"Hobo Phoenix" is actually to Wright what "Godot" was to Diego Armando, if you think about it: Both men are lovers of different drinks (Godot/Diego's coffee; Phoenix's grape juice) who were utterly ruined by complete Sociopaths (Godot/Diego by Dahlia Hawthorne; Phoenix by Kristoph Gavin), spent roughly a half-decade in obscurity (Godot/Diego in a coma; Phoenix as a poker-player), started wearing special headgear (Godot/Diego's sight-aiding visor; Phoenix's Spy Cam hat), got fed up and decided to become vigilantes of sorts (Godot/Diego with his The Heavy role in the 3-5; Phoenix with his sudden Anti-Hero methods in both 4-1 and 4-4), and then finally found some eventual peace (Godot/Diego ultimately being a Graceful Loser; Phoenix ultimately deciding to become a defense attorney again).
At first glance, Kristoph's attempts to sabotage Apollo and Phoenix's case during "Turnabout Succession" just seem like an Evil Is Petty way of getting the last laugh after his original conviction at the end of "Turnabout Trump". However, if you think about it, he still has plenty to lose pragmatically as well: He essentially Might as Well Not Be in Prison at All thanks to both his many in-prison perks (such as his Luxury Prison Suite) and his mentioned connections (it's made clear that the legal community still respects him, albeit as a "good lawyer who simply snapped one day"), not to mention how it's revealed in more than one game that killers in this series don't always get death row (though multiple murders under your belt are almost assuredly a way to make yourself much more eligible), and a second conviction would probably ruin all of that for him.
Also, his first conviction would be for second-degree murder, while the poisoning would arguably be first-degree. Since the death penalty is tossed around in the Ace Attorney series, it's possible that a more serious conviction would change his sentence from prison to death.
"A lawyer is someone who smiles no matter how bad it gets." A running theme throughout the Phoenix arc. Now take a look at Nick's portrait animations. The majority of the time, he's smiling. "The only time a lawyer can cry is when it's all over." At the end of the game, it's very clear that even though he lost his badge, Nick never gave up. He was still fighting in other ways. Not once did he ever acknowledge that it was "all over". Despite what he says, it seems that he's still an attorney at heart...
When you see speak to Nick throughout the game, he seems to have changed greatly in the last seven years. However, when you see things from his perspective in the final case, it's clear that he hasn't changed that much at all. And then it hits you. He's been playing poker for seven years, so he must have developed an incredible poker face. He even expresses surprise when Zak says he can't tell if Nick is serious or joking, which seems to imply that even he doesn't realize how good he's gotten with it.
Trucy's name: break it apart and you get "True See". Now, what can she do in the game again? She can tell when people are lying, to a certain degree.
Two things, both to do with the first poker game between Zak Gramarye and Phoenix Wright. At first, I asked how Phoenix could beat such a seasoned player, who had previously only lost to someone who literally had a super-power that allowed him to pierce through others' lies... and then I remembered how Nick wings his way through every trial he's ever been involved in. He's a master of bluffing, and that's how he won. -Anomaly
Secondly, the question of why Zak tests people in such a way in the first place. Then it finally hit me, just a little before Apollo said it outright: it's not whether his opponent won or lost, but how they played the game. Their play style gave Zak a way to get their measure.
On top of that, Zak makes a point of mentioning that he's only ever lost twice now; once to Phoenix, and the other time to his mentor. This simple fact mirrors Phoenix's own situation: he's only ever lost two cases, once to Edgeworth, the reason why Phoenix became an attorney to begin with, and the other time was this same case with Zak. End result: Zak disappears and Phoenix is disbarred. Both men faced their second defeat ever on account of each other, with disastrous results for them both.
