Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / MyWay

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SelfPlagiarism: ''My Way'' lifts several elements from it's director Kang Je-gyu's earlier, more well-known war film, ''Film/{{Taegukgi}}'', from the brotherhood bonding scenes, camerawork and cinematography of the big battle scenes, dramatic elements, and having a protagonist played by Creator/JangDongGun who [[spoiler:dies at the end for the secondary character he had grown estranged with]]. Even the final battle scenes look similar, right up to a CG plane being shot down by ground forces before crashing into the trenches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: One of the Korean conscripts suffers this fate courtesy of a Russian tank running over where his belt would be while the guy's injured and unable to move. Jun-Shik tries helping him, but unfortunately the latter's pants are the only thing holding his body parts together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* JerkToNiceGuyPlot: Tatsuo's character arc, from a JerkJock and TheNeidermeyer VillainProtagonist to a LovableJock who is FireForgedFriends with his Korean rival.

Added: 780

Removed: 225

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BasedOnATrueStory: [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yang_Kyoungjong Yang Kyoungjong]], who was conscripted into the Imperial Japanese Army, then the Red Army, then the Wehrmacht before being captured by Americans after D-Day.


Added DiffLines:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Possibly even BasedOnAGreatBigLie. The plot is based on the story of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yang_Kyoungjong Yang Kyoungjong]], a Korean who was conscripted into the Imperial Japanese Army, then the Red Army, then the Wehrmacht before being captured by Americans after D-Day, but all this movie does is use that general premise, inventing a new character as protagonist. And beyond that, there isn't a lot of firm evidence that anyone named Yang Kyoungjong existed in the first place, except for a picture that shows an unnamed "Japanese man" surrendering.[[note]]It has been suggested that the man in the [[https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Yang_Kyoungjong.jpg famous photo]] might be an ethnic Georgian rather than Korean.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Khalkhin Gol battles are some of the worst examples of movie tactics. They consist of just one side or both sides charging towards the other, the two meeting, and then a massive scrum occurring in which soldiers of both sides are mixed indiscriminately and almost constantly within reach of an enemy. This tactic was never considered viable. The closest to it is probably the way trench raids were conducted in WWI, but even then the defenders would stay in their trenches, and the attackers would move as fast as possible to get out of the open field. Mixing together friendly and enemy like that, above ground, with no cover, would cause pretty much everybody involved in the mix to die, which makes it awfully hard to claim victory for either side. Ironically, a brief scene before the Japanese suicide assault on the Soviet tanks is [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5nEzakYbFc far more accurate]] to what the actual battle was like.

to:

** The Khalkhin Gol battles are some of the worst examples of movie tactics. They consist of just one side or both sides charging towards the other, the two meeting, and then a massive scrum occurring in which soldiers of both sides are mixed indiscriminately and almost constantly within reach of an enemy. This tactic was never considered viable. The closest to it is probably the way trench raids were conducted in WWI, but even then the defenders would stay in their trenches, and the attackers would move as fast as possible to get out of the open field. Mixing together friendly and enemy like that, above ground, with no cover, would cause pretty much everybody involved in the mix to die, which makes it awfully hard to claim victory for either side. Ironically, a brief scene before the Japanese suicide assault on the Soviet tanks is [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5nEzakYbFc com/watch?v=lfI9de2YDQg far more accurate]] to what the actual battle was like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ManOnFire: The battle between the Japanese platoon and Russian tanks have the Japanese charging napalm-loaded trucks into the Russian columns, incinerating themselves as well as the Russian tank operators. And then the Russians retaliating by unleashing [[FireBreathingWeapon flamethrower-equipped]] tanks into the Japanese columns.


Added DiffLines:

* TakingYouWithMe: The battle against Russian tanks have more than one Japanese soldier, having a bandoleer of grenades strapped on them, pulling the pin while they clung on Soviet tanks.


Added DiffLines:

* ThoseWereOnlyTheirScouts: The Japanese army had seemingly won their first battle against the Russians, who came with ''tanks'', while sustaining ''massive'' casualties in the process. The surviving Japanese troops (what pitiful amount theere is that's left) began celebrating, before a second Russian tank unit, even bigger than the first, follows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Korean character Jong-dae becoming a cruel DirtyCommunist FatBastard to a point he even turned against his fellow Koreans who were not communists foreshadowed the subsequent rise of North Korea and their animosity towards the anti-communist South Korea that even spawned the Korean War between them.

