History YMMV / WouldILieToYou

* {{Squick}}: In a Series 3 episode, Claudia Winkleman had a taxidermic cat (ostensibly her childhood pet) as her possession in the Quick Fire Lies round. She stroked it lovingly for most of her turn, but as soon as her story was revealed to be a lie she dropped it back into its box and shook her hands in disgust.
** Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's claim that he smeared Marmite on his face for his dog to lick off, [[spoiler: which was thankfully a lie]].
-->'''Rhod Gilbert''': It has to be a lie, David, or else there's ''something wrong with him''.
** In Series 6, Miles Jupp claimed that, after showering, he brushes water off his arms with his hands before drying off with a towel. Richard Madeley asked if he also brushed water off between his legs with his hands, causing Rob and Lee to make identical disgusted expressions.

----

** AcceptableCulturalTargets: High- and low-class jokes directed at David Mitchell and Lee Mack, respectively.

* TheyJustDidntCare: The series 6 promotional material reused all the promotional images from series 5, and used clips from previous series in the trailer. This lack of effort was made obvious because David Mitchell had grown a beard whilst filming series 6.

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: During Dara O'Briain's story about needing to wear a cycle helmet in bed because of the violent nature of his dreams, Rob interrupts with a story about how he once dreamt he was spooning a tiger. It has no relevance to anything being said beyond the fact that it is a dream, which David promptly points out before Lee drags the story back on-topic.

YMMV page for ''WouldILieToYou'':

----

* SpecialEffectFailure: The set design is often accused of this; the lurid colour-scheme aside, one review said it looked like the panellists were sitting "behind giant tubes of fruit Polos", and Julian Clary claimed it resembled a game of Bumper Cars on his guest appearance.

** AcceptableNationalityTargets: Mainly from the British Isles, but some "Polish builder" jabs get through.

* MissedMomentOfAwesome: Dara O'Briain and Konnie Huq are both appearing in the fifth series. What a shame nobody thought to put them on the same programme! (For context: the bit in series 5 of ''MockTheWeek'', where David Mitchell was present, where Dara is mercilessly teased for having a crush on Konnie.)
** Of course, when you consider that ''Would I Lie to You'' is produced by Zeppotron, which is owned in part by Mr. Konnie Huq, aka CharlieBrooker...

YMMV page for ''WouldILieToYou?'':

** AcceptableEthnicTargets: When Ronnie Corbett appeared on the show, there were plenty of cracks about his short stature. [[SelfDeprecatingHumor Several of them made by Corbett himsef]].

** Similarily, Rob Brydon imagining David and KeeleyHawes going on a date after series 4 episode 1 of ''ThatMitchellAndWebbLook''.

* [[WTHCastingAgency WTH Booking Agency]]: There were some... ''questionable'' choices of guests (Kelvin [=MacKenzie=] and Janet Street-Porter amongst them) in the third series.

* SpecialEffectFailure: The set design is often accused of this by reviewers.

*** After this, the third series of ''ThatMitchellAndWebbLook'' had "The Quiz Broadcast", a series of sketches in which David's character hosted a [[AfterTheEnd post-apocalyptic]] GameShow in a world that had been destroyed by [[NoodleIncident the Event]].

* [[WTHCastingAgency WTH Booking Agency]]: There were some... ''questionable'' choices of guests in the third series.

* MemeticMutation: The Horse Story.