Crowner

Go To

Projects: Long Term/Perpetual: Real Life cleanup 02/23/22

23rd Feb '22 7:51:14 AM

Crown Description:

Vote up to forbid real life examples; vote down to Keep Real Life Examples.

To add a trope to a No Real Life Examples Please index, its crowner option must meet the following criteria:

2:1 ratio needed for NRLEP
Must have been up for a minimum of a week
If the vote is exactly 2:1 or +/- 1 vote from that, give it a couple extra days to see if any more votes come in

After you bring up a trope for discussion, please try to wait at least a day or so for feedback before you add the trope to the crowner. Entries that have been called are marked with "(CLOSED)" and are no longer up for discussion.

15 (Yeas:18 Nays:3) 6.00 : 1

Sea Serpents - Impossible in real life (added Feb. 26th) (CLOSED)

14 (Yeas:17 Nays:3) 5.67 : 1

Hopeless War - Too common, attracting natter/shoehorns (added Apr 1) (CLOSED)

12 (Yeas:15 Nays:3) 5.00 : 1

Villain Over for Dinner - Narrative trope, since real life doesn\'t have a script with protagonists and antagonists (added April 3rd) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:16 Nays:6) 2.67 : 1

Buxom Is Better - Sex and sexuality, discussing the bodies of actresses (added Mar 25th) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:15 Nays:5) 3.00 : 1

Cassandra Truth - Too common (added Mar 12th) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:12 Nays:2) 6.00 : 1

Last Disrespects - Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment violations/Too Controversial. (added Mar. 3rd) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:12 Nays:2) 6.00 : 1

Rousseau Was Right - Morality trope (added Mar 13th) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:12 Nays:2) 6.00 : 1

Hobbes Was Right - Morality trope (added Mar 13th) (CLOSED)

10 (Yeas:17 Nays:7) 2.43 : 1

Insistent Terminology - Attracts nitpicking at best and potentially controversial examples at worst. The page had to be locked because a Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment-violating example related to the Russian invasion of Ukraine had to be removed twice. (added April 6th) (CLOSED)

9 (Yeas:12 Nays:3) 4.00 : 1

Benevolent Boss - Morality trope (added Mar 29th) (CLOSED)

8 (Yeas:12 Nays:4) 3.00 : 1

Cool Plane— Too subjective, bloated real life section (added Mar 27th) (CLOSED)

4 (Yeas:9 Nays:5) 1.80 : 1

Vetinari Job Security - Too common, attracting natter and shoehorns (added Mar 30th) (CLOSED)

-9 (Yeas:4 Nays:13)

Popularity Polynomial - Too common, attracting natter (added Mar 12th) (CLOSED)