: I would like to remedy that situation. Spock
: If you believe I have acted irregularly, then relieve me of duty. That is your prerogative as medical officer of this ship.
You're The Leader
, the Reasonable Authority Figure
, The Captain
, The Emperor
! You rule a world, a galaxy
, a dimension
, multiple universes
! Everyone obeys you
! Even if you do have a cold, or a broken arm! So who is this man who dares to order you about? And act huffy when you don't obey in haste?
Well, he's your doctor. By which we mean, he is that kind of doctor.
Unless, of course, he's the healer
, the midwife, the nurse, The Medic
, or any other member of the healing profession. And he is quite certain that you must obey The Doctor's Orders
No matter what exalted position their patients hold, and what power the patient has over the doctor in non-medical matters, in their field of expertise, doctors are adamant that they are in charge. This does not mean that the patient will actually obey — even the Reasonable Authority Figure
may defy him for reasons of state — but the doctor will regard it as being a bad patient, not their exercising rightful authority.
Can also apply when the figure gives orders about a third party, the doctor's patient.
Rule of Drama
dictates it will be most often seen when the patient does not want to obey, as when a character chooses to Pull the I.V.
, brush aside the ineffectual medic stuttering "You Can Barely Stand
!" and get back to business
. Alternately, a doctor may invoke this trope in a less serious context, to order their friend to take some time off or enjoy themselves
Not to be confused with the Star Trek
novel, Doctor's Orders
, although the title is a pun on this trope.
open/close all folders
- In Doctor Strange: The Oath, another physician pulls this on Strange a few times. Justified since he's genuinely injured; though if he hadn't been somewhat taken with her he probably wouldn't have listened.
- Whenever a member of the Bat-clan gets sick or injured enough that they need rest, Alfred will make sure their fool-asses stay in bed so they can heal properly.
- This is the premise of Analyze This: a mob boss needs a psychiatrist, who has trouble helping him because he's afraid to assert himself.
- In John C. Wright's Count To A Trillion, Menelaus can talk casually with the effective ruler of Earth. When he must be examined by a doctor, he finds it much harder to assert himself.
- In Harry Potter, Madam Pomfrey asserted herself quite strongly in The Prisoner of Azkaban when authority figures wanted to speak to students in her care. And in Half-Blood Prince told Harry, who wanted to beat the crap out of the student who put him in the hospital wing, that it would qualify as over exerting himself and to stay there.
- Later, Dumbledore averts this trope when he instead goes to the more trustworthy Snape because Snape is better at curse-related magical injuries.
- Zig-Zagged in Artemis Fowl: The Corrupt Corporate Executive's doctors are very much aware of his Mafia connections, so they give medical advice very politely. In fact, when he sends his secretary out for celebratory cigars, she invokes this trope by trying to remind him of what the doctors said before remembering who she's talking to.
- Happens all the time in Mercedes Lackey's Heralds of Valdemar series. Healers commands are more or less absolute.
- There are so many times in Warrior Cats when the medicine cat says "As your medicine cat, I'm ordering you to rest" or something along those lines - even when the cat they're ordering around is their Clan leader and older than them.
- In Jack Campbell's The Lost Fleet novel Invincible, Geary orders a day of rest despite many urgent needs, because exhaustion is hampering their work efforts. He suspects that a doctor who speaks to him hasn't slept for days, including that one, and thinks of how doctors take their oaths more seriously than they do their positions as officers.
- In Dan Abnett's Gaunt's Ghosts novel His Last Command, Dorden strenously resists Gaunt's orders to revive Mkoll, though he gives up in the end.
- In Jim Butcher's The Dresden Files novel Cold Days, Butters gives them to Harry, who takes them more seriously than he usually takes orders, but not seriously enough for Butters's taste.
- In Seanan McGuire's October Daye novels
- A Local Habitation, when Toby threatens Quentin during her After-Action Patchup, Quentin cheerfully says that Gordan won't let her get up; Gordan agrees.
- Ashes Of Honor, Jin tries to force Tybalt not to stand after the After-Action Healing Drama. When that fails, she asks him to at least try to take it easy the next few days, and he says he will bow to her wisdom. She is pleasantly surprised.
- Chimes At Midnight: Jin succeeds in ordering Sylvester out of Toby's sickroom. When Toby wakes up, she is less successful about keeping her in bed.
