Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheGiver

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jonas [[spoiler:escaping]] is actually the most obvious and sensible explanation. This conclusion is similar to what happens in "This Perfect Day", where [[spoiler:isolated communities of "incurables" really do exist outside of the Family.]]

to:

* ** Jonas [[spoiler:escaping]] is actually the most obvious and sensible explanation. This conclusion is similar to what happens in "This Perfect Day", where [[spoiler:isolated communities of "incurables" really do exist outside of the Family.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jonas [[spoiler:escaping] is actually the most obvious and sensible explanation. This conclusion is similar to what happens in "This Perfect Day", where [[spoiler:isolated communities of "incurables" really do exist outside of the Family.]

to:

* Jonas [[spoiler:escaping] [[spoiler:escaping]] is actually the most obvious and sensible explanation. This conclusion is similar to what happens in "This Perfect Day", where [[spoiler:isolated communities of "incurables" really do exist outside of the Family.]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jonas [[spoiler:escaping] is actually the most obvious and sensible explanation. This conclusion is similar to what happens in "This Perfect Day", where [[spoiler:isolated communities of "incurables" really do exist outside of the Family.]

Added: 1817

Changed: 163

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BiblicalMotifs: A bit subtler than most examples, but they're still there. Two of the central characters are named after an Old Testament prophet and an angel, respectively, and the plot starts with an incident with an apple that {{foreshadow|ing}}s a loss of innocence.



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Early on, we learn that Jonas' younger sister Lily has a stuffed toy elephant as her "comfort object", and that she believes that elephants are imaginary creatures that never existed. Much later in the book, Jonas receives a memory of an elephant being killed for its ivory by poachers. This is a major step in Jonas learning about the lost memory of sorrow, and it makes him realize just how much of the old world people have left behind.



* MeaningfulName: Ophelia in ''{{Hamlet}}'' reminds us that "There's [R]osemary, that's for remembrance" - is it any wonder the community banned her name after what she did to them?

to:

* MeaningfulName: MeaningfulName:
**
Ophelia in ''{{Hamlet}}'' reminds us that "There's [R]osemary, that's for remembrance" - is it any wonder the community banned her name after what she did to them?


Added DiffLines:

** "Jonas" is a variant form of the Hebrew name "Jonah". Much like the prophet Jonah in TheBible, Jonas (who's arguably a "prophet" in his own way) is a ChosenOne selected by his rulers to receive great messages, and he ultimately [[spoiler: decides to elude his destiny by running away and starting a new life somewhere else]].


Added DiffLines:

* OnlyOneName: Everyone in the Community. Justified, since all of them are raised by adoptive parents assigned by the government, and have no reason to carry family names. This also prevents people from becoming too attached to their adoptive families, since familial love is one of the many emotions that society has let go of.
* PassingTheTorch: An essential part of the Giver's relationship with the Receiver. Every Receiver accepts the job with the understanding that he/she will eventually become the next Giver, with the task of passing on the accumulated memories to the next Receiver.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace stuff


Newbery Medal-winning young adult novel by Lois Lowry. Known for its expertly merciless {{Deconstruction}} of the {{Utopia}}, and incidentally provides an introduction to the {{Dystopia}} genre for grade-school readers for whom some of the bits of ''NineteenEightyFour'' and ''Literature/BraveNewWorld'' would be a bit too saucy.

to:

Newbery Medal-winning young adult novel by Lois Lowry. Known for its expertly merciless {{Deconstruction}} of the {{Utopia}}, and incidentally provides an introduction to the {{Dystopia}} genre for grade-school readers for whom some of the bits of ''NineteenEightyFour'' ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour'' and ''Literature/BraveNewWorld'' would be a bit too saucy.



Anyone who cannot or will not conform - the very Old, the handicapped, people who break the Rules three times - is "{{released to Elsewhere}}", vaguely understood to mean sent somewhere outside the Community.

to:

Anyone who cannot or will not conform - the very Old, the handicapped, people who break the Rules three times - is "{{released to Elsewhere}}", "ReleasedToElsewhere", vaguely understood to mean sent somewhere outside the Community.



