Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanAtWorldsEnd

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Fridge Brilliance

to:

!!Fridge Brilliance!!FridgeBrilliance



!!Fridge Horror

to:

!!Fridge Horror!!FridgeHorror
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* As explained in [[https://prokopetz.tumblr.com/post/149133498452/the-funniest-thing-in-the-entire-pirates-of-the this Tumblr post]], during the parlay scene, Davy Jones gets around the "can't set foot on dry land" rule by standing in a bucket of seawater. But there's another layer to it: the bucket is on a sandbar - a sand deposit that is usually submerged underwater, and therefore technically doesn't qualify as ''dry'' land.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> ''Others sail on the sea'' [[note]]Referring to pirates as a whole. The third line ''may'' refer to pirates who are neither dead nor fully alive - examples being the cursed crew in the first movie and Davy Jones's henchmen in the second and third... and perhaps foreshadowing (if unintentionally) Blackbeard's zombies in Movie 4. Alternately, it may refer to the nine Pirate Lords' roles as LegacyCharacter bearers of the "keys" mentioned next.[[/note]]

to:

---> ''Others sail on the sea'' [[note]]Referring to pirates as a whole. The third line ''may'' refer to pirates who are neither dead nor fully alive - examples being the cursed crew in the first movie and Davy Jones's henchmen in the second and third... and perhaps foreshadowing (if unintentionally) Blackbeard's zombies in Movie 4. Alternately, it may refer to the nine Pirate Lords' roles [[LegacyCharacter inherited roles]] as LegacyCharacter bearers of the "keys" mentioned next.in the next line.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> ''Others sail on the sea'' [[note]]Referring to pirates as a whole. The third line ''may'' refer to pirates who are neither dead nor fully alive - examples being the cursed crew in the first movie and Davy Jones's henchmen in the second and third... and perhaps foreshadowing (if unintentionally) Blackbeard's zombies in Movie 4.[[/note]]

to:

---> ''Others sail on the sea'' [[note]]Referring to pirates as a whole. The third line ''may'' refer to pirates who are neither dead nor fully alive - examples being the cursed crew in the first movie and Davy Jones's henchmen in the second and third... and perhaps foreshadowing (if unintentionally) Blackbeard's zombies in Movie 4. Alternately, it may refer to the nine Pirate Lords' roles as LegacyCharacter bearers of the "keys" mentioned next.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** as discussed above, Ragetti’s wooden eye is one of them and was actually given to Barbossa by Boris Palachnik, the pirate lord who came before him.

to:

** as As discussed above, Ragetti’s wooden eye is one of them and was actually given to Barbossa by Boris Palachnik, the pirate lord who came before him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The pieces of Eight may seem like 9 pieces of random junk but they’re not as random as you’d think. Background lore reveals these are each items of personal value to each of the nine pirate lords.
** Ammand the Corsair’s pewter goblet was given to him by outcast sisters that were banished because of him.
** Chevalle places a queen of spades in the plate. Being a gambler, his preferred hands always held a queen.
** Mistress Ching’s wore her glasses until she went blind.
** Gentleman Jocard’s tobacco cutters were from the plantation where he was enslaved and used to cut his master’s tongue.
** Sao Feng’s knot was made from silk and passed down from his father.
** Sir Sumbahjee’s snuff box is a souvenir from his temple in India.
** Eduardo Villanueva’s broken bottle neck is from what he used to win a bar fight once.
** as discussed above, Ragetti’s wooden eye is one of them and was actually given to Barbossa by Boris Palachnik, the pirate lord who came before him.
** Jack’s coin that he keeps woven into his hair is one of the first two bits he ever pirated. He bought his favorite hat with the other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The moment where Barbossa is taking in the rain. At first it seems like a bit of a random thing to throw in until you realize why he’s taking in the rain. Back when he was cursed in the first movie, he felt nothing. No taste, no pain, no sensations. Now here’s the first time he’s felt the sensation of rain falling on his fingers and the true risk of death has truly dawned on him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We aren't rooting for villanous pirates (except maybe Barbossa). We're rooting for the 3 leads, all of whom are only pirates because of their hearts. Jack was branded a pirate because he freed slaves, while Will and Elizabeth were only stated to be as such because they saved Jack. They also all have personal reasons to go after the bad guys, with Jack loving his freedom (not to mention that he was branded by Beckett, as well as his somewhat selfish wish to not be caught by Davy Jones that has caused so much trouble), Will wanting to save his dad, and Elizabeth having had her dad killed on Beckett's orders. None of these characters are the best, but they are way more sympathetic than Beckett, who is responsible for all of their problems, and is a SmugSnake to boot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The title card shows a piece of eight falling on the ground. This not only foreshadows the Nine Pieces of Eight, but it also is a continuation of the hanging scene - the coin fell out of the boy’s hand when they hanged him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** More Fridge for Ragetti: it's ''his'' lover-like recitation of the ritual's words in Tia Dalma's ear that enables her to revert to Calypso. When Calypso ends her giant-sized rant by breaking up into thousands of scuttling crabs, one of the crustaceans winds up down Ragetti's ''pants'' ... which is either her pincer-inflicted retaliation for him getting fresh with Tia without an invitation, or some ''really'' unsubtle GettingCrapPastTheRadar.

