Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* OneArmedWarrior: [[spoiler:Liu Jinxi himself]], and self-inflicted at that. He's still fully capable of holding his own even afterward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moral Dilemma is being dewicked
Changed line(s) 46 (click to see context) from:
* ToBeLawfulOrGood: [[spoiler:The MoralDilemma that Xu Baijiu faces, as he gradually realizes Lu Jinxi truly has reformed himself.]]
to:
* ToBeLawfulOrGood: [[spoiler:The MoralDilemma conflict in morals that Xu Baijiu faces, as he gradually realizes Lu Jinxi truly has reformed himself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by Creator/PeterChan and starring Creator/DonnieYen and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
to:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by Creator/PeterChan and starring Creator/DonnieYen Creator/DonnieYen, Creator/JimmyWangYu, Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
Creator/KaraWai.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* RemakeCameo: The Master is played by Creator/JimmyWangYu, star of the original Film/OneArmedSwordsman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted line(s) 34 (click to see context) :
* ManInWhite: Detective Baijiu dresses in bright white.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring Creator/DonnieYen and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
to:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan Creator/PeterChan and starring Creator/DonnieYen and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
Thus begins a martial arts thriller that touches on themes of law versus good and destiny versus free will.
to:
Thus begins a martial arts thriller that touches on themes of [[ToBeLawfulOrGood law versus good good]] and [[SlidingScaleOfFreeWillVsFate destiny versus free will.
will]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/swordsmen.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
Not related to the similarly-titled fanfic, ''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}'', nor the 1990s ''Swordsman'' trilogy.
to:
Not related to the similarly-titled fanfic, ''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}'', nor the 1990s ''Swordsman'' ''Film/{{Swordsman}}'' trilogy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
Not related to the similarly-titled fanfic, ''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}''.
to:
Not related to the similarly-titled fanfic, ''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}''.
''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}'', nor the 1990s ''Swordsman'' trilogy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
to:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen Creator/DonnieYen and Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Making a distinction between two similarly-named works.
Added DiffLines:
Not related to the similarly-titled fanfic, ''FanFic/{{Swordsmen}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
to:
* HandicappedBadass: Lu Jinxi after [[spoiler:cutting off his arm.]]
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend andally]].ally.]]
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and
Added DiffLines:
* NonActionGuy: Defied by Baijiu, who has no proper martial arts training and still [[spoiler:charges to fight the Master with his needles.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* BadassNormal: Xu Baijiu does not know martial arts beyond his acupuncture skills, but [[spoiler:he manages to defeat the Master using needless and lightning, at the cost of his life.]]
to:
* BadassNormal: Xu Baijiu does not know martial arts beyond his acupuncture skills, but [[spoiler:he manages to defeat the Master using needless needles and lightning, at the cost of his life.]]
Changed line(s) 14,15 (click to see context) from:
* BittersweeterEnding: [[spoiler:Detective Baijiu is dead, Jinxi has lost an arm, and the 72 Demons are still free. However, the Master is dead for good, and Jinxi can live peacefully with his family from now.]]
* BloodFromMouth: [[spoiler:Baijiu's death.]]
* BloodFromMouth: [[spoiler:Baijiu's death.]]
to:
* BittersweeterEnding: BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Detective Baijiu is dead, Jinxi has lost an arm, and the 72 Demons are still free. However, the Master is dead for good, and Jinxi can live peacefully with his family from now.]]
*BloodFromMouth: BloodFromTheMouth: [[spoiler:Baijiu's death.]]
*
Changed line(s) 17 (click to see context) from:
* CombatPragmatist: Tang Long disarms the Madam and dominates her by using small joints manipulation when she is distracted with her sword lodged on the wall.
to:
* CombatPragmatist: Tang Long disarms the Madam and dominates her by using small joints joint manipulation when she is distracted with her sword lodged on the wall.
* FourEyesZeroSoul: Baijiu.
Changed line(s) 26,27 (click to see context) from:
* InspectorJavert: Baijiu becomes increasingly distrustful paranoid towards Jinxi, and soon gets obsessed over uncovering his true identity.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
to:
* InspectorJavert: Baijiu becomes increasingly distrustful and paranoid towards Jinxi, and soon gets obsessed over uncovering his supposed true identity.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his formercrimes, crimes through his personal repentance.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former
Changed line(s) 29 (click to see context) from:
* MaskOfSanity: Possibly; it is not clear whether Baijiu is clinically off his rocker or it is just an artistic device to show his inner thoughts, but aside his quirks and obsessions, we actually see sides of his mind taking physical shape and talking to him as evil clones.
to:
* MaskOfSanity: Possibly; it is not clear whether Baijiu is clinically off his rocker or it is just an artistic narrative device to show his inner thoughts, but aside his quirks and obsessions, we actually see sides a side of his mind taking physical shape and talking to him as an evil clones.clone.