Thanks to his new position, young Jonas is exposed to how life used to be, and slowly but surely grows to believe it was better that way. His dilemma comes to a head when he discovers he's now allowed access to the most secret ceremonies of his Community, including the ceremonies of Release. Excited to peek in on his gentle father at work as a Nurturer of newborn babies, [[TheReveal Jonas instead finds himself watching]] him [[MoodWhiplash cheerfully kill]] a newborn twin with a painful lethal injection, simply because 'having two identical people running around' would disrupt community harmony.

to:

Thanks to his new position, young Jonas is exposed to how life used to be, and slowly but surely grows to believe it was better that way. His dilemma comes to a head when he discovers he's now allowed access to the most secret ceremonies of his Community, including the ceremonies of Release. Excited to peek in on his gentle father at work as a Nurturer of newborn babies, [[TheReveal Jonas instead finds himself watching]] him [[MoodWhiplash cheerfully kill]] a newborn twin with a painful lethal injection, simply because 'having two identical people running around' would disrupt community harmony.
harmony.



* GainaxEnding: [[spoiler:Either Jonas escapes, or the ending is a DyingDream. Lois Lowry responded with a {{Shrug of God}} when asked about it.]]

to:

* GainaxEnding: [[spoiler:Either Jonas escapes, or the ending is a DyingDream. Lois Lowry responded with a {{Shrug of God}} ShrugOfGod when asked about it.]]



* HeroesWantRedheads- Our protagonist Jonas has his Stirrings on Fiona, who has red hair.

to:

* HeroesWantRedheads- Our protagonist Jonas has his Stirrings on Fiona, who has red hair.



* NuclearFamily: All of them, without the dog.

to:

* NuclearFamily: All of them, without the dog.



** Each family unit is allowed a maximum of 2 children, the same number of children are born each year and they are all assigned to a family unit. Not all adults have children, and not all family units have the maximum of 2 children.
** Birthmothers, the only job that allows giving birth, are only allowed to have 3 children each before they become laborers. This would require that at least 2/3 of all women become birth mothers to maintain a stable population, but this doesn't happen at the beginning of the book as the administration is handing out jobs to graduates.

to:

** ** Each family unit is allowed a maximum of 2 children, the same number of children are born each year and they are all assigned to a family unit. Not all adults have children, and not all family units have the maximum of 2 children.
** Birthmothers, the only job that allows giving birth, are only allowed to have 3 children each before they become laborers. This would require that at least 2/3 of all women become birth mothers to maintain a stable population, but this doesn't happen at the beginning of the book as the administration is handing out jobs to graduates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneSteveLimit: [[EnforcedTrope Enforced]]. In the Community, only one person is allowed to carry a given first name at any given time. In the rare event that a person dies unexpectedly, their name is immediately passed on to a newborn baby to create the impression that they never really left.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommonKnowledge: Despite strict regulations on behavior, the book acknowledges that people in the Community still have distinct personalities (government-mandated personality tests are a huge plot point) and that certain people have distinctive physical traits (in spite of selective breeding designed to prevent this). Still, ''The Giver'' is generally known as "that book about a futuristic society where everyone looks and acts the same", even though the truth is a bit more complex.

to:

* CommonKnowledge: Despite strict regulations on behavior, the book acknowledges that people in the Community still have distinct personalities (government-mandated personality tests are a huge plot point) and that certain people have distinctive physical traits (in in spite of selective breeding designed to prevent this). them. Still, ''The Giver'' is generally known as "that book about a futuristic society where everyone looks and acts the same", even though the truth is a bit more complex.complex than that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CommonKnowledge: Despite strict regulations on behavior, the book acknowledges that people in the Community still have distinct personalities (government-mandated personality tests are a huge plot point) and that certain people have distinctive physical traits (in spite of selective breeding designed to prevent this). Still, ''The Giver'' is generally known as "that book about a futuristic society where everyone looks and acts the same", even though the truth is a bit more complex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, the Giver's official title is The Receiver - that is, the Receiver of memories. The Giver asks Jonas to call him such because, as Jonas points out, there can only be ONE Receiver, and Jonas is training to become that Receiver.