to:

** More Fridge for Ragetti: it's ''his'' lover-like recitation of the ritual's words in Tia Dalma's ear that enables her to revert to Calypso. When Calypso ends her giant-sized rant by breaking up into thousands of scuttling crabs, one of the crustaceans winds up down Ragetti's ''pants'' ... which is either her pincer-inflicted retaliation for him getting fresh with Tia without an invitation, or some ''really'' unsubtle GettingCrapPastTheRadar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As first viewing, many considered Beckett's VillainousBreakdown to be the biggest AssPull in the series' history to justify how two frigates (The Black Pearl and The Flying Dutchman) can outgun a Ship of the line (Endeavor) even when the latter is outflanked, to the extent that it has become a meme. Upon rewatching, a few major details that got overlooked can justify why he didn't just order his crew to fire.

to:

* As On first viewing, many considered Beckett's VillainousBreakdown to be the biggest AssPull in the series' history to justify how two frigates (The Black Pearl (''Black Pearl'' and The Flying Dutchman) ''Flying Dutchman'') can outgun beat a Ship of the line (Endeavor) (''Endeavor'') even when the latter is outflanked, to the extent that it has become a meme. Upon rewatching, a few major details that got overlooked can justify why he didn't just order his crew to fire.



** He is too used to being the one in control. When he found out that the Flying Dutchman is no longer in control, he froze. A person who always put their career in the highest priority will freeze if their plans fail because they are more concerned about how this mess will affect their standing rather than the overall situation.

to:

** [[ControlFreak He is too used to being the one in control. control]]. When he found out that the Flying Dutchman is no longer in his control, he froze. A person who always put their career in the highest priority will has the tendency to freeze if their plans fail because they are more concerned about how this mess will affect their standing rather than trying to fix the overall situation.

Added: 1116

Changed: 416

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" and flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!

to:

* When the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon "Abandon ship!" and flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!




to:

* As first viewing, many considered Beckett's VillainousBreakdown to be the biggest AssPull in the series' history to justify how two frigates (The Black Pearl and The Flying Dutchman) can outgun a Ship of the line (Endeavor) even when the latter is outflanked, to the extent that it has become a meme. Upon rewatching, a few major details that got overlooked can justify why he didn't just order his crew to fire.
** His career was already ruined. He declared that the EITC would control all trading routes by using the Flying Dutchman to destroy their rival ships, but now he's lost it. Even if he fought back, he can no longer fulfil his promise and will become an embarrassment, so he chose to die there rather than to face the shame back home. If he tries to raid the ship again to gain Will's heart instead now that the crew are no longer monsters, it will just leave his other side target practice for the Black Pearl's cannons.
** He is too used to being the one in control. When he found out that the Flying Dutchman is no longer in control, he froze. A person who always put their career in the highest priority will freeze if their plans fail because they are more concerned about how this mess will affect their standing rather than the overall situation.
** The Flying Dutchman is an ''[[ResurrectiveImmortality undead]]'' ship that will just keep coming back in any spot of the captain's choosing. He can put it down 100 times and it'll just keep coming back until there's nothing left of his fleet but blood and ashes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Later on in the movie, it's implied that Jones knows where Shipwreck Cove is, as the First Court summoned him to help bind Calypso. Why didn't he tell Beckett about that in the first place? Considering he is a loose cannon, it's very likely that he didn't, out of spite. In any case Beckett never knew that Jones had dealings with he Court before, until Will came along. It's possible after his last meeting with Calypso, Jones revealed the location of Shipwreck Island (or if he didn't, Beckett likely used the compass anyway).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While in Davy Jones' Locker, the crew of the ''Black Pearl'' had to flip their own ship upside down to escape. The picturesque scene of the inverted ''Pearl'' in the water is a clever ShoutOut to one of the explanations of the real life ''Flying Dutchman'' legend, which is a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fata_Morgana_(mirage)#The_Flying_Dutchman Fata Morgana superior mirage]] of a ship seen at sea. Fitting that the only way to escape from the purgatory controlled by the captain of the ''Flying Dutchman'', the ''Black Pearl'' has to invert itself just like how the 'real' ''Dutchman'' would look like.

