Written & storyboarded by Pearl Low & Richie Pope
Duane asks Craig to look after Nicole's anniversary present while he's gone.
Tropes:
- Bait-and-Switch: When Jessica offers to give Richard something important to her in exchange for the box and Craig's satchel, it at first appears that she's going to give him Small Uncle. Instead, what she's giving him is "a lesson: DON'T STEAL!!" and proceeds to lay the smackdown on Richard.
- Cannot Keep a Secret: When Duane calls Craig, he almost immediately confesses to losing the box.
- Comically Missing the Point: J.P. believes that the box is some kind of ball, fancy enough to have corners. At the end, Craig and Jessica are both completely surprised that there's something inside.
- Laser-Guided Karma: After stealing Craig's satchel and going back on his deal with the Trio, Richard is taught a lesson by Jessica, who painfully knocks the jerk into the ground with her version of Steve Austin's Stone Cold Stunner before taking back the box and Craig’s satchel.
- Sentimental Sacrifice: Richard offers to trade the box for Craig's beloved satchel. Craig agrees, but Richard ends up taking both. It then appears that Jessica is going to trade Small Uncle for the box and satchel; instead, she beats Richard to a pulp and takes both items back.
- Worthless Treasure Twist: Inverted; the box had a gold locket inside, which comes as a complete surprise to Craig and Jessica.
- Wrestler in All of Us: Jessica taking down Richard with wrestling moves, complete with a ring appearing out of nowhere.
- You Monster!: Said word for word by Kelsey in reference to Richard