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Korean character Jong-dae becoming a cruel DirtyCommunist FatBastard FatBastard, to a point he even turned against his fellow Koreans who were solely because they're not communists foreshadowed communists, foreshadows the subsequent rise of North Korea and their animosity towards the anti-communist South Korea, where the film was made and where most of its cast and crew hails from. South Korea's animosity towards communist North Korea that even spawned rose in turn until the Korean War broke out between them. both states.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Shirai uses a German Karabiner 98 kurz with a ZF 39 scope. The rifle is not inherently wrong, but the Kar 98k was actually ''rare'' within the Chinese military by that point, as many had been used by the Nationalist's few German-trained divisions, many who were wiped out in the Battle of Shanghai in 1937, two years before Shirai shows up. Both Nationalists and Communists also armed themselves with local copies of German rifles, the most widely used being the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiang_Kai-shek_rifle Type 24]] and [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanyang_88 Hanyang 88]]. The scope is also a bit odd, for the same reason as the Type 99 rifle. What's really strange, though, is how a cartridge is seen ejecting from Shirai's rifle at the exact same moment as her gunshot is heard. The K98k is a bolt-action rifle, meaning that the shooter has to manually open and pull back the bolt in order to eject a round after firing. A cartridge won't eject from a bolt-action rifle at the same time as its fired unless there's something very, very wrong with the rifle. Either the locking lugs that hold the bolt in place would have sheared off, or the firing pin would have been improperly installed, causing the rifle to fire when the bolt isn't fully closed and thus not locked. Either way, something is very wrong with Shirai's rifle, and it would be very unsafe to fire the rifle again without fixing it.

to:

** Shirai uses a German Karabiner 98 kurz with a ZF 39 ZF-39 scope. The rifle is not inherently wrong, but the Kar 98k was actually ''rare'' within the Chinese military by that point, as many had been used by the Nationalist's few German-trained divisions, many who were wiped out in the Battle of Shanghai in 1937, two years before Shirai shows up. Both Nationalists and Communists also armed themselves with local copies of German rifles, the most widely used being the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiang_Kai-shek_rifle Type 24]] Zhongzheng]] and [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanyang_88 Hanyang 88]]. The scope is also a bit odd, for the same reason as the Type 99 rifle. What's really strange, though, is how a cartridge is seen ejecting from Shirai's rifle at the exact same moment as her gunshot is heard. The K98k is a bolt-action rifle, meaning that the shooter has to manually open and pull back the bolt in order to eject a round after firing. A cartridge won't eject from a bolt-action rifle at the same time as its fired unless there's something very, very wrong with the rifle. Either the locking lugs that hold the bolt in place would have sheared off, or the firing pin would have been improperly installed, causing the rifle to fire when the bolt isn't fully closed and thus not locked. Either way, something is very wrong with Shirai's rifle, and it would be very unsafe to fire the rifle again without fixing it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: [[spoiler: Tatsuo finds the brutality of a Russian Commissar very similar to his own,. Which helps BreakTheHaughty.]]

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: [[spoiler: Tatsuo finds the brutality of a Russian Commissar very similar to his own,. own, Which helps BreakTheHaughty.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Khalkhin Gol battles are some of the worst examples of movie tactics. They consist of just one side or both sides charging towards the other, the two meeting, and then a massive scrum occurring in which soldiers of both sides are mixed indiscriminately and almost constantly within reach of an enemy. This tactic was never considered viable. The closest to it is probably the way trench raids were conducted in WWI, but even then the defenders would stay in their trenches, and the attackers would move as fast as possible to get out of the open field. Mixing together friendly and enemy like that, above ground, with no cover, would cause pretty much everybody involved in the mix to die, which makes it awfully hard to claim victory for either side.

to:

** The Khalkhin Gol battles are some of the worst examples of movie tactics. They consist of just one side or both sides charging towards the other, the two meeting, and then a massive scrum occurring in which soldiers of both sides are mixed indiscriminately and almost constantly within reach of an enemy. This tactic was never considered viable. The closest to it is probably the way trench raids were conducted in WWI, but even then the defenders would stay in their trenches, and the attackers would move as fast as possible to get out of the open field. Mixing together friendly and enemy like that, above ground, with no cover, would cause pretty much everybody involved in the mix to die, which makes it awfully hard to claim victory for either side. Ironically, a brief scene before the Japanese suicide assault on the Soviet tanks is [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5nEzakYbFc far more accurate]] to what the actual battle was like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImprobableAimingSkills: Shirai the Chinese sniper manages to shoot down a ''fighter plane'' with her rifle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreepyCrows: Crows are feasting on corpses on the Khalkhin Gol battlefield.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The movie is about two marathon runners, Jun-shik Kim (a Korean) and Tatsuo Hasegawa (a Japanese), who are fierce racing competitors from childhood. Years later during a marathon where Jun-shik wins, a riot breaks out when the Japanese judge declares Tatsuo the winner, wrongly disqualifying Jun-shik for cheating. Afterward, the riot instigators, including Jun-shik, are conscripted into the Japanese Army, where he is stationed at Nomonhan under command of the now Colonel Tatsuo. Jun-shik fights alongside Tatsuo during the Khalkin Gol campaign against the Russians in 1937. Both are captured by the Soviet Red Army and are sent to a hellish gulag. With the Soviet Union reeling under the weight of the German invasion in 1941, they are drafted at gunpoint to fight in the Battle of Hedosk. Tatsuo and Jun-shik survive and are then captured by the Wehrmacht, who in turn conscript them as ''Osttruppen''. The film climaxes with D-Day as the Americans invade Normandy where Jun-shik and Tatsuo are stationed.

to:

The movie is about two marathon runners, Jun-shik Kim (a Korean) Korean, played by Creator/JangDongGun) and Tatsuo Hasegawa (a Japanese), who are fierce racing competitors from childhood. Years later during a marathon where Jun-shik wins, a riot breaks out when the Japanese judge declares Tatsuo the winner, wrongly disqualifying Jun-shik for cheating. Afterward, the riot instigators, including Jun-shik, are conscripted into the Japanese Army, where he is stationed at Nomonhan under command of the now Colonel Tatsuo. Jun-shik fights alongside Tatsuo during the Khalkin Gol campaign against the Russians in 1937. Both are captured by the Soviet Red Army and are sent to a hellish gulag. With the Soviet Union reeling under the weight of the German invasion in 1941, they are drafted at gunpoint to fight in the Battle of Hedosk. Tatsuo and Jun-shik survive and are then captured by the Wehrmacht, who in turn conscript them as ''Osttruppen''. The film climaxes with D-Day as the Americans invade Normandy where Jun-shik and Tatsuo are stationed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** American soldiers fire grappling hooks up the hill into the German trenches. These were only used by Rangers at the cliffs of Point du Hoc. However, the American soldiers can be seen with 4th Division shoulder patches, and the German positions are captured very quickly, suggesting that the scene takes place at Utah beach. Then again, the high American casualties, which are easily in excess of 100 on screen and thus many more hundreds at other points along the beach, are much more like Omaha beach. This troper actually quite liked the movie, but dear god, the battle scenes are so inaccurate.

to:

** American soldiers fire grappling hooks up the hill into the German trenches. These were only used by Rangers at the cliffs of Point du Hoc. However, the American soldiers can be seen with 4th Division shoulder patches, and the German positions are captured very quickly, suggesting that the scene takes place at Utah beach. Then again, the high American casualties, which are easily in excess of 100 on screen and thus many more hundreds at other points along the beach, are much more like Omaha beach. This troper actually quite liked the movie, but dear god, the battle scenes are so inaccurate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedemptionEqualsDeath: [[spoiler:Becoming succumbing to his wounds, Jong-dae apologizes for going all HeWhoFightsMonsters to Jun-shik and tells him to hide while BuriedInAPileOfCorpses to survive once the futile battle is over.]]

to:

* RedemptionEqualsDeath: [[spoiler:Becoming [[spoiler:Before succumbing to his wounds, Jong-dae apologizes for going all HeWhoFightsMonsters to Jun-shik and tells him to hide while BuriedInAPileOfCorpses to survive once the futile battle is over.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The "Battle of Hedosk" is fictional.