to:

* While in Davy Jones' Locker, the crew of the ''Black Pearl'' had to flip their own ship upside down to escape. The picturesque scene of the inverted ''Pearl'' in the water is a clever [[GeniusBonus clever]] ShoutOut to one of the explanations of the real life ''Flying Dutchman'' legend, which is a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fata_Morgana_(mirage)#The_Flying_Dutchman Fata Morgana superior mirage]] of a ship seen at sea. Fitting that the only way to escape from the purgatory controlled by the captain of the ''Flying Dutchman'', the ''Black Pearl'' has to invert itself just like how the 'real' ''Dutchman'' would look like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While in Davy Jones' Locker, the crew of the ''Black Pearl'' had to flip their own ship upside down to escape. The picturesque scene of the inverted ''Pearl'' in the water is a clever ShoutOut to one of the explanations of the real life ''Flying Dutchman'' legend, which is a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fata_Morgana_(mirage)#The_Flying_Dutchman Fata Morgana superior mirage]] of a ship seen at sea. Fitting that the only way to escape from the purgatory controlled by the captain of the ''Flying Dutchman'', the ''Black Pearl'' has to invert itself just like how the 'real' ''Dutchman'' would look like.

Changed: 239

Removed: 498

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This complaint was very conservative-minded. Deleting it.


** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes (and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), executed people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap.
** It's simple really: we live in a society that A) [[CoolPeopleRebelAgainstAuthority idolizes rebellion against all logic]], and B) [[CommonKnowledge couldn't get a single historical fact right if their damn lives depended on it]]. Really the pirates aren't much different than famed explorers like Colombus, Pizarro, etc., only because the Pirates' crimes weren't [[PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad committed only against a single race]], people have romanticized them to an outright ludicrous degree.

to:

** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes (and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), executed people with other ideals, religions and opinions… Meanwhile the Brethren Court is a council of many races and religions (e.g Ammand, the Turkish Lord, being strongly implied to be Muslim and Sri Shumbajee, the Indian Lord, being clearly either Hindu or Sikh). In the fourth film, if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much any better. I think the only good people at the time where were farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap.
** It's simple really: we live in a society that A) [[CoolPeopleRebelAgainstAuthority idolizes rebellion against all logic]], and B) [[CommonKnowledge couldn't get a single historical fact right if their damn lives depended on it]]. Really the pirates aren't much different than famed explorers like Colombus, Pizarro, etc., only because the Pirates' crimes weren't [[PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad committed only against a single race]], people have romanticized them to an outright ludicrous degree.
crap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** They probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at each other to realize until they pulled the trigger.

to:

*** They probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at each other to realize until they pulled the trigger.trigger, also Jack's already questionable sanity had decided to take a leave of absence while he was in the Locker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> ''' ''And bound her in her bones'' '''[[note]]Sealed Calypso into her human form, Tia Dalma[[/note]]

to:

---> ''' ''And bound her in her bones'' '''[[note]]Sealed [[note]]Sealed Calypso into her human form, Tia Dalma[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes(and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), executed people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap.

to:

** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes(and taxes (and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), executed people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap.



*** Strictly speaking, the trapdoor methods used in all POTC hanging scenes indicate a form of long-drop hanging is in operation, though Norington's early comments about a 'short drop and a sudden stop' suggest otherwise. The trapdoor hangings in the start of World's End seem to be instantaneous: they drop, feet shake, next row. And they put the boy on a barrel (or something similar) to get him up to the noose, increasing the distance his smaller frame has to drop when the barrel and the trapdoor drop out from under him so if anyone dies quickly in that scene: it would be him.

to:

*** Strictly speaking, the trapdoor methods used in all POTC hanging scenes indicate a form of long-drop hanging is in operation, though Norington's Norrington's early comments about a 'short drop and a sudden stop' suggest otherwise. The trapdoor hangings in the start of World's End seem to be instantaneous: they drop, feet shake, next row. And they put the boy on a barrel (or something similar) to get him up to the noose, increasing the distance his smaller frame has to drop when the barrel and the trapdoor drop out from under him so if anyone dies quickly in that scene: it would be him.



