Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheLordOfTheRings

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected misspellings


* LargeHam: Gandalf gets lines like "I will draw you Saruman, as poison is drawn from a wound!" and "[[PunctuatedForEmphasis YOU...SHALL NOT...PASS!]]. Also see "Evil Is Hammy" above.
* LeaveNoSurvivors: In the films both Saruman and the Witch-King tell their minions to kill everyone in Helm's Deep and Minas Tirith, respectively.

to:

* LargeHam: Gandalf gets lines like "I will draw you you, Saruman, as poison is drawn from a wound!" and "[[PunctuatedForEmphasis YOU...SHALL NOT...PASS!]]. Also see "Evil Is Hammy" above.
* LeaveNoSurvivors: In the films films, both Saruman and the Witch-King tell their minions to kill everyone in Helm's Deep and Minas Tirith, respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected misspellings


* {{Determinator}}: Sam is Frodo's only companion to stay with him clear from the Shire to Mt. Doom, in spite of being turned away by Frodo twice, and in spite of Frodo and the others twice secretly conspiring with regards to the journey without Sam or the other hobbits. He also saves Frodo from an EldritchAbomination and Orcs, then carries him partway up Mt Doom on his own back. The only incentive he gets to do any of this is when Gandalf says, "Don't you leave him Samwise Gamgee" once, right at the beginning.

to:

* {{Determinator}}: Sam is Frodo's only companion to stay with him clear from the Shire to Mt. Doom, in spite of being turned away by Frodo twice, and in spite of Frodo and the others twice secretly conspiring with regards to the journey without Sam or the other hobbits. He also saves Frodo from an EldritchAbomination and Orcs, then carries him partway up Mt Doom on his own back. The only incentive he gets to do any of this is when Gandalf says, "Don't you leave him him, Samwise Gamgee" once, right at the beginning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** To the Creator/RalphBakshi animated ''Lord Of The Rings'' (the Nazgûl emerging from the tree as the four Hobbits hide in the roots), ''Shaka Zulu'' (the pre-Battle Of Helms Deep build-up), ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'' (Aragorn's dazed horse ride to Helm's Deep; Frodo being carried by the Eagles).

to:

** To the Creator/RalphBakshi animated ''Lord Of The Rings'' (the (Mr. Proudfoot's "ProudFEET!" with his feet up on the table at the Party; the Nazgûl emerging from the tree as the four Hobbits hide in the roots), ''Shaka Zulu'' (the pre-Battle Of Helms Deep build-up), ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'' (Aragorn's dazed horse ride to Helm's Deep; Frodo being carried by the Eagles).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Must be intentional. Details don't change that both were still meant to be equally sympathetic. Comes of as complaining against handling of Gondor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalSympathy: Because of the extra material added to ''[[Film/TheLordOfTheRingsTheTwoTowers The Two Towers]]'', the Rohirrim are unintentionally portrayed more sympathetically than the Gondorians. Especially in the extended editions, we see more of Rohan civilians escaping from Edoras, taking refuge in Helm's Deep, and celebrating their victory afterwards. On the other hand, characters in Minas Tirith from the books who could have humanized the Gondorians, such as Beregond, Bergil and Ioreth, were cut out of the movies. The Rohirrim's architecture and costumes also have a warmer color scheme than the Gondorians, where because the national colors of Gondor are black and white, the production team designed most things in Minas Tirith to be shades of gray.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneHeadTaller: As best demonstrated when the Fellowship stand together in Rivendell for the first time, dwarves are one head taller than hobbits, and men and elves are about a head and half taller than dwarves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambig


* DaylightHorror: The Ringwraiths are frightening at night. They prove to be just as frightening when they chase Arwen and a sickly Frodo across a bright green field in the middle of the day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* RatedMForManly: [[AdaptationDistillation Gimli's personality in the film]], as opposed to the book. The Dwarves in the book, as conceived by Tolkien, are far more dignified. But Gimli's part in the film has been written partly to provide comic relief and partly to provide a contrast to Legolas as played by Orlando Bloom and therefore he got a comically-exaggerated masculine attitude: almost-suicidally brave, gruff, deep-voiced, tremendously proud and braggart, [[StockAnimalDiet fond of malt beer and red meat off the bone]], DeadpanSnarker to the best, spiteful towards those who don't live to his standards of bravery.
--> '''Gimli''' (in the caves of the Dead): ''You waste your time, Aragorn! They had no honour in life, they have none now in death!''

