is to some degree TruthInTelevision. Not only is it a holdover from class differences, but it reflects the fundamental role between the two roles: The officer must concern himself with the big picture, providing direction to his unit in the form of plans and orders, while the NCO's business is in the details, enforcing discipline, maintaining the unit's proficiency, and personally directing his soldiers in battle. It can also be a useful psychological trick that bears relations with GoodCopBadCop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Only in the last episode was it revealed that Wilson was indeed a genuine Regular Army Captain Smooth from the previous war. He was filling in as sergeant so that Mainwaring could be Captain if he wanted to; having been a real captain he had no intention of squabbling over who should be a Home Guard captain at his time of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''{{Firefly}}'' plays this straight and subverts this at the same time with Malcolm Reynolds, who keeps his Sergeant Rough from his war days even as he calls himself a captain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:ComicBooks]]
* CaptainAmerica occasionally features this during his WWII adventures, with the Sergeant usually being Sgt. NickFury, but his first mission featured Bucky as the Sergeant Rough as seen in WolverineOrigins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is a type of ensemble, in which the top authority figure rules in a more refined way and the under boss in a more straightforward way. That is TheCaptain will be an OfficerAndAGentleman and AFatherToHisMen. When he needs to intimidate he will use subtle means like a DeathGlare. By contrast lower level bosses like a FatherNeptune, a SergeantRock or if the crew is unlucky, DrillSergeantNasty will be harsh and direct in their method of rule.

to:

This is a type of ensemble, in which the top authority figure rules in a more refined way and the under boss in a more straightforward way. That is is, TheCaptain will be an OfficerAndAGentleman and AFatherToHisMen. When he needs to intimidate he will use subtle means like a DeathGlare. By contrast lower level bosses like a FatherNeptune, a SergeantRock or or, if the crew is unlucky, DrillSergeantNasty will be harsh and direct in their method of rule.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''TourOfTheMerrimack'' has this sort of contrast between John Farragut, the smooth captain of the ''Merrimack'', and TR Steele, the rough colonel who leads its SpaceMarines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Winters and Speirs on ''Series/BandOfBrothers'', kind of. Also TruthInTelevision.

to:

* Winters [[OfficerAndAGentleman Winters]] and Speirs [[BloodKnight Speirs]] on ''Series/BandOfBrothers'', kind of. Also TruthInTelevision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Inverted in the first episode. Captain Sobel is the DrillSergeantNasty while Lieutenant Winters is the nice officer the men like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Winters and Speirs on ''Series/BandOfBrothers'', kind of. Also TruthInTelevision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[TeamMom Lieutenant Filicia Heideman]] and [[HotBlooded Sergeant Rio Kazumiya]] of ''SoraNoWoto''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The main character of the ''CodexAlera'', Tavi, is the calm, refined, [[GuileHero highly intelligent]] and [[TheCallPutMeOnHold singularly unpowered]] [[TheCaptain captain]]; his primary lieutenants are the absurdly powerful BoisterousBruiser Maximus and the cynical, grizzled veteran centurion Valiar Marcus. This is one of the subversions, though-- Tavi is probably [[BadassNormal the most dangerous of the lot]], due to a combination of intellect, [[CrazyEnoughToWork creativity]], training, and sheer {{badass}} [[RefugeInAudacity audacity]].

Changed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Lightning, being an actual sergeant, literalizes this trope. Her solution to everything is to crack heads, while her cooler-headed superior officer Amodar suggests she try to stay out of the business of Cocoon's leaders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Cavalry in ''FinalFantasyXIII'' are led by the gentlemanly Brigadier General Cid Raines (prettiest Cid yet!), and his more rough-and-tumble subordinate Rygdea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''RevoltingPeople'', the redcoats are represented by the polite and charming Captain Bradshaw and the obnoxious, cynical Sergeant [=McGurk=].

to:

* In ''RevoltingPeople'', the redcoats are represented by the polite and charming Captain Bradshaw Brimshaw and the obnoxious, cynical Sergeant [=McGurk=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Anime and Manga]]
* Taki and Klaus of ''HyakujitsuNoBara'' fit this trope, although their positions are more analogous to "colonel" and "captain" respectively. Although Klaus is shown to have a lot of concern for his subordinates in action, he is distastefully viewed by Taki's compatriots as wild and rough-around-the-edges, and he is very frank with orders. In contrast Taki is idolized by his troops who see him as someone who can never do wrong, and the DeathGlare is the most he will exercise on his own men. At one point Taki does come closer to the "rough" side however, when he uses training to vent his own frustration, resulting in him ruthlessly beating soldiers (one of whom was already injured) foolish enough to try their luck against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:Radio]]
* In ''Revolting People'', the redcoats are represented by the polite and charming Captain Bradshaw, and the obnoxious, cynical Sergeant [=McGurk=].

[[AC: Video Games]]

to:

[[AC:Radio]]
[[AC:{{Radio}}]]
* In ''Revolting People'', ''RevoltingPeople'', the redcoats are represented by the polite and charming Captain Bradshaw, Bradshaw and the obnoxious, cynical Sergeant [=McGurk=].

[[AC: Video Games]][[AC:VideoGames]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Radio]]
*In ''Revolting People'', the redcoats are represented by the polite and charming Captain Bradshaw, and the obnoxious, cynical Sergeant [=McGurk=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*The {{Discworld}} novel ''Discworld/MonstrousRegiment'' has Lieutenant Blouse as the soft, inexperienced "Rupert" with Sargent Jackrum as the experienced, conniving, shouty NCO.

to:

*The {{Discworld}} novel ''Discworld/MonstrousRegiment'' has [[EnsignNewbie Lieutenant Blouse Blouse]] as the soft, inexperienced "Rupert" with Sargent Jackrum [[SergeantRock Sergeant Jackrum]] as the experienced, conniving, shouty NCO.
NCO who [[PussInBoots actually makes the decisions]].



* Inverted in ''[[DadsArmy Dad's Army]]'' where Captain Mainwaring is a oafish but brave amateur and Sergeant Wilson is a suave aristocrat with extensive military experience. Mainwaring's (and Wilsons's) intense awareness of the class inversion was a comedy goldmine.

to:

* Inverted in ''[[DadsArmy Dad's Army]]'' where Captain Mainwaring is a oafish but brave amateur and Sergeant Wilson is a suave aristocrat with extensive military experience. Mainwaring's (and Wilsons's) Wilson's) intense awareness of the class inversion was a comedy goldmine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In {{Pokémon Mystery Dungeon}} Explorers of Time/Darkness/Sky, Guild Leader Wigglytuff and his second-in-command Chatot work as this!

to:

* In {{Pokémon [[PokemonMysteryDungeon Pokémon Mystery Dungeon}} Dungeon]] Explorers of Time/Darkness/Sky, Guild Leader Wigglytuff and his second-in-command Chatot work as this!

Top