Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Maskerade

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EyelashFluttering: Christine flutters her eyelashes when reviving from her swoon, or possibly when realising people aren't paying enough attention to her reviving from her swoon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ILetYouWin: Death cannot be beaten at Chess. Or Poker. Or games of chance. People can still challenge him, but unless Death is actively trying to lose, he'll always win no matter what he does. He ''can'', however, engage in some LoopholeAbuse by folding to Granny's hand of four queens, because he has "only four ones" - all of which are aces.


Added DiffLines:

* PetTheDog: Death [[ILetYouWin allows Granny Weatherwax to beat him at]] [[ChessWithDeath a hand of poker]] so that he won't have to reap a sick infant.

Added: 247

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChessWithDeath: As usual Death dislikes the traditional game, so Granny challenges him to a hand of poker instead for a boy's life. She wins, though it's implied that Death let her, because he's ''on our side''. Death had four "ones" -- an ace can either be counted as below the deuce or above the king. She also fixes his arm for him with her chiropractic know-how.

to:

* ChessWithDeath: As usual usual, Death dislikes the traditional game, so Granny challenges him to a hand of poker instead for a boy's life. She wins, though it's implied that Death let her, because he's ''on our side''. Death had four "ones" -- an ace can either be counted as below the deuce or above the king. She also fixes his arm for him with her chiropractic know-how.


Added DiffLines:

** Death and Granny Weatherwax [[ChessWithDeath play a hand of poker for the life of an infant]]. Death, naturally, wins - but, due to Granny having a hand of four queens and him having a hand of four aces, he folds, saying he only has four ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Possibly'' Christine. It's very hard to be sure, but when Christine makes sure to scream and faint before anything actually happens, and land in such a fashion that it probably doesn't hurt, Agnes sourly notes that Christine is actually very intelligent in some very specialised ways. Additionally, when Agnes finally gets mad and snaps at her when Christine dismisses her suspicions that [[spoiler: Walter]] is the Ghost, she seems to drop the excitable pixie act for a moment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: A... ''probably'' friendly jibe at [[MostWritersAreWriters the publishing industry]] in the form of Mr Goatberger, who "dreamed the dream of all who publish books, which was to have so much gold in your pockets that you would need to employ two people just to hold your trousers up". He is confused and shocked at the suggestion that he should give Nanny a share of the profits from her book -- as far as he's concerned, authors should pay for the privilege of having their work published, even though he's the one who goes on to sell them.
-->I don't know, authors wanting to be paid, good grief...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HotInHumanForm: Greebo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They're also the first to consider there might be [[spoiler: two Ghosts]] in the first place. "You recognized him because he'd got a mask on?"

Added: 240

Changed: 232

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
example indentation, Fainting is being divided into subtropes


* {{Fainting}}: Christine is a master of feminine fainting, with Agnes' inner monologue sourly noting that it's something she's intelligent about, considering how she managed to do so with such precision that it likely didn't even hurt.

to:

* {{Fainting}}: FakeFaint:
**
Christine is a master of [[FaintInShock feminine fainting, fainting]], with Agnes' inner monologue sourly noting that it's something she's intelligent about, considering how she managed to do so with such precision that it likely didn't even hurt.

Added: 431

Changed: 152

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitAndSwitch: Early on, Granny and Nanny discuss Greebo doing "It" when he got caught somewhere he shouldn't have been. It's a little later on it turns out "It" is Greebo turning human when startled.



* BrainlessBeauty: Christine is a heavy parody of the trope.

to:

* BrainlessBeauty: Christine is a heavy parody of the trope. She is both tremendously stupid and has an astoundingly low attention span for anything that's not her, zoning out within seconds.



* DramaQueen: According to Salzella everyone in opera is a highly-strung maniac on a good day.



* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. You can probably just blame the History Monks for that one.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. ''[[Literature/NightWatchDiscworld Night Watch]]''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would to recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. You can probably just blame the History Monks for that one.


Added DiffLines:

* FelonyMisdemeanour: Granny treats Nanny having written a book with the same sort of disdain usually held for committing actual crime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Big Name Fan is now Fandom VIP. Examples that don't fit the trope are being removed


* {{Tuckerization}}: Colette, of the "fascinatin' earrings" is based on BigNameFan and convention organizer Colette Reap, who once wore a pair of Clairecraft [[http://www.anorankh.demon.co.uk/afp/anorankh.html Anorankh]] pins as earrings to a signing.

to:

* {{Tuckerization}}: Colette, of the "fascinatin' earrings" is based on BigNameFan FandomVIP and convention organizer Colette Reap, who once wore a pair of Clairecraft [[http://www.anorankh.demon.co.uk/afp/anorankh.html Anorankh]] pins as earrings to a signing.

