Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HonorHarrington

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I keep noticing these tiny corrections


* MovingTheGoalposts: An admiral who did not care for the development of LAC-based tactics and technology managed to get himself put on charge of the evaluation board and started putting more and more restrictions on how the weapons could be used in an effort to get a test battle in which the new [=LACs=] would be decisively defeated. Captain Truman recognized the plan and sent notification letters to even ''higher'' ranking officers; not asking them to change anything or intervene on her behalf, but simply appraising them of the situation so that they would look at ''all'' the data when it came time to review the exercise. [[spoiler: When the Peeps launch an actual attack on the system the entire plan becomes moot, as the [=LACs=] are put into real combat and perform superbly]].

to:

* MovingTheGoalposts: An admiral who did not care for the development of LAC-based tactics and technology managed to get himself put on in charge of the evaluation board and started putting more and more restrictions on how the weapons could be used in an effort to get a test battle in which the new [=LACs=] would be decisively defeated. Captain Truman recognized the plan and sent notification letters to even ''higher'' ranking officers; not asking them to change anything or intervene on her behalf, but simply appraising them of the situation so that they would look at ''all'' the data when it came time to review the exercise. [[spoiler: When the Peeps launch an actual attack on the system the entire plan becomes moot, as the [=LACs=] are put into real combat and perform superbly]].



* NervesOfSteel: Half of the characters, but ''especially'' Honor, if only because she is routinely thrown into the worst situations. (Hundreds or thousands of other people are along with her in the same situations, but she is in command, and their lives are ''her'' responsibility.)

to:

* NervesOfSteel: Half of the characters, but ''especially'' Honor, if only because she is routinely thrown into the worst situations. (Hundreds Hundreds or thousands of other people are along with her in the same situations, but she is in command, and their lives are ''her'' responsibility.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoTranshumanismAllowed: The Beowulf Life Code outlaws anything that adjusts the human body beyond its natural limits, even [[ReallySevenHundredYearsOld prolong]] is described as just modifying and extending natural biological processes as opposed to drastically altering the human genome. Honor has faced occasional issues with her own status as a "Genie," a person whose ancestry includes genetic modifcation (In her case, the Meyerdahl First Wave modification which adjusted her ancestors for life on the high-gravity world of Sphinx). The role of the Mesa is designed to explore this. [[spoiler: David Weber has commented that Mesa has perfectly valid concerns and is right about Beowulf holding back humanity by outlawing transhumanism, but that they have been corrupted by hundreds of years of insular planning and hiding and now believe they must show that Beowulf is wrong by force]].

to:

* NoTranshumanismAllowed: The Beowulf Life Code outlaws anything that adjusts the human body beyond its natural limits, even [[ReallySevenHundredYearsOld prolong]] is described as just modifying and extending natural biological processes as opposed to drastically altering the human genome. Honor has faced occasional issues with her own status as a "Genie," a person whose ancestry includes genetic modifcation (In her case, the Meyerdahl First Wave modification which adjusted her ancestors for life on the high-gravity world of Sphinx). The role of the Mesa is designed to explore this. [[spoiler: this; David Weber has commented that Mesa has perfectly valid concerns and is right about Beowulf holding back humanity by outlawing transhumanism, but that they have been corrupted by hundreds of years of insular planning and hiding and now believe they must show that Beowulf is wrong by force]].force.

Added: 464

Changed: 483

Removed: 298

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ObfuscatingStupidity: A number of Havenite military and political officers, most spectacularly Admiral Lester "Cowboy" Tourvile. It was something of a survival trait in the old [=PRH=], thanks to StateSec.
** Kevin Usher practiced obfuscating ''[[PlayingDrunk drunkenness]]'', for a similar reason. ([[spoiler: Well, that practice was also helped by his being owed a favor by Saint-Just, for Usher's role in the conspiracy to overthrow the Legislaturalists]]).
--->"Lesson number - what is it, now? - eight, I think. A ''reputation'' for being a drunk can keep you out of as much trouble as being one gets you into." [Usher] padded to his couch and sunk into it. "I've got a high capacity for alcohol, but I don't drink anywhere near as much as people think."

to:

* ObfuscatingStupidity: ObfuscatingStupidity:
**
A number of Havenite military and political officers, most spectacularly Admiral Lester "Cowboy" Tourvile. Tourville. It was something of a survival trait in the old [=PRH=], thanks to StateSec.
** Kevin Usher practiced obfuscating ''[[PlayingDrunk drunkenness]]'', for a similar reason. ([[spoiler: Well, that practice was also helped by his being owed a favor by Saint-Just, for Usher's role in the conspiracy to overthrow the Legislaturalists]]).
--->"Lesson number - what is it, now? - eight, I think. A ''reputation'' for being a drunk can keep you out of as much trouble as being one gets you into." [Usher] padded to his couch and sunk into it. "I've got a high capacity for alcohol, but I don't drink anywhere near as much as people think."
StateSec.


