Follow TV Tropes

Following

Playing With / Scunthorpe Problem

Go To

Basic Trope: Censoring swear words that are found inside other words.

  • Straight: Alice is on an Internet forum and is trying to write "Hello", but the word keeps appearing as "Hecko" after processing.
  • Exaggerated:
    • Alice gets automatically and permanently banned from the forum for posting the word "Hello".
    • It even censors words that, while they could be considered impolite, aren't even profanity, such as "stupid" and "butt".
    • If the letters 'h', 'e', 'l', and 'l' are arranged in that order, even if there are other characters in between (for example, "Hey, let's play a game!"), Alice gets an error message saying her post cannot be accepted, without even telling her what in her post is a banned word.
    • The site censors any word which contains "h_ll", regardless of which letter comes between the h and the first l. This causes problems when Alice tries to make a post about her hobby, which happens to be hill-walking.
    • The filter also blocks misspelled swear words, such as the string "hel", so Alice can't talk about the helicopter ride she went on or the new football helmet she bought.
  • Downplayed:
    • Alice was trying to write a word that by itself could be interpreted as profanity, but in a non-swearing context, such as "pussy" when referring to a cat or "bitch" when referring to a female dog.
    • Alice isn't banned but is warned not to write "hell" again on the site. She's still miffed, especially if the administrator doesn't admit the content filter is unnecessarily stringent.
  • Justified: The person who came up with the site made a list of words that needed to be censored, but forgot to add exceptions.
  • Inverted: Alice tries to talk about how much she loves butter on toast, but it keeps changing the word to asser.
  • Subverted: Alice writes "Hello", sends the post, and holds her breath, waiting for it to be accepted... and it is.
  • Double Subverted:
    • It's replaced with "Hecko" soon after.
    • When Alice tries to write about her collection of seashells, the censorship filter kicks in and changes that to "seashecks."
    • "Hell" isn't blocked by the filter, but "ass" is, so when Alice tries to write about a class she's taking, the filter changes it to "clbutt".
  • Parodied: Alice is on a dog breeder's website but she isn't allowed to write "bitch".
  • Averted:
    • There are no profanity filters.
    • The profanity filters don't censor text strings inside other words.
  • Zig-Zagged:
    • Some words that Alice writes have strings of letters that add up to swear words. A few get censored, a few don't.
    • There is Selective Enforcement of the anti-profanity edict.
  • Enforced:
    • "What if someone tries to use those words to swear? I'd better ban them too!"
    • The profanity filter came as part of the package with the software used to create the site and cannot be turned off or modified.
  • Lampshaded: "Honestly, 'hello'?! How is that a bad word?!"
  • Invoked: The forum admin doesn't like the fact that the word hello contains the word hell.
  • Exploited: Bob tries to prove that Alice swears a lot to Charlie by showing her something she wrote on an Internet forum that's mostly blanked out.
  • Defied:
    • The person writing the site makes sure to list all the words that have swears inside them and make sure it doesn't censor those.
    • The site's users are given the option to set the profanity filter to a lower level, or to turn it off altogether.
    • After having her posts censored once too often, Alice migrates to another site where anti-swearing measures are less strictly enforced.
    • Alice deliberately misspells words which contain swears so they won't be caught by the filter. For example, "Hello" becomes "Helo".
    • Alice uses alternative words that don't contain any swears inside of them. For instance, instead of saying "Hello", she says "Hi".
  • Discussed: "I'm a studiously clean-mouthed person. There won't be a reason to censor my writing anywhere."
  • Conversed: "Why on Earth is it censoring 'hello'?"
  • Implied: The word "Hecko" is seen on Alice's post, followed by "I did not mean to write that!"
  • Deconstructed:
    • The other people on the forum cannot understand Alice.
    • Members start leaving the forum after the word filter renders all the messages unintelligible.
  • Reconstructed: They're having the same problem, so they know what she's trying to say.
  • Played for Laughs: Posts that contain strings of letters that add up to profanity are turned into jokes.
  • Played for Drama: Alice's boss sees that some of her writing is blanked out and thinks she's swearing.
  • Played for Horror: Posts that contain strings of letters that add up to profanity are censored. Death threats, on the other hand, are not, and somebody acts on them.

Back to Scunthorpe Problem.

Top