*** They probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at each other to realise until they pulled the trigger.

to:

*** They probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at each other to realise realize until they pulled the trigger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Aside from the fact that the Flying Dutchman under Will's command has sided with the Black Pearl, there's another good reason why the [[MegaCorp British East India Company]] armada simply [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere turned tail]]: they were following the "rules of engagement." With the Endeavor gone sunk and Lord Beckett certainly blown up with the ship, the fleet had just lost their commander and flagship in one go, reducing it into a disorganized mess. Leaving it easy pickings for the pirates.
* In At World's End when the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!

to:

* Aside from the fact that the Flying Dutchman under Will's command has sided with the Black Pearl, there's another good reason why the [[MegaCorp British East India Company]] armada simply [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere turned tail]]: they were following the "rules of engagement." With the Endeavor gone sunk and Lord Beckett certainly blown up with the ship, the fleet had just lost their commander and flagship in one go, reducing it into a disorganized mess. Leaving mess, leaving it easy pickings for the pirates.
* In At World's End when When the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And and flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!



* The first time I wondered why Davy Jones was so hell bent on getting Jack's soul... to the point where he wants 100 souls in exchange for it. It's not like he has any trouble find desperate sailors willing to crew his ship and it seems rather petty for someone as powerful as him. Then I realize there are two very good reasons why he might want Jack in particular trapped in the Locker
** Jack is a Pirate Lord and holds one of the 9 Pieces of Eight. If Jack is trapped in the Locker along with the piece then there is no way to release Calpyso. Jones still loves Calypso but he also hates her for betraying him. This way Jones can keep Calypso trapped forever if he wants to and if at some point he chooses to release her it would be simple enough for him to take the piece from the Locker. Noone (least of all Jones) expected Barbossa & Co would go to save Jack... or that they would succeed

to:

* The first time I wondered why Why is Davy Jones was so hell bent on getting Jack's soul... soul, to the point where he wants 100 souls in exchange for it. it? It's not like he has any trouble find desperate sailors willing to crew his ship and it seems rather petty for someone as powerful as him. Then I realize there are two very good reasons why he might want Jack in particular trapped in the Locker
** Jack is a Pirate Lord and holds one of the 9 Pieces of Eight. If Jack is trapped in the Locker along with the piece then there is no way to release Calpyso. Jones still loves Calypso but he also hates her for betraying him. This way Jones can keep Calypso trapped forever if he wants to and if at some point he chooses to release her it would be simple enough for him to take the piece from the Locker. Noone Nobody (least of all Jones) expected Barbossa & Co would go to save Jack... or that they would succeed



* Is it only me that has noticed the inherent horror of rooting for the pirates in Worlds End. Yes, the English are being led by a dick, but most of them are innocent and honest sailors, and when you think about it, the pirates are basically all just thieving and murdering scum! I say this, of course, but I still can't stop myself rooting for the pirates at the end.

to:

* Is it only me that has noticed the inherent horror of rooting for the pirates in Worlds End. End? Yes, the English are being led by a dick, but most of them are innocent and honest sailors, and when you think about it, the pirates are basically all just thieving and murdering scum! scum. I say this, of course, but I still can't stop myself rooting for the pirates at the end.



** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes(and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), excecuted people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap..!

to:

** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes(and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), excecuted executed people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap..!crap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** they probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at eachother to realise until they pulled the trigger

to:

*** they They probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at eachother each other to realise until they pulled the triggertrigger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also theorized that Jones will accept 100 souls instead of Jack's because of the deal they made, and the events preceding it. Jack was a trader working for the EITC, but he was told to ship slaves, and instead freed them (hence the conversation he has with Beckett). In retaliation, he was branded a pirate and his ship, then the Wicked Wench, was set on fire. Jack made a deal with Jones to get the Wench back, but it came back still black from being burned, so he renamed it the Black Pearl. Jack freed 100 slaves, which is why Jones will accept 100 souls-he has a sick sense of irony.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** More Fridge for Ragetti: it's ''his'' lover-like recitation of the ritual's words in Tia Dalma's ear that enables her to revert to Calypso. When Calypso ends her giant-sized rant by breaking up into thousands of scuttling crabs, one of the crustaceans winds up down Ragetti's ''pants'' ... which is either her pincer-inflicted retaliation for him getting fresh with Tia without an invitation, or some ''really'' unsubtle GettingCrapPastTheRadar.