Added: 1828

Changed: 471

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrickJoke: From [[Literature/LordsAndLadies four books ago]]. In preparation for his wedding to Magrat, Verence tried to get a book on "[[TheTalk marital arts]]", but ended up with one on ''martial'' arts instead. Apparently he has since succeeded, since Nanny found such a book in the castle and spent a few minutes [[MustacheVandalism drawing moustaches]] on all the illustrations.

to:

* BrickJoke: BrickJoke:
**
From [[Literature/LordsAndLadies four books ago]]. In preparation for his wedding to Magrat, Verence tried to get a book on "[[TheTalk marital arts]]", but ended up with one on ''martial'' arts instead. Apparently he has since succeeded, since Nanny found such a book in the castle and spent a few minutes [[MustacheVandalism drawing moustaches]] on all the illustrations.illustrations.
** Early on, the opera staff regard it as a sign of dread that Mr. Bucket is the sort of person who thinks he can determine what people are like by looking in their eyes and shaking their hand. Later on, Granny Weatherwax reveals she thinks along the same lines.
** Nanny Ogg is familiar with Mrs. Palm's because her son stayed there while he was stealing lead off the roof of the opera house (in Nanny's mind, it's not a crime when an Ogg does it). Later on, Mr. Salzella lists off the list of "... accidents" the opera house has been having, but mentions he's pretty sure the missing lead from the roof isn't part of the Ghost's antics. [[spoiler:He'd know.]]



* ChandelierSwing: When Greebo is chasing the Opera Ghost around the Opera House.

to:

* ChandelierSwing: When Greebo is chasing the Opera Ghost around the Opera House. Reality itself actually realigns so he can accomplish this, rather than plummeting to his death.
* ChekhovsGag: Nanny Ogg's "suicider" scumble, mentioned in a footnote, comes up toward the end when she uses it to knock out Mrs. Plinge, and Nobbs and Detritus.



* GeniusDitz: Christine has all the skills and traits needed to be a legendary opera Diva...save for the actual singing part. Which fortunately isn't all that important nowadays.

to:

* GeniusDitz: Christine has all the skills and traits needed to be a legendary opera Diva... save for the actual singing part. Which fortunately isn't all that important nowadays.nowadays.
* GenreSavvy: Agnes knows full well that in stories the girl with "a great personality" is not the one who stumbles onto the villain's secret basement lair, but if it was someone like Christine, she'd find it no problem.


Added DiffLines:

* GoodOlWays: Nobby Nobbs complains about modern policing, where you have to do things like ''detect'' and ''catch people'', rather than the old days where you just let criminals run away and didn't try too hard to catch them.


Added DiffLines:

* OpenSecret: King Verence knows Nanny Ogg is brewing her aptly named scumble brand "Suicider", but won't (and ''can't'') get her to stop, so everyone operates on plausible deniability.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to trivia


* AlanSmithee: "Walter Plinge" is used as a fictitious actor name in cast lists in British theatre, when it is necessary to avoid a major plot twist of the TwoAliasesOneCharacter type being SpoiledByTheCastList. The real-life Walter Plinge was said to be a pub owner in London who a group of actors honored by using his name in this manner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: One might be forgiven for suspecting that [=PTerry=] may have had some financial differences of opinion with his publishers. Nanny initially pays Mr Goatberger to publish her book for her; when copies start flying off the shelves, the most she gets for it (until [[NeverMessWithGranny Granny intervenes]]) is her money back, plus three extra dollars which were apparently sent by mistake. Goatberger, whose dream (like all those who publish books) is to have have so much gold in his pockets that he has to employ two people just to hold his trousers up, is incredulous at the suggestion that authors should be ''paid'' for their work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: One might be forgiven for suspecting that [=PTerry=] may have had some financial differences of opinion with his publishers. Nanny initially pays Mr Goatberger to publish her book for her; when copies start flying off the shelves, the most she gets for it (until [[NeverMessWithGranny Granny intervenes]]) is her money back, plus three extra dollars which were apparently sent by mistake. Goatberger, whose dream (like all those who publish books) is to have have so much gold in his pockets that he has to employ two people just to hold his trousers up, is incredulous at the suggestion that authors should be ''paid'' for their work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InnocentSoprano: Played with. The cheerful, bubbly, and pretty but unbelievably dim Christine has no singing talent, and in fact only got the main role because her father is one of the opera's backers. Agnes has to sing in her place thanks to her MagicMusic talents letting her sing multiple voices at the same time — she can both be in the choir and cover for Christine's tone-deaf "soprano" squeaking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GeniusDitz: Christine has all the skills and traits needed to be a legendary opera Diva...save for the actual singing part. Which fortunately isn't all that important nowadays.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 180

