The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Yannow, we have an entire trope to explain why.

Anime.Mnemosyne has been flagged. It's very very not porn, though it does have more than a few explicit themes. The bigger question is whether the Really 700 Years Old little girl counts as pedopandering. Now, it has been a while since I watched it, but I only recall one brief scene in the third or fourth episode with her. The vast majority of the fanservice and explicit sex revolves around the twenty-something Rin.

Also, Series.Robin Hood and Evil Overlooker have been flagged. I'm assuming those are mistakes, but I'll leave them up for now so the mods can figure out who's doing it.

They are mistakes. Zap them. If they happen again, I'll take other measures.

Mnemosyne is very much not porn. It has a surprisingly in depth plot for something only 6 episodes long, and while there's some fanservice with Mimi, she's not drawn in a way that makes me think "underage" when I see her, and acts like an adult most of the time. Honestly, if it weren't for one offhand remark in the first episode, I wouldn't think she was underage at all.

edited 6th Jul '12 7:47:52 AM by NineThePuma

@ Catbert - my library has never been sane. It comes with being in a rapidly expanding small town that wants to embrace "culture" but isn't quite sure what they're doing on that front.

I think that Manga.Yumeiro Patissiere should be deleted for mixing young girls and Food Porn.

Judging by Google, the Food Porn accusation is true, but it's not cuttable, not even if it's Little Girl Food Porn as opposed to Little Girl Actual Porn.

Catbert's kidding. I'd frankly be shocked if anyone actually thought a story about a girl trying to become a great pastry chef was something that'd raise the attention of the media watchdogs.

Well, If she was used as the ingredients...

Well, you know, there was that basketball series that seemed so innocent...

To quote Wikipedia, in an effort to assuage your worries...

The manga won the 56th Shogakukan Manga Awards in the Children's category. [ 4 ]

edited 6th Jul '12 10:53:59 AM by Raidouthe21st

While we have gotten better about it there was still that time when Cupcakes had a long and serious discussion simply because it was called Torture Porn...

Everything here is done now.

@6845 Ojamajo Lime Pie: Virgin Night doesn't appear to have gone through the panel though. No sign of it in the voting tool or decisions thread anyway.

Looking at the history of the pages in Main and Manga (and specifically the timestamps), I think the page in Main was blanked/locked for a namespace move, not from a P5 decision. Which would make just getting rid of it violation of process.

On a related note, can someone give me an example of where the gushing is on the page? I'm starting to feel like people are using it to mean something entirely different than what the word means to me.

Actually, Main.Virgin Night was cut by Fast Eddie when he initially cut everything on the Hentai index. But he didn't cut any sub-pages, so some things on there like Virgin Night and Cool Devices which were namespaced but still listed with Main/ on the index just had their redirect cut and not the actual page.

edited 6th Jul '12 12:34:51 PM by KuroBaraHime

Huh. Well, sounds like it should still get an actual discussion and vote then.

Everything that got cut because of the policy change, but before the P5 was made and started voting on things, can be found on this page.

-Takes a look at the index of stuff-

Th-THAT GUY WITH THE GLASSES PORN? D8

-Walks to a corner to cry in despair-

edited 6th Jul '12 1:19:26 PM by Sachiko

...that's pretty mild in terms of RPF, honestly. Political RPF is INSANE. And thankfully has few references on this site.

What do you expect from a site that had a four part series where one guy rapes people and brags about it?

Let us hope that they never discover the Romney bot and Obama's Kenyan time machine.

Hey, guys, I'm back from my college interview an-

-reads Emeriin's post-

... Well, damn.

And rule 34 strikes again, and claimed Sachiko as its next victim.

Aaaaand I should have explained better. Spooning With Spoony (the series) is one of the rape jokes that makes fun of the rapist, in this case how smarmy he is, it's not gross or explicit in the slightest. It's just Ship Tease-y comedy.

edited 6th Jul '12 1:34:49 PM by emeriin

To Love Ru seems rather questionable (fanservice of a grade schooler, one character got so much fanservice in one of the media that it got a R18+ label). Should it be flagged?