Added DiffLines:

* PlayingDrunk: Kevin Usher put on a charade as a hopeless (and constant) drunk in order to avoid suspicion while under the authority of the Committee of Publc Safety.
-->"Lesson number - what is it, now? - eight, I think. A ''reputation'' for being a drunk can keep you out of as much trouble as being one gets you into." [Usher] padded to his couch and sunk into it. "I've got a high capacity for alcohol, but I don't drink anywhere near as much as people think."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Warning: Spoilers ahead. As a LongRunner, [[LateArrivalSpoiler Late Arrival Spoilers]] of the early books are unavoidable. Caution advised.'''

to:

'''Warning: Spoilers ahead. As a LongRunner, [[LateArrivalSpoiler Late {{Late Arrival Spoilers]] Spoiler}}s of the early books are unavoidable. Caution advised.'''

Changed: 271

Removed: 111

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trying to actually explain the usage


* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters: Several examples, many of them, of course, from Haven, where seemingly the leading cause of death is being in politics. Or aircar accidents, [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch depending on who you ask.]]
** This proves especially nasty when a prominent politician ACTUALLY has an aircar accident at a very bad time.

to:

* YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters: Several examples, many Haven goes through several cycles of them, of course, from Haven, where seemingly revolution and new governments, each time legitimizing the leading cause of death is being in politics. Or aircar accidents, [[TheCoronerDothProtestTooMuch depending on who you ask.]]
** This proves especially nasty when a prominent politician ACTUALLY has an aircar accident at a very bad time.
previous rebels as freedom fighters and fighting new "terrorists."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This proves especially nasty when a prominent politician ACTUALLY has an aircar accident at a very bad time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Warning: Tropes may have spoilers. Caution advised.'''

to:

'''Warning: Tropes may have spoilers.Spoilers ahead. As a LongRunner, [[LateArrivalSpoiler Late Arrival Spoilers]] of the early books are unavoidable. Caution advised.'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsentAliens: Not really absent, just... not important. Humanity has made contact with at least twelve sapient species during its exploration of the galaxy, and at least one multi-stellar species has gone extinct (The Alphanes), but they are not involved in the story at all. The Medusans of Basilisk are important in the first novel, but fade into the background once Honor leaves their system since they only possess a Bronze Age level of technology. The only sapient aliens that have a presence throughout the series are the treecats of Sphinx, primarily represented by Nimitz, the 'cat who has adopted Honor.

to:

* AbsentAliens: Not really Used in spirit. They're not actually absent, just... not Not important. Humanity has made contact with at least twelve sapient species during its exploration of the galaxy, and at least one multi-stellar species has gone extinct (The Alphanes), but they are not involved in the story at all. The Medusans of Basilisk are important in the first novel, but fade into the background once Honor leaves their system since they only possess a Bronze Age level of technology. The only sapient aliens that have a presence throughout the series are the treecats of Sphinx, primarily represented by Nimitz, the 'cat who has adopted Honor.Honor-- and tropewise they're more Manticoran BondCreatures than an alien faction.

Added: 440

Changed: 17

Removed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NWordPrivileges: Honor makes her guest feel uncomfortable when she explains that she is a "Genie". She then goes on to venture that most people on her homeworld are genetically modified by now they just do not think about it.



* NicknamingTheEnemy: "Manties" (Star Kingdom/Empire of Manticore), "Peeps" (People's Repubic of Haven),"Andies" (Andermani Empire), "Sillies" or "Confeds" (Silesian Confederacy), and "Sollies" (Solarian League).



* NWordPrivileges: Honor makes her guest feel uncomfortable when she explains that she is a "Genie". She then goes on to venture that most people on her homeworld are genetically modified by now they just do not think about it.



** Kevin Usher practiced obfuscating ''drunkenness'', for a similar reason. ([[spoiler: Well, that practice was also helped by his being owed a favor by Saint-Just, for Usher's role in the conspiracy to overthrow the Legislaturalists]]).

to:

** Kevin Usher practiced obfuscating ''drunkenness'', ''[[PlayingDrunk drunkenness]]'', for a similar reason. ([[spoiler: Well, that practice was also helped by his being owed a favor by Saint-Just, for Usher's role in the conspiracy to overthrow the Legislaturalists]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s neither trope. This is a flat statement of (at least tentative) bisexuality, so it\'s not Les Yay (Which is about subtext), and the laconic Even The Girls Want Her specifies how it\'s about straight women, whereas (Like I said) this was an admission of bisexuality