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Adorkable}}: Walter Plinge, until [[spoiler: his Ghost persona is made the dominant one.]] Agnes seems disappointed, as Walter was fundamentally ''nicer'' before that happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. You can probably just blame the History Monks for that one.



** Commander Vimes does this off-screen. He sends Detritus and Corporal Nobbs to act as "undercover officers" in the last act of the book. The attention on them leaves the ''real'' undercover officer, [[spoiler:André]], free to get on with things.

to:

** Commander Vimes does this off-screen. He sends Detritus and Corporal Nobbs to act as "undercover officers" in the last act of the book. The attention on them leaves the ''real'' undercover officer, [[spoiler:André]], free to get on with things. Once she figures it out, Granny is grudgingly impressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButHeSoundsHandsome: When the Ghost offers "Perdita" singing lessons thinking she's Christine[[note]]Christine and Agnes switched rooms, but he can't tell because it's dark and Agnes decides to play along to find out what he wants[[/note]] she can't resist telling him, "Perdita is a lot better than me". She quickly comes to regret it, because, with his natural BrutalHonesty, he responds by telling her precisely why he doesn't consider Perdita worth his time. To be exact, while Perdita is an incredibly talented singer, whose talent he genuinely admires, she's also a fairly textbook BrawnHilda. And while he can train Christine to be as good as Perdita (he later modifies this once he finds out the truth, admitting that Christine won't ever be ''quite'' as good as her, not even after many months of one to one tuition), he can't train Perdita to be as slim, pretty, and graceful as Christine.

to:

* ButHeSoundsHandsome: When the Ghost offers "Perdita" singing lessons thinking she's Christine[[note]]Christine and Agnes switched rooms, but he can't tell because it's dark and Agnes decides to play along to find out what he wants[[/note]] she can't resist telling him, "Perdita is a lot better than me". She quickly comes to regret it, because, with his natural BrutalHonesty, he responds by telling her precisely why he doesn't consider Perdita worth his time. To be exact, while Perdita is an incredibly talented singer, whose talent he genuinely admires, she's also a fairly textbook BrawnHilda. And while he can train Christine to be as good as Perdita (he later modifies this once he finds out the truth, admitting that Christine won't ever be ''quite'' as good as her, not even after many months of one to one tuition), he can't train Perdita to be as slim, pretty, and graceful as Christine.



* {{Fainting}}: Christine is a master of feminine fainting, with Agnes' inner monologue sourly noting that it's something she's genuinely intelligent about, considering how she managed to do so with such precision that it likely didn't even hurt.

to:

* {{Fainting}}: Christine is a master of feminine fainting, with Agnes' inner monologue sourly noting that it's something she's genuinely intelligent about, considering how she managed to do so with such precision that it likely didn't even hurt.



* ItsAllAboutMe: Christine, [[SelfishGood not because she's a bad person]] (she appears to be genuinely fond of Agnes/Perdita) but because thanks to her chronically short attention span/lack of brains, [[LawfulStupidChaoticStupid she can't really comprehend anything more complex than her own immediate interests]]. This leads to a strange dichotomy with her being able to pick up stage-tricks like conveniently learning to faint in a dramatic pose whenever something "operatic" happens, but limits her ability to realize that Agnes is pretending to be her voice:

to:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Christine, [[SelfishGood not because she's a bad person]] (she appears to be genuinely fond of Agnes/Perdita) but because thanks to her chronically short attention span/lack of brains, [[LawfulStupidChaoticStupid she can't really comprehend anything more complex than her own immediate interests]]. This leads to a strange dichotomy with her being able to pick up stage-tricks like conveniently learning to faint in a dramatic pose whenever something "operatic" happens, but limits her ability to realize that Agnes is pretending to be her voice:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. However, ''Night Watch'' takes place after/during time shattering, so it's possible to {{handwave}} this as a side effect of history being put together imperfectly.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. However, ''Night Watch'' takes place after/during time shattering, so it's possible to {{handwave}} this as a side effect of history being put together imperfectly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The romantic aria Agnes learns about how hard it is for a character to leave her lover turns out, when translated, to have lyrics that go "this damn door sticks/it sticks no matter what the hell I do". Which disappoints Agnes, but hey, that ''would'' make it hard to leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CouldSayItBut: [[spoiler:Walter]] resorts to this to tell Nanny Ogg what they know about The Ghost, as they've been told not to tell but know they should.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''In the scullery, [[Obfuscating Stupidity Nanny Ogg]] smiled to herself.''

to:

-->''In the scullery, [[Obfuscating Stupidity [[ObfuscatingStupidity Nanny Ogg]] smiled to herself.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg not only has [[Obfuscating Stupidity"a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple"]] which she goes to some lengths to hide, but also a serious ruthless streak. Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".

to:

* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg not only has [[Obfuscating Stupidity"a [[ObfuscatingStupidity "a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple"]] which she goes to some lengths to hide, but also a serious ruthless streak. Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Agnes''' ''(to Walter)'': But it was ''me'' you taught!

to:

--> '''Agnes''' ''(to Walter)'': [[spoiler:Walter]])'': But it was ''me'' you taught!



-->''In the scullery, [[ObfuscatingStupidity Nanny Ogg]] smiled to herself.''
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg not only has "a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple" [[Obfuscating stupidity]] which she goes to some lengths to hide, but also a serious ruthless streak. Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".

to:

-->''In the scullery, [[ObfuscatingStupidity [[Obfuscating Stupidity Nanny Ogg]] smiled to herself.''
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg not only has "a [[Obfuscating Stupidity"a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple" [[Obfuscating stupidity]] apple"]] which she goes to some lengths to hide, but also a serious ruthless streak. Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Walter Plinge" is used as a alias for actors in British theatre cast list, when it is necessary to avoid a major plot twist of the TwoAliasesOneCharacter type being SpoiledByTheCastList. The twist here being [[spoiler:Walter is one of the characters pretending to be the opera ghost]].

to:

** "Walter Plinge" is used as a an alias for actors in British theatre cast list, lists, when it is necessary to avoid spoiling a major plot twist of the TwoAliasesOneCharacter type being SpoiledByTheCastList.type. The twist here being [[spoiler:Walter is one of the characters pretending to be the opera ghost]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MeaningfulName:
** "Walter Plinge" is used as a alias for actors in British theatre cast list, when it is necessary to avoid a major plot twist of the TwoAliasesOneCharacter type being SpoiledByTheCastList. The twist here being [[spoiler:Walter is one of the characters pretending to be the opera ghost]].
** Salzella (pronounced like “salt seller”) is a reference to Italian composer Antonio Salieri whose surname means "seller of salt"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrickJoke: From [[Literature/LordsAndLadies four books ago]]. In preparation for his wedding to Magrat, Verence tried to get a book on "[[TheTalk marital arts]]", but ended up with one on ''martial'' arts instead. Apparently he has since succeeded, since Nanny found such a book in the castle and spent a few minutes drawing moustaches on all the illustrations.

to:

* BrickJoke: From [[Literature/LordsAndLadies four books ago]]. In preparation for his wedding to Magrat, Verence tried to get a book on "[[TheTalk marital arts]]", but ended up with one on ''martial'' arts instead. Apparently he has since succeeded, since Nanny found such a book in the castle and spent a few minutes [[MustacheVandalism drawing moustaches moustaches]] on all the illustrations.

Added: 1236

Changed: 2894

Removed: 394

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingResponse: This exchange between Walter and Agnes has a devastating but utterly true one:

to:

* ArmorPiercingResponse: This exchange between Walter [[spoiler: Walter]] and Agnes has a devastating but utterly true one:



--> '''Walter''': Then you were ''very'' good. I suspect she will never be quite that good, even with many months of my tuition. But, Perdita, have you ever heard of the words "star quality"?

to:

--> '''Walter''': '''[[spoiler: Walter]]''': Then you were ''very'' good. I suspect she will never be quite that good, even with many months of my tuition. But, Perdita, have you ever heard of the words "star quality"?



--> '''Walter''': It is rarer.

to:

--> '''Walter''': '''[[spoiler: Walter]]''': It is rarer.



* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg, "a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple". Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".
-->''And don't go thinking I'm nice. I'm only nice compared to Esme, but so is practic'ly everyone.''

to:

* BewareTheNiceOnes: Nanny Ogg, Ogg not only has "a mind like a buzzsaw behind a face like an elderly apple".apple" [[Obfuscating stupidity]] which she goes to some lengths to hide, but also a serious ruthless streak. Sharp remarks from her are described like "being bitten by a friendly dog".
-->''And -->"And don't go thinking I'm nice. I'm only nice compared to Esme, but so is practic'ly everyone.''"



* BrutalHonesty: One the Ghost's defining character traits, with responses to questions tending to be along these lines. He's not doing it to be cruel, but some of his responses can be absolutely ''vicious'' in their accuracy, particularly in his response to Agnes (pretending to be Christine in the dark) when she says [[ButHeSoundsHandsome (correctly) that "Perdita" is much better than 'her' (Christine)]].
* ButHeSoundsHandsome: When the Ghost offers "Perdita" singing lessons thinking she's Christine[[note]]Christine and Agnes switched rooms, but he can't tell because it's dark and Agnes decides to play along to find out what he wants[[/note]] she can't resist telling him, "Perdita is a lot better than me". She quickly comes to regret it, because he responds by telling her precisely why he doesn't consider Perdita worth his time. To be exact, while Perdita is an incredibly talented singer, she's also a fairly textbook BrawnHilda. And while he can train Christine to be as good as Perdita (he later modifies this once he finds out the truth, admitting that Christine won't ever be quite as good as Perdita, not even after many months of one to one tuition), he can't train Perdita to be as slim, pretty, and graceful as Christine.

to:

* BrutalHonesty: One the Ghost's [[spoiler: (or more accurately, Walter's as the Ghost)]] defining character traits, with responses to questions tending to be along these lines. He's not doing it to be cruel, but some of his responses can be absolutely ''vicious'' in their accuracy, particularly in his response to Agnes (pretending to be Christine in the dark) when she says [[ButHeSoundsHandsome (correctly) that "Perdita" is much better than 'her' (Christine)]].
(Christine)]].
-->"This is true. But while I can teach you to sing like her, I cannot teach her to look like you."
* ButHeSoundsHandsome: When the Ghost offers "Perdita" singing lessons thinking she's Christine[[note]]Christine and Agnes switched rooms, but he can't tell because it's dark and Agnes decides to play along to find out what he wants[[/note]] she can't resist telling him, "Perdita is a lot better than me". She quickly comes to regret it, because because, with his natural BrutalHonesty, he responds by telling her precisely why he doesn't consider Perdita worth his time. To be exact, while Perdita is an incredibly talented singer, whose talent he genuinely admires, she's also a fairly textbook BrawnHilda. And while he can train Christine to be as good as Perdita (he later modifies this once he finds out the truth, admitting that Christine won't ever be quite ''quite'' as good as Perdita, her, not even after many months of one to one tuition), he can't train Perdita to be as slim, pretty, and graceful as Christine.



* ChekhovsSkill: When Granny calculates the royalties Nanny should be getting, the text notes that she's "keenly numerate" because she suspects anyone using numbers is trying to get away with something. At the end of the novel[[spoiler: she quickly deciphers the Opera House accounts book, which has been carefully curated by Salzella to conceal his embezzlement.]]

to:

* ChekhovsSkill: When Granny calculates the royalties Nanny should be getting, the text notes that she's "keenly numerate" because she suspects anyone using numbers is trying to get away with something. At the end of the novel[[spoiler: she quickly deciphers the Opera House accounts book, which has been carefully curated by Salzella to conceal his embezzlement.]]embezzlement]].



* ContrivedCoincidence: Played for laughs when someone's long-lost love shows up at the very end, with no real impact on the plot. Hey, that's how opera works.

to:

* ContrivedCoincidence: Played for laughs when someone's long-lost love shows up at the very end, with no real impact on the plot.plot, to Agnes' despair. Hey, that's how opera works.



* DoesNotLikeSpam: Basilica has gotten incredibly sick of pasta, but he can't tell anyone he hates it because it's part of his makeover as a singer from Brindisi.

to:

* DoesNotLikeSpam: Basilica has gotten incredibly sick of pasta, pasta (it doesn't help that it's usually cooked very badly), but he can't tell anyone he hates it because it's part of his makeover as a singer from Brindisi.



