Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Fatherland

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* ProperlyParanoid: Buhler, Stuckhart and Luther preserved evidence of the Holocaust to protect themselves in the event that the regime later decided to [[HeKnowsTooMuch kill them merely for knowing about it]]. They were right to worry.

to:

* ProperlyParanoid: Buhler, Stuckhart Stuckart and Luther preserved evidence of the Holocaust to protect themselves in the event that the regime later decided to [[HeKnowsTooMuch kill them merely for knowing about it]]. They were right to worry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ProperlyParanoid: Buhler, Stuckhart and Luther preserved evidence of the Holocaust to protect themselves in the event that the regime later decided to [[HeKnowsTooMuch kill them merely for knowing about it]]. They were right to worry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TokenGoodCop: Xavier March is seemingly the only detective in Berlin who ''isn't'' a die-hard Nazi stooge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Note violates ROCEJ. Discussed here.


** The European Community, the predecessor of [[UsefulNotes/TheEuropeanUnion the modern European Union]], was still formed, albeit it is clear that the other member states are all subordinate to Germany.[[note]]A fair few people in our time have alleged that this part came to be anyway.[[/note]]

to:

** The European Community, the predecessor of [[UsefulNotes/TheEuropeanUnion the modern European Union]], was still formed, albeit it is clear that the other member states are all subordinate to Germany.[[note]]A fair few people in our time have alleged that this part came to be anyway.[[/note]]

Added: 257

Removed: 714

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No tropeslashing. Filed this under just Shown Their Work because example reads like "author did research on the Holocaust", and that's closer to "author did a lot of research on something" than "story-telling device has real-life precedence". Also, this is not an example of Surprisingly Realistic Outcome; it was discussed here.


* ShownTheirWork: Robert Harris includes an explanatory note about the historical characters he uses in the novel and their actual fates, as well as the real-life documents that he cites, just in case anyone thought he made up the thing about the Holocaust.



* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: This is one of the most realistic outcomes of a Nazi victory depicted in fiction. Rather than taking over the world, the Nazi empire consists only of Europe, and is basically no different than the Soviet Union in our universe. Most of the land conquered is also poor and undeveloped except for a guerrilla movement resisting Nazi rule, and the entire empire will most likely collapse in the near future.



* TruthInTelevision[=/=]ShownTheirWork: Robert Harris includes an explanatory note about the historical characters he uses in the novel and their actual fates, as well as the real-life documents that he cites, just in case anyone thought he made up the thing about the Holocaust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeGapRomance: Xavier March is a depressed divorcee in his 40s, while Charlie is a plucky American reporter in her 20s. The two bond over the course of their investigation into the conspiracy. March doesn't like Charlie at first, owning to her TheGadfly nature, but her youth and energy inspire him to take a greater interest in the wider world. Charlie HasAType for older men, but she's initially weary of March, seeing him as a dog of the Nazi regime; after she sees him out of uniform and learns that he refuses to join the Nazi party, she likes him more.

to:

* AgeGapRomance: Xavier March is a depressed divorcee in his 40s, while Charlie is a plucky American reporter in her 20s. The two bond over the course of their investigation into the conspiracy. March doesn't like Charlie at first, owning owing to her TheGadfly nature, but her youth and energy inspire him to take a greater interest in the wider world. Charlie HasAType for older men, but she's initially weary of March, seeing him as a dog of the Nazi regime; after she sees him out of uniform and learns that he refuses to join the Nazi party, she likes him more.

Added: 1520

Changed: 437

Removed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Actually just Age Gap Romance since one partner is in his 40s and the other is in her 20s; May December Romance specifically requires a 30 year age gap. Expanding on this and a few other ZCEs


* AgeGapRomance: Xavier March is a depressed divorcee in his 40s, while Charlie is a plucky American reporter in her 20s. The two bond over the course of their investigation into the conspiracy. March doesn't like Charlie at first, owning to her TheGadfly nature, but her youth and energy inspire him to take a greater interest in the wider world. Charlie HasAType for older men, but she's initially weary of March, seeing him as a dog of the Nazi regime; after she sees him out of uniform and learns that he refuses to join the Nazi party, she likes him more.



* BoomHeadshot: [[spoiler:Luther’s fate.]]

to:

* BoomHeadshot: [[spoiler:Luther’s fate.[[spoiler:At the last minute, Luther is shot in the head while trying to defect to the Americans.]]