* LesYay:
** Emily Alexander says she would be attracted to Honor, if she wasn't paralyzed, in a conversation with Allison. (This is also a case of EvenTheGirlsWantHer.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Emily Alexander says she would be attracted to Honor, if she wasn't paralyzed, in a conversation with Allison.

to:

** Emily Alexander says she would be attracted to Honor, if she wasn't paralyzed, in a conversation with Allison. (This is also a case of EvenTheGirlsWantHer.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Combined with the fact that the SLN would have to act ''without'' an official declaration of war (which it's clear Beowulf would veto) this would doubtless cause a political storm. This is ExactlyAsPlanned for the Mesan Alignment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Combined with the fact that the SLN would have to act ''without'' an official declaration of war (which it's clear Beowulf would veto) this would doubtless cause a political storm. This is ExactlyAsPlanned for the Mesan Alignment.

Removed: 274

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Berry\'s straight, and she and Thandi explicitly think of each other as little and big sister.


** The ''first'' thing Berry says to Thandi when they meet is "if you were a guy, I'd tear my clothes off right now!" Various lines throughout ''Crown of Slaves'' indicate that if Thandi were not already taken or completely straight herself, Berry might have done so anyway.

Added: 148

Removed: 151

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IThoughtItMeant: Despite what it sounds like, Manticore is not at war with [[http://marshmallowpeeps.com trays of marshmallow chickens and bunnies]].


Added DiffLines:

* NamesTheSame: Despite what it sounds like, Manticore is not at war with [[http://marshmallowpeeps.com trays of marshmallow chickens and bunnies]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiHero: Mostly as secondary characters. Chief Harkness, Jeremy X, Klaus Hauptmann, etc. The Spook Duo are more than willing to ignore some pesky little rules in their pursuits, too...

to:

* AntiHero: Mostly as secondary characters. Chief Harkness, Jeremy X, Klaus Hauptmann, etc. The Spook Duo (Victor Cachat and Anton Zilwicki) are more than willing to ignore some pesky little rules in their pursuits, too...too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Honor Harrington'' is a MilitaryScienceFiction series by DavidWeber. The book series is mainly set around the adventures of the titular heroine, although we see a fair amount of the wider universe. The primary conflict of the storyline is the Kingdom of Manticore (The Good Guys) vs. The (People's) Republic of Haven (The Bad Guys Who Get Something Of A HeelFaceTurn).

to:

''Honor Harrington'' is a MilitaryScienceFiction series by DavidWeber. The book series is mainly set around the adventures of the titular heroine, although we see a fair amount of the wider universe. The primary conflict of the storyline is the Kingdom of Manticore (The Good Guys) vs. The (People's) Republic of Haven (The ([[AntiVillain The Bad Guys Who Get Something Of A HeelFaceTurn).
Aren't Entirely Unsympathetic]]).

Added: 374

Changed: 372

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WineIsClassy: William Alexander is a real connoisseur of the fine vintages and explicitly calls other drinks uncultured and low-class. Played with in that it is his older brother, Hamish, who holds the family title, and he doesn't drink anything except beer. Ham even [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] over his brother's love of wine in one of their frequent after-dinner banters.

to:

* WineIsClassy: WineIsClassy:
**
William Alexander is a real connoisseur of the fine vintages and explicitly calls other drinks uncultured and low-class. Played with in that it is his older brother, Hamish, who holds the family title, and he doesn't drink anything except beer. Ham even [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] over his brother's love of wine in one of their frequent after-dinner banters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Honor's father Alfred is a self-professed wine snob and gourmand; Honor refuses to follow in his shoes, instead preferring beer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Anyone who fails Albrecht Detweiler is terrified he'll adopt this policy, though there have been no examples of it (yet).

to:

** Anyone who fails Albrecht Detweiler has a reputation of executing those who fail him, but once Aldona Anisimovna is terrified he'll adopt this policy, though promoted to the inner circle he confesses that his bark is a lot worse than his bite, at least when it comes to higher-ranking operaties, since he knows there have been no examples of it (yet).is a difference between failure and gross incompetence/treason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Anyone who fails Albrecht Detweiler is terrified he'll adopt this policy, though there have been no examples of it (yet).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, in chapter 35 of ''Ashes of Victory'', Weber says that missiles accelerating at 48,000''g'' (470 kps-squared) over a distance of 3.5 light-minutes will have a final velocity of 0.83''c''. But under special relativity, at high speeds an object accelerating at 470 km/s[[superscript:2]] will actually gain ''less than'' 470 km/s of velocity every second. For an object accelerating over a given distance, where the distance is measured ''in a fixed observer's reference frame'', the formula for how much time it takes ''in the accelerating object's reference frame'' is T = (''c''/a) * [=ArcCosh=] (a * d/''c''[[superscript:2]] + 1), which for these missiles works out to T = 504 seconds. The formula for the final velocity you'll have when accelerating for a certain length of time, where the time is measured ''in the accelerating object's reference frame'', is v = ''c'' * Tanh(a*T/''c''). Even if we generously assume that these missiles can actually accelerate for a full 9 minutes (T = 540 seconds) in their own reference frames, their final velocity will only be '''0.69''c''''', not 0.83''c''.