Deleted line(s) 31 (click to see context) :
* NerdGlasses: Baijiu has them.
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. His qiong is so strong that he cannot be hurt by the impact of baldes, and he also can throw people clear across the room. The old man is practically TheJuggernaut.
to:
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. His qiong qigong is so strong that he cannot be hurt by the impact of baldes, blades, and he also can throw people clear across the room. The old man is practically TheJuggernaut.
Changed line(s) 37 (click to see context) from:
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool, almost killing him, in a paroxism of frustration and conviction about his theory.
to:
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool, almost killing him, in a paroxism of frustration and conviction about his theory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AmbiguouslyEvil: The detective Baijiu firmly adheres to law, but he is shown to be quite underhanded and amoral.
* ArmorIsUseless: The master's qigong or control of his internal energy is enough to stop a blade.
* ArmorIsUseless: The master's qigong or control of his internal energy is enough to stop a blade.
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Jinxi [[spoiler:aka Tang Long]] is mainly a peaceful villager, but if you attack his family, he will show to you his true self.
* BigBad: The Master of the 72 Demons.
* BittersweeterEnding: [[spoiler:Detective Baijiu is dead, Jinxi has lost an arm, and the 72 Demons are still free. However, the Master is dead for good, and Jinxi can live peacefully with his family from now.]]
* BloodFromMouth: [[spoiler:Baijiu's death.]]
* ChekhovsSkill: Xu Baijiu's acupuncture skills come handy at the end of the film.
* CombatPragmatist: Tang Long disarms the Madam and dominates her by using small joints manipulation when she is distracted with her sword lodged on the wall.
* BigBad: The Master of the 72 Demons.
* BittersweeterEnding: [[spoiler:Detective Baijiu is dead, Jinxi has lost an arm, and the 72 Demons are still free. However, the Master is dead for good, and Jinxi can live peacefully with his family from now.]]
* BloodFromMouth: [[spoiler:Baijiu's death.]]
* ChekhovsSkill: Xu Baijiu's acupuncture skills come handy at the end of the film.
* CombatPragmatist: Tang Long disarms the Madam and dominates her by using small joints manipulation when she is distracted with her sword lodged on the wall.
* DarkActionGirl: The 13th Madam.
* MaskOfSanity: Possibly; it is not clear whether Baijiu is clinically off his rocker or it is just an artistic device to show his inner thoughts, but aside his quirks and obsessions, we actually see sides of his mind taking physical shape and talking to him as evil clones.
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistFight: Not when your opponent is a qi master. It will be useless.
* NerdGlasses: Baijiu has them.
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistFight: Not when your opponent is a qi master. It will be useless.
* NerdGlasses: Baijiu has them.
Changed line(s) 21,22 (click to see context) from:
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. His Qi Gong is so strong that he cannot be hurt by the impact of baldes, and he also can throw people clear across the room. The old man is practically TheJuggernaut.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool and almost severs his arteries.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool and almost severs his arteries.
to:
* OhCrap: The detective has this look in his eyes when Jinxi and him are alone in the road and he believes he is gonna be murdered.
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. HisQi Gong qiong is so strong that he cannot be hurt by the impact of baldes, and he also can throw people clear across the room. The old man is practically TheJuggernaut.
* OneManArmy: Tang Long.
* PressurePoint: Baijiu' fighting style, if it can be called such.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agriculturaltool and tool, almost severs killing him, in a paroxism of frustration and conviction about his arteries.theory.
* ScreamingWarrior: Many, especially among the 72 Demons.
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. His
* OneManArmy: Tang Long.
* PressurePoint: Baijiu' fighting style, if it can be called such.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural
* ScreamingWarrior: Many, especially among the 72 Demons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7,9 (click to see context) from:
!!Tropes used in this work:
!!!Setting, Plot, and Themes
!!!Setting, Plot, and Themes
to:
!!!Setting, Plot,
* BadassNormal: Xu Baijiu does not know martial arts beyond his acupuncture skills, but [[spoiler:he manages to defeat the Master using needless and
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* TheDon: The Master of the 72 Demons gang of assassins.