Changed: 368

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup.


* ManOnFire:
** [[spoiler:The Steward of Gondor and nearly Faramir.]]
** Also the [[spoiler:Nazgûl that Aragorn throws a torch at]] on Weathertop.
** Also includes an Ent on fire at one point. Dousing the flames as the dam on the River Isen burst is a fairly notable FunnyBackgroundEvent.

to:

* ManOnFire:
**
ManOnFire: An Ent catches fire at one point. Dousing the flames as the dam on the River Isen burst is a fairly notable FunnyBackgroundEvent.
%%**
[[spoiler:The Steward of Gondor and nearly Faramir.]]
** %%** Also the [[spoiler:Nazgûl that Aragorn throws a torch at]] on Weathertop.
** Also includes an Ent on fire at one point. Dousing %% Please expand the flames above commented-out examples with proper context before removing markup. Once expanded, be sure to fix indentation as the dam on the River Isen burst is a fairly notable FunnyBackgroundEvent.well.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 106

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope is renamed Prefers Going Barefoot. Dewicking old name


* DoesNotLikeShoes: Frodo and the Hobbits are the obvious examples, but Lady Galadriel also goes barefoot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AThicketOfSpears:
** In ''Film/TheLordOfTheRingsTheTwoTowers'', when Eomer's army of renegades arrives to lift the siege of Helm's Deep, the Uruk-hai form a solid line of pike-orcs to meet Eomer's charge. Being orcs, however, many of them run in terror and the line collapses just as the Rohirrim reach them (helped along by Gandalf amplifying the light of the sun coming over the hilltop and blinding them).
** In ''Film/TheLordOfTheRingsTheReturnOfTheKing'', the Mordor-orcs besieging Minas Tirith try to meet the charge of the Rohirrim with a line of pike-orcs backed by archers. As at Helm's Deep, however, the Rohirrim scare the hell out of the orcs, and the line collapses as many of them turn and run.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Blade On A Stick is now a disambiguation page.


* BladeOnAStick: Elf King Gil-Galad's spear in the prologue of Fellowship of the Ring, and the Chinese style polearms carried by Haldir's Elves at the Battle of Helm's Deep.

Added: 749

Changed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSiege: The battle of ''Helm's Deep'', ''Osgiliath'' and ''Minas Tirith''. Osgiliath is the only battle the heroes lose.

to:

* TheSiege: The battle SeeNoEvilHearNoEvil:
** When the band
of ''Helm's Deep'', ''Osgiliath'' Rohirrim rides right by, the three give each other quizzical looks as if to say "huh ... they didn't notice." This was on account of the cloaks from Lothlórien, which make it difficult to see against any background -- green, grey, brown.
** In the original book, they spot the Riders from ''very'' far off already (five leagues by Legolas' estimation), consciously move down to the foot of the hill so as to not present an easily visible silhouette, sit huddled in their Elven cloaks,
and ''Minas Tirith''. Osgiliath is the only battle the heroes lose.have to wait for some time.



* ShutUpHannibal: Aragorn's response to the Mouth of Sauron's taunts is to [[spoiler: cut his head off]].

to:

* ShutUpHannibal: ShutUpHannibal:
**
Aragorn's response to the Mouth of Sauron's taunts is to [[spoiler: cut his head off]].


Added DiffLines:

* TheSiege: The battle of ''Helm's Deep'', ''Osgiliath'' and ''Minas Tirith''. Osgiliath is the only battle the heroes lose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Despite ostensibly serving as one of his protectors and being a member of the Fellowship, Legolas says exactly three words directly to Frodo: "And my bow". Justified in that the two are separated for most of the story - they meet at the House of Elrond, split up at the end of ''The Fellowship of the Ring'', and don't see each other again until the tail end of ''The Return of the King'', but awkward nonetheless. Legolas primarily interacts with Aragorn and Gimli, barely even looking at anyone else in the fellowship.
** Gimli has a similar problem to a lesser degree than Legolas. As he's mostly the comic relief to the Three Hunters trio of himself Aragorn and Legolas, he rarely talks to anyone outside that dynamic. He never once spoke to Boromir or Sam.

to:

** Despite ostensibly serving as one of his protectors and being a member of the Fellowship, Legolas says exactly three five words directly to Frodo: "And you have my bow". Justified in that the two are separated for most of the story - they meet at the House of Elrond, split up at the end of ''The Fellowship of the Ring'', and don't see each other again until the tail end of ''The Return of the King'', but awkward nonetheless. Legolas primarily interacts with Aragorn and Gimli, barely even looking at anyone else in the fellowship.
** Gimli has a similar problem to a lesser degree than Legolas. As he's mostly the comic relief to the Three Hunters trio of himself Aragorn and Legolas, he rarely talks to anyone outside that dynamic. He never once spoke speaks to Boromir or Sam.Sam.