The ending of the last case when Kristoph is found guilty only due to the jury system being introduced may seem like a giant Ass Pull from a Western perspective. But that changes completely when put in the context of what was happening to the Japanese legal system at the time. Japan made the decision to introduce a jury system in 2004. The last time juries had been used in Japan was 1943. The system was set to go into effect in 2009. However, in the lead up to the introduction of the jury system, many Japanese citizens expressed concerns about the wisdom of the jury system with 80% of Japanese citizens "dreading the change and [not wanting] to serve as jurors." Apollo Justice came out in Japan in 2007 in the middle of an all-out PR blitz by the Japanese government to get people to accept the jury system. And in that last case you know Kristoph is guilty but you just can't prove it! The villian is going to get away with murder! But what's this? The jury system sweeps in to save the day! The jury system succeeded where the old system couldn't! All glory to the jury system! In other words, the entire ending of the game, and, for that matter, the purpose of the game is to serve as pro-jury system propaganda.
On the other hand, the strength of the jury comes from its weakness of relying on emotional anecdotes rather than proof. Phoenix picked the perfect case to take advantage of what could potentially have been a disadvantage for the defense in some types of cases.
On yet another hand, the jury not requiring as much proof as the Judge may seem like a disadvantage, but remember, that's to convict a witness. The Judge's standards of evidence to convict a defendant are much lower than, say, a sane normal person who can tell things don't make sense. Thus, until the police start arresting actual murderers, the Jury System will make the defense's job much much easier.
For that matter, this troper found the third case extremely frustrating. It was blindingly obvious that Daryan Crescend was the murderer, but because just the right evidence wasn't on hand, it took forever to pin him down. Then, she realized that it was deliberately like that. The trial was made to make extremely clear just how flawed the current system is, and how the Jury System is much better! Just think, had the Jury System been in effect, the jurists could have figured out Daryan was the murderer just as quickly as the player did and, unlike with the current legal system, they could have him arrested without decisive evidence.
Actually, the revelation of the Jurist System (TM) wasn't all that much of an Ass Pull to begin with. While we can argue about themes and whether or not the Jurist System (TM) was actually better than what they had before, the idea that the System (TM) purely as a plot device came out of nowhere is, in itself, ridiculous- it received a great deal of foreshadowing, with Phoenix's secret mission that he was often away on during the game, and it was outright stated many a time during the final case that it was being watched by a jury- it was no big secret that came out of nowhere to save the day, it was well-established from the beginning. While everything else still stands, the idea that the Jurist System (TM) was ever an Ass Pull to begin with.... doesn't.
Heck, there's foreshadowing of this sort of thing way back in the second trial of the first game: The only reason Phoenix was able to continue cross examining Redd White, in spite of him owning the Judge, was the gallery, i.e. a group of normal individuals with no stake in what's going on, armed only with common sense.
Phoenix's involvement with the Misham case goes much further than his disbarment. Kristoph poisoned and betrayed Drew (by sending him the kiss of death under the guise of monetary reward). Due to his experiences with Dahlia Hawthorne, Nick can't forgive people who are cowardly enough to use those tactics - and, given that Kristoph tried to kill two neurotic agoraphobes and tried to make it look like a murder-suicide, Nick likely considers him the epitome of dirty cowardice. No wonder he spent seven years looking into it - the whole thing is personal in many levels.
Not long after the game's initial release, there was some complaining about how cocky and out of character Phoenix seemed to be during the flashback case in 4-4. But the fact is, he had every right to be. Phoenix had just beaten both Dahlia Hawthorne and Godot and had finally surpassed his mentor in the process. In other words, he had just closed the book on basically every piece of unfinished business in his entire life. Plus, for the first time, he was the one up against a newbie. Sure, Godot had technically never prosecuted before, but he had already been set up as being a challenging opponent by Luke Atmey, and he also had years of experience being a defense attorney under his belt. In contrast, Klavier was a rock star who randomly decided to become a prosecutor. No experience, no reputation, no grudge against Wright... it was natural for Phoenix to be feeling good about himself during the trial. Of course, that just made the whole diary page debacle that much more depressing. To be fair, said complaining has essentially ceased, possibly because people came to a similar conclusion.
