Follow TV Tropes

Following

History EsotericHappyEnding / Literature

Go To

OR

Added: 1530

Changed: 859

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/DevilVenerableAlsoWantsToKnow'': ''Abusive Romance'', the book Wenren E received from another world that [[ReadingAheadInTheScript told future possible story events]] [[PerspectiveFlip from Baili Qingmiao's perspective]], ended with Baili Qingmiao choosing to stay with He Wenzhao and give up her divine nature to be with him. A lot of its in-universe readers hated this ending because they thought that He Wenzhao was a terrible boyfriend and wanted Baili Qingmiao to hook up with one of her other love interests instead or at least wisen up enough to stop sacrificing everything for a man who kept breaking her heart by sleeping with other women or ignoring her feelings whenever it suited him. Even Wenren E disliked the ending enough that one of his thoughts upon finishing it was that he wanted to yank Baili Qingmiao's soul out of its body and free it of its obsession with He Wenzhao.

to:

* ''Literature/DevilVenerableAlsoWantsToKnow'': ''Literature/DevilVenerableAlsoWantsToKnow'':
**
''Abusive Romance'', the InUniverse book Wenren E received from another world that [[ReadingAheadInTheScript told future possible story events]] [[PerspectiveFlip from Baili Qingmiao's perspective]], ended with Baili Qingmiao choosing to stay with He Wenzhao and give up her divine nature to be with him. A lot of its in-universe readers hated this ending because they thought that He Wenzhao was a terrible boyfriend and wanted Baili Qingmiao to hook up with one of her other love interests instead or at least wisen up enough to stop sacrificing everything for a man who kept breaking her heart by sleeping with other women or ignoring her feelings whenever it suited him. Even Wenren E disliked the ending enough that one of his thoughts upon finishing it was that he wanted to yank Baili Qingmiao's soul out of its body and free it of its obsession with He Wenzhao.Wenzhao.
** Later in the novel, another book turns up that also garnered this kind of ending reaction from its in-universe readers: [[spoiler:''God of Annihilation'', which ended with the entire universe other than He Wenzhao being completely destroyed but He Wenzhao seemingly using his newfound powers to restore it and bring everyone back to life. Many of its readers, instead of thinking of it as a triumphant EverybodyLives ending, interpreted it as a depressing ending where He Wenzhao hadn't truly fixed things and only created false illusions based on his memories. According to the novel's extras, this downer ending interpretation was indeed the true one.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/DevilVenerableAlsoWantsToKnow'': ''Abusive Romance'', the book Wenren E received from another world that [[ReadingAheadInTheScript told future possible story events]] [[PerspectiveFlip from Baili Qingmiao's perspective]], ended with Baili Qingmiao choosing to stay with He Wenzhao and give up her divine nature to be with him. A lot of its in-universe readers hated this ending because they thought that He Wenzhao was a terrible boyfriend and wanted Baili Qingmiao to hook up with one of her other love interests instead or at least wisen up enough to stop sacrificing everything for a man who kept breaking her heart by sleeping with other women or ignoring her feelings whenever it suited him. Even Wenren E disliked the ending enough that one of his thoughts upon finishing it was that he wanted to yank Baili Qingmiao's soul out of its body and free it of its obsession with He Wenzhao.

Changed: 338

Removed: 308

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/RobertSilverberg's stories fall into this occasionally because his personal philosophy is so different from how most people (or at least most modern Western readers) view life and humanity. A particularly jarring example is ''The Face Upon The Waters''--the main character spends most of the story trying to maintain his cultural identity after the destruction of Earth and the scattering of its people, but ultimately concludes that people should adapt to whatever culture they live amongst... and joins up with TheCorruption[=/=]AssimilationPlot, which has a stated goal of assimilating everyone it can and killing everyone it can't.

to:

* Creator/RobertSilverberg's stories fall into this occasionally because his personal philosophy is so different from how most people (or at least most modern Western readers) view life and humanity. A particularly jarring example is ''The Face Upon The Waters''--the ''Literature/TheFaceUponTheWaters''--the main character spends most of the story trying to maintain his cultural identity after the destruction of Earth and the scattering of its people, but ultimately concludes that people should adapt to whatever culture they live amongst... and joins up with TheCorruption[=/=]AssimilationPlot, which has a stated goal of assimilating everyone it can and killing everyone it can't.



* In the gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', it's strongly implied that the main characters will get to be together, but thanks to some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that Lucian's father is going to go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the rather awkward fact that Lucian left his fiancée at the altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for life. Plus with the binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.
* ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Creator/TanithLee's ''Birthgrave'' trilogy, ends with Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the two decide that they like each other enough to enter into an incestuous mother/son marriage. This is considered “all right” because they are both essentially deities.

to:

* In the gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', ''Literature/TheBinding'', it's strongly implied that the main characters will get to be together, but thanks to some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that Lucian's father is going to go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the rather awkward fact that Lucian left his fiancée at the altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for life. Plus with the binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.
* ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Creator/TanithLee's ''Birthgrave'' ''Literature/{{Birthgrave}}'' trilogy, ends with Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the two decide that they like each other enough to enter into an incestuous mother/son marriage. This is considered “all right” because they are both essentially deities.



* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'' is meant to have a happy ending, but many would argue that marrying and starting a family with a controlling abuser is NOT a happy ending.
** The first book actually has a potential ''inversion''; it ends with Ana deciding she and Christian are incompatible and leaving him, which the book treats as a DownerEnding, but many readers see this as a good thing because the relationship is unhealthy and disproportionately skewed in Christian's favor.

to:

* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'' is meant to have a happy ending, but many would argue that marrying and starting a family with a controlling abuser is NOT a happy ending.
**
ending. The first book actually has a potential ''inversion''; it ends with Ana deciding she and Christian are incompatible and leaving him, which the book treats as a DownerEnding, but many readers see this as a good thing because the relationship is unhealthy and disproportionately skewed in Christian's favor.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheRedShoes'': OK, so Karen has found peace and joy at the end. But she has to endure ridiculous trials and ''die'' first, all over a moment of envy for a pretty pair of shoes? It's hard to overlook the ValuesDissonance to see what would have made Andersen (and his audience) consider this a happy story.

Added: 160

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!By Author

to:

!!By Author
%%%
%%
%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order. Thanks!
%%
%%%
{{Esoteric Happy Ending}}s in {{Literature}}.
----
!!!By Author:



!!By Title

to:

!!By Title
!!!By Title:



* ''Literature/TheWumpWorld'', a children's book by Creator/BillPeet, ends with the [[MeaningfulName Pollutians]] abandoning the titular planet, their cities being reclaimed by nature and the Wumps repopulating their world. It's a perfectly good ending for a GreenAesop... if you ignore the fact that the Pollutians are presumably still out there, doing the same thing to ''other'' planets.

to:

* ''Literature/TheWumpWorld'', a children's book by Creator/BillPeet, ends with the [[MeaningfulName Pollutians]] abandoning the titular planet, their cities being reclaimed by nature and the Wumps repopulating their world. It's a perfectly good ending for a GreenAesop... if you ignore the fact that the Pollutians are presumably still out there, doing the same thing to ''other'' planets.planets.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'': Yay! The heroes survive the collapse of the corrupt multicultural U.S. government and the warring successor states and are free to build their enlightened, traditional Christian society. Where heathens are banished or burned at the stake, Black people can be hanged for a violent crime within a week, and technology created after the 1930s is severely frowned upon, as are women working or getting higher education. Oh, and Victoria will be serving as a training center for a global crusade against Islam.

to:

* ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'': Yay! The heroes survive the collapse of the corrupt multicultural U.S. government and the warring successor states and are free to build their enlightened, traditional Christian society. Where heathens are banished or burned at the stake, Black people can be hanged for a violent crime within a week, week (while [[DoubleStandard whites still get due process]]), and technology created after the 1930s is severely frowned upon, as are women working or getting higher education. Oh, and Victoria will be serving as a training center for [[InferredHolocaust a global crusade against Islam.Islam]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
** The last book gave Jacob, who suffered from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated imprinting, his own happy romantic ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem there's apparently no good way to get rid of the Volturi or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they have been given all the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.

to:

* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
''Literature/TheTwilightSaga'':
** The last book gave gives Jacob, who suffered suffers from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated hates imprinting, his own happy romantic ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
life?
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem there's apparently no good way to get rid of the Volturi or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, Blog/DasSporking's {{MST}}, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', ''Literature/BreakingDawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they have been given all the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Word Of God clearly stated that all the heroes would end the corruption and discrimination causing the troubles, up to leasing the school tensions and the elve's lot


* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottingly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InUniverse example in ''LightNovel/EndoAndKobayashiLiveTheLatestOnTsundereVillainessLieselotte''. While the {{Fictional|VideoGame}} RomanceGame ''Love Me Magically!'' already contains an EveryoneLives ending in form of a [[MarryThemAll Reverse Harem Route]], both Endo and Kobayashi voice a dislike and distrust towards it. Yes, everyone survives, but they're firm believers in monogamy and furthermore doubt the wisdom of having so many powerful figures (the crown prince ''and'' [[LesbianOption his fiancee]], one of the top priests of the kingdom, a PersonOfMassDestruction, among others) attached to a single girl. This is later shown to be a wise concern: In this ending, Finne is discovered and adopted by her maternal grandparent's ducal family but said grandparents are actually {{manipulative bastard}}s who [[spoiler:[[OffingTheOffspring attempted to assassinate their own daughter]], Finne's mother, for refusing to break off her engagement to her dying fiance]]. Also, while they don't mind a Finne x Lise pairing, they would still much rather Lise end up with Sieg, mainly because while Lieselotte is canonically deeply in love with Siegwald, there isn't a single scenario from the game that ends up with the two together.

to:

* InUniverse example in ''LightNovel/EndoAndKobayashiLiveTheLatestOnTsundereVillainessLieselotte''.''Literature/EndoAndKobayashiLive''. While the {{Fictional|VideoGame}} RomanceGame ''Love Me Magically!'' already contains an EveryoneLives ending in form of a [[MarryThemAll Reverse Harem Route]], both Endo and Kobayashi voice a dislike and distrust towards it. Yes, everyone survives, but they're firm believers in monogamy and furthermore doubt the wisdom of having so many powerful figures (the crown prince ''and'' [[LesbianOption his fiancee]], one of the top priests of the kingdom, a PersonOfMassDestruction, among others) attached to a single girl. This is later shown to be a wise concern: In this ending, Finne is discovered and adopted by her maternal grandparent's ducal family but said grandparents are actually {{manipulative bastard}}s who [[spoiler:[[OffingTheOffspring attempted to assassinate their own daughter]], Finne's mother, for refusing to break off her engagement to her dying fiance]]. Also, while they don't mind a Finne x Lise pairing, they would still much rather Lise end up with Sieg, mainly because while Lieselotte is canonically deeply in love with Siegwald, there isn't a single scenario from the game that ends up with the two together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The tale “The Stolen Body” written by Creator/HGWells, narrates the story of Mr. Bessel, who performs a paranormal experience of astral projection, in which he actually manages to get his spirit out of his physical body. However, when this happens, his body is taken over by an evil entity, which then leaves and wanders around London, causing riots and attacking several people, including women, children and police; finally, with the help of a medium and a friend, the protagonist manages to return to his body and be rescued. However, nothing is said about the consequences for Mr. Bessel of violent incidents committed by someone who externally can only be identified as himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of a video game, possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.

to:

* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's Creator/ZilphaKeatleySnyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of [[TheGameOfTheBook a video game, game]], possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Scheherazade living happily ever after with her husband the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and then had her executed after sleeping with her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth and power?[[/note]]

to:

* The ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Scheherazade living happily ever after with her husband the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and then had her executed after sleeping with her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack"[[note]]Wealth and power?[[/note]]
Tabs MOD

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].

to:

** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] there as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/MansfieldPark'' ends with the long-suffering Fanny Price marrying her cousin Edmund Bertram, who she's secretly loved for years, after their dishonest romantic rivals are finally exposed and leave. Well and good, except Edmund is only a little better than the rest of his self-centered family, having ignored her warnings and failed to perceive her feelings until everything blew up, and even then demanding sympathy for his own heartbreak despite thinking she had been just as wounded (thereby ''continuing'' not to understand her). And her destiny is to continue living in seclusion with him in the country. This has led to readers wishing that Henry Crawford hadn't [[IgnoredEpiphany reneged on his character development]] so he could have married her--or that she didn't marry ''anyone'' and instead went to live with her brother in the little cottage he wanted to buy once he got some prize money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/ATaleOfTwoCities'': Stryver gets one. Since Carton was the one doing much of the actual work in their partnership, his death means that Stryver's career as a lawyer will probably be ruined.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.

to:

* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly tooth-rottingly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/{{Emma}}'', Frank Churchill profusely apologizes to his fiancee Jane Fairfax and they end up getting married after all. But given that he persuaded her into a secret engagement and then went about hiding his attachment by ''very convincingly'' attaching himself to Emma, it's easy to agree with Mr. Knightley that Jane deserves a much better husband.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While not nearly as dark as the two above, one has to question just how HappilyEverAfter the Prince in ''Literature/ThePrincessAndThePea'' is actually going to live with his new bride. Someone who complains about a single pea under 40 mattresses has got to be ''ridiculously'' high-maintenance.

to:

* While not nearly as dark as the two above, many of Creator/HansChristianAndersen's works, one has to question just how HappilyEverAfter the Prince in ''Literature/ThePrincessAndThePea'' is actually going to live with his new bride. Someone who complains about a single pea under 40 mattresses has got to be ''ridiculously'' high-maintenance.

Changed: 380

Removed: 1417

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hans Christian Andersen was very depressed as the editor themselves pointed and therefore he didn't see his stories as happy therefore he didn't intend to readers to see them as unambiguously pleasant either. Bittersweet and downer endings embrace the things that darken them. All this considered, I don't think that those works should stay here being as openly saddening as they are and should go to either bittersweet or downer endings


* By all accounts, Creator/HansChristianAndersen [[CreatorBreakdown was a very depressed man]]. Out of all his fairy tales, there are only a few with unambiguously happy endings.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'' (not [[{{Disneyfication}} the Disney version]]). The little mermaid is turned into "daughter of air" with the prospect of eventually entering Heaven, very probably a result of revision by Andersen. Initially this was the selected ending, even put in the working title, but there was a happily reworked version in which the mermaid apparently just dissolved into foam in the end. Even the happier version has the FridgeHorror of knowing that the [[DeaderThanDead dissolving into foam]] fate is eventually going to befall the Little Mermaid's sisters and family if they don't act as she did.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl''. TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth turned UpToEleven. The tone of the ending is [[BittersweetEnding very sad for the townspeople who discover her frozen corpse, but happy for the girl as she has ascended into Heaven]]. As such, some remakes from our more cynical times either rewrite it to give her a more materialistic HappyEnding ([[DeusExMachina somehow]]) or portray it as a truly tear-jerking DownerEnding. [[Literature/{{Hogfather}} Even Death can't stand it.]]
** While not nearly as dark as the two above, one has to question just how HappilyEverAfter the Prince in ''Literature/ThePrincessAndThePea'' is actually going to live with his new bride. Someone who complains about a single pea under 40 mattresses has got to be ''ridiculously'' high-maintenance.

to:

* By all accounts, Creator/HansChristianAndersen [[CreatorBreakdown was a very depressed man]]. Out of all his fairy tales, there are only a few with unambiguously happy endings.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'' (not [[{{Disneyfication}} the Disney version]]). The little mermaid is turned into "daughter of air" with the prospect of eventually entering Heaven, very probably a result of revision by Andersen. Initially this was the selected ending, even put in the working title, but there was a happily reworked version in which the mermaid apparently just dissolved into foam in the end. Even the happier version has the FridgeHorror of knowing that the [[DeaderThanDead dissolving into foam]] fate is eventually going to befall the Little Mermaid's sisters and family if they don't act as she did.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl''. TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth turned UpToEleven. The tone of the ending is [[BittersweetEnding very sad for the townspeople who discover her frozen corpse, but happy for the girl as she has ascended into Heaven]]. As such, some remakes from our more cynical times either rewrite it to give her a more materialistic HappyEnding ([[DeusExMachina somehow]]) or portray it as a truly tear-jerking DownerEnding. [[Literature/{{Hogfather}} Even Death can't stand it.]]
**
While not nearly as dark as the two above, one has to question just how HappilyEverAfter the Prince in ''Literature/ThePrincessAndThePea'' is actually going to live with his new bride. Someone who complains about a single pea under 40 mattresses has got to be ''ridiculously'' high-maintenance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It would be lovely if it was readded with a few specific examples of stories


* The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes in his myopic characters and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.

to:

* %%* The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes in his myopic characters and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[PlayedForLaughs Played for laughs]] in one of the endings for ''Literature/TheFortressOfTheBlackCauldron'' in which you save the continent of Alkior... by creating a phoenix, which promptly destroys a good chunk of the world, killing you, your enemies and your allies as well as countless other people.
->"Congratulation, everyone lost. And that's a victory!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think that was kind of the point.


* The ''{{Literature/Goosebumps}}'' books were famous for featuring {{Cruel Twist Ending}}s, but ''Literature/TheCuckooClockOfDoom'' has one that's played as happy and upbeat despite being utterly horrifying in implication: After repairing the titular clock and returning to the present, the protagonist discovers that he has inadvertently erased his [[AnnoyingYoungerSibling Annoying Younger Sister]] from existence. This is played as a good thing for him because the girl is portrayed as a real EnfantTerrible and the vast majority of fans ''despise'' her. To them, the ending is a straight-up KarmicTwistEnding that works out happily for the protagonist. Still, it is DisproportionateRetribution to have her actions result in her complete disappearance. While he does say that there's ''probably'' a way to use the clock to revive her, and he'll ''probably'' do it someday, given that he himself was nearly erased the first time he used the clock, what guarantee is there he'll even survive trying, let alone actually succeed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InUniverse example in ''LightNovel/EndoAndKobayashiLiveTheLatestOnTsundereVillainessLieselotte''. While the {{Fictional|VideoGame}} RomanceGame ''Love Me Magically!'' already contains an EveryoneLives ending in form of a [[MarryThemAll Reverse Harem Route]], both Endo and Kobayashi voice a dislike and distrust towards it. Yes, everyone survives, but they're firm believers in monogamy and furthermore doubt the wisdom of having so many powerful figures (the crown prince ''and'' [[LesbianOption his fiancee]], one of the top priests of the kingdom, a PersonOfMassDestruction, among others) attached to a single girl. This is later shown to be a wise concern: In this ending, Finne is discovered and adopted by her maternal grandparent's ducal family but said grandparents are actually {{manipulative bastard}}s who [[spoiler:[[OffingTheOffspring attempted to assassinate their own daughter]], Finne's mother, for refusing to break off her engagement to her dying fiance]]. Also, while they don't mind a Finne x Lise pairing, they would still much rather Lise end up with Sieg, mainly because while Lieselotte is canonically deeply in love with Siegwald, there isn't a single scenario from the game that ends up with the two together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!By Author


Added DiffLines:


!!By Title

Added: 262

Changed: 619

Removed: 881

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''The Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to the happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, the Beast is human again, and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifi
cally abusing his second fiancee and gleefully allowing her family to go to ruin, and ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't like the fact that the painting reflected the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly ending up with someone considerably worse than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's no chance of him learning from his past or making amends. The ending is still treated as completely happy, but more than a few readers have expressed a wish for Belle to leave the Beast altogether.

to:

* ''The Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to the happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, the Beast is human again, and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifi
cally
horrifically abusing his second fiancee and gleefully allowing her family to go to ruin, and ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't like the fact that the painting reflected the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly ending up with someone considerably worse than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's no chance of him learning from his past or making amends. The ending is still treated as completely happy, but more than a few readers have expressed a wish for Belle to leave the Beast altogether.



* Some of the "good" endings in the ''Literature/ChooseYourOwnAdventure'' books merely consists of the main character surviving, stopping the BigBad temporarily, or implying that ''perhaps'' you will have success in the future, leaving many plot points unsolved.



* Some of the "good" endings in the ''Literature/ChooseYourOwnAdventure'' books merely consists of the main character surviving, stopping the BigBad temporarily, or implying that ''perhaps'' you will have success in the future, leaving many plot points unsolved.

Added: 14582

Changed: 17336

Removed: 13337

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes in his myopic characters and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.
* Most of Creator/FlanneryOConnor's works share this trait--but she herself insisted that she was a writer of comic stories, rightly regarded. Again and again, her protagonists (often ironically and grotesquely) lose everything they thought they wanted and valued--their possessions, their dignity, their self-image, even their lives. Burned down back to the foundations, they are left unarmored, often ridiculous and humiliated, but finally open to the [[GoodIsNotNice terrible incursion of God's grace]]. O'Connor famously claimed that ''Literature/WiseBlood'' had a "very hopeful" ending; this reading, though, absolutely depends on understanding the author's and protagonist's priorities, which many readers have trouble internalizing.
* Creator/HPLovecraft's works:
** "Celephais," which ends with the main character finally returning to the wondrous dream-city that he created in his youth where he is appointed the chief god of all of the regions of Dream; and all he had to do was fall off a cliff and let the tides cast his corpse upon the rocks. Lovecraft {{lampshade|Hanging}}s this later in ''Literature/TheDreamQuestOfUnknownKadath'' when ''that'' story's protagonist meets this exact character who's since come to regret his decision but obviously can never go back.
** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].



* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
** It's explored in ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' where Lilith gives what is usually considered to be a happy ending to people whether they want it or not. This includes convincing a wolf it's human so that it nearly starves to death and goes insane, since it can't live as either human or wolf now, so that it would eat a grandmother and dress up like her a la ''Little Red Riding Hood''. By the time the three witches arrive, all the Big Bad Wolf wants is ''[[SuicideByCop an ending]]''.
** Intentionally played in ''Literature/{{Eric}}'' which ends by saying that three wishes provided a happy ending for most of the people they've affected and giving as examples the Tezumen, who continue to slaughter people but no longer do so because of religion so they don't need to get up so early; the Tsorteans and Ephebians, whose war is over, allowing them to prepare for the next one; the demons and damned souls, who get back to inflicting/experiencing material punishment on immaterial spirit in the knowledge that at least it's not Astfgl's psychological torture; and Astfgl himself, who as Life President of Hell gets to spend his time writing policy statements entirely unaware that the rest of the demonic lowerarchy is completely ignoring him. What happened to our actual protagonists, we don't get told beyond "It could be worse". Lampshaded by the last two lines "And this too was happiness. Of a sort."