Removed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* StupidStatementDanceMix:
** "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uE-1RPDqJAY They're taking the Hobbits to Isengard]]"
** "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jr_01rYKQLg Po-tay-toes! Boil 'em, mash 'em, stick 'em in a stew.]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: In the prologue of Fellowship of the Ring, we see Sauron explode once the Ring is severed from his hand. Though this may be subverted as the affected scores of Men and Elves were more likely blown off of their feet than killed.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: In the prologue of Fellowship of the Ring, we see Sauron explode once the Ring is severed from his hand. Though this may be subverted as the affected scores of Men and Elves were more likely blown off of their feet than killed.killed; after all, Isildur was at ground zero, and survived with no sign of injury.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing this example, it is from The Hobbit, not Lord of the Rings.


** In ''Film/TheHobbit'' trilogy, a giant elk ridden by Thranduil as a steed is inspired by the large prehistoric deer ''Megaloceros'', particularly the giant antlers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffscreenInertia: PlayedForLaughs. In the extended version of ''The Two Towers'' (but not the theatrical version), the last thing we see Merry and Pippin doing before the film ends is [[TheStoner lighting one up,]] and they're ''still'' smoking away several in-movie days later at the beginning of the next film.

to:

* OffscreenInertia: PlayedForLaughs. In the extended version of ''The Two Towers'' (but not the theatrical version), the last thing we see Merry and Pippin doing before the film ends is [[TheStoner lighting one up,]] and they're ''still'' smoking away several in-movie days later at the beginning of the next film. Admittedly, considering the way Hobbits in general (and Merry and Pippin in particular) are, it's completely believable that they ''did'' spend the entire time smoking, drinking and eating.

Added: 1166

Removed: 1166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CurbStompBattle:
** [[spoiler: Ents vs. Isengard]].
** [[spoiler: Army of the Dead vs. Forces of Sauron]], unlike the book, which describes it as a long day of battle.[[note]]In the books, the Dead don't fight at Minas Tirith but rather disperse after killing the Corsairs of Umbar, allowing Aragorn to lead the living men of the region north to join the battle.[[/note]]
* CurbStompCushion:
** While the Rohirrim's battle against the Haradrim outside Minas Tirith is nearly this, as the Mumakil the Haradrim ride are basically unstoppable juggernauts that impale, crush, and swat horsemen away with impunity, the Rohirrim give a good accounting of themselves, managing to bring down a number of Mumakil by taking advantage of their greater numbers and maneuverability, though it still takes the Army of the Dead to tip the scales in Middle-earth's favour.
** Nearly all of the battles of the soldiers of Gondor against the forces of Mordor. When the trolls break through the gate of Minas Tirith the soldiers manage to kill at least one troll and in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owzk91QqbEA this video]] you can see at least one soldier who spears down an Orc.



* KerbStompBattle:
** [[spoiler: Ents vs. Isengard]].
** [[spoiler: Army of the Dead vs. Forces of Sauron]], unlike the book, which describes it as a long day of battle.[[note]]In the books, the Dead don't fight at Minas Tirith but rather disperse after killing the Corsairs of Umbar, allowing Aragorn to lead the living men of the region north to join the battle.[[/note]]
* KerbStompCushion:
** While the Rohirrim's battle against the Haradrim outside Minas Tirith is nearly this, as the Mumakil the Haradrim ride are basically unstoppable juggernauts that impale, crush, and swat horsemen away with impunity, the Rohirrim give a good accounting of themselves, managing to bring down a number of Mumakil by taking advantage of their greater numbers and maneuverability, though it still takes the Army of the Dead to tip the scales in Middle-earth's favour.
** Nearly all of the battles of the soldiers of Gondor against the forces of Mordor. When the trolls break through the gate of Minas Tirith the soldiers manage to kill at least one troll and in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owzk91QqbEA this video]] you can see at least one soldier who spears down an Orc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImprobableAimingSkills: Elvish archery in general; see for example the Elves in the prologue shooting Orcs off the slopes of Mount Doom at what looks like over a ''mile away''. And there's Legolas specifically, of course, who shoots Orcs in the head while shield-surfing.

