There's nothing beyond there.Dogville
is a minimalist drama directed by Lars von Trier
and starring, among others, Nicole Kidman
, Paul Bettany and Lauren Bacall
. It's based on the poem "Jenny die Seeräuberbraut" ("Pirate Jenny
" or "The Black Freighter") from Bertolt Brecht
's The Threepenny Opera
. It's also inspired, in part, by Friedrich Dürrenmatt's play The Visit
. It is very, very
hard to watch, and not for kids
, despite getting a 12+ rating in some countries.
The story focuses around Grace, a woman running from The Mafia
, who hides in nearby Dogville and is found by Thomas Edison, Junior (no relation). Tom presents her to the townsfolk of Dogville who, at first, are reluctant to take care of her and accept her favors, but as time passes, they are more than willing to have Grace to do all the work around town. And all the... work
The film is notorious for being shot in one sound stage, with the sets drawn on the floor and only a bare minimum of props visible. The minimalist aspects of the film, like the plot, are based on Bertolt Brecht
's epic theatre: Brecht once said a play never needs to be more complicated than "a man on a street corner re-enacting an accident for a crowd". He also stated that an actor should always be presented as themselves playing
a character instead of as a character, to prevent total immersion, and to encourage critical reception. It shows.
At first it was conceived as trilogy, and the sequel, titled Manderlay
(based in part on Brecht's opera The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny
) takes Grace (now played by
Bryce Dallas Howard) to the Deep South
and comments on racism, but it was not as well-received as Dogville
was. The third installment, Wasington
, may never get made
, but let's hope.
The film is highly popular as a topic of scientific research, and at least half of all publications about the film mention its trauma-inducing psychological effects. About half of those, in turn, focus
This film provides examples of:
- Aristocrats Are Evil: Or in this case, rich people are evil Averted with the townsfolk who manage to be evil while being miserably poor.
- Asshole Victim: The people of the town are all such massive pricks that you don't feel sympathy for any of them when Mafia Princess Grace orders the mobsters to kill them all.
- Break the Cutie: Grace.
- Break the Haughty: Vera
- Cassandra Truth: Chuck is never quite convinced Grace is what she seems she is. At the end he's right.
- City in a Bottle
- Confession Cam: Used by the director, so the actors could cope with the gruesome shooting. It's on the DVD extras.
- Dawson Casting: Intentionally so. Grace seems to be barely out of puberty. She's played by Nicole Kidman.
- The Ditz: Ben Henson, no matter how much he studies, he continues to be as dumb as a doorknob.
- Elephant in the Living Room: Mr. McKay is blind, everyone knows he's blind, yet nobody dares to mention such a thing in front of him.
- Even Evil Has Standards: The Mafia, who are quite comfortable with murder and extortion, are horrified and outraged when they discover that Grace has been abused and chained to her bed. Of course, this is most likely because she was the daughter of their boss.
- Humans Are Bastards: Something of a common theme in Lars von Trier's work.
- Hypocrite: The townsfolk find it increasingly easy to rationalize and justify their increasingly exploitative and abusive treatment of Grace.
- In Which a Trope Is Described
- Infant Immortality: Averted.
- Interrogation by Vandalism: the townspeople torture Grace by smashing her porcelain figures.
- Ironic Echo: Grace tells the mobsters to kill a kid named Jason first, then tell his mother that if she can hold back her tears they won't kill the rest. This comes after the woman in question smashed the dolls that Grace had bought with money she got from helping the townspeople, telling her that if she could hold back her tears she wouldn't destroy the rest.
- Kick the Dog: Happens a LOT in this movie, and the movie showcases the dangers of Dog Kicking. Literally averted at the end, where Grace prevents the mafia from killing the dog.
- Kick the Son of a Bitch Grace may have been wrong in ordering the deaths of the townspeople but it's hard not to understand why she did it.
- Kill 'em All: Nicole Kidman's character takes the name of this trope literally and indeed sends her goons to kill the entire village, except the dog.
- Made a Slave: Implicit from the beginning, made real in Chapter 6.
- The Mafia: The people looking for Grace.
- Mafia Princess: Grace turns out to be one.
- Messianic Archetype: Grace throughout pretty much the whole play. She offers inspiration and kindness, asking only to be allowed to help others and live peacefully among them. Eventually, she suffers for the sins of others and even ends up lugging around a cross-analog. In the end she's offered up as a sacrifice by the towns people and her father shows up to save her. Then it's all turned on its head when he talks her OUT of turning the other cheek any longer and she has the town wiped out for what they did to her
- Minimalism: in order to focus more on the characters and their actions and avoid immersion in the story (related to Bertolt Brecht ideas about epic theater) the entire village of Dogville drawn with chalk in the floor in a sound stage.
- Even the town dog, Moses, is just a drawing on the floor. Until the very final moment in the movie, where the drawing shifts into an actual dog, barking at the sky. The dog being the only living thing remaining in the village makes this mildly creepy.
- Also pays off in a big, BIG way when Grace is raped. The audience can see the crime taking place - and can also see the townspeople milling around obliviously while it occurs.
- Middle-of-Nowhere Street
- Painting the Medium: On many different levels. Including a textual example: when Grace quotes directly from "Pirate Jenny", she is genuinely shocked by what she says, and the narrator explains that Grace is wondering where such words would come from. Grace proceeds to accept her identity as a Jenny-character and act out the ending of "Pirate Jenny" almost to the letter.
- Pay Evil unto Evil
- Pet the Dog: A quite literal example.
- Premise Ville
- Rape as Drama
- Resignations Not Accepted: Subverted. Although Grace is held captive and her attempts to leave just lead her right back to the village, it turns out to be the result of her own stubborn decisions.
- Shout-Out: Some lines in the film are directly lifted from "Pirate Jenny", most notably: "Nobody gonna sleep here...".
- So Beautiful, It's a Curse: Liz.
- The Other Darrin: Bryce Dallas Howard replaced Kidman for Manderlay. Presumably, Howard herself will be replaced if the third installment ever gets out of Development Hell.
- "The Reason You Suck" Speech Most notable is the Mafia Don's one to Grace, calling her arrogant for holding impossible high standards for herself; and forgiving everyone else for failing to meet them. She realizes he's right, and tells the Mob to Kill 'em All.
- The Smart Guy: Tom likes to see himself as such, though he isn't.
- Town with a Dark Secret: Grace is the dark secret.
- What The Hell, Townspeople?: Dogville is a character study about this trope. The character of a town.
- Woobie, Destroyer of Worlds: Grace. Made all the more ambiguous by the discussion just before the ending, where it suddenly becomes very clear that she's only a child.