TV Tropes Org

Forums

search forum titles
google site search
Total posts: [46]
1
2

Realistic Sword Gun design:

 1 Handsome Rob, Wed, 10th Apr '13 7:03:57 PM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
Or to be more precise, a plausible one.

One day, I may do a story where a character wields a shield in one hand, and while trying to decide whether to give them a gun(for a sort of riot cop appeal) or a sword(and make them more like a knight or roman centurion) it hit me:

Just do both. So now, Swordgun!!!

I think either something like The Cell delete gun used by Alphas from Zet Man, or The Wizar Sword-Gun used by Kamen Rider Wizard.

The latter seems like a good short sword, but is a little too big(I want it to be something you could put in a holster like a regular pistol), while the former is slightly preferred, but I'm not really sure if you could use it for all the things you regularly use swords for(like parrying and the like, or if you lose the shield and need to block).

The design has to avoid anything that would damage the gun part when using it as a sword as well.

Help a troper out with some ideas please.
 2 Madrugada, Wed, 10th Apr '13 7:58:15 PM Relationship Status: In season
Zzzzzzzzzz
If you want to be able to holster it like a pistol, you aren't going to be able to have a sword. A sword is simply too long for that. But knives and swords with pistol mechanisms and barrels have actually been made and used in the past. They never caught on, though because "instead of getting two weapons in one, one got a heavy pistol and a heavy, off-balance sword..."

edited 10th Apr '13 7:59:23 PM by Madrugada

'He strutted across the bedroom, his hard manhood pointing the way' sounds like he owns a badly named seeing-eye dog. 'Sit, Hard Manhood!
 3 Handsome Rob, Wed, 10th Apr '13 8:12:37 PM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
Hmm.

What if I used a little Applied Phlebotinum to fix the balance issues. Would that make it more possible?

I should note that both examples I used have the characters wearing Powered Armour of a sort(well, Kamen Rider Wizard is something else, but close enough), so maybe if my hypothetical warrior was wearing some kind of strength enhancing device to work around any balance problem.
 4 Major Tom, Wed, 10th Apr '13 8:38:21 PM Relationship Status: Barbecuing
Eye'm the cutest!
About the only way you fix the balance in a sword-gun is the barrel runs right through the center of the blade and the blade is gladius shaped. (The firing mechanism would be in the hilt and the hilt be sword-biased)

It would have to forgo sights, indeed magazine capacity greater than one shot a la shotgun canes, and the whole thing would have to be overengineered.

I mean yeah with today's technology (especially 3D printing but it could be done with metal casting) you could build a balanced sword-gun like that. It has however several problems. One it won't be as good as a properly built sword since you have to worry about the gun part and you'll lack a stabbing tip owing to the barrel location. Two it will be a terrible gun since it would be short ranged, only one shot and difficult to reload.

You might be better off with some kind of Schizo Tech sword bayonet attached to your Hand Cannon. That way you can have your swordfight and have a viable pistol. (Wouldn't be the first time a pistol has been mated to a sword bayonet.)
Endless Conflict: Every war ends in time, even supposedly this one.
On the topic of weight distribution, swords would frequently have their weight towards the business end of the blade to better facilitate slashing motions. Conversely, a gun wouldn't want the weight on the far end as it would be harder to aim or hold it steady. As such, the weight would be balanced towards the opposite end - by the hand. In which case, the sword wouldn't be very good at slashing and instead would need to be designed for stabbing motions in order to be useful and not just window dressing.
 
 6 Red Eyes Negro Dragon, Thu, 11th Apr '13 6:20:55 AM from straight outta Compton
OG
A rifle with a bayonet is the best swordgun.

 7 Khantalas, Thu, 11th Apr '13 6:24:53 AM from ((Not actually a creepy adorable little girl.))
Creepy adorable little girl
A rifle with a bayonet is not a sword gun, it's a polearm gun.
"Be mine, dear big brother."
 8 Major Tom, Thu, 11th Apr '13 6:44:11 AM Relationship Status: Barbecuing
Eye'm the cutest!
If the bayonet is bigger than the rifle and the rifle is compact carbine sized....
Endless Conflict: Every war ends in time, even supposedly this one.
 9 Khantalas, Thu, 11th Apr '13 6:45:41 AM from ((Not actually a creepy adorable little girl.))
Creepy adorable little girl
Even then, you have to use it like a spear rather than a sword, unless the carbine is really oddly shaped.
"Be mine, dear big brother."
 10 Red Eyes Negro Dragon, Thu, 11th Apr '13 7:12:54 AM from straight outta Compton
OG
Naw, it's still a swordgun.

Bayonet = Sword

Rifle = Gun

Bayonet + Rifle = Swordgun

edited 11th Apr '13 7:13:02 AM by RedEyesNegroDragon

 11 Khantalas, Thu, 11th Apr '13 7:15:17 AM from ((Not actually a creepy adorable little girl.))
Creepy adorable little girl
You can't swing a fixed bayonet around like a sword, though, because if you try, the "hilt" becomes the most unwieldy thing ever.
"Be mine, dear big brother."
 12 Major Tom, Thu, 11th Apr '13 7:15:51 AM Relationship Status: Barbecuing
Eye'm the cutest!
So I have a swordgun? My rifle has a bayonet. (It's of the spike type though...)
Endless Conflict: Every war ends in time, even supposedly this one.
 13 Red Eyes Negro Dragon, Thu, 11th Apr '13 7:26:41 AM from straight outta Compton
OG
@KHAAAAN Just because it can't be used like a convenient sword doesn't stop it from technically being one. Variants of the Zweihänder could be held and wielded like spears due to their length, but that didn't stop people from referring to them as swords.