In addition, only a prosecutor who is really searching for the truth could ever defeat Phoenix Wright in court... and unlike Payne, Edgeworth, the Von Karmas or Godot when Wright initially faced them, Klavier Gavin began his career as a prosecutor searching for the truth. It only makes sense for Wright's ultimate defeat to be from a prosecutor such as him. The only other time when Wright had been defeated in court was by Edgeworth who had chosen to become a prosecutor who wanted to search for the truth.
Meanwhile, the real mastermind behind Phoenix' disbarment was a fellow defense attorney. It probably never occured to Nick that there might be someone just as bad as Manfred von Karma on his side of the court, so Kristoph backstabbing him must have come as a complete blindside.
Further, the hero being exceptionally able at one thing, developing hubris, and it all bringing his downfall is one of the oldest tropes in the book. It's Greek Tragedy 101.
And even with all that in mind, Phoenix being cocky actually...isn't that out of character. In the original trilogy, his internal monologue is incredibly sarcastic and derisive towards just about everyone he meets - not even Mia is immune to his sass at times! There are three reasons why his attitude doesn't come across as cocky in previous games. One, he's always, always the underdog, so when he does get to celebrate, it feels as if he's earned it. Two, as the underdog, he also has fewer opportunities to gloat - but make no mistake that he takes them when he gets them (remember the case in the first game where he calls himself "Sherlock Holmes II?"). And three, he's the perspective character, so his triumphant statements match up with the feelings of the player; but in Apollo Justice, the player knows, going into the trial, that Phoenix will make a mistake that will get him disbarred.
They probably brought back the "poisoned coffee" thing from Trials and Tribulations so that you'd be surprised when they put a new twist on it where it wasn't the coffee that was poisoned.
Guy Eldoon's blond hair looks like noodles. The fact that his eyebrows are black foreshadows the fact that the blond hair isn't real.
I thought his eyebrows were supposed to look like strips of nori you get in a bowl of ramen, to continue the noodle theme.
During the first day of the last trial, Vera keeps staring at Klavier. Trucy thinks that it's because Klavier is handsome, but the real reason is that Klavier looks like "the Devil" who gave her the diary page forging job. This is actually similar to what happens when Apollo meets Klavier and Klavier thinks Apollo is checking him out.
Vera might have a touch of the 'power', since it's never explained why she called her client "the Devil" when their only meeting consisted of them bonding over Troupe Gramarye and her good luck charm. Maybe she saw the tiny skull face tell on the back of his hand?
Around that same time, Klavier starts sweating bullets when he hears that there was a request for evidence forgery around the time the 7 year old letter was received and that Vera likes Troupe Gramarye. He asks to know what, exactly, the request was. This is because he suspects that it was the piece of forged evidence he remembers from 7 years ago in a case involving Troupe Gramarye.
Symbolic name that isn't immediately obvious: Misham contains the word "sham."
"My sham", no less.
Vera and Drew Misham. "Vera drew my sham."
Some fans tend to make fun of the name Apollo for the title character and even I had thought it a bit over the top until I read the Oresteia, an ancient Greek play wherein the character Orestes is defended in the first ever court presided over by the goddess Athena and defended by, you guessed it, the god Apollo who won the case and earned himself the title, god of justice among other things. For the ancient Athenians, this made the god Apollo the first ever defense attorney. And suddenly the name Apollo Justice becomes a brilliant, high-brow wink to the well-read gamer.
Not only was Apollo the first defense attorney, but the first defense attorney ever with a jury system. And the crime Apollo defends Orestes for? A child's murder of a parent.
And on the Japanese side, too: Apollo's Japanese name, 'Odoroki Housuke' is one of the worst, most unnatural sounding puns in the Japanese versions of the games- until you realize something. Apollo is an orphan, most likely even a doorstep baby, given his last name... So Apollo Justice/Odoroki Housuke might not even be his real name. No wonder it sounds unnatural.