Changed: 114

Removed: 1676

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to Headscratchers


* ''Hoist the Colours'', the song played throughout ''At World's End'', at first sounds like a generic pirate tune. But watch the film a second time and you suddenly realise ''why'' singing that song in particular heralds a meeting of the Brethren Court. [[spoiler: It's about the sealing of Calypso.]]

to:

* ''Hoist the Colours'', the song played throughout ''At World's End'', at first sounds like a generic pirate tune. But watch the film a second time and you suddenly realise ''why'' singing that song in particular heralds a meeting of the Brethren Court. [[spoiler: It's about the sealing of Calypso.]]



---> ''' ''And bound her in her bones'' '''[[note]][[spoiler:Sealed Calypso into her human form, Tia Dalma]][[/note]]

to:

---> ''' ''And bound her in her bones'' '''[[note]][[spoiler:Sealed '''[[note]]Sealed Calypso into her human form, Tia Dalma]][[/note]]Dalma[[/note]]



* The mid-battle wedding's dialogue from ''At World's End'' is pretty funny the first time through, but when you view it again, knowing that Will [[spoiler: is about to be killed and revived as the ''Dutchman'''s new captain]], you realize that the parts they ''omitted'' from a traditional marriage ceremony were just as important as the wisecracks. Why? Because none of them -- not Will, not Elizabeth, not Barbossa -- had the chance to say [[spoiler: till death do us part/as long as you both shall live]], meaning that their married state persists even after [[spoiler: Jones kills Will]].
* Aside from the fact that [[spoiler:the Flying Dutchman under Will's command]] has sided with the Black Pearl, there's another good reason why the [[MegaCorp British East India Company]] armada simply [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere turned tail]]: they were following the "rules of engagement." With [[spoiler:the Endeavor gone sunk and Lord Beckett certainly blown up with the ship]], the fleet had just lost their commander and flagship in one go, reducing it into a disorganized mess. Leaving it easy pickings for the pirates.

to:

* The mid-battle wedding's dialogue from ''At World's End'' is pretty funny the first time through, but when you view it again, knowing that Will [[spoiler: is about to be killed and revived as the ''Dutchman'''s new captain]], captain, you realize that the parts they ''omitted'' from a traditional marriage ceremony were just as important as the wisecracks. Why? Because none of them -- not Will, not Elizabeth, not Barbossa -- had the chance to say [[spoiler: till death do us part/as long as you both shall live]], live, meaning that their married state persists even after [[spoiler: Jones kills Will]].
Will.
* Aside from the fact that [[spoiler:the the Flying Dutchman under Will's command]] command has sided with the Black Pearl, there's another good reason why the [[MegaCorp British East India Company]] armada simply [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere turned tail]]: they were following the "rules of engagement." With [[spoiler:the the Endeavor gone sunk and Lord Beckett certainly blown up with the ship]], ship, the fleet had just lost their commander and flagship in one go, reducing it into a disorganized mess. Leaving it easy pickings for the pirates.



* The inspiration Jack has in ''At World's End'' to use a bench as "leverage" to lift the brig door off its hinges seems pretty arbitrary unless you watch the first movie right before it. [[spoiler: It's how Will breaks Jack out of Port Royal Jail!]]
** Not so much fridge as it is a subtle CallBack, considering Jack is muttering [[WhatWouldXDo "think like the whelp"]] over and over before discovering that the hinges on the Dutchman's brig are the same kind (half-barrel hinges) [[spoiler: that Will busted him out of]].

to:

* The inspiration Jack has in ''At World's End'' to use a bench as "leverage" to lift the brig door off its hinges seems pretty arbitrary unless you watch the first movie right before it. [[spoiler: It's how Will breaks Jack out of Port Royal Jail!]]
Jail!
** Not so much fridge as it is a subtle CallBack, considering Jack is muttering [[WhatWouldXDo "think like the whelp"]] over and over before discovering that the hinges on the Dutchman's brig are the same kind (half-barrel hinges) [[spoiler: that Will busted him out of]].of.



!!Fridge Logic
* At World's End- When William sets sail and proceeds to leave Elizabeth behind in a bittersweet ending, his father assures him that she cannot go with them. No explanation is given for why this has to happen, merely that it must be this way. Which leaves the audience to wonder- given that Elizabeth successfully navigated to Davy Jones' locker at the beginning of the movie, and that Will and his father can both apparently survive the journey intact, what exactly is preventing this from happening? Is there some as yet unexplained aspect to the bargain of the Dead Man's Chest? Is Will's father just a big believer in the old adage that it is bad luck to bring a woman on board a ship? Does he secretly not approve of the marriage and want to make his daughter in law miserable?
** WordOfGod is that if the wife stays faithful for the ten years, the captain can elect to leave and become mortal again, and appoint someone else. Meeting up before ten years isn't staying true to the rules, and that would turn Will into a sea monster.
* So... at the end of the first film, Captain Barbosa is dead, and Ragetti isn't. And Ragetti has the wooden eye that was Barbossa's "piece of eight". Wouldn't that have made Ragetti the new Pirate Lord of the Caspian Sea?
** Given how Sao Feng actively tells Elizabeth about her being a Pirate Lord and hands it to her, it could be that Pirate Lords need to be outright named as successors, rather than it just coming down to who ends up with the Piece of Eight if the Pirate Lord dies.



** Let's be honest. Elizabeth is a ManipulativeBastard , which makes her the only known predator of [[spoiler: Jack's MagnificentBastard]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Aside from the AnachronismStew element involved, Jack using the sail from the Dutchman as a parasail makes sense when you consider that Jack's a sailor. Pirate or not, he's worked with sails enough to know how they move in the wind. While they may not have been invented or used for that purpose yet, it's likely that Jack would've known it would work, especially with the maelstrom causing all sorts of crosswinds to carry them away from the whirlpool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's simple really: we live in a society that A) [[CoolPeopleRebelAgainstAuthority idolizes rebellion against all logic]], and B) [[CommonKnowledge couldn't get a single historical fact right if their damn lives depended on it]]. Really the pirates aren't much different than famed explorers like Colombus, Pizarro, etc., only because the Pirates' crimes weren't [[PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad committed only against a single race]], people have romanticized them to an outright ludicrous degree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
move 1 more from that page

Added DiffLines:

* Ragetti is very protective of his wooden eye, despite the fact it's mentioned to not fit properly and keeps falling out. Come ''At World's End'', we find out why.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Move from the Fridge page about Pirates of the Caribbean (franchise).

Added DiffLines:

!!Fridge Brilliance
* ''Hoist the Colours'', the song played throughout ''At World's End'', at first sounds like a generic pirate tune. But watch the film a second time and you suddenly realise ''why'' singing that song in particular heralds a meeting of the Brethren Court. [[spoiler: It's about the sealing of Calypso.]]
** Hell, the '''''entire song''''' is brilliant. It pretty much outlines the movie's plot and backstory.
---> ''The king and his men''[[note]]The First Brethren Court[[/note]]
---> ''Stole the queen from her bed''
---> ''' ''And bound her in her bones'' '''[[note]][[spoiler:Sealed Calypso into her human form, Tia Dalma]][[/note]]
---> ''The seas be ours''
---> ''And by the powers''
---> ''Where we will, we'll roam'' [[note]](Human) pirates wanted full control of the seas, as later referenced by Barbossa.[[/note]]

---> ''Some have died''
---> ''And some are alive''
---> ''Others sail on the sea'' [[note]]Referring to pirates as a whole. The third line ''may'' refer to pirates who are neither dead nor fully alive - examples being the cursed crew in the first movie and Davy Jones's henchmen in the second and third... and perhaps foreshadowing (if unintentionally) Blackbeard's zombies in Movie 4.[[/note]]
---> ''With the keys to the cage'' [[note]]The nine Pieces of Eight are the "keys" needed to release Calypso from her human "cage"[[/note]]
---> ''And the Devil to pay'' [[note]]Davy Jones is referred to as "The Devil", and Jack, of course, owed him a debt of service. And as for several other characters, it could refer to the desire to pay Jones back (i.e. revenge) for the havoc his presence has created.[[/note]]
---> ''We lay to Fiddler's Green'' [[note]]Refers to the mythical pirate paradise - think the exact opposite of Davy Jones' Locker. Shipwreck Cove is implied to be the world's last pirate haven - run by pirates, only for pirates.[[/note]]