@Major Major Indeed. Wield your gunblade with pride.

 14 Ars Thaumaturgis, Thu, 11th Apr '13 7:36:27 AM Relationship Status: I've been dreaming of True Love's Kiss
If you have magic or sufficiently advanced technology, you might get away with something along the lines of a "mass shifter" that rearranges the effective mass distribution without rearranging the actual physical structure of the device. The first squeeze of the trigger (or perhaps better the deactivation of the safety) flips a switch, pulling the mass backwards to balance the weapon for firing, while doing the opposite — releasing the trigger or activating the safety — sends it forwards to balance for sword-work.

(That said, I imagine that there would still be the potential issue of worrying about ruining your gun's barrel — or other workings, for that matter — in melee...)

 15 Handsomerob, Thu, 11th Apr '13 9:17:48 AM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
[up]

Yeah, sounds like I'll need some Phletbotinum to work around the issues.

For an alternate design, I was thinking of a Gun Baton(like a a police officer would use): The idea is similar to the sword, but a metal shaft comes out of the barrel, and acts as a stun baton to shock melee opponents. The head would be like a Silencer or muffler for the gun, or something else, and if the shaft gets bent, it can be disconnected.

How does that fly with you guys?
[up] What you're describing sounds a lot like Gun-Tonfas.

@Red Eyes: You can't call classify the bayonet as a sword since the "blade" is disproportionately shorter than its "handle" (the rest of the rifle). A rough guideline is that swords have blades that are longer than their handles while polearms have handles that are longer than their blades.

Moreover, the length of the bayonet would be too short to be considered a "sword"; its length being more in keeping with a "knife".

edited 11th Apr '13 11:26:47 AM by peasant

 
 17 Handsome Rob, Thu, 11th Apr '13 5:04:44 PM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
I don't really like Tonfa's (not sure why. As weapons go, they are really quite practical).

I was thinking more of an extendable baton type thing(that's also a Stun Baton, that's also a gun).
 18 Paktra, Tue, 3rd Dec '13 7:28:38 PM from C.U.P.S Relationship Status: I don't mind being locked in this eternal maze!
INSERT COIN
Why not include swords that use guns in the design instead? The original Gunblade of FF 8 was a complete sword with a solid blade, not barrel but what appears to be Compensator-like vents in the blade here to relieve the back pressure gasses when fired.

It is an one of the more plausible examples of VibroWeapons. Plus, avoids the issues... "lack a stabbing tip", "a heavy, off-balance sword", etc. simply by using blanks.

"Despite its name, it cannot be used as a gun, meaning it does not fire projectiles, and can therefore only be used in melee combat, making it more like a gun supplementing a sword than a blade supplementing a firearm, e.g. a bayonet on a rifle. The firing of the gunblade's rounds induces a tremor in the blade causing it to deal additional damage to whatever it strikes." -finalfantasywikia

edited 3rd Dec '13 9:33:12 PM by Paktra

 19 demarquis, Tue, 3rd Dec '13 7:46:25 PM from Hell, USA Relationship Status: Buried in snow, waiting for spring
Who Am I?
What about a gun in the handle that fires the blade as a projectile?
“Disobedience is the true foundation of liberty. The obedient must be slaves.”
 20 Paktra, Tue, 3rd Dec '13 7:56:40 PM from C.U.P.S Relationship Status: I don't mind being locked in this eternal maze!
INSERT COIN
[up]What you're referring to is a ballistic knife.

Although usually spring loaded, there have been gas powered and, I want to say, firearm versions as well... like the NRS-2. A knife with a bullet in the grip.

edited 3rd Dec '13 9:31:26 PM by Paktra

 21 Noaqiyeum, Wed, 4th Dec '13 12:01:38 PM from out of the night from pole to pole Relationship Status: Showing feelings of an almost human nature
the it-thingy
What about a sword (or long dagger) with a crossguard containing a gun barrel?
We dance around in a ring and suppose,
But the Secret sits in the middle and knows.
- Robert Frost
 22 Paktra, Wed, 4th Dec '13 12:32:24 PM from C.U.P.S Relationship Status: I don't mind being locked in this eternal maze!
INSERT COIN
[up] I will direct you to Cervantes de León, of Soul Caliber.

His Espada pistola de Nirvana 1, 2, and a real WWII-era "Katana Luger"

edited 4th Dec '13 12:36:42 PM by Paktra

 23 Handsome Rob, Wed, 4th Dec '13 4:02:02 PM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
[up]

Both of those are quite similar to Kamen Rider Gaim's Musou Saber.

I guess that's the most practical form of a Gun sword.

…. I still prefer the fold out version, even if it's not too logical a design.
 24 Paktra, Wed, 4th Dec '13 4:41:18 PM from C.U.P.S Relationship Status: I don't mind being locked in this eternal maze!
INSERT COIN
[up] True... mainly because its just a fully functional gun on a fully functional sword nothing more.

However, if your still looking for a folding, bladed firearm, I will mention the gun blades of Final Fantasy 13.

Being in a separate, futuristic continuity from the old-school revolvers of FF 8, they are capable of transforming from sword to plasma weapon in one smooth butterfly knife-like motion.

edited 4th Dec '13 4:43:38 PM by Paktra

 25 Handsome Rob, Wed, 4th Dec '13 5:12:06 PM from The lair of the Majestic 12
Wonderful to the GODDAMN future!!!
I never gave the Final Fantasy 13 gun blades much thought, but I must admit: they look pretty slick.
Total posts: 46
1
2


TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy