YMMV / The Mask of Zorro

  • Anvilicious: Arguably, both films seem to carry a recurring trend that, when Zorro loses focus and starts thinking of his own gain or gratification, things go very wrong for him. (Significantly observable in the second film where everything turns around for Zorro after he prays for the strength to do what's right.)
  • Awesome Music: James Horner cuts loose with an outrageously fun, Latin-flavored score.
  • Complete Monster: Captain Harrison Love, the Psycho for Hire Dragon, keeps the dismembered body parts of Alejandro's brother pickled in alcohol, which he drinks "based on an Incan custom". When he learns Zorro has the means to expose Don Rafael's plan (buying California with stolen gold), he calmly suggests destroying the mine to hide evidence of the theft...with the slaves who did the mining still inside, "to destroy all the evidence".
  • Draco in Leather Pants: Don Rafael Montero gets this from the fans at times. By no means a one-dimensional villain, Montero does genuinely have a few positive traits despite being an otherwise ruthless villain. He's capable of fighting both Zorros on his own and isn't totally reliant upon his troops. Plus he genuinely does love Elena and tried to be as good of a father to her as possible, to the point he chastised Don Diego for thinking he would ever shoot her just to gain an advantage over him. And he does show a small hint of hesitation over blowing up all the workers in the mine. However a lot of fans have a tendency to take the few minor humanizing traits he has and exaggerate them to the point where they make Don Rafael out to be a loving father figure who would never harm Elena and deeply regrets the loss of innocent life. In the end, none of this detracts from the fact that he was willing to have multiple innocent people executed just to draw out Zorro. And it doesn't change the fact that he only became Elena's father because he fought the first Zorro in a duel that led to her mother's death in the first place and then took the baby Elena from Don Diego and had Don Diego put in prison for up to two decades, plus he had no problem pretending to be willing to shoot Elena to make Don Diego drop his weapon and leave him open for a fatal shot. And with regards to all the workers who slaved away in his mines, no matter how horrified he may have looked at Captain Love's suggestion to blow them all up, Don Rafael really had no qualms about enslaving those people and putting them into slave labor in the first place. Plus he outranked Captain Love to begin with and could have easily overridden his plan to kill all the workers but ultimately chose to go along with it in the span of only a few short seconds.
  • First Installment Wins: The Mask Of Zorro is a great film (Roger Ebert went so far to say it was one of the best Zorro films ever made), The Legend Of Zorro... not so much.
  • Fridge Logic: Did Diego know about Alejandro giving his daughter Elena a Shameful Strip when he decided to ship them together at the end?
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • Magnificent Bastard: Both Don Rafael and Don Diego.
  • Nightmare Fuel: There's something really unsettling about Joaquin Murrieta's head floating in a jar of wine, particularly the eyes, staring away blankly.
  • Signature Scene: Zorro using his sword to render Elena topless.
  • Tear Jerker: The finale of the prologue, as Don Diego loses everything he cared for: His wife gunned down in front of him, his child taken to be raised by his Arch-Enemy, his home burned to the ground, and his freedom.
    Diego: Rafael!! You'll never be rid of me! Rafael!!!!