In fact...considering the fact that Apollo, right out of the gate, starts making ridiculous Justice puns like "here comes Justice"...does that mean he picked his last name himself? Is there such a thing as Fridge Hilarity?
Actually when you think about it Phoenix is a pretty odd name too, but we all know in the rejuvenating sunlight a phoenix will rise from its ashes, in this particular case that Phoenix needed the help of the sun god Apollo.
When you listen to it closely, the prologue song and the song for Drew Studio sound a lot like each other. If you think about it, this make sense. The beginning opens with (probably) Drew (or Vera) drawing the scene of Phoenix playing cards with Shadi. In case 4-4 you actually find out that Drew (again, or Vera) actually had drawn that scene. Listen to this first and then this and you will hear what this troper means.
Case three involves an item that can be used to create a never named deadly poison, and then case four comes along revolving around a "rare and hard to get" poison.
Said poison has an incredibly small lethal dosage, works on a delay of about fifteen minutes, and the judge mentioned the very strict over enforcement of it is because it was used in some truly horrifying cases a number of years ago. Atroquinine is the poison used in the Dahlia Hawthorne cases.
At the end of the last case, Vera Misham surviving being poisoned by a super-deadly poison that nobody has ever survived exposure to before seems like a 'And then everything was perfect' sort of Deus ex Machina ending, especially considering that she wasn't exactly a picture of good health to begin with... until you realize a vital detail: She's spend the last 7 years wearing poison-infused nail-polish. Even though she didn't start biting her nails until she went to court, microscopic amounts of it would have been absorbed through her pores, and for a poison that potent, microscopic amounts count for a lot. Thus, following in the footsteps of the Dread Pirate Roberts, she's built up a resistance to that particular poison - not an immunity, but just enough so that when she's finally directly exposed to it, she can survive.
Even then, it would likely be a 50-50 chance of survival - in the bad ending, her condition worsens from the poison and she died the next day.
During the last case, Zak ripping the real diary page and keeping it from Phoenix at first seems completely idiotic, since it puts him on the run (not the best position to help Trucy). But then you realize that Zak didn't know Magnifi had comitted suicide—with that page in place, it points to Valant as the murderer. So he inadvertently got Phoenix disbarred to protect his partner.
At first, this troper was confused as to why Kristoph didn't admit to murdering Drew Misham, even though he was already charged with murdering Shadi Smith. But, as has been implied throughout the series, first-degree murder warrants the death penalty, and probably nothing else. The murder of Shadi Smith was second-degree, meaning that he would be in his fabulous jail room forever. But the murder of Drew Misham was premeditated, just intended for seven years earlier, meaning he could get the death penalty.
Personally I always thought it was because, had Kristoph actually admitted to the Drew's murder, he'd be simultaneously be admitting to first-degree murder, another attempted murder via Vera's poisoned nail polish, making a request for forged evidence, and pulling the strings behind Wright's disbarment. It wasn't that he was afraid of being charged with the death penalty. He was afraid of being revealed as a fraud and at the same time clearing Wright's name and revealing that he had intentionally ruined him.
Trucy and Maya have a deeper connection than simply being young Genki Girl assistants: Both of them have a parent that went into hiding after a big court case. Said parents came back under a different alias for reasons benefiting their children, only to die afterward. Also, both of them have an older sibling that became a defense attorney.
In Turnabout Trump, Kristoph mocks Phoenix when Phoenix speculates a fourth person was in on the crime scene (other than Phoenix, Shadi Smith, and Olga Orly). Naturally, Phoenix is correct. This also happened in the DL-6 incident in which Yanni Yogi was accused as the murderer of Gregory Edgeworth (the only other suspect being a young Miles Edgeworth), in which case the real criminal, Manfred von Karma, did not arrive on the scene and commit the murder until later. While it's probably a coincidence, Turnabout Good-Byes, in which the DL-6 incident is featured, is considered to be case "1-4". Turnabout Trump is case "4-1".