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* HeroicSacrifice: [[spoiler:The detective gives his life to turn the The Master into a lightning rod. It's worth it.]]
to:
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* HeroicSacrifice:[[spoiler:The detective [[spoiler:Baijiu gives his life to turn the The Master into a lightning rod. It's worth it.]]]]
* InspectorJavert: Baijiu becomes increasingly distrustful paranoid towards Jinxi, and soon gets obsessed over uncovering his true identity.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* ManInWhite: Detective Baijiu dresses in bright white.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* HeroicSacrifice:
* InspectorJavert: Baijiu becomes increasingly distrustful paranoid towards Jinxi, and soon gets obsessed over uncovering his true identity.
* KnightTemplar: Baijiu, especially to Lu Jinxi. The detective explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* ManInWhite: Detective Baijiu dresses in bright white.
* OldMaster: The Master of the 72 Demons. His Qi Gong is so strong that he cannot be hurt by the impact of baldes, and he also can throw people clear across the room. The old man is practically TheJuggernaut.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool and almost severs his arteries.
* SanitySlippage: When Baijiu attacks Jinxi with a bladed agricultural tool and almost severs his arteries.
Changed line(s) 15,30 (click to see context) from:
* {{Wuxia}}: The setting--with small rural tribes and secret martial artists--is effectively this, even though the detective's western clothing is unusual for the genre, and the film is technically set in the early 20th century.
!!!Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster: [[spoiler:TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.]] He's practically a LightningBruiser, exhibiting excellent offense, defense, and speed.
* TheDon: The Master of the "72 Demons" gang of assassins.
!!!Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
* WholePlotReference: largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
----
!!!Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster: [[spoiler:TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.]] He's practically a LightningBruiser, exhibiting excellent offense, defense, and speed.
* TheDon: The Master of the "72 Demons" gang of assassins.
!!!Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
* WholePlotReference: largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
----
to:
* {{Wuxia}}: The setting--with small rural tribes and secret martial artists--is effectively this, even though the detective's western clothing is unusual for the genre, and the film is technically set in the early 20th century.
!!!Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster: [[spoiler:TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.]] He's practically a LightningBruiser, exhibiting excellent offense, defense, and speed.
* TheDon: The Master of the "72 Demons" gang of assassins.
!!!Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
* WholePlotReference: largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
----century.
!!!Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster: [[spoiler:TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.]] He's practically a LightningBruiser, exhibiting excellent offense, defense, and speed.
* TheDon: The Master of the "72 Demons" gang of assassins.
!!!Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
* WholePlotReference: largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
Thus begins a martial arts thriller that asks touches on themes of law versus good and destiny versus free will.
to:
Thus begins a martial arts thriller that asks touches on themes of law versus good and destiny versus free will.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Do not spoiler tag trope names on work pages or the names of works on trope pages; please see Handling Spoilers for more information.
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* [[spoiler:HeroicSacrifice]]: [[spoiler:The detective gives his life to turn the The Master into a lightning rod. It's worth it.]]
to:
* [[spoiler:HeroicSacrifice]]: HeroicSacrifice: [[spoiler:The detective gives his life to turn the The Master into a lightning rod. It's worth it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen and TakeshiKaneshiro.
to:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen and TakeshiKaneshiro.
Creator/TakeshiKaneshiro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 20,21 (click to see context) from:
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the number two member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the number two member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
to:
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to poison his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as thenumber two NumberTwo member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 28,30 (click to see context) from:
* SpiritualSuccessor:
** Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
** Plotwise, largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
** Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
** Plotwise, largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
to:
* SpiritualSuccessor:
**SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
** Plotwise, * WholePlotReference: largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
**
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s true, and I\'m not the first to notice. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22history+of+violence%22+%22wu+xia%22
Changed line(s) 28 (click to see context) from:
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
to:
* SpiritualSuccessor: SpiritualSuccessor:
** Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in thisone.one.
** Plotwise, largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
** Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this
** Plotwise, largely a remake of [[spoiler:AHistoryOfViolence]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
Setting, Plot, and Themes
to:
Changed line(s) 17 (click to see context) from:
Characterization
to:
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
Metacontext
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,3 (click to see context) from:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen.
Liu Jinxi (Donnie Yen) is a father with a loving wife and two young children, and works at a paper mill in early 20th-century rural China. So why is detective Xu Baijiu (Takeshi Kaneshiro) investigating him? Thus begins this martial arts thriller film.