---> ''The bell has been raised from its watery grave''
---> ''Hear its sepuchral tone'' [[note]]The Brethren Court is being called together for the first time in several decades.[[/note]]
---> ''A call to all, pay heed the squall'' [[note]]The overall "squall" of the conflict between the Pirates and the EITC. Also serves as {{Foreshadowing}} to the final battle being fought in a maelstrom, which is a type of squall.[[/note]]
---> ''Turn your sails to home'' [[note]]If you're not prepared to pick a side, it's best to keep clear of the situation[[/note]]
* The mid-battle wedding's dialogue from ''At World's End'' is pretty funny the first time through, but when you view it again, knowing that Will [[spoiler: is about to be killed and revived as the ''Dutchman'''s new captain]], you realize that the parts they ''omitted'' from a traditional marriage ceremony were just as important as the wisecracks. Why? Because none of them -- not Will, not Elizabeth, not Barbossa -- had the chance to say [[spoiler: till death do us part/as long as you both shall live]], meaning that their married state persists even after [[spoiler: Jones kills Will]].
* Aside from the fact that [[spoiler:the Flying Dutchman under Will's command]] has sided with the Black Pearl, there's another good reason why the [[MegaCorp British East India Company]] armada simply [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere turned tail]]: they were following the "rules of engagement." With [[spoiler:the Endeavor gone sunk and Lord Beckett certainly blown up with the ship]], the fleet had just lost their commander and flagship in one go, reducing it into a disorganized mess. Leaving it easy pickings for the pirates.
* In At World's End when the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!
* The inspiration Jack has in ''At World's End'' to use a bench as "leverage" to lift the brig door off its hinges seems pretty arbitrary unless you watch the first movie right before it. [[spoiler: It's how Will breaks Jack out of Port Royal Jail!]]
** Not so much fridge as it is a subtle CallBack, considering Jack is muttering [[WhatWouldXDo "think like the whelp"]] over and over before discovering that the hinges on the Dutchman's brig are the same kind (half-barrel hinges) [[spoiler: that Will busted him out of]].
* The first time I wondered why Davy Jones was so hell bent on getting Jack's soul... to the point where he wants 100 souls in exchange for it. It's not like he has any trouble find desperate sailors willing to crew his ship and it seems rather petty for someone as powerful as him. Then I realize there are two very good reasons why he might want Jack in particular trapped in the Locker
** Jack is a Pirate Lord and holds one of the 9 Pieces of Eight. If Jack is trapped in the Locker along with the piece then there is no way to release Calpyso. Jones still loves Calypso but he also hates her for betraying him. This way Jones can keep Calypso trapped forever if he wants to and if at some point he chooses to release her it would be simple enough for him to take the piece from the Locker. Noone (least of all Jones) expected Barbossa & Co would go to save Jack... or that they would succeed
** It's implied several times in Dead Man's Chest and At Worlds End that Jack and Tia had a sexual relationship in the past and it didn't end very well. In At World's End it's revealed Tia is the goddess Calypso, true love of Davy Jones and the reason he tore out his heart. If Davy knew about Jack's affair with Tia then he would no doubt want revenge on Jack for sleeping with his woman!
*** Beyond that, the reason Jones is cursed on the Dutchman is because Calypso ''cheated on him'' (her betrayal). Dealing with someone she'd taken as a lover would have just been rubbing salt in a wound.
* At the end of ''At World's End'', Will is bound to serve as the captain of the ''Flying Dutchman'' for ten years. Ten years later in real time, he makes his triumphant return to the franchise in ''Dead Men Tell No Tales''. Coincidence? I think NOT!