* DoorDumb: Either the person singing Porta Maledetta (literally "Damn Door" in [[FantasyCounterpartCulture Italian, er, Brindisian]]) is Door Dumb or the person who labeled the door in the first place was, because it's labeled Pull and indeed she is pulling...perhaps it should be marked Push? (Then again, it sticks no matter what the hell she does.)

to:

* DoorDumb: Either the person singing Porta Maledetta (literally "Damn Door" in [[FantasyCounterpartCulture Italian, er, Brindisian]]) is Door Dumb or the person who labeled labelled the door in the first place was, because it's labeled Pull and indeed she is pulling...perhaps it should be marked Push? (Then again, it sticks no matter what the hell she does.)



* DudeNotFunny: In-universe example. Salzella makes several jokes about people who have just been murdered; Mr. Bucket finds them distasteful. [[spoiler: This takes on a whole new meaning after the reveal Salzella was the one who did the murders]].

to:

* DudeNotFunny: In-universe example. Salzella makes several jokes about people who have just been murdered; Mr. Bucket finds them distasteful. [[spoiler: This takes on a whole new meaning after the reveal Salzella was the one who did committed the murders]].



* {{Fainting}}: Christine is a master of feminine fainting.

to:

* {{Fainting}}: Christine is a master of feminine fainting.fainting, with Agnes' inner monologue sourly noting that it's something she's genuinely intelligent about, considering how she managed to do so with such precision that it likely didn't even hurt.



** Dame Timpani does this as well, pointedly, before resorting to hysterics to try and get some of the attention back from Christine. It doesn't work.



* {{Flynning}}: Shown and mentioned between the two ghosts, until it becomes deadly real.
** Except, in true Discworld fashion, they're ''still just Flynning''.
* {{Foreshadowing}}: Henry Slugg from Ankh-Morpork becomes Enrico Basilica from Brindisi, because "the trick is to make sure that everywhere you go, you are from somewhere else." Later, Andre claims that he "...used to teach music to the Seriph's children in Klatch" indicating he isn't who he claims to be.

to:

* {{Flynning}}: Shown and mentioned between [[spoiler: the two ghosts, Ghosts]], until it becomes deadly real.
** Except,
real. Except not, because in true Discworld fashion, they're ''still just Flynning''.
* {{Foreshadowing}}: Henry Slugg from Ankh-Morpork becomes Enrico Basilica from Brindisi, because "the trick is to make sure that everywhere you go, you are from somewhere else." else", with Nanny noting that conjurers are the same way, making grandiose claims about being fresh from the Court of Klatch. Later, Andre claims that he "...used to teach music to the Seriph's children in Klatch" indicating he isn't who he claims to be.



* HumanityEnsues: The human-form Greebo the cat from ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' reappears, pressed into service as Granny's fake paramour and bodyguard.

to:

* HumanityEnsues: The human-form Greebo the cat from ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' reappears, first as a gag about how he tends to do it when in a tight corner (thereafter spending most of his brief time as a human desperately looking for a pair of trousers), and a nod to the Discworld shapeshifting concept (once an object/living creature has taken a form, it is much easier to take it again). Later, he's pressed into service as Granny's fake paramour and bodyguard.



* HypocriticalHumor: The villain gives a long FinalSpeech about how ridiculous opera conventions like the long FinalSpeech are. This comes not long after he claims to be the OnlySaneMan, using multiple exclamation marks (a sure sign of madness).
* IJustWantToBeNormal: Agnes.
** Or at least, she wants to be able to ''choose'' what she wants to stand out ''for''.

to:

* HypocriticalHumor: The villain gives a long FinalSpeech about how ridiculous opera conventions like the long FinalSpeech are. This comes not long after he claims to be the OnlySaneMan, using multiple exclamation marks (a sure sign of madness).
madness). Oh, and [[spoiler: he's not been skewered through the heart - the sword went between arm and body, to make it look like it]]. The absurdity of this is lampshaded.
* IJustWantToBeNormal: Agnes.
**
Agnes. Or at least, she wants to be able to ''choose'' what she wants to stand out ''for''.



