Nightmare Fuel: Platypus Comix
- Imagine being a comic book character like the ones in "True Believers", living under the beck and call of editors who can change your life to suit their twisted whims, without a care for your personal happiness. Peter Parker even tells Mary Jane that he considers this scarier than anything the Rogues Gallery can pull.
- The Mulberry comic "Heiress A Parent" gets pretty scary once one of the wards becomes corrupted strongly enough to try and kill Mulberry and her friends For the Evulz.
- The last two pages of "Vess MacMeal Starring in: The More You Know!"
- In Free Spirit, one can kill a witch by trapping her in a mirror, then shattering it.
- The Big Creepy-Crawlies from the Free Spirit comic "Bedbugs and Broomsticks", as seen for the first time here.
- From the Free Spirit comic "Junkyard Stories", the ending of the story about the bowl. Mr. Wu's boss, and some of his co-workers, electrocute themselves to death with a malfunctioning server. Mr. Wu proceeds to declare himself the new boss, which surprisingly doesn't prompt any of the surviving employees to ask what happened to their old one.
- Scariest Corporate Logos.
- "It Came From the Public Domain" includes some off-model covers of animation compilation videos produced by third-party distributors.
- Walt Disney: One Man's Nightmare, a review of an unusual TV biography of Walt Disney, features the sight of Ben Vereen dancing with Disney characters for five minutes!
- The smile of the guy in this ABC Afterschool Special ad.
- The expression Jasmine makes in this still◊ from one of the Disney Princess shorts reviewed in "When Disney Magic Goes Wrong: The New Adventures of Aurora and Jasmine" reportedly creeped out Peter.
- One of the commercials Peter sourced from a 1979 recording of Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer features the Invisible Man breaking into someone's house to endorse Scotch tape.
- When asked in "My Ocarina in Time Walkthrough" what the Great Fairies from The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time look like, Peter answers, "Like the mother-in-law of your nightmares." Later in the walkthrough, Peter admits a fear of the Wallmasters, who can appear unexpectedly and drag Link all the way back to the beginning of the temple.
- The "Dark TV Vault" review of Free Spirit warns word-for-word that Franc Luz, the actor who played Thomas Harper, can cause this.
- The "Concept Unification" process used to create the animatronic character bands at Chuck E. Cheese restaurants shortly after they merged with Showtime Pizza. The skins of the old Rock-Afire Explosion characters are removed piece by piece, slowly stripping each of the mechanical skeletons of their personalities, and replaced with completely new, completely different Chuck E. Cheese character skins. Not helped at all by the depressing muzak and deadpan monotone narrator, the fact that Chuck E. himself used to be two characters (Rolfe the ventriloquist wolf and his sentient Muppet Earl), and the fact that a dog character named Dook is turned into a creepy cartoon chef.