Apollo's Chords of Steel are actually kind of a smart little character trait, once you realize they're probably genetic; his mother's a famous singer, so she's got a powerful voice too. This also explains why Apollo prefers Lamiroir's performances to the Gavinners - this troper can't quite recall, but doesn't he even call her music "nostalgic" at one point?
Have you ever counted how many cases Phoenix worked before getting disbarred? Including Rise from the Ashes, you have five in the first game, four in the second, and taking out Mia's two cases in the third game you have three. Factor in the Gramarye case that got him disbarred and you have five, then add four to get nine, then three is twelve plus one? You get thirteen.
!Objection! Case 1-4 and Case 3-2 actually featured two trials for two separate crimes. *slams desk* Therefore the Apollo Justice case was really Phoenix's fifteenth case!
Not sure if this goes under Brilliance or Logic, but when Kristoph ordered the forgery, it was well before the poker game. There was a letter sent to the Mishams about how Kristoph deposited $100,000 in their account to buy the forgery. Zak plays poker with Kristoph, Kristoph loses. Kristoph has suddenly wasted $100,000 on a man he can no longer represent. While money was never brought up as a motive, I know I'd be enraged if I lost out on a $100K bet. This troper has NEVER seen the money he lost discussed. A lot of people say that Kristoph is incredibly petty for killing someone over a card game, but this troper believes part of the motive had to do with wasting money on something he couldn't return or get any true use out of.
In the first case, Apollo gets from Phoenix through Trucy a forged piece of evidence to get Kristoph convicted. In the fourth case, we find out that, seven years ago, Phoenix got from Kristoph through Trucy a forged piece of evidence that would have the former disbarred. A message from Phoenix telling Kristoph that he's found out everything, perhaps?
Practically confirmed by Kristoph flat-out asking, "Is... this your idea of revenge, Phoenix Wright? Revenge for the events that took away your attorney's badge seven years ago!" at the end.
Usually, the final case of an Ace Attorney game has a different prosecutor than the mid-cases at some point, so at first, it seemed odd that Klavier prosecuted Turnabout Succession. It actually makes sense, since usually, the final prosecutor is meant to be tied to the story, and with Kristoph as the killer in the case, who would be better to be involved in the trial than his brother?
Klavier is regarded as one of the more helpful prosecutors when he's up against Apollo, but one has to remember that he wasn't that way when up against Phoenix. He was given the knowledge of the forged diary page, but spent seven years wondering about the why and especially how Kristoph had known about it. After seeing what the aftermath of the trial did to Phoenix, he spent the time focusing on his band and didn't prosecute another case that whole time until 4-2, where he outright told Alita Tiala that he was on the side of truth and not her. Klavier's Character Development happened offscreen during those seven years.
Actually, that is pretty much exactly what happened. As you can see, Magnifi was very much a Jerkass.
Now this troper has asked themselves the question why Thalassa Gramarye gave up her son, Apollo Justice in the first place, but then I realized: If you compare Lamiroir's and Apollo's ages from their profiles, they are listed as 40 and 22 respectively- Which means that Thalassa had him when she was 18 years old. I believe it was stated that she left Troupe Gramarye to marry another performer, but he died a year after Apollo was born. Now imagine being 19 years old with a 1 year-old child, with no way to support it (as she can't perform and watch over him at the same time). Now from what we've seen of Magnifi, he probably wasn't too thrilled that his daughter ran off with someone else and had a child and would have refused to support Apollo, leaving Thalassa with no choice but to leave him at an orphanage. "But why was it different with Trucy?", you might ask. The things is, Zak was part of Troupe Gramarye. Magnifi approved of him as he was his favourite apprentice and when his daughter and his preferred apprentice married and had a daughter, of course he would have no objections as Trucy would be born into the Troupe with parents that he himself "chose", which I think would be realistic considering his manipulative behaviour.