Added: 39

Removed: 57

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWorldIsNotReady: for the memories.



* YouAreNotReady: The everyday citizens for the memories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouAreNotReady: The everyday citizens for the memories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HappinessIsMandatory: Well, actual happiness might disrupt things with excess energy, more "Quiet Contentment Is Mandatory."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jonas' slightly goofy, fun-loving friend Asher shows some signs of ADHD such as hyperactivity, impulsiveness, and blurting things out without thinking them through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguousDisorder: Gabriel does not meet typical developmental goals for babies/toddlers. It's vaguely implied that he had some kind of Pervasive Developmental Disorder. Note that when the book was written, PDD and Autism were thought to be much rarer than they are today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScienceFictionVersusFantasy / MohsScaleOfSciFiHardness: Everything that happens in the book is mostly within the realm of reality, except for the psychic way memories are passed from The Giver to The Receiver. No science is involved, just physical contact and concentration, implying use of some form of magic or supernatural ability. But in the sequels, especially ''Messenger'', certain people possess "gifts" that are essentially magical powers that perform a set task. There is even a [[ClapYourHandsIfYouBelieve forest that changes itself to reflect the attitudes of the members of a community]].

to:

* ScienceFictionVersusFantasy ScienceFantasy / MohsScaleOfSciFiHardness: Everything that happens in the book is mostly within the realm of reality, except for the psychic way memories are passed from The Giver to The Receiver. No science is involved, just physical contact and concentration, implying use of some form of magic or supernatural ability. But in the sequels, especially ''Messenger'', certain people possess "gifts" that are essentially magical powers that perform a set task. There is even a [[ClapYourHandsIfYouBelieve forest that changes itself to reflect the attitudes of the members of a community]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
First Time in the Sun

Added DiffLines:

* FirstTimeInTheSun: Among the memories Jonas gets from the Receiver is one of the sun, suggesting it's somehow filtered out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a spoiler tag to Gainax Ending


** One theory received by Lowry from a reader was that Jonas and Gabe traveled in a huge circle, and by the time they got back to the Community, it had been transformed by the memories of hope and love.

to:

** One theory received by Lowry from a reader was that Jonas [[spoiler:Jonas and Gabe traveled in a huge circle, and by the time they got back to the Community, it had been transformed by the memories of hope and love.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Newbery Medal-winning young adult novel by Lois Lowry. Known for its expertly merciless {{Deconstruction}} of the {{Utopia}}, and incidentally provides an introduction to the {{Dystopia}} genre for grade-school readers for whom some of the bits of ''NineteenEightyFour'' and ''BraveNewWorld'' would be a bit too saucy.

to:

Newbery Medal-winning young adult novel by Lois Lowry. Known for its expertly merciless {{Deconstruction}} of the {{Utopia}}, and incidentally provides an introduction to the {{Dystopia}} genre for grade-school readers for whom some of the bits of ''NineteenEightyFour'' and ''BraveNewWorld'' ''Literature/BraveNewWorld'' would be a bit too saucy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverSayDie: Not in the book -- eventually -- but in the Community.

to:

* NeverSayDie: Not Nobody *dies* in the book -- eventually -- but Community, they are "released" - or in the Community.rare cases, "lost".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BureaucraticallyArrangedMarriage: All couples are arranged this way.

Changed: 16

Removed: 495

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Repair Dont Respond. If the entry is incorrect, please fix it rather than add a Justifying Edit. Do not pothole to Fridge Logic


** Actually, it's more accurate to refer to the books as companions, not sequels, seeing as how they share no specific plot points, no characters, and only one theme: color.