* ItsAllAboutMe: Christine, [[SelfishGood not because she's a bad person]] but because [[LawfulStupidChaoticStupid she can't really comprehend anything more complex than her own immediate interests]]. This leads to a strange dichotomy with her being able to pick up stage-tricks like conveniently learning to faint in a dramatic pose whenever something "operatic" happens, but limits her ability to realize that Agnes is pretending to be her voice:

to:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Christine, [[SelfishGood not because she's a bad person]] (she appears to be genuinely fond of Agnes/Perdita) but because thanks to her chronically short attention span/lack of brains, [[LawfulStupidChaoticStupid she can't really comprehend anything more complex than her own immediate interests]]. This leads to a strange dichotomy with her being able to pick up stage-tricks like conveniently learning to faint in a dramatic pose whenever something "operatic" happens, but limits her ability to realize that Agnes is pretending to be her voice:



* LongLastingLastWords: The death of opera director Salzella goes on, and on, and on for a ''long'' time...

to:

* LongLastingLastWords: The death of [[spoiler: opera director Salzella Salzella]] goes on, and on, and on for a ''long'' time...



* MaskOfConfidence: The Phantom, [[spoiler:Walter Plinge,]] is not suspected of what he is because without the mask he is acting like an altogether different person.

to:

* MaskOfConfidence: The Phantom, [[spoiler:Walter Ghost - [[spoiler:the original, Walter Plinge,]] is not suspected of what he is because without the mask mask, he is acting acts like an altogether different person.



-->You can recognize him because he's got a mask on? You recognize him because you ''don't'' know who he is?

to:

-->You can recognize him because he's got ''got a mask on? You recognize him because you ''don't'' know who he is?on?''



* MotiveRant: [[spoiler: Salazella gives one after being revealed before dying.]]

to:

* MotiveRant: [[spoiler: Salazella Salzella gives one after being revealed before dying.]]



* NoodleIncident: The scene where Nanny Ogg takes over serving drinks during the opera and decides to take some revenge on behalf of Mrs. Plinge. The narration cuts away as she shakes up a couple of champagne bottles and steps out into the corridor, and picks up again as she ducks into a room while a lot of people run past. What, exactly, she did is never elaborated; some fairly simple scenarios are obvious, but Nanny wouldn't be a witch if she wasn't good at inventive cruelty.

to:

* NoodleIncident: The scene where Nanny Ogg takes over serving drinks during the opera and decides to take some revenge on the demanding customers on behalf of Mrs. Plinge. The narration cuts away as she shakes up a couple of champagne bottles and steps out into the corridor, and picks up again as she ducks into a room while a lot of people run past. What, exactly, she did is never elaborated; some fairly simple scenarios are obvious, but Nanny wouldn't be a witch if she wasn't good at inventive cruelty.



** The villain has done this to the theater's account books. It ''looks'' like it's been slap-dashedly put together by people who don't think money is important, and the owner spends most of the story trying to work out what they were trying to record. When Granny gets time to look at it she realizes that it's been deliberately messed with to hide massive theft; for instance, she finds a page where the columns are misaligned to hide that they don't all have the same number of entries.

to:

** The villain has done this to the theater's opera's account books. It ''looks'' like it's been slap-dashedly put together by people who don't think money is important, and the owner spends most of the story trying to work out what they were trying to record. When Granny gets time to look at it she realizes that it's been deliberately messed with to hide massive theft; for instance, she finds a page where the columns are misaligned to hide that they don't all have the same number of entries.



* RagingStiffie: Salzella and Bucket find it ... awkward ... to leave the table after sampling Nanny's Chocolate Delight with Special Secret Sauce, and when they do depart hurriedly, it's in a ''very'' hunched manner. Interestingly, it doesn't seem to have the same effect on Enrico Basilica, possibly because being face-deep in chocolate sauce has a deeper effect on him than the sauce's aphrodisiac effects normally have on people.

to:

* RagingStiffie: Salzella and Bucket find it ... awkward ...''awkward'' ... to leave the table after sampling Nanny's Chocolate Delight with Special Secret Sauce, and when they do depart hurriedly, it's in a ''very'' hunched manner. Interestingly, it doesn't seem to have the same effect on Enrico Basilica, possibly because being face-deep in chocolate sauce has a deeper effect on him than the sauce's aphrodisiac effects normally have on people.people - though Granny speculates that it hasn't had any effect "on account of not touching the sides."



** There is a mention in Wyrd Sisters as well; Nanny can't magic the torture implements that are made of iron. It's also often been indicated that witch magic is much better at affecting things that are or once were alive, such as wood, than metal.

to:

** There is a mention in Wyrd Sisters ''Wyrd Sisters'' as well; Nanny can't magic the torture implements that are made of iron. It's also often been indicated that witch magic is much better at affecting things that are or once were alive, such as wood, than metal.