* ''Literature/AGirlCalledBlue'' is about girls growing up in a strict home for children in 1960s Ireland (run by Sadist Nuns). The book ends with Blue rejoicing that she's finally found a family of her own. Except the "family" is two people she's met twice and they're not allowed to adopt her so she has to wait three years before she's old enough to leave the school with them only allowed to visit her twice a year. Also three of her best friends have now left, one being drowned, another going back to live with her father and the last being sent to another school and she has been forced to sleep alone in a cramped room, and will likely still have to endure plenty more abuse from the nuns for the next three years. Oh and she never finds out who her real mother is either and the nuns will keep abusing children for many years in Ireland.
* The ending of Creator/CSLewis's final [[Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia Narnia]] book, ''Literature/TheLastBattle'', qualified as this for many young readers. Narnia ends, and everyone except Susan dies. Some minor characters are tormented and destroyed by a horrific many-armed GodOfEvil, while others are judged unworthy and vanish forever into Aslan's shadow. [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding But the important people don't care about that]] because they all go to the "real" Narnia (a stand-in for heaven) as the Christian subtext becomes text. It can be uplifting or inspire nightmares, depending on which scenes stick with you. (Creator/NeilGaiman brilliantly deconstructed this in his short story ''Literature/TheProblemOfSusan'', in which he shows what happened to Susan after her siblings died in a train crash and she had to [[BodyHorror identify their corpses]].)
* Creator/RoaldDahl's ''Literature/TheWitches''. The protagonist learns that he's stuck as a mouse and that mice don't live very long, but he's happy because he'll probably die near the same time as his elderly grandmother and doesn't care about living if he's not with her; they will live out their lives tracking down and destroying other witches together. The two also ponder Bruno's fate. One states that his mouse-hating mother probably drowned him in a bucket, but nobody seems very disturbed by this possibility. The [[Film/TheWitches1990 1990 movie]] has an unabashed happy ending where the last witch, who had undergone a HeelFaceTurn, undoes the mouse spell on the protagonist and is implied to do the same to Bruno. While many were appreciative of this happier ending, Roald Dahl was infamously ''not''.
* Coupled with ValuesDissonance for ''Literature/ALittlePrincess''. The book ends with Sara being restored to her wealth while Becky becomes her personal attendant. Oh and [[SadistTeacher Miss Minchin]] gets [[KarmaHoudini away with treating them like prisoners]]. However, if one takes into context the period the story is set in (Victorian London) then Becky going from little better than a slave to a powerful position in the household (with a kind and generous mistress too) where she would get a roof over her head and financial security, it's a happy ending for Becky indeed. And while Miss Minchin doesn't get an over-the-top instant comeuppance (save in the film adaptations, which pretty much need one) it's worth remembering that not only has she irrevocably lost her chance at a pupil who could've single-handedly ensured her school's success and her own financial comfort for life; once Sara's story becomes common knowledge in her social circle--as it inevitably will--Minchin's reputation will be in tatters and her school likely ruined. There's also a WhatHappenedToTheMouse for Melchisedec the rat and his family; one hopes kindhearted Sara will remember them and send Ram Dass over there with bread crumbs.

to:

* ''Literature/AGirlCalledBlue'' is about girls growing up in a strict home for children in 1960s Ireland (run by Sadist Nuns). The book ends ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Blue rejoicing that she's finally found a family of her own. Except the "family" is two people she's met twice and they're not allowed to adopt her so she has to wait three years before she's old enough to leave the school with them only allowed to visit her twice a year. Also three of her best friends have now left, one being drowned, another going back to live Scheherazade living happily ever after with her father husband the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and the last being sent to another school and she has been forced to sleep alone in a cramped room, and will likely still have to endure plenty more abuse from the nuns for the next three years. Oh and she never finds out who then had her real mother is either and the nuns will keep abusing children for many years in Ireland.
* The ending of Creator/CSLewis's final [[Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia Narnia]] book, ''Literature/TheLastBattle'', qualified as this for many young readers. Narnia ends, and everyone except Susan dies. Some minor characters are tormented and destroyed by a horrific many-armed GodOfEvil, while others are judged unworthy and vanish forever into Aslan's shadow. [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding But the important people don't care about that]] because they all go to the "real" Narnia (a stand-in for heaven) as the Christian subtext becomes text. It can be uplifting or inspire nightmares, depending on which scenes stick with you. (Creator/NeilGaiman brilliantly deconstructed this in his short story ''Literature/TheProblemOfSusan'', in which he shows what happened to Susan
executed after her siblings died in a train crash and she had to [[BodyHorror identify their corpses]].)
* Creator/RoaldDahl's ''Literature/TheWitches''. The protagonist learns that he's stuck as a mouse and that mice don't live very long, but he's happy because he'll probably die near the same time as his elderly grandmother and doesn't care about living if he's not
sleeping with her; they will live out their lives tracking down and destroying other witches together. The two also ponder Bruno's fate. One states that her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his mouse-hating mother probably drowned him in a bucket, but nobody seems very disturbed by this possibility. The [[Film/TheWitches1990 1990 movie]] has an unabashed happy ending where the last witch, who had undergone a HeelFaceTurn, undoes the mouse spell on the protagonist and is implied to do the same to Bruno. While past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many were appreciative of this happier ending, Roald Dahl was infamously ''not''.
* Coupled with ValuesDissonance for ''Literature/ALittlePrincess''. The book ends with Sara being restored to her wealth while Becky becomes her personal attendant. Oh
readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth and [[SadistTeacher Miss Minchin]] gets [[KarmaHoudini away with treating them like prisoners]]. However, if one takes into context the period the story is set in (Victorian London) then Becky going from little better than a slave to a powerful position in the household (with a kind and generous mistress too) where she would get a roof over her head and financial security, it's a happy ending for Becky indeed. And while Miss Minchin doesn't get an over-the-top instant comeuppance (save in the film adaptations, which pretty much need one) it's worth remembering that not only has she irrevocably lost her chance at a pupil who could've single-handedly ensured her school's success and her own financial comfort for life; once Sara's story becomes common knowledge in her social circle--as it inevitably will--Minchin's reputation will be in tatters and her school likely ruined. There's also a WhatHappenedToTheMouse for Melchisedec the rat and his family; one hopes kindhearted Sara will remember them and send Ram Dass over there with bread crumbs.power?[[/note]]



* ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.'' Shu, Wei, and Wu are united into one at last and peace throughout the entire country of China can finally begin. Unfortunately the victors are a splinter group of Wei who usurped the throne, conquered Wu and Shu who at the time were being ruled by Liu Shan (a truly incompetent ruler who defiles everything Shu originally stood for) and Sun Hao (a tyrant almost as bad as Dong Zhuo). The kicker? When these two surrendered they were given lucrative positions and the readers were told they lived out their remaining lives in luxury. To be fair though this novel closely follows the real-life events in history and not a lot could be changed. And historically, the hard-fought reunification of China ended a decade or two later with [[HereWeGoAgain a new barbarian invasion.]] Also, the war to unify China was itself one of the bloodiest in human history, killing (by highest estimates) 74% of China's population, more people than the Second World War. The victors ruled dust and ashes.
* Back when ''The Iron Giant'' was a book instead of [[WesternAnimation/TheIronGiant a movie]], it ended with an encounter with a dragon-like alien that sang in a hypnotic manner. It sang loud enough that the entire world heard it, and everyone in the world spent the rest of their lives alternately taking care of necessities and listening to the song. It's specified that all war was completely eliminated, and the implication would be that art and culture vanished too. If the wording is to be taken literally, people didn't even converse with each other. Now, does this sound {{Utopia}}n, or more like a nightmare?
* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
** The last book gave Jacob, who suffered from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated imprinting, his own happy romantic ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem there's apparently no good way to get rid of the Volturi or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they have been given all the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.
** On a more personal note, Nessie is hardly the "perfect ending" for the rest of the Cullens that Meyer claims. Esme and Rose want biological children of their own to care for and raise. Nessie is already nearly at adult-level independence within weeks of birth, and she's ''Bella's'' daughter, not theirs. Nessie also can't bring back Alice's human memories, she has almost no relationship with any of the other male Cullens, etc. Meyer seems to think that Nessie fixes everything just by existing, but realistically she creates many, many more problems than she fixes for them.

to:

* ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.'' Shu, Wei, and Wu are united into one at last and peace throughout the entire country of China can finally begin. Unfortunately the victors are a splinter group of Wei who usurped the throne, conquered Wu and Shu who at the time were being ruled by Liu Shan (a truly incompetent ruler who defiles everything Shu originally stood for) and Sun Hao (a tyrant almost as bad as Dong Zhuo). The kicker? When these two surrendered they were given lucrative positions and the readers were told they lived out their remaining lives in luxury. To be fair though this novel closely follows the real-life events in history and not a lot could be changed. And historically, the hard-fought reunification of China ended a decade or two later with [[HereWeGoAgain a new barbarian invasion.]] Also, the war to unify China was itself one of the bloodiest in human history, killing (by highest estimates) 74% of China's population, more people than the Second World War. The victors ruled dust and ashes.
* Back when
''The Iron Giant'' was a book instead of [[WesternAnimation/TheIronGiant a movie]], it ended with an encounter with a dragon-like alien that sang in a hypnotic manner. It sang loud enough that the entire world heard it, and everyone in the world spent the rest of their lives alternately taking care of necessities and listening Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to the song. It's specified happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, the Beast is human again, and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that all war was completely eliminated, involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifi
cally abusing his second fiancee
and the implication would be that art gleefully allowing her family to go to ruin, and culture vanished too. If the wording is to be taken literally, people ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't even converse with each other. Now, does this sound {{Utopia}}n, or more like a nightmare?
* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
** The last book gave Jacob, who suffered from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated imprinting, his own happy romantic
the fact that the painting reflected the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship up with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem
someone considerably worse than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's apparently no good way to get rid chance of the Volturi him learning from his past or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing making amends. The ending is still treated as completely happy, but more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is than a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they few readers have been given all expressed a wish for Belle to leave the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.
** On a more personal note, Nessie is hardly the "perfect ending" for the rest of the Cullens that Meyer claims. Esme and Rose want biological children of their own to care for and raise. Nessie is already nearly at adult-level independence within weeks of birth, and she's ''Bella's'' daughter, not theirs. Nessie also can't bring back Alice's human memories, she has almost no relationship with any of the other male Cullens, etc. Meyer seems to think that Nessie fixes everything just by existing, but realistically she creates many, many more problems than she fixes for them.
Beast altogether.



* ''Literature/LeftBehind'' gets this a lot for its ending where not only are all non-Christians sent to FireAndBrimstoneHell, but the paradise where all the protagonists end up is depicted as a faintly creepy commune where you can no longer eat meat or form relationships with anyone you want, and nobody experiences any strong emotions other than love of God. [[ValuesDissonance The writers treat this as a utopia.]]
* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of a video game, possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.
* Creator/HPLovecraft's works:
** "Celephais," which ends with the main character finally returning to the wondrous dream-city that he created in his youth where he is appointed the chief god of all of the regions of Dream; and all he had to do was fall off a cliff and let the tides cast his corpse upon the rocks. Lovecraft {{lampshade|Hanging}}s this later in ''Literature/TheDreamQuestOfUnknownKadath'' when ''that'' story's protagonist meets this exact character who's since come to regret his decision but obviously can never go back.
** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].
* ''Literature/{{Mindswap}}'' by Creator/RobertSheckley. The protagonist is in the corrupted world but believes he has succeeded in his mission and has returned home.
* ''Literature/HushHush'' has a great happy ending, if you ignore the fact that part of Nora's house was burned down, there's a ClingyJealousGirl of a fallen angel after her, and that she is blissfully dating the guy who spent the book stalking her, sexually harassing her, and outright attempting to ''murder her''.
* At the end of ''Literature/TheGoddessTest'', Kate's beloved mother is actually the goddess Demeter, so she and her mother can be together for eternity. Sounds great, huh? Except if you think back to the prologue, where we hear Demeter outright telling Hades that she's going to have her second daughter take the goddess test and be his wife, even though eleven girls have already died in the attempt and Hades ''says'' he wants to just give up rather than see anyone else die for him. There's also the fact that the last girl who was manipulated into an arranged marriage with Hades later begged for death. Throughout the story, there is a lot of emphasis on the fact that being there is Kate's choice. However, the reason she made the deal with Henry in the first place was to save Ava and then the reason she kept the deal was so that he could keep her mother alive and she could spend time with her before she died. Except you find out that both Ava and Diana are Goddesses and were never in any real danger. So that means that while it was technically Kate's choice, her entire choice was based on a lie. Plus the ending reveals that Diana put her daughter through four years of emotional turmoil by making her think that her mother was on the verge of death for years and forcing Kate to take care of her for no reason other than to set her up for the test.
* The "Susannah in New York" epilogue of ''Franchise/TheDarkTower'' series has Susannah going into an alternate reality version of New York where Eddie and Jake are still alive and in fact are brothers. She appears in Central Park at Christmas time, alternate-Eddie greets her with a cup of hot chocolate, and it's clearly supposed to be her happy ending... Except many readers feel that Susannah abandoned the quest and is now trapped in a world that isn't her own with a couple of ReplacementGoldfish who aren't really the people she loved.
* The end of ''Literature/TheDarkIsRising'' sequence is unsatisfying in several ways. The forces of the Dark have been beaten back; all the main characters are OK and have forged a close bond; Bran has grown up normal, decided to stay with his foster-father, and has realised he's attracted to Jane. But not only do five of the Six have to forget that magic exists and never see their beloved Merriman again, the lovely magic of the Light is going to withdraw from the world altogether. And poor John Rowland is going to believe that his wife has suddenly died (which is presented as better than knowing she was an agent of the Dark). Will gets to remember everything because he's an Old One, but he'll have nobody to talk to about it for most of the time.
* Chris Adrian's ''Literature/TheChildrensHospital'' ends with every single adult left on Earth dying, as the global flooding recedes and the children leave the eponymous hospital to inherit their new Earth. The final image is the main character screaming as her newborn child is taken away and she dissolves into ash. Lampshaded throughout the book by the narrator who, as an angel who was once human, is supposed to wholeheartedly accept the end of the world as righteous, but can't quite do so.