Added: 510

Removed: 510

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen:
** Subverted, Colonel Takakura at the beginning of the film shows this, but is demoted and forced to commit suicide for "shamelessly retreating" from an overpowering Soviet armor attack.
** Tatsuo's grandfather, General Hasegawa, was a very BenevolentBoss to the Korean servants on his estate, in contrast to the mistreatment Koreans usually suffered at the hands of the Japanese. This makes his HeroicSacrifice all the more tragic, as his Korean retainers are just as horrified as his family.


Added DiffLines:

* AFatherToHisMen:
** Subverted, Colonel Takakura at the beginning of the film shows this, but is demoted and forced to commit suicide for "shamelessly retreating" from an overpowering Soviet armor attack.
** Tatsuo's grandfather, General Hasegawa, was a very BenevolentBoss to the Korean servants on his estate, in contrast to the mistreatment Koreans usually suffered at the hands of the Japanese. This makes his HeroicSacrifice all the more tragic, as his Korean retainers are just as horrified as his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TroubledSympatheticBigot: Tatsuo's beloved grandfather's assassination is what inflamed his hatred of Koreans and even takes out on his rival Jun-shik. However, after undergoing CharacterDevelopment with a dash of HeelRealization, Tatsuo becomes FireForgedFriends with his rival who TookALevelInKindness. Jong-dae's excessively abusing his prisoners is due to himself being on the receiving end of the Japanese's mistreatment of the Koreans.

to:

* TroubledSympatheticBigot: Tatsuo's beloved grandfather's assassination is what inflamed his hatred of Koreans and even takes out on his rival Jun-shik. However, after undergoing CharacterDevelopment with a dash of HeelRealization, Tatsuo TookALevelInKindness and becomes FireForgedFriends with his rival who TookALevelInKindness.rival. Jong-dae's excessively abusing his prisoners is due to himself being on the receiving end of the Japanese's mistreatment of the Koreans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil: Unlike Jun-shik who still kept his morale even when being treated poorly by others, Jong-dae becomes a DirtyCommunist who is [[{{Understatement a little too]] overzealous in getting back at his Japanese oppressors who mistreated him as a "Korean dog" with sheer sadism much to Jun-shik's worry.

to:

* BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil: Unlike Jun-shik who still kept his morale even when being treated poorly by others, Jong-dae becomes a DirtyCommunist who is [[{{Understatement [[{{Understatement}} a little too]] overzealous in getting back at his Japanese oppressors who mistreated him as a "Korean dog" with sheer sadism much to Jun-shik's worry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DyingAsYourself: [[spoiler:Before expiring from his wounds, Jong-dae reconciles with Jun-shik for having TookALevelInJerkass before and lamenting for not expressing his feelings for his sister.]]


Added DiffLines:

* RedemptionEqualsDeath: [[spoiler:Becoming succumbing to his wounds, Jong-dae apologizes for going all HeWhoFightsMonsters to Jun-shik and tells him to hide while BuriedInAPileOfCorpses to survive once the futile battle is over.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil: Unlike Jun-shik who still kept his morale even when being treated poorly by others, Jong-dae becomes a DirtyCommunist who is [[{{Understatement a little too]] overzealous in getting back at his Japanese oppressors who mistreated him as a "Korean dog" with sheer sadism much to Jun-shik's worry.


Added DiffLines:

* TragicBigot: Tatsuo's initial contempt of the Koreans is personally due to the death of his grandfather. Jong-dae himself would qualify as his viciousness as Anton towards the Japanese [=POW=]s with methods that would be in violation of the Geneva Convention is stemmed from how the Japanese treated him as a "Korean dog."


Added DiffLines:

* TroubledSympatheticBigot: Tatsuo's beloved grandfather's assassination is what inflamed his hatred of Koreans and even takes out on his rival Jun-shik. However, after undergoing CharacterDevelopment with a dash of HeelRealization, Tatsuo becomes FireForgedFriends with his rival who TookALevelInKindness. Jong-dae's excessively abusing his prisoners is due to himself being on the receiving end of the Japanese's mistreatment of the Koreans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkToNiceGuyPlot: Tatsuo's character arc, from a JerkJock and TheNeidermeyer VillainProtagonist to a LovableJock who is FireForgedFriends with his Korean rival.


Added DiffLines:

* TookALevelInJerkass: Jong-dae, when he goes too far to PayEvilUntoEvil towards the Axis [=POW=]s after becoming a DirtyCommunist.
* TookALevelInKindness: Tatsuo, when he undergoes CharacterDevelopment.

Top