to:

* ImprobableAimingSkills: Elvish archery in general; see for example the Elves in the prologue shooting Orcs off the slopes of Mount Doom at what looks like over a ''mile away''. And there's Legolas specifically, of course, who shoots Orcs in the head while shield-surfing. It's never stated whether this is the Elves getting good from having had centuries of practice, being just that good due to being Elves (enhanced eyesight, reflexes, hand-eye coordination, etc.), or some combination of the two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably the cruellest one in film history is when Gandalf sends Balrog off the bridge and begins turning back...only for the tips of its whip to catch Gandalf by the foot and leave him dangling off the side of the bridge.

to:

** Probably the cruellest one in film history is when Gandalf sends drops the Balrog off the bridge and begins turning back...only for the tips of its it's whip to catch Gandalf by the foot and leave him dangling off the side of the bridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HopelessWar: The War of the Ring was very much this trope for the Free People of Middle-earth. Sauron's power and forces were growing stronger by the day, the odds of the Quest's success were becoming increasingly slim, and all the while the armies of Gondor and Rohan were struggling to bring their tactics up-to-par with that of the Enemy.

to:

* HopelessWar: The War of the Ring was very much this trope for the Free People of Middle-earth. Sauron's power and forces were growing stronger by the day, the odds of the Quest's success were becoming increasingly slim, and all the while the armies of Gondor and Rohan were struggling to bring their tactics up-to-par with that of the Enemy. The massive battle at Minas Tirith is only a small fraction of Sauron's total forces, and it took almost everything they had to stop it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreatOffscreenWar: Not a typical example, as it takes place at the same time, rather than before, the main conflict--but in the extended edition of [=RotK=], there is a moment when Gimli says that he wishes he had Dwarf warriors beside him. Legolas replies that he fears the Dwarves are already at war; anyone who has read the appendices knows that ''both'' of their homelands (Erebor and Mirkwood, respectively) are indeed fighting Sauron's armies in the north. The Dwarves even lose their king in the conflict. The fighting around Gondor is a sideshow by comparison to the scale of the attacks on Erebor and Mirkwood.

to:

* GreatOffscreenWar: Not a typical example, as it takes place at the same time, rather than before, the main conflict--but in the extended edition of [=RotK=], there is a moment when Gimli says that he wishes he had Dwarf warriors beside him. Legolas replies that he fears the Dwarves are already at war; anyone who has read the appendices knows that ''both'' of their homelands (Erebor and Mirkwood, respectively) are indeed fighting Sauron's armies in the north. The Dwarves even lose their king in the conflict. The fighting around Gondor is a sideshow by comparison to the scale of the attacks on Erebor and Mirkwood.Mirkwood[[note]]Giving the Dwarves their homeland back by killing Smaug in ''The Hobbit'' is in fact the one of the reasons Gandalf helped them in that quest; he wants a strong, Dwarven-controlled Erebor to help stand against the eventual attacks from Mordor (the other reason is to prevent Smaug from being a wild-card problem they have to deal with, if not an outright ally of Sauron)[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the climax of the story, Gollum dies while falling into Mount Doom with the Ring, but the book and the film depict the exact circumstances a bit differently. In the book, Gollum trips and falls over the precipice while celebrating his retaking of the Ring. This was filmed, but when translated to film this ending came off as too anticlimactic. A couple of other scenarios were tried, and what eventually made it to the screen was that Frodo, still caught in his own desire for the Ring, started struggling with Gollum for it again, eventually resulting in both falling over the precipice together. Gollum fell into the lava with the Ring, but Frodo managed to grab the ledge, and Sam managed to pull him up and out of immediate danger.

to:

** At the climax of the story, Gollum dies while falling into Mount Doom with the Ring, but the book and the film depict the exact circumstances a bit differently. In the book, Gollum trips and falls over the precipice while celebrating his retaking of the Ring. This was filmed, but when translated to film this ending came off as too anticlimactic. A couple of other scenarios were tried, and what eventually made it to the screen was that Frodo, still caught in his own desire for the Ring, started struggling with Gollum for it again, eventually resulting in both falling over the precipice together. Gollum fell into the lava with the Ring, but Frodo managed to grab the ledge, and Sam managed to pull him up and out of immediate danger. It also allows Frodo to participate in the Ring's destruction, while also making Gollum not look like such an idiot as to fall into the lava all on his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolMask: The Witch-King spiky, crowned helmet, which immediately sets him apart from the other Nazgul.