to:

* ''Literature/LeftBehind'' gets this a lot for its ending where not only are all non-Christians sent to FireAndBrimstoneHell, but In the paradise where all the protagonists end up is depicted as a faintly creepy commune where you can no longer eat meat or form relationships with anyone you want, and nobody experiences any strong emotions other than love of God. [[ValuesDissonance The writers treat this as a utopia.]]
* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of a video game, possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.
* Creator/HPLovecraft's works:
** "Celephais," which ends with the main character finally returning to the wondrous dream-city that he created in his youth where he is appointed the chief god of all of the regions of Dream; and all he had to do was fall off a cliff and let the tides cast his corpse upon the rocks. Lovecraft {{lampshade|Hanging}}s this later in ''Literature/TheDreamQuestOfUnknownKadath'' when ''that'' story's protagonist meets this exact character who's since come to regret his decision but obviously can never go back.
** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why
gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum strongly implied that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].
* ''Literature/{{Mindswap}}'' by Creator/RobertSheckley. The protagonist is in the corrupted world but believes he has succeeded in his mission and has returned home.
* ''Literature/HushHush'' has a great happy ending, if you ignore the fact that part of Nora's house was burned down, there's a ClingyJealousGirl of a fallen angel after her, and that she is blissfully dating the guy who spent the book stalking her, sexually harassing her, and outright attempting to ''murder her''.
* At the end of ''Literature/TheGoddessTest'', Kate's beloved mother is actually the goddess Demeter, so she and her mother can be together for eternity. Sounds great, huh? Except if you think back to the prologue, where we hear Demeter outright telling Hades that she's going to have her second daughter take the goddess test and be his wife, even though eleven girls have already died in the attempt and Hades ''says'' he wants to just give up rather than see anyone else die for him. There's also the fact that the last girl who was manipulated into an arranged marriage with Hades later begged for death. Throughout the story, there is a lot of emphasis on the fact that being there is Kate's choice. However, the reason she made the deal with Henry in the first place was to save Ava and then the reason she kept the deal was so that he could keep her mother alive and she could spend time with her before she died. Except you find out that both Ava and Diana are Goddesses and were never in any real danger. So that means that while it was technically Kate's choice, her entire choice was based on a lie. Plus the ending reveals that Diana put her daughter through four years of emotional turmoil by making her think that her mother was on the verge of death for years and forcing Kate to take care of her for no reason other than to set her up for the test.
* The "Susannah in New York" epilogue of ''Franchise/TheDarkTower'' series has Susannah going into an alternate reality version of New York where Eddie and Jake are still alive and in fact are brothers. She appears in Central Park at Christmas time, alternate-Eddie greets her with a cup of hot chocolate, and it's clearly supposed to be her happy ending... Except many readers feel that Susannah abandoned the quest and is now trapped in a world that isn't her own with a couple of ReplacementGoldfish who aren't really the people she loved.
* The end of ''Literature/TheDarkIsRising'' sequence is unsatisfying in several ways. The forces of the Dark have been beaten back; all
the main characters are OK and have forged a close bond; Bran has grown up normal, decided will get to stay with his foster-father, and has realised he's attracted be together, but thanks to Jane. But not only do five of the Six have to forget some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that magic exists and never see their beloved Merriman again, the lovely magic of the Light Lucian's father is going to withdraw from go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the world altogether. And poor John Rowland is going to believe rather awkward fact that Lucian left his wife has suddenly died (which is presented as better than knowing she was an agent of fiancée at the Dark). Will gets to remember everything because he's an Old One, but he'll have nobody to talk to about it altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for most of life. Plus with the time.
binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.
* Chris Adrian's ''Literature/TheChildrensHospital'' ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Creator/TanithLee's ''Birthgrave'' trilogy, ends with every single adult left on Earth dying, as Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the global flooding recedes and the children leave the eponymous hospital two decide that they like each other enough to inherit their new Earth. The final image is the main character screaming as her newborn child is taken away and she dissolves enter into ash. Lampshaded throughout the book by the narrator who, as an angel who was once human, incestuous mother/son marriage. This is supposed to wholeheartedly accept considered “all right” because they are both essentially deities.
* At
the end of ''Literature/TheBookOfTheDunCow'''s ''Peace at the Last'', almost all of the named sympathetic characters are killed in a LastStand by a mob of corrupted animals. Meanwhile, Wyrm's HatePlague has corrupted the world and divided its animal inhabitants beyond repair. But it's played as righteous, but can't quite do so.a happy ending since they're reunited in the afterlife, along with characters who died in the previous books.



* ''Literature/TheSoldierSon''. After almost three books of stressing how bad it is for Nevare's soul to be split, he is finally reunited with Soldier's Boy and absorbed by an ancestor tree, together with his beloved Lisana. Is this the end? No, he is split again. Admittedly, that half gets back together with Amzil, marries her and inherits the Nevare estate, but wasn't it bad to have one's personality split? Other issues concern the discovery of gold that draw the Gernians away from the Speck lands: how long before they'll return? And finally, Nevare completely destroys the source of the Plainspeople's magic in the process, sealing their fate. This is given almost no attention.

to:

* ''Literature/TheSoldierSon''. After almost three books of stressing how bad it is for Nevare's soul to be split, he is finally reunited Chris Adrian's ''Literature/TheChildrensHospital'' ends with Soldier's Boy every single adult left on Earth dying, as the global flooding recedes and absorbed by an ancestor tree, together with his beloved Lisana. Is this the end? No, he children leave the eponymous hospital to inherit their new Earth. The final image is split again. Admittedly, that half gets back together with Amzil, marries the main character screaming as her and inherits the Nevare estate, but wasn't it bad to have one's personality split? Other issues concern the discovery of gold that draw the Gernians newborn child is taken away from and she dissolves into ash. Lampshaded throughout the Speck lands: how long before they'll return? And finally, Nevare completely destroys book by the source narrator who, as an angel who was once human, is supposed to wholeheartedly accept the end of the Plainspeople's magic in world as righteous, but can't quite do so.
* The ending of Creator/CSLewis's final Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia's book, ''Literature/TheLastBattle'', qualified as this for many young readers. Narnia ends, and everyone except Susan dies. Some minor characters are tormented and destroyed by a horrific many-armed GodOfEvil, while others are judged unworthy and vanish forever into Aslan's shadow. [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding But
the process, sealing important people don't care about that]] because they all go to the "real" Narnia (a stand-in for heaven) as the Christian subtext becomes text. It can be uplifting or inspire nightmares, depending on which scenes stick with you. (Creator/NeilGaiman brilliantly deconstructed this in his short story ''Literature/TheProblemOfSusan'', in which he shows what happened to Susan after her siblings died in a train crash and she had to [[BodyHorror identify their fate. This is given almost no attention.corpses]].)



* The end of ''Literature/TheDarkIsRising'' sequence is unsatisfying in several ways. The forces of the Dark have been beaten back; all the main characters are OK and have forged a close bond; Bran has grown up normal, decided to stay with his foster-father, and has realised he's attracted to Jane. But not only do five of the Six have to forget that magic exists and never see their beloved Merriman again, the lovely magic of the Light is going to withdraw from the world altogether. And poor John Rowland is going to believe that his wife has suddenly died (which is presented as better than knowing she was an agent of the Dark). Will gets to remember everything because he's an Old One, but he'll have nobody to talk to about it for most of the time.
* The "Susannah in New York" epilogue of ''Franchise/TheDarkTower'' series has Susannah going into an alternate reality version of New York where Eddie and Jake are still alive and in fact are brothers. She appears in Central Park at Christmas time, alternate-Eddie greets her with a cup of hot chocolate, and it's clearly supposed to be her happy ending... Except many readers feel that Susannah abandoned the quest and is now trapped in a world that isn't her own with a couple of ReplacementGoldfish who aren't really the people she loved.



* Inverted with Edmond Hamilton's 1932 short story 'The Man Who Evolved', which is traditionally interpreted as having the soul-crushingly nihilistic ending of learning that the human race is doomed to devolve into primordial ooze, and there is nothing that anybody, not even a Sufficiently Advanced super-intelligence, can do to prevent it. However, FridgeLogic shows that there are two ways in which the ending can be interpreted more optimistically: either Pollard continues down the path of Hollywood Evolution, [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence ascending to a higher plane of existence]] and becoming an {{Energy Being|s}} while leaving his body behind as protoplasm, or the story can be interpreted as set in the same universe as Hamilton's later short story, "Devolution", in which microbes are the most advanced forms of life, which developed an interstellar civilization and only got stuck on Earth after they de-evolved into all other forms of life (in which case Pollard could conceivably have retained his augmented intelligence). Note that neither of these interpretations alleviates the horror of Pollard's steady LossOfIdentity as he travels through the EvolutionaryLevels, however.
* The ''Literature/RevelationSpaceSeries'' ends with humanity ([[StarfishAliens with some help]]) defeating the [[AbsoluteXenophobe Inhibitors]], at the cost of fleeing the Milky Way as humanity's rogue [[AIIsACrapShoot Greenfly terraforming robots]] - now uncontained by the Inhibitors - overrun the galaxy, [[HordeOfAlienLocusts breaking apart worlds and anything artificial to turn into greenhouse habitats]] orbiting stars. ''Galactic North'' shows that the Greenfly has begun to expand outside the galaxy. [[EarthAllAlong The Shadows]] in ''Absolution Gap'' explain that their entire local cluster has been effectively overrun by the Greenfly. The author said that this ending was "[[http://web.archive.org/web/20050204072321/http://www.scifi.com/sfw/issue406/interview.html actually quite optimistic]]"
* In ''Literature/TheWormOuroboros'', the 'good guy' princes have lots of battles and perform heroic deeds to overcome the 'bad guys'. Having done so, they're bored. So the gods recreate the bad guys so that the good guys can have fun beating them again. And so the world is condemned to an eternity of warfare because otherwise the princes would get bored. This was because the book is specifically inspired by Nordic myth and legend, retaining the [[ProudWarriorRace original source morality]].
* ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Tanith Lee’s ''Birthgrave'' trilogy, ends with Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the two decide that they like each other enough to enter into an incestuous mother/son marriage. This is considered “all right” because they are both essentially deities.
* Creator/GillianFlynn's ''Literature/GoneGirl'' is deliberately written to be this. Amy finally has someone she can be herself with and Nick has the child he always wanted. They may eventually kill each other but, at heart, they're ''both'' sociopaths. This is averted in the film version, where Nick comes across more sympathetically.

to:

* Inverted with Edmond Hamilton's 1932 short story 'The Man Who Evolved', which ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
** It's explored in ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' where Lilith gives what
is traditionally interpreted as having the soul-crushingly nihilistic ending of learning that the human race is doomed to devolve into primordial ooze, and there is nothing that anybody, not even a Sufficiently Advanced super-intelligence, can do to prevent it. However, FridgeLogic shows that there are two ways in which the ending can be interpreted more optimistically: either Pollard continues down the path of Hollywood Evolution, [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence ascending to a higher plane of existence]] and becoming an {{Energy Being|s}} while leaving his body behind as protoplasm, or the story can be interpreted as set in the same universe as Hamilton's later short story, "Devolution", in which microbes are the most advanced forms of life, which developed an interstellar civilization and only got stuck on Earth after they de-evolved into all other forms of life (in which case Pollard could conceivably have retained his augmented intelligence). Note that neither of these interpretations alleviates the horror of Pollard's steady LossOfIdentity as he travels through the EvolutionaryLevels, however.
* The ''Literature/RevelationSpaceSeries'' ends with humanity ([[StarfishAliens with some help]]) defeating the [[AbsoluteXenophobe Inhibitors]], at the cost of fleeing the Milky Way as humanity's rogue [[AIIsACrapShoot Greenfly terraforming robots]] - now uncontained by the Inhibitors - overrun the galaxy, [[HordeOfAlienLocusts breaking apart worlds and anything artificial to turn into greenhouse habitats]] orbiting stars. ''Galactic North'' shows that the Greenfly has begun to expand outside the galaxy. [[EarthAllAlong The Shadows]] in ''Absolution Gap'' explain that their entire local cluster has been effectively overrun by the Greenfly. The author said that this ending was "[[http://web.archive.org/web/20050204072321/http://www.scifi.com/sfw/issue406/interview.html actually quite optimistic]]"
* In ''Literature/TheWormOuroboros'', the 'good guy' princes have lots of battles and perform heroic deeds to overcome the 'bad guys'. Having done so, they're bored. So the gods recreate the bad guys so that the good guys can have fun beating them again. And so the world is condemned to an eternity of warfare because otherwise the princes would get bored. This was because the book is specifically inspired by Nordic myth and legend, retaining the [[ProudWarriorRace original source morality]].
* ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Tanith Lee’s ''Birthgrave'' trilogy, ends with Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the two decide that they like each other enough to enter into an incestuous mother/son marriage. This is
usually considered “all right” to be a happy ending to people whether they want it or not. This includes convincing a wolf it's human so that it nearly starves to death and goes insane, since it can't live as either human or wolf now, so that it would eat a grandmother and dress up like her a la ''Little Red Riding Hood''. By the time the three witches arrive, all the Big Bad Wolf wants is ''[[SuicideByCop an ending]]''.
** Intentionally played in ''Literature/{{Eric}}'' which ends by saying that three wishes provided a happy ending for most of the people they've affected and giving as examples the Tezumen, who continue to slaughter people but no longer do so
because of religion so they are both essentially deities.
* Creator/GillianFlynn's ''Literature/GoneGirl'' is deliberately written
don't need to be this. Amy finally has someone she can be herself with get up so early; the Tsorteans and Nick has Ephebians, whose war is over, allowing them to prepare for the child he always wanted. They may eventually kill each other but, at heart, they're ''both'' sociopaths. This is averted next one; the demons and damned souls, who get back to inflicting/experiencing material punishment on immaterial spirit in the film version, where Nick comes across more sympathetically.knowledge that at least it's not Astfgl's psychological torture; and Astfgl himself, who as Life President of Hell gets to spend his time writing policy statements entirely unaware that the rest of the demonic lowerarchy is completely ignoring him. What happened to our actual protagonists, we don't get told beyond "It could be worse". Lampshaded by the last two lines "And this too was happiness. Of a sort."



* Most of Creator/FlanneryOConnor's works share this trait--but she herself insisted that she was a writer of comic stories, rightly regarded. Again and again, her protagonists (often ironically and grotesquely) lose everything they thought they wanted and valued--their possessions, their dignity, their self-image, even their lives. Burned down back to the foundations, they are left unarmored, often ridiculous and humiliated, but finally open to the [[GoodIsNotNice terrible incursion of God's grace]]. O'Connor famously claimed that ''Literature/WiseBlood'' had a "very hopeful" ending; this reading, though, absolutely depends on understanding the author's and protagonist's priorities, which many readers have trouble internalizing.
* The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes in his myopic characters and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.

to:

* Most ''Literature/AGirlCalledBlue'' is about girls growing up in a strict home for children in 1960s Ireland (run by Sadist Nuns). The book ends with Blue rejoicing that she's finally found a family of Creator/FlanneryOConnor's works share this trait--but her own. Except the "family" is two people she's met twice and they're not allowed to adopt her so she has to wait three years before she's old enough to leave the school with them only allowed to visit her twice a year. Also three of her best friends have now left, one being drowned, another going back to live with her father and the last being sent to another school and she has been forced to sleep alone in a cramped room, and will likely still have to endure plenty more abuse from the nuns for the next three years. Oh and she never finds out who her real mother is either and the nuns will keep abusing children for many years in Ireland.
* Creator/GillianFlynn's ''Literature/GoneGirl'' is deliberately written to be this. Amy finally has someone she can be
herself insisted with and Nick has the child he always wanted. They may eventually kill each other but, at heart, they're ''both'' sociopaths. This is averted in the film version, where Nick comes across more sympathetically.
* The ''{{Literature/Goosebumps}}'' books were famous for featuring {{Cruel Twist Ending}}s, but ''Literature/TheCuckooClockOfDoom'' has one that's played as happy and upbeat despite being utterly horrifying in implication: After repairing the titular clock and returning to the present, the protagonist discovers that he has inadvertently erased his [[AnnoyingYoungerSibling Annoying Younger Sister]] from existence. This is played as a good thing for him because the girl is portrayed as a real EnfantTerrible and the vast majority of fans ''despise'' her. To them, the ending is a straight-up KarmicTwistEnding that works out happily for the protagonist. Still, it is DisproportionateRetribution to have her actions result in her complete disappearance. While he does say that there's ''probably'' a way to use the clock to revive her, and he'll ''probably'' do it someday, given that he himself was nearly erased the first time he used the clock, what guarantee is there he'll even survive trying, let alone actually succeed?
* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of a video game, possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.
* At the end of ''Literature/TheGoddessTest'', Kate's beloved mother is actually the goddess Demeter, so she and her mother can be together for eternity. Sounds great, huh? Except if you think back to the prologue, where we hear Demeter outright telling Hades that she's going to have her second daughter take the goddess test and be his wife, even though eleven girls have already died in the attempt and Hades ''says'' he wants to just give up rather than see anyone else die for him. There's also the fact that the last girl who was manipulated into an arranged marriage with Hades later begged for death. Throughout the story, there is a lot of emphasis on the fact that being there is Kate's choice. However, the reason she made the deal with Henry in the first place was to save Ava and then the reason she kept the deal was so that he could keep her mother alive and she could spend time with her before she died. Except you find out that both Ava and Diana are Goddesses and were never in any real danger. So that means that while it was technically Kate's choice, her entire choice was based on a lie. Plus the ending reveals that Diana put her daughter through four years of emotional turmoil by making her think that her mother was on the verge of death for years and forcing Kate to take care of her for no reason other than to set her up for the test.
* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.
* ''Literature/HushHush'' has a great happy ending, if you ignore the fact that part of Nora's house was burned down, there's a ClingyJealousGirl of a fallen angel after her, and
that she is blissfully dating the guy who spent the book stalking her, sexually harassing her, and outright attempting to ''murder her''.
* Back when ''The Iron Giant''
was a writer book instead of comic stories, rightly regarded. Again [[WesternAnimation/TheIronGiant a movie]], it ended with an encounter with a dragon-like alien that sang in a hypnotic manner. It sang loud enough that the entire world heard it, and again, her everyone in the world spent the rest of their lives alternately taking care of necessities and listening to the song. It's specified that all war was completely eliminated, and the implication would be that art and culture vanished too. If the wording is to be taken literally, people didn't even converse with each other. Now, does this sound {{Utopia}}n, or more like a nightmare?
* ''Literature/LeftBehind'' gets this a lot for its ending where not only are all non-Christians sent to FireAndBrimstoneHell, but the paradise where all the
protagonists (often ironically end up is depicted as a faintly creepy commune where you can no longer eat meat or form relationships with anyone you want, and grotesquely) lose everything nobody experiences any strong emotions other than love of God. [[ValuesDissonance The writers treat this as a utopia.]]
* Coupled with ValuesDissonance for ''Literature/ALittlePrincess''. The book ends with Sara being restored to her wealth while Becky becomes her personal attendant. Oh and [[SadistTeacher Miss Minchin]] gets [[KarmaHoudini away with treating them like prisoners]]. However, if one takes into context the period the story is set in (Victorian London) then Becky going from little better than a slave to a powerful position in the household (with a kind and generous mistress too) where she would get a roof over her head and financial security, it's a happy ending for Becky indeed. And while Miss Minchin doesn't get an over-the-top instant comeuppance (save in the film adaptations, which pretty much need one) it's worth remembering that not only has she irrevocably lost her chance at a pupil who could've single-handedly ensured her school's success and her own financial comfort for life; once Sara's story becomes common knowledge in her social circle--as it inevitably will--Minchin's reputation will be in tatters and her school likely ruined. There's also a WhatHappenedToTheMouse for Melchisedec the rat and his family; one hopes kindhearted Sara will remember them and send Ram Dass over there with bread crumbs.
* Inverted with Edmond Hamilton's 1932 short story 'The Man Who Evolved', which is traditionally interpreted as having the soul-crushingly nihilistic ending of learning that the human race is doomed to devolve into primordial ooze, and there is nothing that anybody, not even a Sufficiently Advanced super-intelligence, can do to prevent it. However, FridgeLogic shows that there are two ways in which the ending can be interpreted more optimistically: either Pollard continues down the path of Hollywood Evolution, [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence ascending to a higher plane of existence]] and becoming an {{Energy Being|s}} while leaving his body behind as protoplasm, or the story can be interpreted as set in the same universe as Hamilton's later short story, "Devolution", in which microbes are the most advanced forms of life, which developed an interstellar civilization and only got stuck on Earth after
they thought they wanted and valued--their possessions, their dignity, their self-image, even their lives. Burned down back to the foundations, they are left unarmored, often ridiculous and humiliated, but finally open to the [[GoodIsNotNice terrible incursion de-evolved into all other forms of God's grace]]. O'Connor famously claimed life (in which case Pollard could conceivably have retained his augmented intelligence). Note that ''Literature/WiseBlood'' had a "very hopeful" ending; neither of these interpretations alleviates the horror of Pollard's steady LossOfIdentity as he travels through the EvolutionaryLevels, however.
* The ''Literature/MaximumRide'' series ends
this reading, though, absolutely depends on understanding way. The apocalypse that the author's and main characters have been trying to prevent comes to pass, killing off the majority of the planet's population (including the protagonist's priorities, which many readers have trouble internalizing.
biological mother and sister, the latter of whom was also the love interest for said protagonist's adopted brother), and the new world is a dangerous place inhabited mostly by mutants...but hey, [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding the Flock survived!]] And Max [[BabiesMakeEverythingBetter gave birth to a daughter!]] [[TeenPregnancy At about sixteen]]...and this is all before ''[[SpinOffspring Hawk]]'' came out and hit it with a HappyEndingOverride.
* ''Literature/{{Mindswap}}'' by Creator/RobertSheckley. The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies protagonist is in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes corrupted world but believes he has succeeded in his myopic characters mission and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.has returned home.



