Follow TV Tropes

Reviews WesternAnimation / My Little Pony Equestria Girls 1

Go To

PDL Since: Jul, 2010
06/23/2013 12:49:18 •••

Not Complete Crap

So there's been a lot of apprehension (Or as Pinkie put it, "nervicitment") over this adaptation. Namely there were fears that it'll crap all over what we know and love about Friendship Is Magic. Now that I've seen the movie... My feelings on it are a bit mixed.

On one hand, there were plenty of nice jokes about Twilight having to adjust to an environment and body that is totally alien to her. Having to deal with the things most of us take for granted, such as information technology or merely walking and fine manipulation. There's also plenty of appearances of favorite characters as humans and in a high school setting.

On the other hand, there were points that I personally didn't like. Such as the romantic subplot between Twilight and one of the new characters, Flash Sentry. One of the biggest draws of Friendship Is Magic was that it was a show aimed at girls that didn't touch romance in any serious sense. One of the biggest fears is that this is a sign that things are going to backslide and it'll turn to the very thing the show was made to go against. Hopefully though, this romantic subplot will not be present at all in Season 4 of Friendship Is Magic. Some other subplots that seemed hackneyed were plots like where Twilight was going to sleep, or even Sunset Shimmer's ultimate fate, but that's to be expected when you're given an hour and 13 minutes.

Overall, this movie wasn't totally bad, they managed to turn a sow's ear of an idea into a silk purse with this movie... Now if only Hasbro's toy department can get it together and produce better looking dolls...

EDIT: One event that still sticks in my mind is the fact that they've brought up the issue of cyber-bullying. This wouldn't have been possible in Friendship Is Magic, given the setting, but there's something very poignant about a character like Twilight getting hit with a problem that's unfortunately all too real. Especially since Twilight is my favorite character. It reminded me a lot of the whole "Derpygate" affair, which is quite an intriguing piece of Reality Subtext.

thedeviant105 Since: May, 2011
06/18/2013 00:00:00

From what I heard Flash Sentry will not appear in season 4. It is in this review where he mentions it. http://www.unleashthefanboy.com/movies/my-little-pony-equestria-girls-review/59102

"Any problem can be solved with a giant robot."
kay4today Since: Jan, 2011
06/18/2013 00:00:00

Thankfully. A bland and boring love interest isn't what this show needs. Forced romance is always groan-worthy.

KMA10k Since: Dec, 2009
06/22/2013 00:00:00

I don't know if it's fair to say it "brought up" cyber-bullying. More like it just used cyber-bullying as a cheap plot device for about thirty seconds. The whole thing is solved so quickly and painlessly that it's almost more of a disservice to the issue than anything else.

PDL Since: Jul, 2010
06/23/2013 00:00:00

@KM A10k

To be fair, I didn't really expect them to go in-depth with the issue. Its the fact that they actually had Youtube (or something very close to it) as a reference. Its surreal in a sense because Friendship is Magic owes a lot of its success to Youtube, and the fandom virtually does the exact same thing with the characters.


Leave a Comment:

Top