* EtTuBrute: [[spoiler:Pili AND Max.]]
* EvilAllAlong: [[spoiler:Nebe and Jaeger.]]

to:

* EtTuBrute: [[spoiler:Pili AND Max.EtTuBrute:
**Pili reports his father March Xavier to the authorities twice: the first time for not participating in any Nazi social clubs or initiatives, the second time when [[spoiler:he visits Pili one last time before attempting to escape Germany.]] Xavier is deeply hurt by both betrayals, with the former incident giving him nightmares about Pili rejecting him.
**When March realizes that [[spoiler:Max Jaeger was betraying him to Globus]] he finds it bitterly ironic that [[spoiler:the man he knew the least, Nightingale, was completely loyal to him, while the man he knew the most, was really TheMole. Max seems pretty aware of the enormity of his betrayal, since he reacts to March's realization by laughing madly and then breaking down in tears.]]
* EvilAllAlong:
** [[spoiler:Nebe engineers March's escape from the SS, telling him to bring news so that Nebe can live long enough to "see those bastards hang". However, it's all just a ruse to get March to lead the police to Charlie and prevent her from leaking information about how the Nazi regime exterminated millions of Jews on an industrial scale.
]]
* EvilAllAlong: [[spoiler:Nebe ** [[spoiler:It turns out March's best friend and Jaeger.]]fellow investigator Max Jaeger was actually leaking information to Globus, so he too was part of the conspiracy to keep the Nazi empire's dark secret under wraps.]]



* MayDecemberRomance: Xavier March and Charlie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war in Europe, America defeated Imperial Japan and remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]

to:

* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war in Europe, America defeated Imperial Japan and remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that it is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war, America defeated Imperial Japan and remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]

to:

* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war, war in Europe, America defeated Imperial Japan and remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war, America remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]

to:

* FallenStatesOfAmerica: Averted. While the Nazis did win the war, America defeated Imperial Japan and remains a functional and free society, and it is all but stated that is pulling ahead of Germany in the Cold War. [[note]]It is noted that even Hitler, the megalomaniacal egomaniac that he was, thought a physical conquest of the United States was impossible. He did foresee a future conflict with America, but his plans for global dominance were more about ''deterring'' future American aggression than actually taking over all of North America, even as a puppet.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: Hitler, Heydrich, Goebbels and the other leading Nazis who were responsible for the war and the Holocaust got away with it and are still in power two decades later.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: Hitler, Heydrich, Goebbels and the other leading Nazis who were responsible for the war and the Holocaust got away with it and are still in power two decades later.later, although it's implied their rule will eventually collapse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MinorCrimeRevealsMajorPlot: Doesn't get much more major than [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust this one]].

to:

* MinorCrimeRevealsMajorPlot: Doesn't get much more major than The suspicious death of high-ranking Nazi Josef Bühler leads to March discovering that the German government [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust this one]].systemically slaughtered the empire's entire Jewish population]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BatterUp: Globus treats Xavier March to a mini-lecture on the wonders of the baseball bat as an instrument for inflicting grievous bodily harm. Globus admits that as much as he usually despises anything that wasn't thought up by Germans[[note]] Like Adolf Hitler, Globus was Austrian by birth, but aggressively re-identified himself as German[[/note]], this American invention is a divine gift to a sadist like him.

Added: 212

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeKnowsTooMuch: The plot is essentially driven by March investigating his own government and finding out far more than he should.

to:

* HeKnowsTooMuch: HeKnowsTooMuch:
**
The plot is essentially driven by March investigating his own government and finding out far more than he should.should.
** This is also why men with direct knowledge of the Holocaust [[spoiler:are all being killed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheStarscream: It is implied that Heydrich arranged for his boss Heinrich Himmler to be [[DroppedABridgeOnHim killed in a a plane crash]] so he could take over the S.S.

to:

* TheStarscream: It is implied that Heydrich arranged for his boss Heinrich Himmler to be [[DroppedABridgeOnHim killed in a a plane crash]] so he could take over the S.S.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheStarscream: It is implied that Heydrich arranged for his boss Heinrich Himmler to be [[DroppedABridgeOnHim killed in a a plane crash]] so he could take over the S.S.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: Hitler, Heydrich, Goebbels and the other leading Nazis who were responsible for the war and the Holocaust got away with it and are still in power two decades later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpannerInTheWorks: [[spoiler:The Gestapo arranged for [[TheMole Max Jaeger]] to be assigned to the Buhler murder case (so he could ensure it went nowhere)]], but their Kripo superior screwed up the rotas and called March instead.

Added: 435

Changed: 439

Removed: 508

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RomanticFalseLead: {{Averted|Trope}}. March suspects Maguire is in a relationship with Henry Nightingale, with his behaviour not helping.
* ShowerOfAngst: Xavi takes a long, long bath after the HeroicBSOD above.

to:

* RomanticFalseLead: {{Averted|Trope}}. March suspects Maguire is ScrubbingOffTheTrauma: Xavier a former U-Boat captain, finds out that [[spoiler:some of the uniform clothing he was issued while in a relationship with Henry Nightingale, with his behaviour the service was manufactured from the hair of Holocaust victims]]. He describes not helping.
* ShowerOfAngst: Xavi takes a long, long bath
feeling clean after bathing repeatedly for days; more justified than most given the HeroicBSOD above.close physical contact involved...Overlaps with ShowerOfAngst.



* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: This is one of the most realistic outcomes of a Nazi victory depicted in fiction. Rather than taking over the world, the Nazi empire consists only of Europe, and is basically no different than the Soviet Union in our universe. Most of the land conquered is also poor and undeveloped except for a guerrilla movement resisting Nazi rule, and the entire empire will most likely collapse in the near future.


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: This is one of the most realistic outcomes of a Nazi victory depicted in fiction. Rather than taking over the world, the Nazi empire consists only of Europe, and is basically no different than the Soviet Union in our universe. Most of the land conquered is also poor and undeveloped except for a guerrilla movement resisting Nazi rule, and the entire empire will most likely collapse in the near future.

Added: 73

Changed: 18

Removed: 73

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope renamed and redefined per TRS


* HeroicBSOD: While reading secret documents, Xavier comes across a [[TruthInTelevision real historical]] note about concentration camp victims' hair being cut off and turned into felt, which was then made into socks for U-boat crews. He [[OutDamnedSpot reacts badly]] to the news that he wore dead Jews' hair during the war.

to:

* HeroicBSOD: While reading secret documents, Xavier comes across a [[TruthInTelevision real historical]] note about concentration camp victims' hair being cut off and turned into felt, which was then made into socks for U-boat crews. He [[OutDamnedSpot reacts badly]] badly to the news that he wore dead Jews' hair during the war.



* OutDamnedSpot: Xavi takes a long, long bath after the HeroicBSOD above.


Added DiffLines:

* ShowerOfAngst: Xavi takes a long, long bath after the HeroicBSOD above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Page was cut and sent to Permanent Red Link Club due to Rule Of Cautious Editing Judgment violations, so all wicks must be removed.


* TruthInTelevision[=/=]ShownTheirWork: Robert Harris includes an explanatory note about the historical characters he uses in the novel and their actual fates, as well as the real-life documents that he cites, just in case anyone thought [[UsefulNotes/ConspiracyTheories he made up the thing about the Holocaust]].

to:

* TruthInTelevision[=/=]ShownTheirWork: Robert Harris includes an explanatory note about the historical characters he uses in the novel and their actual fates, as well as the real-life documents that he cites, just in case anyone thought [[UsefulNotes/ConspiracyTheories he made up the thing about the Holocaust]].Holocaust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PuppetState: We don't see a lot of Europe outside of Germany or territory directly controlled by Germany, but the mentions we get suggest that this is somewhat downplayed. Following the Nazi victory Western Europe has naturally been brought into a European Community which makes them basically puppets. But, in keeping with Hitler's real-life lack of interest in dominating Western Europe (he was more concerned with establishing "living space" in the east) and the fact that dominating Eastern Europe is hinted to basically have turned out to be a resource-draining PyrrhicVictory, it's implied that beyond unfavourable economic ties, making sure that they come second to Germany in sporting contests and doing whatever Germany tells them in terms of world relations Western Europe is more-or-less left alone to get on with things. For example, mentions of a band that is almost certainly Music/TheBeatles becoming popular with the youth and books by Creator/GeorgeOrwell and Creator/GrahamGreene circulating among the black market would seem to suggest that Britain, for one example, has a relatively more liberal public and cultural life than is enjoyed in Germany and the places directly controlled by it.

to:

* PuppetState: We don't see a lot of Europe outside of Germany or territory directly controlled by Germany, but the mentions we get suggest that this is somewhat downplayed. Following the Nazi victory Western Europe has naturally been brought into a European Community which makes them basically puppets. But, in keeping with Hitler's real-life lack of interest in dominating Western Europe (he was more concerned with establishing "living space" in the east) and the fact that dominating Eastern Europe is hinted to basically have turned out to be a resource-draining PyrrhicVictory, it's implied that beyond unfavourable economic ties, making sure that they come second to Germany in sporting contests and doing whatever Germany tells them in terms of world relations Western Europe is more-or-less left alone to get on with things. For example, mentions of a band that is almost certainly Music/TheBeatles becoming popular with the youth and books by Creator/GeorgeOrwell and Creator/GrahamGreene Creator/GrahamGreeneAuthor circulating among the black market would seem to suggest that Britain, for one example, has a relatively more liberal public and cultural life than is enjoyed in Germany and the places directly controlled by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PuppetState: We don't see a lot of Europe outside of Germany or territory directly controlled by Germany, but the mentions we get suggest that this is somewhat downplayed. Following the Nazi victory Western Europe has naturally been brought into a European Community which makes them basically puppets. But, in keeping with Hitler's real-life lack of interest in dominating Western Europe (he was more concerned with establishing "living space" in the east) and the fact that dominating Eastern Europe is hinted to basically have turned out to be a resource-draining PyrrhicVictory, it's implied that beyond unfavourable economic ties, making sure that they come second to Germany in sporting contests and doing whatever Germany tells them in terms of world relations Western Europe is more-or-less left alone to get on with things. For example, mentions of a band that is almost certainly Music/TheBeatles becoming popular with the youth and books by Creator/GeorgeOrwell and Creator/GrahameGreene circulating among the black market would seem to suggest that Britain, for one example, has a relatively more liberal public and cultural life than is enjoyed in Germany and the places directly controlled by it.