to:

* CoolMask: The Witch-King Witch-King's spiky, crowned helmet, which immediately sets him apart from the other Nazgul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If counting where Bilbo and Frodo's sword, Sting, received its name in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' [[spoiler: killing the giant spiders of Mirkwood as they attacked the ensnared dwarves]], it's perhaps one of these or a BrickJoke that Samwise uses Sting to defeat Shelob.

to:

** If counting where Bilbo and Frodo's sword, Sting, received its name in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' [[spoiler: killing the giant spiders of Mirkwood as they attacked the ensnared dwarves]], it's perhaps one of these or a BrickJoke that Samwise uses Sting to defeat Shelob.Shelob (the Mirkwood spiders are literally her offspring).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In the film, Theoden refuses Gandalf's advice to fight Saruman in the open on the grounds that his main force is too far away with the banished Eomer, so he must abandon vulnerable Edoras for the fortress of Helm's Deep. However, this plan is treated as inherently wrong by Aragorn and Gandalf, the later of whom rides off to retrieve Eomer apparently in defiance of Theoden even though the king only said summoning him was unfeasible, not unwanted. In the novels, by contrast, Theoden [[JumpedAtTheCall immediately accepts]] Gandalf's advice to call up all his forces and immediately leads his household guard to join the forces already defending the Westfold while the rest of his forces assemble.

to:

*** In the film, Theoden refuses Gandalf's advice to fight Saruman in the open on the grounds that his main force is too far away with the banished Eomer, so he must abandon vulnerable Edoras for the fortress of Helm's Deep. However, this plan is treated as inherently wrong by Aragorn and Gandalf, the later latter of whom rides off to retrieve Eomer apparently in defiance of Theoden even though the king only said summoning him was unfeasible, not unwanted. In the novels, by contrast, Theoden [[JumpedAtTheCall immediately accepts]] Gandalf's advice to call up all his forces and immediately leads his household guard to join the forces already defending the Westfold while the rest of his forces assemble.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Eomer gets in a good one when he finds [[spoiler:Eowyn's body]] on the battlefield(only in Extended Cut).

to:

** Eomer gets in a good one when he finds [[spoiler:Eowyn's body]] on the battlefield(only battlefield (only in Extended Cut).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassBoast: [[InTheNameOfTheMoon "I am a servant of the Secret Fire]], wielder of the flame of Anor. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn![[note]]There is some debate about ''exactly'' what Gandalf is invoking here, but he is generally considered to be saying that he is a wielder of the flame of creation (and thus an immensely powerful being, on a par with the Balrog's own power), and that the Balrog's power (dark fire) will not overcome his (flame of Udûn is apparently a way of referring to the Balrog itself). See [[http://tolkien.cro.net/else/gdfire.html here]] for more info[[/note]]. Go back to the shadow... YOU SHALL NOT PASS!"

to:

* BadassBoast: [[InTheNameOfTheMoon "I am a servant of the Secret Fire]], wielder of the flame of Anor. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn![[note]]There is some debate about ''exactly'' what Gandalf is invoking here, but he is generally considered to be saying that he is a Maia, a servant of the Valar, and thus wielder of the flame of creation (and thus an immensely powerful being, on a par with the Balrog's own power), and that the Balrog's power (dark fire) will not overcome his (flame of Udûn is apparently a way of referring to the Balrog itself). See [[http://tolkien.cro.net/else/gdfire.html here]] for more info[[/note]]. Go back to the shadow... YOU SHALL NOT PASS!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassBoast: [[InTheNameOfTheMoon "I am a servant of the Secret Fire]], wielder of the flame of Anor. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn! Go back to the shadow... YOU SHALL NOT PASS!"

to:

* BadassBoast: [[InTheNameOfTheMoon "I am a servant of the Secret Fire]], wielder of the flame of Anor. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn! Udûn![[note]]There is some debate about ''exactly'' what Gandalf is invoking here, but he is generally considered to be saying that he is a wielder of the flame of creation (and thus an immensely powerful being, on a par with the Balrog's own power), and that the Balrog's power (dark fire) will not overcome his (flame of Udûn is apparently a way of referring to the Balrog itself). See [[http://tolkien.cro.net/else/gdfire.html here]] for more info[[/note]]. Go back to the shadow... YOU SHALL NOT PASS!"

Top