Proof that the remaining 10% is worth being decapitated for here:
These are recommendations made by Tropers for Durarara!!!Fan Fics, all of which have been signed. After a few samples, you will be able to judge whether you might be interested in the 'fic, based on who recommended it. No-name recommendations will be zapped. Nobody would back up the rec. Discussion of the recommendation is welcome on the discussion page. As such discussion is important, do remember to add the discussion page to the watchlist, if need be.
Do warn when a fanfic may head into non-canon territory. Some people just don't like it, and as we all know, Shipping is Serious Business.
If you love Aoba, don't like smut or if you love violentdark fic, then this is for you. Most of her stories focus on Aoba, Mikado and Izaya and her pairings tend to lean toward Mikado/Aoba (despite saying that she doesn't like the pairing) and Izaya/Mikado/Aoba. The characters are always in character. There's a lot of dark humor and character death in her fics. She has a few funny fics that will make you smile at the end but most of her fics have Downer Endings/Bittersweet Endings. Also, this author seems to love torturing Kidain themost horriblewayspossible. If you love Kida, her fics are not meant for you and if you don't like him...then these are perfect for you. (Saki also gets the same treatment, only worse.) Also, she tends to portray Mikado as Bosskado.
Nicely written and for the most part grammatically correct Shizaya fics that are a bit angsty/depressing but don't over do it. Her writing style is really brilliant, and even though she's sporadic about updating at best I really think it's worth the wait. Especially considering she comes out with things like the epically beautiful If There is Light.
Comments: Basically, a humorous summary of the entire anime plot told by the characters' activities on Facebook. Incredibly short and simple but amazingly effective — especially if you imagine that you're on Facebook and actually seeing all of those notifications. The author pulls the concept off flawlessly.
YMMV on this. While there are some very interesting ideas on how Izaya interacts with others, and how Masaomi's revenge causes a much bigger fallout, the story became a slow drag for me about halfway through (definitely after Masaomi is murdered. A lot of scenes seemed to be there just to be dark for the sake of being Darker and Edgier, and later events related to the beginning by barely a thread (at least to me. This may be different for different people). For something that originated from a Kink Meme, the fact that v-e-i tried to create an actual story out of the prompt was commendable, but it's still not a story I would recommend people to read, aside from those Izaya moments at the beginning.
Synopsis: It's deceptively familiar, but this is not the Ikebukuro he knows. Shizuo dies. Izaya deals with it the way only he can.
Comments: Not a shipping fic. This oneshot maintains a melancholy mood throughout without being overwhelmed by angst. Izaya is in-character. A good piece that also perfectly captures the whole Durarara!! cast's possible reaction to the loss of Shizuo.
Synopsis: A new gang comes to town looking for something special, and is willing to turn all of Ikebukuro upside down until they find it.
Comments: Good characterisation of everyone involved, as well as a engaging plot that includes an inventive use of folklore. The story also gets bonus points for including something that has long been suspected by the fandom regarding the nature of a couple of the main cast and making a good job of doing so.
Synopsis: A beautiful, in character story of the Orihara's home life. Izaya gets sick and returns home, a place he hadn't been in years, where he is not so welcome and not so trusted, by almost everyone in the family. It's a really interesting and emotional exploration of the burdens of being related to the someone who is pretty much the devil, and with oddly relatable themes throughout.
Comments: YMMV on whether it's in-character or not, but either way, this is wonderful story. The prose is unique and slightly embellished, but thankfully, it isn't flowery at all. A wonderfully realistic family-centered story and well worth the read, even for Izaya/Orihara-haters. May be tear-jerking for some.
Synopsis: Izaya birthday drabble. He can't read her, but maybe he doesn't want to.
Comments: Centers around Izaya and Namie while "working," but not really a shipping fic. A refreshing change from a lot of the more recent Izanami fics because of its wonderful characterization. The prose is reminiscent of Narita's own writing, and very simplistic and short, but it manages to say so much in so little and it adds a little bit of depth into the characters, especially Namie.
Pairing: Shizuo/Izaya, Shinra/Celty and Kasuka/Ruri (probably more to come)
Synopsis: Besides of one unpredictable person, he loves all humans. There are so many kind of humans and observing their behavior is simply enthralling. He forgets one thing to observe though. His own feelings.
Comments:This one stands out from the other Shizaya fics for many reasons. First, this author brings in the characters from the novel and does a good job characterizing them. Next, this person brings a lot of novel references from the more recent chapters like Izaya getting stabbed by Yadogiri Jinnai uses them as plot points to explain why Yadogiri Jinnai wants to ruin Izaya. Izaya might be OOC every now and then, but this is what would happen if the characters actually made an attempt to talk to Izaya. This story is definitely aiming for the Break the Haughty trope and as of recent chapters, it seems to have worked. A definite read but beware of spoilers from the novel.