Added: 714

Changed: 145

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeButImpractical: Even Honor admits that the Grav Lance represents a potentially revolutionary military technology that could, if properly developed, upset the entire manner of space combat, but she also decries the fact that it has ''not'' yet been developed to that level. As it is, though it has the ability to render even a superdreadnaught defenseless, it can only function at 1/4 (or less) the range of all other existing weaponry, and that assumes it does not malfunction all on its own.



* SecretWeapon: The Grav Lance in ''On Basilisk Station.'' It's devastatingly effective, but only if you can trick your enemy into closing to point-blank range.

to:

* SecretWeapon: SecretWeapon:
**
The Grav Lance in ''On Basilisk Station.'' It's It is devastatingly effective, [[AwesomeButImpractical but only if you can trick your enemy into closing to point-blank range.at 1/4 (or less) the range of all other weaponry]] and assuming it doesn't malfunction all on its own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FixedForwardFacingWeapon: Spine-mounted grasers on [=LACs=].

to:

* FixedForwardFacingWeapon: Spine-mounted grasers on the later generations of [=LACs=].



** In ''Ashes of Victory'', there were three: Project Ghostrider, the Pod Superdreadnoughts, and the ''Shrike''-class LACs.

to:

** In ''Ashes of Victory'', there were three: Project Ghostrider, the Pod Superdreadnoughts, and the ''Shrike''-class LACs.[=LACs=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''Ashes of Victory'', there were three: Project Ghostrider, the Pod Superdreadnoughts, and the ''Shrike''-class LACs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Literally when a hardcore fundamentalist Grayson [[spoiler:kills the head of his own church in an attempt to assassinate Honor. He suffers a BSOD upon realising and his grief stricken testimony is the main plank in the case that convicts the Steadholder Burdette of treason and murder.]]

to:

** Literally when when, in ''Flag in Exile'', a hardcore fundamentalist Grayson [[spoiler:kills the head of his own church in an attempt to assassinate Honor. He suffers a BSOD upon realising and his grief stricken testimony is the main plank in the case that convicts the Steadholder Burdette of treason and murder.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SinkTheLifeboats: PRH propaganda claimed that Manticore would shoot up escape pods of destroyed PRN warships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LeaveNoSurvivors: Narrowed averted in ''Echoes''. When the combined Grayson-Manticore fleet with the new [[MacrossMissileMassacre podnaughts]] rides to [[spoiler: the defence of Basilisk]], Earl White Haven nearly has a heart attack when he thinks Admiral Yanakov ordered no quarter. Fortunately, the latter only called for no mercy.

to:

* LeaveNoSurvivors: Narrowed averted in ''Echoes''. When In ''Echoes of Honor'', when the combined Grayson-Manticore fleet with the new [[MacrossMissileMassacre podnaughts]] rides to [[spoiler: the defence of Basilisk]], Earl White Haven nearly has a heart attack when he thinks Admiral Yanakov ordered no quarter. Fortunately, [[SubvertedTrope the latter only called for no mercy.no]] ''[[SubvertedTrope mercy]]'', which is a powerful emotional statement but is not actually a command to execute survivors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LeaveNoSurvivors: Narrowed averted in ''Echoes''. When the combined Grayson-Manticore fleet with the new [[MacrossMissileMassacre podnaughts]] rides to [[spoiler: the defence of Basilisk]], Earl White Haven nearly has a heart attack when he thinks Admiral Yanakov ordered no quarter. Fortunately, the latter only called for no mercy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OperationBlank: Manticoran op names are randomly assigned, which gives us gems like Operations Buttercup, Cutworm, and Lunch Basket. Haven tends to favor grandiose names like Operations Icarus, Pegasus, and Thunderbolt. So far Solarian naval ops favor the poetic, like Operations East Wind and Winter Forage, while Mesan covert ops favor very direct names like Operation Rat Poison and Operation [[TrojanHorse Wooden Horse]].

to:

* OperationBlank: Manticoran op names are randomly assigned, so that if the name leaks there's no indication what the plan is, which gives us gems like Operations Buttercup, Cutworm, and Lunch Basket. Haven tends to favor grandiose names like Operations Icarus, Pegasus, and Thunderbolt. So far Solarian naval ops favor the poetic, like Operations East Wind and Winter Forage, while Mesan covert ops favor very direct names like Operation Rat Poison and Poison, Operation [[TrojanHorse Wooden Horse]].Horse]], and Operation Oyster Bay (they're really not even ''trying'' with that one).

Top