* ''The Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to the happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, the Beast is human again, and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifically abusing his second fiancee and gleefully allowing her family to go to ruin, and ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't like the fact that the painting reflected the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly ending up with someone considerably worse than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's no chance of him learning from his past or making amends. The ending is still treated as completely happy, but more than a few readers have expressed a wish for Belle to leave the Beast altogether.
* In a similar case to ''The Last Battle'' above, at the end of ''[[Literature/TheBookOfTheDunCow Peace at the Last]]'', almost all of the named sympathetic characters are killed in a LastStand by a mob of corrupted animals. Meanwhile, Wyrm's HatePlague has corrupted the world and divided its animal inhabitants beyond repair. But it's played as a happy ending since they're reunited in the afterlife, along with characters who died in the previous books.
* The ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Scheherazade living happily ever after with her husband the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and then had her executed after sleeping with her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth and power?[[/note]]

to:

* ''The Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to The ''Literature/RevelationSpaceSeries'' ends with humanity ([[StarfishAliens with some help]]) defeating the happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, [[AbsoluteXenophobe Inhibitors]], at the Beast is human again, cost of fleeing the Milky Way as humanity's rogue [[AIIsACrapShoot Greenfly terraforming robots]] - now uncontained by the Inhibitors - overrun the galaxy, [[HordeOfAlienLocusts breaking apart worlds and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifically abusing his second fiancee and gleefully allowing her family anything artificial to go to ruin, and ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't like the fact turn into greenhouse habitats]] orbiting stars. ''Galactic North'' shows that the painting reflected Greenfly has begun to expand outside the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly galaxy. [[EarthAllAlong The Shadows]] in ''Absolution Gap'' explain that their entire local cluster has been effectively overrun by the Greenfly. The author said that this ending up was "[[http://web.archive.org/web/20050204072321/http://www.scifi.com/sfw/issue406/interview.html actually quite optimistic]]"
* ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.'' Shu, Wei, and Wu are united into one at last and peace throughout the entire country of China can finally begin. Unfortunately the victors are a splinter group of Wei who usurped the throne, conquered Wu and Shu who at the time were being ruled by Liu Shan (a truly incompetent ruler who defiles everything Shu originally stood for) and Sun Hao (a tyrant almost as bad as Dong Zhuo). The kicker? When these two surrendered they were given lucrative positions and the readers were told they lived out their remaining lives in luxury. To be fair though this novel closely follows the real-life events in history and not a lot could be changed. And historically, the hard-fought reunification of China ended a decade or two later
with someone considerably worse [[HereWeGoAgain a new barbarian invasion.]] Also, the war to unify China was itself one of the bloodiest in human history, killing (by highest estimates) 74% of China's population, more people than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten Second World War. The victors ruled dust and ashes.
* ''Literature/TheSoldierSon''. After almost three books of stressing how bad it is for Nevare's soul to be split, he is finally reunited with Soldier's Boy and absorbed by an ancestor tree, together with
his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's no chance beloved Lisana. Is this the end? No, he is split again. Admittedly, that half gets back together with Amzil, marries her and inherits the Nevare estate, but wasn't it bad to have one's personality split? Other issues concern the discovery of him learning gold that draw the Gernians away from his past or making amends. The ending is still treated as the Speck lands: how long before they'll return? And finally, Nevare completely happy, but more than a few readers have expressed a wish for Belle to leave destroys the Beast altogether.
* In a similar case to ''The Last Battle'' above, at
source of the end of ''[[Literature/TheBookOfTheDunCow Peace at Plainspeople's magic in the Last]]'', process, sealing their fate. This is given almost all of no attention.
* ''Literature/TheirEyesWereWatchingGod'': So
the named sympathetic characters are killed in a LastStand great love of Janie's life is dead, she is socially stigmatized by a mob of corrupted animals. Meanwhile, Wyrm's HatePlague has corrupted the world and divided its animal inhabitants beyond repair. But it's played as a happy ending since they're reunited in the afterlife, along with characters who died in the previous books.
* The ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Scheherazade living happily ever after
her community, she had surrendered just about everything she had to be with her husband love, and now she returns to the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and then place she had her executed after sleeping with her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth and power?[[/note]]started from.



* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
** The last book gave Jacob, who suffered from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated imprinting, his own happy romantic ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem there's apparently no good way to get rid of the Volturi or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they have been given all the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.
** On a more personal note, Nessie is hardly the "perfect ending" for the rest of the Cullens that Meyer claims. Esme and Rose want biological children of their own to care for and raise. Nessie is already nearly at adult-level independence within weeks of birth, and she's ''Bella's'' daughter, not theirs. Nessie also can't bring back Alice's human memories, she has almost no relationship with any of the other male Cullens, etc. Meyer seems to think that Nessie fixes everything just by existing, but realistically she creates many, many more problems than she fixes for them.



* ''Literature/TheWumpWorld'', a children's book by Creator/BillPeet, ends with the [[MeaningfulName Pollutians]] abandoning the titular planet, their cities being reclaimed by nature and the Wumps repopulating their world. It's a perfectly good ending for a GreenAesop... if you ignore the fact that the Pollutians are presumably still out there, doing the same thing to ''other'' planets.
* The ''{{Literature/Goosebumps}}'' books were famous for featuring {{Cruel Twist Ending}}s, but ''The Cuckoo Clock of Doom'' has one that's played as happy and upbeat despite being utterly horrifying in implication: After repairing the titular clock and returning to the present, the protagonist discovers that he has inadvertently erased his [[AnnoyingYoungerSibling Annoying Younger Sister]] from existence. This is played as a good thing for him because the girl is portrayed as a real EnfantTerrible and the vast majority of fans ''despise'' her. To them, the ending is a straight-up KarmicTwistEnding that works out happily for the protagonist. Still, it is DisproportionateRetribution to have her actions result in her complete disappearance. While he does say that there's ''probably'' a way to use the clock to revive her, and he'll ''probably'' do it someday, given that he himself was nearly erased the first time he used the clock, what guarantee is there he'll even survive trying, let alone actually succeed?
* In the gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', it's strongly implied that the main characters will get to be together, but thanks to some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that Lucian's father is going to go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the rather awkward fact that Lucian left his fiancée at the altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for life. Plus with the binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.
* The ''Literature/MaximumRide'' series ends this way. The apocalypse that the main characters have been trying to prevent comes to pass, killing off the majority of the planet's population (including the protagonist's biological mother and sister, the latter of whom was also the love interest for said protagonist's adopted brother), and the new world is a dangerous place inhabited mostly by mutants...but hey, [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding the Flock survived!]] And Max [[BabiesMakeEverythingBetter gave birth to a daughter!]] [[TeenPregnancy At about sixteen]]...and this is all before ''[[SpinOffspring Hawk]]'' came out and hit it with a HappyEndingOverride.
* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.
* ''Literature/TheirEyesWereWatchingGod'': So the great love of Janie's life is dead, she is socially stigmatized by her community, she had surrendered just about everything she had to be with her love, and now she returns to the place she had started from.

to:

* Creator/RoaldDahl's ''Literature/TheWitches''. The protagonist learns that he's stuck as a mouse and that mice don't live very long, but he's happy because he'll probably die near the same time as his elderly grandmother and doesn't care about living if he's not with her; they will live out their lives tracking down and destroying other witches together. The two also ponder Bruno's fate. One states that his mouse-hating mother probably drowned him in a bucket, but nobody seems very disturbed by this possibility. The [[Film/TheWitches1990 1990 movie]] has an unabashed happy ending where the last witch, who had undergone a HeelFaceTurn, undoes the mouse spell on the protagonist and is implied to do the same to Bruno. While many were appreciative of this happier ending, Roald Dahl was infamously ''not''.
* In ''Literature/TheWormOuroboros'', the 'good guy' princes have lots of battles and perform heroic deeds to overcome the 'bad guys'. Having done so, they're bored. So the gods recreate the bad guys so that the good guys can have fun beating them again. And so the world is condemned to an eternity of warfare because otherwise the princes would get bored. This was because the book is specifically inspired by Nordic myth and legend, retaining the [[ProudWarriorRace original source morality]].
* ''Literature/TheWumpWorld'', a children's book by Creator/BillPeet, ends with the [[MeaningfulName Pollutians]] abandoning the titular planet, their cities being reclaimed by nature and the Wumps repopulating their world. It's a perfectly good ending for a GreenAesop... if you ignore the fact that the Pollutians are presumably still out there, doing the same thing to ''other'' planets. \n* The ''{{Literature/Goosebumps}}'' books were famous for featuring {{Cruel Twist Ending}}s, but ''The Cuckoo Clock of Doom'' has one that's played as happy and upbeat despite being utterly horrifying in implication: After repairing the titular clock and returning to the present, the protagonist discovers that he has inadvertently erased his [[AnnoyingYoungerSibling Annoying Younger Sister]] from existence. This is played as a good thing for him because the girl is portrayed as a real EnfantTerrible and the vast majority of fans ''despise'' her. To them, the ending is a straight-up KarmicTwistEnding that works out happily for the protagonist. Still, it is DisproportionateRetribution to have her actions result in her complete disappearance. While he does say that there's ''probably'' a way to use the clock to revive her, and he'll ''probably'' do it someday, given that he himself was nearly erased the first time he used the clock, what guarantee is there he'll even survive trying, let alone actually succeed? \n* In the gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', it's strongly implied that the main characters will get to be together, but thanks to some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that Lucian's father is going to go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the rather awkward fact that Lucian left his fiancée at the altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for life. Plus with the binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.\n* The ''Literature/MaximumRide'' series ends this way. The apocalypse that the main characters have been trying to prevent comes to pass, killing off the majority of the planet's population (including the protagonist's biological mother and sister, the latter of whom was also the love interest for said protagonist's adopted brother), and the new world is a dangerous place inhabited mostly by mutants...but hey, [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding the Flock survived!]] And Max [[BabiesMakeEverythingBetter gave birth to a daughter!]] [[TeenPregnancy At about sixteen]]...and this is all before ''[[SpinOffspring Hawk]]'' came out and hit it with a HappyEndingOverride.\n* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction. \n* ''Literature/TheirEyesWereWatchingGod'': So the great love of Janie's life is dead, she is socially stigmatized by her community, she had surrendered just about everything she had to be with her love, and now she returns to the place she had started from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so devisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.

to:

* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so devisive divisive is because of this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so devisive is because of this trope, [[spoiler:as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction]].

to:

* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is so devisive is because of this trope, [[spoiler:as as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place, and slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction]].extinction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is a big source of EndingAversion is this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and enabling a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota; the Malfoys are still around (and by extension, probably other Death Eaters as well); the {{Masquerade}} remains firmly in place; and even slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry still has one. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it's not unlikely that wizards are heading towards extinction.

to:

* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is a big source so devisive is because of EndingAversion is this trope, as [[spoiler:as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. [[StatusQuoIsGod That nothing seems to have substantially changed in the Magical Society]] from what is shown hasn't helped, either. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and enabling breeding a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota; the Malfoys are still around (and by extension, probably other Death Eaters as well); the {{Masquerade}} iota, TheMasquerade remains firmly in place; place, and even slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry still has one. This means that the systems that allowed Voldemort to rise to power and cause such devastating damage to the Wizarding society both times are still in place. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it's not unlikely it could be likely that British wizards are heading towards extinction.extinction]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Creator/HarlanEllison claims that the ending of ''Literature/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream'' is intended to be happy. Sure, the narrator ends by saying the title line in utter despair, after mercy-killing every other remaining human in the world, but he's so [[UnreliableNarrator unreliable]] he hasn't realized that his actions represent the final triumph of the human spirit. The game makes it into more a BittersweetEnding, with the humans finally taking down AM and settling into the duty of being a watchdog for the [=AIs=] as they await the reawakening of the humans on the moon.
* By all accounts, Creator/HansChristianAndersen [[CreatorBreakdown was a very depressed man]]. Out of all his fairy tales, there are only a few with unambiguously happy endings.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'' (not [[{{Disneyfication}} the Disney version]]). The little mermaid is turned into "daughter of air" with the prospect of eventually entering Heaven, very probably a result of revision by Andersen. Initially this was the selected ending, even put in the working title, but there was a happily reworked version in which the mermaid apparently just dissolved into foam in the end. Even the happier version has the FridgeHorror of knowing that the [[DeaderThanDead dissolving into foam]] fate is eventually going to befall the Little Mermaid's sisters and family if they don't act as she did.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl''. TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth turned UpToEleven. The tone of the ending is [[BittersweetEnding very sad for the townspeople who discover her frozen corpse, but happy for the girl as she has ascended into Heaven]]. As such, some remakes from our more cynical times either rewrite it to give her a more materialistic HappyEnding ([[DeusExMachina somehow]]) or portray it as a truly tear-jerking DownerEnding. [[Literature/{{Hogfather}} Even Death can't stand it.]]
** While not nearly as dark as the two above, one has to question just how HappilyEverAfter the Prince in ''Literature/ThePrincessAndThePea'' is actually going to live with his new bride. Someone who complains about a single pea under 40 mattresses has got to be ''ridiculously'' high-maintenance.
* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
** It's explored in ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' where Lilith gives what is usually considered to be a happy ending to people whether they want it or not. This includes convincing a wolf it's human so that it nearly starves to death and goes insane, since it can't live as either human or wolf now, so that it would eat a grandmother and dress up like her a la ''Little Red Riding Hood''. By the time the three witches arrive, all the Big Bad Wolf wants is ''[[SuicideByCop an ending]]''.
** Intentionally played in ''Literature/{{Eric}}'' which ends by saying that three wishes provided a happy ending for most of the people they've affected and giving as examples the Tezumen, who continue to slaughter people but no longer do so because of religion so they don't need to get up so early; the Tsorteans and Ephebians, whose war is over, allowing them to prepare for the next one; the demons and damned souls, who get back to inflicting/experiencing material punishment on immaterial spirit in the knowledge that at least it's not Astfgl's psychological torture; and Astfgl himself, who as Life President of Hell gets to spend his time writing policy statements entirely unaware that the rest of the demonic lowerarchy is completely ignoring him. What happened to our actual protagonists, we don't get told beyond "It could be worse". Lampshaded by the last two lines "And this too was happiness. Of a sort."
* Creator/RobertSilverberg's stories fall into this occasionally because his personal philosophy is so different from how most people (or at least most modern Western readers) view life and humanity. A particularly jarring example is ''The Face Upon The Waters''--the main character spends most of the story trying to maintain his cultural identity after the destruction of Earth and the scattering of its people, but ultimately concludes that people should adapt to whatever culture they live amongst... and joins up with TheCorruption[=/=]AssimilationPlot, which has a stated goal of assimilating everyone it can and killing everyone it can't.
* ''Literature/AGirlCalledBlue'' is about girls growing up in a strict home for children in 1960s Ireland (run by Sadist Nuns). The book ends with Blue rejoicing that she's finally found a family of her own. Except the "family" is two people she's met twice and they're not allowed to adopt her so she has to wait three years before she's old enough to leave the school with them only allowed to visit her twice a year. Also three of her best friends have now left, one being drowned, another going back to live with her father and the last being sent to another school and she has been forced to sleep alone in a cramped room, and will likely still have to endure plenty more abuse from the nuns for the next three years. Oh and she never finds out who her real mother is either and the nuns will keep abusing children for many years in Ireland.
* The ending of Creator/CSLewis's final [[Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia Narnia]] book, ''Literature/TheLastBattle'', qualified as this for many young readers. Narnia ends, and everyone except Susan dies. Some minor characters are tormented and destroyed by a horrific many-armed GodOfEvil, while others are judged unworthy and vanish forever into Aslan's shadow. [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding But the important people don't care about that]] because they all go to the "real" Narnia (a stand-in for heaven) as the Christian subtext becomes text. It can be uplifting or inspire nightmares, depending on which scenes stick with you. (Creator/NeilGaiman brilliantly deconstructed this in his short story ''Literature/TheProblemOfSusan'', in which he shows what happened to Susan after her siblings died in a train crash and she had to [[BodyHorror identify their corpses]].)
* Creator/RoaldDahl's ''Literature/TheWitches''. The protagonist learns that he's stuck as a mouse and that mice don't live very long, but he's happy because he'll probably die near the same time as his elderly grandmother and doesn't care about living if he's not with her; they will live out their lives tracking down and destroying other witches together. The two also ponder Bruno's fate. One states that his mouse-hating mother probably drowned him in a bucket, but nobody seems very disturbed by this possibility. The [[Film/TheWitches1990 1990 movie]] has an unabashed happy ending where the last witch, who had undergone a HeelFaceTurn, undoes the mouse spell on the protagonist and is implied to do the same to Bruno. While many were appreciative of this happier ending, Roald Dahl was infamously ''not''.
* Coupled with ValuesDissonance for ''Literature/ALittlePrincess''. The book ends with Sara being restored to her wealth while Becky becomes her personal attendant. Oh and [[SadistTeacher Miss Minchin]] gets [[KarmaHoudini away with treating them like prisoners]]. However, if one takes into context the period the story is set in (Victorian London) then Becky going from little better than a slave to a powerful position in the household (with a kind and generous mistress too) where she would get a roof over her head and financial security, it's a happy ending for Becky indeed. And while Miss Minchin doesn't get an over-the-top instant comeuppance (save in the film adaptations, which pretty much need one) it's worth remembering that not only has she irrevocably lost her chance at a pupil who could've single-handedly ensured her school's success and her own financial comfort for life; once Sara's story becomes common knowledge in her social circle--as it inevitably will--Minchin's reputation will be in tatters and her school likely ruined. There's also a WhatHappenedToTheMouse for Melchisedec the rat and his family; one hopes kindhearted Sara will remember them and send Ram Dass over there with bread crumbs.
* At the end of ''Literature/AtlasShrugged,'' Galt's Gulch is the only non-Crapsack place left in the whole world. Which is great, because all of the looters and moochers are gone and the good people can rebuild the world, right? Then you remember the [[InferredHolocaust millions of innocent children who were left to starve...]] (Then again, by the book's morality, this is the looters' and moochers' fault rather than anything to blame on the protagonists...)
* ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.'' Shu, Wei, and Wu are united into one at last and peace throughout the entire country of China can finally begin. Unfortunately the victors are a splinter group of Wei who usurped the throne, conquered Wu and Shu who at the time were being ruled by Liu Shan (a truly incompetent ruler who defiles everything Shu originally stood for) and Sun Hao (a tyrant almost as bad as Dong Zhuo). The kicker? When these two surrendered they were given lucrative positions and the readers were told they lived out their remaining lives in luxury. To be fair though this novel closely follows the real-life events in history and not a lot could be changed. And historically, the hard-fought reunification of China ended a decade or two later with [[HereWeGoAgain a new barbarian invasion.]] Also, the war to unify China was itself one of the bloodiest in human history, killing (by highest estimates) 74% of China's population, more people than the Second World War. The victors ruled dust and ashes.
* Back when ''The Iron Giant'' was a book instead of [[WesternAnimation/TheIronGiant a movie]], it ended with an encounter with a dragon-like alien that sang in a hypnotic manner. It sang loud enough that the entire world heard it, and everyone in the world spent the rest of their lives alternately taking care of necessities and listening to the song. It's specified that all war was completely eliminated, and the implication would be that art and culture vanished too. If the wording is to be taken literally, people didn't even converse with each other. Now, does this sound {{Utopia}}n, or more like a nightmare?
* ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
** The last book gave Jacob, who suffered from unrequited love for Bella and who vehemently hated imprinting, his own happy romantic ending by having him imprint on Bella's newborn daughter Nessie. Oh, don't worry; Nessie grows really fast, so she'll be physically 17 years old in 7 years and ready to start a relationship with her "Uncle Jake" then! And what of Jake's loss of free will? Who cares as long as he's still (forced to be) in Bella's life!
** Also, [[InherentInTheSystem there's apparently no good way to get rid of the Volturi or vampires like them]]. Given that the Volturi are growing more and more afraid of human technology, and more and more inclined to lash out at humanity, this is a ''very bad thing''. Das-Sporking's MST, when it gets to the end of ''Breaking Dawn'', points out that their "victory" at the end really isn't one, as while the Volturi are gone ''for now'', they have been given all the information needed to defeat the Cullens should they come around again.
** On a more personal note, Nessie is hardly the "perfect ending" for the rest of the Cullens that Meyer claims. Esme and Rose want biological children of their own to care for and raise. Nessie is already nearly at adult-level independence within weeks of birth, and she's ''Bella's'' daughter, not theirs. Nessie also can't bring back Alice's human memories, she has almost no relationship with any of the other male Cullens, etc. Meyer seems to think that Nessie fixes everything just by existing, but realistically she creates many, many more problems than she fixes for them.
* ''Literature/BendSinister'' by Creator/VladimirNabokov ends with the protagonist arrested by his nation's totalitarian government, and his young son horrifically killed by a crowd of mental patients--on film!--due to a ''clerical error''. But then Nabokov [[{{Metafiction}} reaches through the layers of reality]] and gives his main character the gift of insanity to make him forget all his pain. The novel ends with Adam Krug, as a result of his insanity, rushing the dictator and being shot to death. Nabokov, however, refuses to write this conclusion (after implying its inevitability) and instead describes his room and decides to go mothing. It's a strange case of being incapable of giving Krug a happy ending (even the insanity so benevolently bestowed upon him results directly in his being killed), and so at least giving him the consolation prize of not writing it at all, and therefore not allowing it to happen. It's about as esoteric as a 'happy ending' can get.
* ''Literature/LeftBehind'' gets this a lot for its ending where not only are all non-Christians sent to FireAndBrimstoneHell, but the paradise where all the protagonists end up is depicted as a faintly creepy commune where you can no longer eat meat or form relationships with anyone you want, and nobody experiences any strong emotions other than love of God. [[ValuesDissonance The writers treat this as a utopia.]]
* Nearly all of Zilpha Keatley Snyder's books have one of these. Save the Literature/GreenSkyTrilogy, and only because she was deluged with mail, realized she made a big goof, and authorized a sequel in the form of a video game, possibly the first video game to be acknowledged as {{Canon}} for something written in another medium.
* Creator/HPLovecraft's works:
** "Celephais," which ends with the main character finally returning to the wondrous dream-city that he created in his youth where he is appointed the chief god of all of the regions of Dream; and all he had to do was fall off a cliff and let the tides cast his corpse upon the rocks. Lovecraft {{lampshade|Hanging}}s this later in ''Literature/TheDreamQuestOfUnknownKadath'' when ''that'' story's protagonist meets this exact character who's since come to regret his decision but obviously can never go back.
** The sheer ValuesDissonance of applying this trope to "The Street" is why it's almost impossible to find it in print, as it involves treating the spontaneous collapse of an overcrowded slum that [[KillEmAll kills everybody living there]] as a good thing. Why? Because A: it used to be a beautiful Colonial country lane line with rosebushes and is now a dirty slum, and B: all of the people living in it are [[EvilForeigner dirty non-WASP immigrants ungratefully plotting revolution against America for taking them in]]... at least, [[TakeOurWordForIt so the narration says they are]].
* ''Literature/{{Mindswap}}'' by Creator/RobertSheckley. The protagonist is in the corrupted world but believes he has succeeded in his mission and has returned home.
* ''Literature/HushHush'' has a great happy ending, if you ignore the fact that part of Nora's house was burned down, there's a ClingyJealousGirl of a fallen angel after her, and that she is blissfully dating the guy who spent the book stalking her, sexually harassing her, and outright attempting to ''murder her''.