!!Fridge Logic
* At World's End- When William sets sail and proceeds to leave Elizabeth behind in a bittersweet ending, his father assures him that she cannot go with them. No explanation is given for why this has to happen, merely that it must be this way. Which leaves the audience to wonder- given that Elizabeth successfully navigated to Davy Jones' locker at the beginning of the movie, and that Will and his father can both apparently survive the journey intact, what exactly is preventing this from happening? Is there some as yet unexplained aspect to the bargain of the Dead Man's Chest? Is Will's father just a big believer in the old adage that it is bad luck to bring a woman on board a ship? Does he secretly not approve of the marriage and want to make his daughter in law miserable?
** WordOfGod is that if the wife stays faithful for the ten years, the captain can elect to leave and become mortal again, and appoint someone else. Meeting up before ten years isn't staying true to the rules, and that would turn Will into a sea monster.
* So... at the end of the first film, Captain Barbosa is dead, and Ragetti isn't. And Ragetti has the wooden eye that was Barbossa's "piece of eight". Wouldn't that have made Ragetti the new Pirate Lord of the Caspian Sea?
** Given how Sao Feng actively tells Elizabeth about her being a Pirate Lord and hands it to her, it could be that Pirate Lords need to be outright named as successors, rather than it just coming down to who ends up with the Piece of Eight if the Pirate Lord dies.

!!Fridge Horror
* Is it only me that has noticed the inherent horror of rooting for the pirates in Worlds End. Yes, the English are being led by a dick, but most of them are innocent and honest sailors, and when you think about it, the pirates are basically all just thieving and murdering scum! I say this, of course, but I still can't stop myself rooting for the pirates at the end.
** It helps that except for a single raid at the beginning of the first movie, (and when not fighting for their lives and freedom) they all seem to be ThePiratesWhoDontDoAnything.
** Beckett is ''also'' thieving and murdering scum. He's just higher-class scum. It's a grey-and-grey morality situation, and we root for the pirates because a. we spend more time with them and b. Beckett's trying to seize control of all the supernatural power of the sea for himself.
** Think over it, who was really worse? Governments kept slaves, took high taxes(and probably took payment in various disgusting ways), excecuted people with other ideals, religions and opinions… if you look carefully is one of Blackbeard's men wearing a turban, so, in that case shows that he's okay with other religions as long as they don't try to force it onto him, like the priests did. But then the Spaniards destroy anything related to other beliefs, and the English wasn't probably much better. I think the only good people at the time where farmers and fishermen whom kept the others alive while being treated like crap..!
* In the opening of ''At World's End'', the hanging scene, where they're hanging everyone remotely associated with piracy, the fact that all Beckett has to do is say someone is a pirate and to hang them, no matter if they were. The real big bit of fridge horror was the kid who began the song; Hanging is potentially immediately fatal, as the sudden stop can (and usually does) snap necks. The kid, however, was on the small side, and probably didn't gain enough momentum in the drop to snap his neck. He strangled until he died.
** Actually, they all did. The "long drop" method of hanging (the one which breaks your neck) wasn't invented until the late 1800's... [[FridgeHorror which means that about 90 percent of all historical hangings were strangulation.]] And yes, the kid still suffered longer due to his lesser weight.
*** Strictly speaking, the trapdoor methods used in all POTC hanging scenes indicate a form of long-drop hanging is in operation, though Norington's early comments about a 'short drop and a sudden stop' suggest otherwise. The trapdoor hangings in the start of World's End seem to be instantaneous: they drop, feet shake, next row. And they put the boy on a barrel (or something similar) to get him up to the noose, increasing the distance his smaller frame has to drop when the barrel and the trapdoor drop out from under him so if anyone dies quickly in that scene: it would be him.
* In the third movie, the whole group of heroes end up quarreling at one point and [[MexicanStandoff holding guns to each other's heads]]. When they pull the trigger, they realize the guns don't work because the powder got wet. Even so: would they really have killed each other?? Jack is the first to pull the trigger on Barbossa, which is somewhat understandable as they were mortal enemies in the first movie. But the next person to try pulling the trigger is Elizabeth, pointing it at Jack! It would have been pretty silly for her to kill Jack at the end of the second movie, feel all guilty about it and go through all the trouble of getting him back from the dead, only to kill him immediately after they returned to the real world (the only explanation that would somewhat excuse her is that [[FridgeBrilliance she already knew the gun wouldn't work, and pulled the trigger only pretending she wanted to kill Jack, in a sort of pouty way.]] [[RecklessGunUsage But it's still really risky!]])
** Let's be honest. Elizabeth is a ManipulativeBastard , which makes her the only known predator of [[spoiler: Jack's MagnificentBastard]].
** Probably a case where, as above, they knew the guns wouldn't work or the writers didn't do their homework, as anyone even minimally familiar with flintlock black-powder weapons knows a sufficiently ''humid'' day will render them inoperable, let alone having been drenched in the sea.
*** they probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at eachother to realise until they pulled the trigger
----

Top