** Granny Weatherwax's observation, on arriving at Mrs. Palm's house, that Colette is wearing some very interesting earrings is an allusion to a prominent Pratchett fan, Colette Reap, who once attended a signing event wearing Ankh earrings
** "Walter Plinge" is a real-life pseudonym used by actors who don't want to be associated with early minor parts (similar to "A.N. Other") and the character's description clearly evokes Frank Spencer from ''Series/SomeMothersDoAveEm'' (Creator/MichaelCrawford, the first actor who played the musical version's Phantom, was once best known for that role).

to:

** Granny Weatherwax's observation, on arriving at Mrs. Palm's house, that Colette is wearing some very interesting earrings is an allusion to a prominent Pratchett fan, Colette Reap, who once attended a signing event wearing Ankh earrings
earrings.
** "Walter Plinge" is a real-life pseudonym used by actors who don't want to be associated with early minor parts (similar to "A.N. Other") and the character's description clearly evokes Frank Spencer from ''Series/SomeMothersDoAveEm'' (Creator/MichaelCrawford, the first actor who played [[spoiler: the musical version's Phantom, Phantom]], was once best known for that role).role).
*** His description also somewhat evokes a young Creator/AndrewLloydWebber, as does his [[spoiler: creation of the modern musical, particularly the Disc's version of {{Theatre/Cats}}]].



** Mrs Lawsley would rather be at the music hall listening to Nellie Stamp sing "She Sits Among the Cabbages and Leeks". This is a reference to an urban legend that Marie Lloyd had a song which was originally "She Sits Among the Cabbages and Peas", but was changed to "Leeks" when MoralGuardians objected to the double meaning (but not, you will note, to actually remove that meanig in any way).

to:

** Mrs Lawsley Lawsey would rather be at the music hall listening to Nellie Stamp sing "She Sits Among the Cabbages and Leeks". This is a reference to an urban legend that Marie Lloyd had a song which was originally "She Sits Among the Cabbages and Peas", but was changed to "Leeks" when MoralGuardians objected to the double meaning (but not, you will note, to actually remove that meanig meaning in any way).



** When Agnes finishes one last yell, going from one side of the audible spectrum to the other, Nanny Ogg remarks "''Now'' it's over". [[DontExplainTheJoke Agnes is very large, and they're in an opera.]]

to:

** When Agnes finishes one last yell, scream, going from one side of the audible spectrum to the other, Nanny Ogg remarks "''Now'' it's over". [[DontExplainTheJoke Agnes is very large, and they're in an opera.]]



--> '''[[spoiler: Walter]]''': It is rarer.

to:

--> '''[[spoiler: Walter]]''': [[BrutalHonesty It is rarer.]]



* UndercoverCopReveal
* VillainousUnderdog: [[spoiler: Salzella]] is really just a guy, and he's going up against a pair of witches who were last seen sending the FairFolk packing. The only thing saving him is that exactly ''because'' he's not a terrifying magical menace, Granny considers it wrong for her to fight him directly.

to:

* UndercoverCopReveal
UndercoverCopReveal: [[spoiler: Andre]].
* VillainousUnderdog: [[spoiler: Salzella]] is really just a guy, and he's going up against a pair of witches who were last seen sending the FairFolk packing. The only thing saving him when he's found out and confronted at the end is that exactly ''because'' he's not a terrifying magical menace, Granny considers it wrong for her to fight him directly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatch''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. However, ''Night Watch'' takes place after/during time shattering, so it's possible to {{handwave}} this as a side effect of history being put together imperfectly.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: [[spoiler:Andre]] being a secret policeman becomes this after ''Literature/NightWatch''.''Literature/NightWatchDiscworld''. While most of this isn't too much of a problem - it makes sense for Vimes would recruit undercover policemen - there's a whacking great problem with the name. Specifically, the idea that he would ''ever'' create anything even ''approximating'' a secret police division that's named the 'Cable Street Particulars' after the reveal of what the [[ANaziByAnyOtherName original Particulars were like]] makes about as much sense as UsefulNotes/MahatmaGandhi advocating the foundation of a Fourth Reich. However, ''Night Watch'' takes place after/during time shattering, so it's possible to {{handwave}} this as a side effect of history being put together imperfectly.

Top