Synopsis: Deathfic. Izaya makes sure that Shizuo sees him fall from a building.
Comments: The best DRRR fic' EVAR. Extremely bitter, with a hint of sweet. This person deserves an award, seriously. A world so beautifully created but not AU.
This fic is so beautiful, my god. Izaya is so perfectly in character and it actually makes Shizaya seem beyond plausible—inevitable, really. I spent an afternoon reading it, bawling my eyes out at some parts, and, yeah. All the other Shizaya fics I've read pale completely in comparison.
Synopsis: Mikado thought that the biggest event in his life was when the love of his life ran off with his best friend. This was, of course, before Celty invited him to Ikebukuro
Comments: I love this fanfic because I made me fall in love with the pairing of Shizuo/Mikado and make it seem believable while building a world and story that feels like episodes of Durarara!! It also creates interesting chemistry between Izaya and Mikado. Although, there is the reminder that this fic is a prequel to another fanfic by the same author,Operator. If you had read Operator, you know how it might probably end. It Needs More Love
Synopsis: As Shinra's birthday draws near, he begins to think about getting older, death and dying. He then wonders if Celty will remember him when he dies...
Comments: I've seen many DRRR!! fics that tried and failed to be tear jerkers (they were usually terrifyingly OOC Shizaya fics) but this definitely qualifies as a fanfic that you will need a box of tissues for. Shinra is in character (Celty's asleep for most of the story so she doesn't really need to be in character) and the ending will definitely make you want to hug him, tightly. Totally reccomended if you love Shinra/Celty.
Synopsis: She captures him through the camera lens...
Comments: Because of her status, there are few Kida/Saki fics, let alone good ones. I found this one to show more in a relatively short one-shot than a twenty-chapter fic. It's a downright haunting story that is not bogged down by a lot of the cliches one finds in Shipping Fics and both Kida and Saki are very in character.
Synopsis: Shizuo falls in love with a faceless pianist – but when he finds out the virtuoso's identity, will his attitude change?
Comments: Okay, admittedly, this one is a bit of a stretch. It's sweet and melancholy, and makes Izaya look like a better person than he actually is, but this is a good piece of writing anyway. It doesn't take Izaya out of character and gives a whole new dimension to Shizuo. The imagery is lovely and the story moves with an amazing flow.
Synopsis: It's a long, slow journey to awareness for someone who is so willfully blind. But, eventually, sight will come.
Comments: I'm not really sure whether this should be under shipping. It's obviously leaning towards there, but this is more like a reflective glance into Izaya's headspace for now. Written believably and convincingly, and shows some good insights into Izaya's relationship with Shizuo. Brilliant.
Synopsis: Izaya wakes up in a coffin with nothing but a flashlight and a cell phone. He doesn't know where he is or how much air he has left. All he knows is that he's running out of time and there's only one person who can save him – Heiwajima Shizuo.
Comments: Holy shit. If you don't read any other story in this section, THIS IS THE ONE YOU HAVE TO READ. It's impeccably on point for each character and will stick in your head for months. It's beautiful, not at all over-done and heartwrenching without being too angsty. Bring tissues. This is definitely one of the best fanfictions I've ever read in any fandom. Hands down.
YMMV. This troper found the story dreadfully predictable (except the last part, maybe, because I was hoping for the author to come through with some kind of unforeseen stroke of genius and save Izaya) and the writing rather bland. Shizuo's irrational actions near the end were much too OOC, and far too coincidental to fit the story. In the author's defence, this is their first Durarara story, and the concept was interesting with an original ending, but not something this troper will recommend. I'm not even sure it should be under Shipping. Readers should be warned that this is a Death Fic, so fans who cringe from that sort of stuff should stay away.
Synopsis: No one else needed to know all the ways Shizuo could break. No one else had the right to see him that way. When Shizuo fell apart, he needed to know Izaya was the only reason for it. The only reason there could ever be. And a broken, afraid Shizuo was of no use to him whatsoever. So there was only one option. I’ll fix you, Shizu-chan. Make you good as new. And then I’ll be the one who brings you to your knees.
Comments: A breathtakingly well written, heart-wrenching examination of how The Strongest Man In Ikebukuro would handle an almost imaginable trauma, and how Izaya responds when a presence so integral to his world is made unrecognizable. Caffeinekitty shows a truly fascinating take on this pair, impeccably in-character, thrilling, sexy, and achingly human, this fic is one of the best I've ever read of any fandom. Be forewarned: This fic deals with the aftereffects of gang rape.