** While that's stated in the book, the Giver later says that the elders actually did not know who was piloting the plane and that they sought his advice on what to do about it, implying that the plane was not, in fact, flown by a Community Pilot and that the announcement was made to ease the Community's collective mind.



** {{Averted}} in that the reader is meant to assume, when the Giver reveals that [[spoiler:Rosemary was his daughter, that he is actually the biological father of Rosemary, Jonas, the female Six, and Gabe.]] And, when you think about it, male genetic DNA has to come from ''[[FridgeLogic somewhere]]''...

to:

** {{Averted}} in that the reader is meant to assume, when the Giver reveals that [[spoiler:Rosemary was his daughter, that he is actually the biological father of Rosemary, Jonas, the female Six, and Gabe.]] And, when you think about it, male genetic DNA has to come from ''[[FridgeLogic somewhere]]''...''somewhere''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** {{Averted}} in that the reader is meant to assume, when the Giver reveals that [[spoiler:Rosemary was his daughter, that he is actually the biological father of Rosemary, Jonas, the female Six, and Gabe.]] And, when you think about it, male genetic DNA has to come from ''[[FridgeLogic somewhere]]''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just clarifying things.

Added DiffLines:

** While that's stated in the book, the Giver later says that the elders actually did not know who was piloting the plane and that they sought his advice on what to do about it, implying that the plane was not, in fact, flown by a Community Pilot and that the announcement was made to ease the Community's collective mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I just felt like fixing an inaccuracy.

Added DiffLines:

**Actually, it's more accurate to refer to the books as companions, not sequels, seeing as how they share no specific plot points, no characters, and only one theme: color.

Added: 159

Changed: 158

Removed: 396

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed natter


* CanonDisContinuity: The two sequels are... there's argument as to whether they really fit with ''The Giver'' or not, with Lowry not giving a concrete answer.



* CanonDisContinuity: The two sequels are... there's argument as to whether they really fit with ''The Giver'' or not.
** Actually, neither of them were ''official'' sequels; Lowry simply says that people can view them as such if they choose.
*** Considering Jonas is mentioned in the second book and appears in the third, it'd kind of hard to think of them as anything other than sequels, though.
**** We're using that weird, fluid definition of sequel that allows us to overwrite WordOfGod for things we don't like.

to:

* CanonDisContinuity: The two sequels are... there's argument DeliberatelyMonochrome: Use by the government, as to whether they really fit with ''The Giver'' or not.
** Actually, neither of them were ''official'' sequels; Lowry simply says that
people can view them as such if they choose.
*** Considering Jonas is mentioned in the second book and appears in the third, it'd kind of hard
have be (presumably genetically modified) to think of them as anything other than sequels, though.
**** We're using that weird, fluid definition of sequel that allows us
be unable to overwrite WordOfGod for things we don't like.see colors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* OccultBlueEyes: Having blue eyes, or at least light as opposed to dark, is very rare in the community in which the book is set, and seems to be a sign that one is capable of "seeing beyond".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Turns out, perfect painlessness isn't as easy to maintain as it looks. There are still memories of the time before Sameness, when people still knew want, and grief, and pain... and excitement... and happiness... and love.

to:

Turns out, perfect painlessness isn't as easy to maintain as it looks. There are still memories of the time before Sameness, when people still knew want, and grief, and pain... and excitement... and happiness... happiness and love.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** We're using that [[DisContinuity weird, fluid definition of sequel]] that allows us to overwrite WordOfGod for things we don't like.

to:

**** We're using that [[DisContinuity weird, fluid definition of sequel]] sequel that allows us to overwrite WordOfGod for things we don't like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisContinuity: The two sequels are... there's argument as to whether they really fit with ''The Giver'' or not.

to:

* DisContinuity: CanonDisContinuity: The two sequels are... there's argument as to whether they really fit with ''The Giver'' or not.

Top