Spirit of Justice finally answers this point: Apollo, Thalassa and her husband were on Khura'in during one of the latter's music exhibitions. However, a fire was started, which not only killed Apollo's father, but also ensued such chaos that Thalassa accidentally lost Apollo, and never found him before returning to the Troupe. Magnifi had nothing to do with it.
With the third case: the victim, Mr. Le Touse was shot during the second set, but Apollo and Ema don't find him until the third set of the concert. The Fridge Horror part comes when Apollo finds him alive. That means Le Touse was there, lying on the floor bleeding to death for that entire time. Also consider, what if Apollo and Ema had found him earlier? They may have found a way to save him before he died...
Crosses over with Fridge Tearjerker: At one point, Machi confesses that he turned to crime because he needed a lot of money, but wouldn't say for what. Given the kind of person he is, it would have been most likely to help pay for Lamiroir's eye treatment.
Then there's the fact that since Machi committed a crime punishable by death in his home country, he can never go home.
Not nessesarily. This troper believes it's reasonable to assume that Borginia has laws that forbid delivering two separate punishments for the same crime, like most modern real-life countries do. So, if Machi gets punished by USA's legal system for smuggling the cocoon, it would probably be illegal for Borginian law system to also punish him. If this troper remembers correctly, something like this is actually implied in the game.
Retroactive Fridge Horror occurs after playing Duel Destinies when you discover black psyche-locks are hide secrets so deeply entrenched in a person's heart that the person themselves don't even remember or realize they're lying. Considering Phoenix never actually breaks Kristoph's black psyche locks, it makes you wonder exactly what horrid psychological experience Kristoph underwent to drive him to murder Zak Gramarye and go so far to punish Phoenix, just because Phoenix got chosen as Zak's lawyer over Kristoph. Clearly there's more to it than what's revealed in this game.
He's just a petty little baby whose ego was hurt. That's his reason why he did all that.
If his wounded ego was really the cause of those black Psyche Locks — which indicate a secret so deeply carved into a person's self that the locks, if broken, can actually cause harm to the person's soul and/or heart — then that's even more Fridge Horror: It means there is absolutely nothing and no one in all the world more important to Kristoph than his own pride. And this man was a defense attorney! With a younger brother who clearly loved him!
There is another explanation for the psyche lock. Given Capcom's few retcons in the AA series, there may have been a different (and more darker) reason than having a traumatic psychological experience. The black psyche locks could represent the darkness, anger and evil that resides in Kristoph's heart. Vera called Kristoph a devil for a very good reason. It was more than just his ego that was hurt that day, he felt humiliated and reviled to be rejected by a client (over a game of cards no less) and having been replaced by the renowned attorney Phoenix Wright. (He could hold a severe envy of Wright.) The trial of Zak Gramarye was said to be the most important trial ever revolving around the famous Gramarye troupe and any who'd defend them would warrant quite the publicity. Kristoph was denied his pride, his fame (and fortune) that he harbored such a resentment against Zak and Wright. Though its debated, Kristoph would had used forged evidence to win him the trial (hence maybe why Zak rejected him in the first place because he could have cheated) against his OWN BROTHER KLAVIER! Coupled with his anger, he also grew paranoid, he's been stalking every single person who has ever been on that case because there was a high probability someone would find the truth. He found Zak after 7 years under the name of Shadi Smith and as stated above, he awaited for the right opportunity to murder him considering Zak was gone for 7 years. He even planned to kill Vera by poisoning since she originally made the forgery and knew Kristoph. Its scary how far Kristoph would go so far to cover everything up. It shows you what kind of an evil person he is.
After you learn just how evil Kristoph Gavin really is, one pops up in Chapter One: Kristoph was trying to set up Olga Orly for the murder. If Phoenix hadn't joined in and the case continued uninterrupted, there is a very good chance Orly would have gotten a Guilty verdict and possibly a death sentence for a crime she didn't commit.
Further Fridge Horror kicks in when you realize this, and then wonder if Kristoph Gavin had done things like this in his own trials before. It would not be out of character for him at all.