- In J. R. R. Tolkien's Return of the King, Faramir tells Éowyn that even if he had assumed his authority as Steward, he would be reluctant to override that of the Warden of the Houses of Healing in the matter of her health.
- In Julie Kagawa's The Iron Daughter, the nurse treats Ash's getting up after she treated his wounds as Youth Is Wasted on the Dumb. When Puck laughs, she turns on him and demands to stitch his wounds.
- In Richard Ellis Preston Jr.'s Chronicles Of The Pneumatic Zeppelin novel Romulus Buckle & the Engines of War, Romulus tells Max, while treating her injuries that she disobeyed him as her captain, but now that he's her surgeon, she has to obey him.
Live Action TV
- Comes up sometimes in Star Trek, where the ship's doctor has the authority to relieve the captain of command if the doctor believes the captain is physically or mentally unfit for duty.
- Such as in the Star Trek: The Original Series episode "The Tholian Web", where Spock tells Bones to do it if he believes it proper.
- In Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, it's also pointed out that not even the commanding officer of a ship or station has the power to override the judgment of the Chief Medical Officer regarding medical matters.
- For Star Trek: Voyager an additional wrinkle was thrown in: due to personnel losses in the first episode, the ship's doctor is a hologram. As such, the captain could just shut him down if she doesn't want to follow his orders — or even reprogram him, as happened to his counterpart on the Equinox. The problem, as touched upon in one episode that didn't actually happen in the end is that while Janeway usually is sane enough to keep her rebellions against doctor's order to small things like dragging her feet about having check-ups, there's nothing saying that will still be the case when she is unhealthy enough that she should be relieved of command.
- Doc Martin is routinely frustrated by patients ignoring his advice and doing what they want. One woman nearly killed herself trying to function with a herniated vertebra.
- Comes up on Merlin. Gaius is one of the few people who can often give Uther direction without getting in trouble, although Uther still tends to yell a lot. Granted,his advice has gone outside the medical realm a few times, again mostly to Uther telling him to get lost.
- A plot point in the Horatio Hornblower Made-for-TV Movie Mutiny involved the officers of the HMS Renown having to convince the ship's doctor to declare Captain Sawyer medically unfit to command due to his slipping sanity. Further complicating the issue was the fact that the doctor and Sawyer were longtime friends.
- Medical doctors in the Stargate Verse (especially Dr. Fraiser) are often given special dispensation to overrule high-ranking military officials on medical matters. As it turns out, Janet Fraiser outranks Hammond on matters medical, much to O'Neill's displeasure.
- Invoked in Firefly. When Jayne tries to make a power play when Mal and Zoe get themselves (possibly) caught by the Feds, nobody wants to go along with it, but they're not strong enough to stop him. Then he starts talking nonsense and falls flat on his face. Turns out that Doctor Tam, when giving him a painkiller for a gunshot wound, gave him considerably more than was necessary to stop him from doing anything. Ironically, he only gave Jayne the painkillers because Jayne ordered him to.
- Doc Cochrane of Deadwood, the surly Frontier Dr. Jerk and one of the few people in camp who can shout Al Swearengen down. One review of the show noted that in a town full of Knife Nuts vying for supremacy, being the only person who can treat a stab wound gives him a kind of power all of its own.
- In Dorothy L. Sayers's radio play The Man Born To Be King, she put notes down for King Herod's physician: he must speak with authority, even though he's giving those orders to the king.
- Surprisingly, inverted in many places for much of history. As James Burke explains on The Day the Universe Changed, in 18th-century France (and other places), doctors were expensive, and so if you were rich enough to afford one you would tell him your symptoms, and then he would match symptoms to a list of treatments, and you would choose which of those you wanted yourself. When Benjamin Franklin showed up in 1778 with tales of Philadelphia's modern public health system (arguably the best in the world at the time), in which healthcare was available to all for a reasonable fee and the good citizens (the shock!) did what the doctor told them rather than the other way 'round, the intellectuals of the Paris salons were intrigued.
- The History Channel documentary It's Good To Be The President devoted a good ten or so minutes to the topic of how the leader of the free world is kept in optimal health. During an interview with the Presidential Physician, the narrator/interviewer asks what standard operating procedure is when the President openly defies Doctor's Orders. The doctor gives a smile somewhere between coy and wry before he quips, "In such circumstances it is the medical professional's duty to appeal to a higher power over the patient," Beat. "so in that case we advise the First Lady."