to:

* PuppetState: We don't see a lot of Europe outside of Germany or territory directly controlled by Germany, but the mentions we get suggest that this is somewhat downplayed. Following the Nazi victory Western Europe has naturally been brought into a European Community which makes them basically puppets. But, in keeping with Hitler's real-life lack of interest in dominating Western Europe (he was more concerned with establishing "living space" in the east) and the fact that dominating Eastern Europe is hinted to basically have turned out to be a resource-draining PyrrhicVictory, it's implied that beyond unfavourable economic ties, making sure that they come second to Germany in sporting contests and doing whatever Germany tells them in terms of world relations Western Europe is more-or-less left alone to get on with things. For example, mentions of a band that is almost certainly Music/TheBeatles becoming popular with the youth and books by Creator/GeorgeOrwell and Creator/GrahameGreene Creator/GrahamGreene circulating among the black market would seem to suggest that Britain, for one example, has a relatively more liberal public and cultural life than is enjoyed in Germany and the places directly controlled by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PuppetState: We don't see a lot of Europe outside of Germany or territory directly controlled by Germany, but the mentions we get suggest that this is somewhat downplayed. Following the Nazi victory Western Europe has naturally been brought into a European Community which makes them basically puppets. But, in keeping with Hitler's real-life lack of interest in dominating Western Europe (he was more concerned with establishing "living space" in the east) and the fact that dominating Eastern Europe is hinted to basically have turned out to be a resource-draining PyrrhicVictory, it's implied that beyond unfavourable economic ties, making sure that they come second to Germany in sporting contests and doing whatever Germany tells them in terms of world relations Western Europe is more-or-less left alone to get on with things. For example, mentions of a band that is almost certainly Music/TheBeatles becoming popular with the youth and books by Creator/GeorgeOrwell and Creator/GrahameGreene circulating among the black market would seem to suggest that Britain, for one example, has a relatively more liberal public and cultural life than is enjoyed in Germany and the places directly controlled by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicence: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows March to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.

to:

* ArtisticLicence: ArtisticLicenseHistory: A minor one. In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows March to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.

Added: 357

Removed: 365

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicence: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows March to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.



* CriticalResearchFailure: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows March to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CriticalResearchFailure: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows the police to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows the police March to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CriticalResearchFailure: In the novel, it is a record of [[spoiler:Josef Bühler]]'s arrest the day after the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch that allows the police to identify him (and to start to realise the depth of what he’s getting into). In reality, [[spoiler:Bühler]] did not join the Nazi Party until 1933, though had been working for the party for some time before that.

Added: 582

Changed: 421

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilIsBigger: Justified and deconstructed. The Nazi Reich has a ton of monuments that are bigger than anywhere else. However, March sees this as a sign of how deeply insecure Germany is as a society, that they have to constantly build such behemoths.

to:

* EvilIsBigger: Justified and deconstructed. The Nazi Reich has a ton of monuments that are bigger than anywhere else. However, March sees this as a sign of how deeply insecure Germany is as a society, that they have to constantly build such behemoths.behemoths and gloat about how much bigger they are than everyone else's.



* InferioritySuperiorityComplex: The Nazis are fond of overtly and implicitly rubbing their victory in the faces of their defeated foes. Their monuments are bigger than everyone else's. Their sporting teams always win (even, it is hinted, if they have to cheat). And so on. March merely considers this as culture-wide evidence of how insecure and inferior the Germans actually feel deep down:

to:

* InferioritySuperiorityComplex: InferioritySuperiorityComplex:
**
The Nazis are fond of overtly and implicitly rubbing their victory in the faces of their defeated foes. Their monuments are bigger than everyone else's. Their sporting teams always win (even, it is hinted, if they have to cheat). And so on. March merely considers this as culture-wide evidence of how insecure and inferior the Germans actually feel deep down:


Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, it's noted that even within the Reich the people who tend to harp on the loudest about the purity of Aryan race and the German bloodline tend to be the ones who fall far short of Aryan standards of purity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: After being rejected by his son and having an argument with his ex-wife on the subject, March ruefully notes that between the two of them and her new husband, the only inhabitant of their household who ''wasn't'' wearing some kind of uniform was the family dog, making them more domesticated and unthinkingly obedient than a member of a species specifically domesticated and bred for blind loyalty and obedience.

Top