Liu Jinxi (Donnie Yen) is a father with a loving wife and two young children, and works at a paper mill in early 20th-century rural China. So why is detective Xu Baijiu (Takeshi Kaneshiro) investigating him? Thus begins this martial arts thriller film.
to:
''Swordsmen'', also known as ''Wu Xia'', is a 2011 film directed by PeterChan and starring DonnieYen.
DonnieYen and TakeshiKaneshiro.
Liu Jinxi (Donnie Yen) is just afather with non-notable villager in a loving wife small village, but he was able to kill a pair of bandits, one of whom was a very skilled fighter and two young children, and works at a paper mill in early 20th-century rural China. So why is detective on the most-wanted list. Detective Xu Baijiu (Takeshi Kaneshiro) investigating him? is sent to investigate.
Thus beginsthis a martial arts thriller film.that asks touches on themes of law versus good and destiny versus free will.
Liu Jinxi (Donnie Yen) is just a
Thus begins
Setting, Plot, and Themes
* EmotionsVersusStoicism: Detective Xu Baijiu falls squarely on the Stoicism side, and he cites his past experiences as a justification. He has even used acupuncture to suppress the emotion of caring and mercy for others when it conflicts with upholding the law. The events of the film challenge this belief.
* [[spoiler:HeroicSacrifice]]: [[spoiler:The detective gives his life to turn the The Master into a lightning rod. It's worth it.]]
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
* OldMaster: TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.
* TheDon
* TheDon
to:
* SlidingScaleOfFreeWillVersusFate: A theme debated through the events of the film. For Lu Jinxi, it is whether [[spoiler:his past will haunt and perhaps kill him, either by his former gang or by the law, or whether he can successfully make a new life for himself]]. For Xu Baijiu, it is how much people choose to be evil and must be held back by law or how much circumstances may conspire to result in evil. These two characters actually sit down once and have a chat about destiny.
* ToBeLawfulOrGood: [[spoiler:The MoralDilemma that Xu Baijiu faces, as he gradually realizes Lu Jinxi truly has reformed himself.]]
* {{Wuxia}}: The setting--with small rural tribes and secret martial artists--is effectively this, even though the detective's western clothing is unusual for the genre, and the film is technically set in the early 20th century.
Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the number two member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster:TheDon [[spoiler:TheDon cannot be hurt by the impact of blades and can throw people clear across the room. This old man is extremely dangerous.
dangerous.]] He's practically a LightningBruiser, exhibiting excellent offense, defense, and speed.
*TheDonTheDon: The Master of the "72 Demons" gang of assassins.
Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.
* ToBeLawfulOrGood: [[spoiler:The MoralDilemma that Xu Baijiu faces, as he gradually realizes Lu Jinxi truly has reformed himself.]]
* {{Wuxia}}: The setting--with small rural tribes and secret martial artists--is effectively this, even though the detective's western clothing is unusual for the genre, and the film is technically set in the early 20th century.
Characterization
* BadassNormal: [[spoiler:How do you expect a mere detective and coroner with knowledge of physiology and acupuncture to aid in a fight against an extremely skilled martial arts master? Well, he could try some acupuncture needles. And then he could try some more needles. And get killed in the process...but actually help them win.]]
* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Considering that a random paper mill worker named Lu Jinxi killed a skilled fighter and bandit who was on the most-wanted list, the detective deduces that Jinxi is not what he seems.
* GoodIsNotNice: Xu Baijiu once released a juvenile offender to foster care, thinking said offender had reformed. The offender proceeded to his foster parents and almost Baijiu himself. Since then, he has resolved to not let people off the hook of the law easy, and to keep any instinct of mercy or kindness out of his work.
* HeelFaceTurn: Lu Jinxi, from [[spoiler:his being a cold-blooded killer many years ago, as the number two member of the 72 Demons]]. And later, [[spoiler:the detective becomes this, as he changes from being an antagonist to Lu Jinxi to a friend and ally]].
* LawfulAnal / KnightTemplar: The detective, especially to Lu Jinxi. The Xu Baijiu explicitly states that law is the only source of true justice in the world, but Lu Jinxi has been trying to establish a new life free from his former crimes, through his personal repentance.
* OldMaster:
*
Metacontext
* ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin: The movie has a {{wuxia}} setting, as indicated by the Chinese title of the film. Averted, however, with the English title, since the film has relatively few swordsmen.
* SpiritualSuccessor: Director Peter Chan cited the 1967 movie ''Film/OneArmedSwordsman'' as a major inspiration, and he and Donnie Yen decided to indirectly reference that movie in this one.