* At the end of ''Literature/TheGoddessTest'', Kate's beloved mother is actually the goddess Demeter, so she and her mother can be together for eternity. Sounds great, huh? Except if you think back to the prologue, where we hear Demeter outright telling Hades that she's going to have her second daughter take the goddess test and be his wife, even though eleven girls have already died in the attempt and Hades ''says'' he wants to just give up rather than see anyone else die for him. There's also the fact that the last girl who was manipulated into an arranged marriage with Hades later begged for death. Throughout the story, there is a lot of emphasis on the fact that being there is Kate's choice. However, the reason she made the deal with Henry in the first place was to save Ava and then the reason she kept the deal was so that he could keep her mother alive and she could spend time with her before she died. Except you find out that both Ava and Diana are Goddesses and were never in any real danger. So that means that while it was technically Kate's choice, her entire choice was based on a lie. Plus the ending reveals that Diana put her daughter through four years of emotional turmoil by making her think that her mother was on the verge of death for years and forcing Kate to take care of her for no reason other than to set her up for the test.
* The "Susannah in New York" epilogue of ''Franchise/TheDarkTower'' series has Susannah going into an alternate reality version of New York where Eddie and Jake are still alive and in fact are brothers. She appears in Central Park at Christmas time, alternate-Eddie greets her with a cup of hot chocolate, and it's clearly supposed to be her happy ending... Except many readers feel that Susannah abandoned the quest and is now trapped in a world that isn't her own with a couple of ReplacementGoldfish who aren't really the people she loved.
* The end of ''Literature/TheDarkIsRising'' sequence is unsatisfying in several ways. The forces of the Dark have been beaten back; all the main characters are OK and have forged a close bond; Bran has grown up normal, decided to stay with his foster-father, and has realised he's attracted to Jane. But not only do five of the Six have to forget that magic exists and never see their beloved Merriman again, the lovely magic of the Light is going to withdraw from the world altogether. And poor John Rowland is going to believe that his wife has suddenly died (which is presented as better than knowing she was an agent of the Dark). Will gets to remember everything because he's an Old One, but he'll have nobody to talk to about it for most of the time.
* Chris Adrian's ''Literature/TheChildrensHospital'' ends with every single adult left on Earth dying, as the global flooding recedes and the children leave the eponymous hospital to inherit their new Earth. The final image is the main character screaming as her newborn child is taken away and she dissolves into ash. Lampshaded throughout the book by the narrator who, as an angel who was once human, is supposed to wholeheartedly accept the end of the world as righteous, but can't quite do so.
* Whatever Evelyn Waugh may say about God's love and the power for redemption in ''Literature/BridesheadRevisited'', the facts remain as such: Sebastian's a hopeless alcoholic, Julia and Charles, having gone through with their respective divorces, decide never to see each other again, and the entire world is going to be inherited by the likes of [[CorruptCorporateExecutive Mottram]] and [[TheScrappy Hooper]].
* ''Literature/TheSoldierSon''. After almost three books of stressing how bad it is for Nevare's soul to be split, he is finally reunited with Soldier's Boy and absorbed by an ancestor tree, together with his beloved Lisana. Is this the end? No, he is split again. Admittedly, that half gets back together with Amzil, marries her and inherits the Nevare estate, but wasn't it bad to have one's personality split? Other issues concern the discovery of gold that draw the Gernians away from the Speck lands: how long before they'll return? And finally, Nevare completely destroys the source of the Plainspeople's magic in the process, sealing their fate. This is given almost no attention.
* Some of the "good" endings in the ''Literature/ChooseYourOwnAdventure'' books merely consists of the main character surviving, stopping the BigBad temporarily, or implying that ''perhaps'' you will have success in the future, leaving many plot points unsolved.
* The final book of ''Literature/TheDemonsLexicon'' has the surviving magicians pulling a mass HeelFaceTurn and joining the Goblin Market. Except we're given no reason to believe that it's genuine with all or even any of them, and they're probably just planning to destroy the Market from within.
* Inverted with Edmond Hamilton's 1932 short story 'The Man Who Evolved', which is traditionally interpreted as having the soul-crushingly nihilistic ending of learning that the human race is doomed to devolve into primordial ooze, and there is nothing that anybody, not even a Sufficiently Advanced super-intelligence, can do to prevent it. However, FridgeLogic shows that there are two ways in which the ending can be interpreted more optimistically: either Pollard continues down the path of Hollywood Evolution, [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence ascending to a higher plane of existence]] and becoming an {{Energy Being|s}} while leaving his body behind as protoplasm, or the story can be interpreted as set in the same universe as Hamilton's later short story, "Devolution", in which microbes are the most advanced forms of life, which developed an interstellar civilization and only got stuck on Earth after they de-evolved into all other forms of life (in which case Pollard could conceivably have retained his augmented intelligence). Note that neither of these interpretations alleviates the horror of Pollard's steady LossOfIdentity as he travels through the EvolutionaryLevels, however.
* The ''Literature/RevelationSpaceSeries'' ends with humanity ([[StarfishAliens with some help]]) defeating the [[AbsoluteXenophobe Inhibitors]], at the cost of fleeing the Milky Way as humanity's rogue [[AIIsACrapShoot Greenfly terraforming robots]] - now uncontained by the Inhibitors - overrun the galaxy, [[HordeOfAlienLocusts breaking apart worlds and anything artificial to turn into greenhouse habitats]] orbiting stars. ''Galactic North'' shows that the Greenfly has begun to expand outside the galaxy. [[EarthAllAlong The Shadows]] in ''Absolution Gap'' explain that their entire local cluster has been effectively overrun by the Greenfly. The author said that this ending was "[[http://web.archive.org/web/20050204072321/http://www.scifi.com/sfw/issue406/interview.html actually quite optimistic]]"
* In ''Literature/TheWormOuroboros'', the 'good guy' princes have lots of battles and perform heroic deeds to overcome the 'bad guys'. Having done so, they're bored. So the gods recreate the bad guys so that the good guys can have fun beating them again. And so the world is condemned to an eternity of warfare because otherwise the princes would get bored. This was because the book is specifically inspired by Nordic myth and legend, retaining the [[ProudWarriorRace original source morality]].
* ''Quest for the White Witch'', the final novel in Tanith Lee’s ''Birthgrave'' trilogy, ends with Vazkor finally meeting his neglectful mother. And the two decide that they like each other enough to enter into an incestuous mother/son marriage. This is considered “all right” because they are both essentially deities.
* Creator/GillianFlynn's ''Literature/GoneGirl'' is deliberately written to be this. Amy finally has someone she can be herself with and Nick has the child he always wanted. They may eventually kill each other but, at heart, they're ''both'' sociopaths. This is averted in the film version, where Nick comes across more sympathetically.
* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'' is meant to have a happy ending, but many would argue that marrying and starting a family with a controlling abuser is NOT a happy ending.
** The first book actually has a potential ''inversion''; it ends with Ana deciding she and Christian are incompatible and leaving him, which the book treats as a DownerEnding, but many readers see this as a good thing because the relationship is unhealthy and disproportionately skewed in Christian's favor.
* Most of Creator/FlanneryOConnor's works share this trait--but she herself insisted that she was a writer of comic stories, rightly regarded. Again and again, her protagonists (often ironically and grotesquely) lose everything they thought they wanted and valued--their possessions, their dignity, their self-image, even their lives. Burned down back to the foundations, they are left unarmored, often ridiculous and humiliated, but finally open to the [[GoodIsNotNice terrible incursion of God's grace]]. O'Connor famously claimed that ''Literature/WiseBlood'' had a "very hopeful" ending; this reading, though, absolutely depends on understanding the author's and protagonist's priorities, which many readers have trouble internalizing.
* The plays and stories of Creator/AntonChekhov are ostensibly comedies, and they are still considered comedies in Russia. However, many other cultures tend to miss the unsentimental amusement Chekhov takes in his myopic characters and their future, and consider his works much darker, even tragic.
* ''Literature/TheQuantumThief'' trilogy ends with Mieli breaking the Planck Locks with the aid of the [[MineralMacGuffin Kaminari Jewel]] and using her newfound power to create an entirely new universe to all the people on Saturn, including the uploaded minds of Earth's remaining population. Unfortunately, this also means that the heartless Sobornost collective is left to rule the rest of the Solar System unchecked, now that their worst enemies are out of the picture, and it's only a matter of time before they consume all the remaining small civilisations in the System, including Mieli's own people, the Oortians. On the other hand, the story ends with [[RayOfHopeEnding another copy of Jean le Flambeur being released]], which could result in another wrench thrown in Sobornost's plans -- maybe.
* ''The Beast Within: Literature/ATaleOf Beauty's Prince'' does this to the happy ending of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast''. The curse is broken, the Beast is human again, and he and Belle are together... except the novella adds a backstory for the Beast that involves dumping his first fiancee for being poor, horrifically abusing his second fiancee and gleefully allowing her family to go to ruin, and ''ordering a hit on a painter'' because he didn't like the fact that the painting reflected the curse on him. Belle never learns about any of this, which means she's unwittingly ending up with someone considerably worse than she thought, while the Beast himself has forgotten his past for reasons never fully explained, meaning there's no chance of him learning from his past or making amends. The ending is still treated as completely happy, but more than a few readers have expressed a wish for Belle to leave the Beast altogether.
* In a similar case to ''The Last Battle'' above, at the end of ''[[Literature/TheBookOfTheDunCow Peace at the Last]]'', almost all of the named sympathetic characters are killed in a LastStand by a mob of corrupted animals. Meanwhile, Wyrm's HatePlague has corrupted the world and divided its animal inhabitants beyond repair. But it's played as a happy ending since they're reunited in the afterlife, along with characters who died in the previous books.
* The ''Literature/ArabianNights'' stories end with Scheherazade living happily ever after with her husband the king. A king who, when he first met Scheherazade, hated women so much that he [[TheBluebeard married a new one every night and then had her executed after sleeping with her]]. Sure, Scheherazade put a stop to all this, but after his past {{serial kill|er}}ings, many readers wonder "WhyWouldAnyoneTakeHimBack?"[[note]]Wealth and power?[[/note]]
* ''Literature/TheTurnerDiaries'' ends with all the world's Jews and non-whites eradicated in a long campaign of nuclear, chemical, and biological warfare, which has also killed 90% of the world's population and no doubt ruined the Earth's ecology beyond repair. Then again, what else could you expect from a poorly-written piece of racist, ultranationalist propaganda? At the very least, the world being bathed in nuclear fallout means that the [[VillainProtagonist protagonists]] are doomed as well.
* ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'': Yay! The heroes survive the collapse of the corrupt multicultural U.S. government and the warring successor states and are free to build their enlightened, traditional Christian society. Where heathens are banished or burned at the stake, Black people can be hanged for a violent crime within a week, and technology created after the 1930s is severely frowned upon, as are women working or getting higher education. Oh, and Victoria will be serving as a training center for a global crusade against Islam.
* ''Literature/TheWumpWorld'', a children's book by Creator/BillPeet, ends with the [[MeaningfulName Pollutians]] abandoning the titular planet, their cities being reclaimed by nature and the Wumps repopulating their world. It's a perfectly good ending for a GreenAesop... if you ignore the fact that the Pollutians are presumably still out there, doing the same thing to ''other'' planets.
* The ''{{Literature/Goosebumps}}'' books were famous for featuring {{Cruel Twist Ending}}s, but ''The Cuckoo Clock of Doom'' has one that's played as happy and upbeat despite being utterly horrifying in implication: After repairing the titular clock and returning to the present, the protagonist discovers that he has inadvertently erased his [[AnnoyingYoungerSibling Annoying Younger Sister]] from existence. This is played as a good thing for him because the girl is portrayed as a real EnfantTerrible and the vast majority of fans ''despise'' her. To them, the ending is a straight-up KarmicTwistEnding that works out happily for the protagonist. Still, it is DisproportionateRetribution to have her actions result in her complete disappearance. While he does say that there's ''probably'' a way to use the clock to revive her, and he'll ''probably'' do it someday, given that he himself was nearly erased the first time he used the clock, what guarantee is there he'll even survive trying, let alone actually succeed?
* In the gothic fantasy novel ''The Binding'', it's strongly implied that the main characters will get to be together, but thanks to some WhatHappenedToTheMouse it's implied that Lucian's father is going to go on sexually abusing his maids and getting away with it and there's also the rather awkward fact that Lucian left his fiancée at the altar without a word of explanation, probably ruining her reputation for life. Plus with the binding library burned down, a lot of people may end up saddled with memories they paid a lot of money to forget about.
* The ''Literature/MaximumRide'' series ends this way. The apocalypse that the main characters have been trying to prevent comes to pass, killing off the majority of the planet's population (including the protagonist's biological mother and sister, the latter of whom was also the love interest for said protagonist's adopted brother), and the new world is a dangerous place inhabited mostly by mutants...but hey, [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding the Flock survived!]] And Max [[BabiesMakeEverythingBetter gave birth to a daughter!]] [[TeenPregnancy At about sixteen]]...and this is all before ''[[SpinOffspring Hawk]]'' came out and hit it with a HappyEndingOverride.
* One of the major reasons the epilogue of ''Franchise/HarryPotter'' is a big source of EndingAversion is this trope, as it ends up being almost tooth-rottenly cheerful despite the many issues from the book that remain apparently intact. The House system at Hogwarts, which has been demonstrated many times in the very last book to be [[AbsurdlyDividedSchool needlessly divisive and enabling a toxic environment of tribalism]], hasn't changed one iota; the Malfoys are still around (and by extension, probably other Death Eaters as well); the {{Masquerade}} remains firmly in place; and even slavery of the House-Elves is still so accepted that Harry still has one. Add in [[InferredHolocaust the likely massive death toll]] from the events of the last book and the established low numbers of wizards in general, and it's not unlikely that wizards are heading towards extinction.
* ''Literature/TheirEyesWereWatchingGod'': So the great love of Janie's life is dead, she is socially stigmatized by her community, she had surrendered just about everything she had to be with her love, and now she returns to the place she had started from.

Top