History YMMV / SouthParkS10E1TheReturnOfChef

* NightmareFuel: ''[[CruelAndUnusualDeath Chef's death]]'', period.

%%Harsher in Hindsight doesn't apply here. It's not an example, for two reasons: 1) that's when the character's death circumstances somehow relate to those of their real-life actor, and 2) everyone dies.

'''Kyle:''' You bastards. YOU BASTARDS!!!

** The Cherry on Top: When Chef [[CallBack craps himself in death]], ''[[OOCIsSeriousBusiness Cartman doesn't laugh]].''

* NightmareFuel: '''Chef's [[CruelAndUnusualDeath death]]''', period.

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: Kyle's eulogy for Chef is quite a touching moment, and really shows how much the kids cared about Chef.

--->'''Stan:''' Oh my god. They killed Chef.
--->'''Kyle:''' You bastards. YOU BASTARDS!!!
* UncannyValley: Chef's dialogue is actually previous dialogue that's been mixed up really badly making him sound like an edited Youtube video. This might come off as unsettling to some.

--->'''Kyle:''' You bastards. YOU BASTARDS!!!

* NightmareFuel: '''Chef's death''', period.

* TearJerker: Chef's death, and his funeral.

* TearJerker: Chef's death, and his funeral.

%%Harsher in Hindsight doesn't apply here, for two reasons: 1) that's when the character's death circumstances somehow relate to those of their real-life actor, and 2) everyone dies.

* HarsherInHindsight: Chef dying in this episode was bad enough, but what makes this more heartbreaking is that his voice actor Isaac Hayes would also die two years after the episode aired and that it was written completely unintentionally.

* HarsherInHindsight: Chef dying in this episode was bad enough, but what makes this more heartbreaking is that his voice actor Creator/IsaacHayes would also die two years after the episode aired and that it was written completely unintentionally.

* HarsherInHindsight: The death of Chef becomes even more painful when his voice actor, Isaac Hayes, passed away 2 years after this episode aired.

* HarsherInHindsight: Chef's death became this when Creator/IsaacHayes died not long after this episode aired. This also dashed some fans' hopes that he and the creators would eventually make amends and Chef would be written back in.

* HarsherInHindsight: Chef's death became this when Creator/IsaacHayes died not look after this episode aired, which also dashed some fans' hopes that he and the creators would eventually make amends and Chef would be written back in.

* HarsherInHindsight: Chef's death became this when IssacHays died not look after this episode aired, which also dashed some fans' hopes that he and the creators would eventually make amends and Chef would be written back in.

* BrokenBase: While the episode got good reviews, the thing is that some considered this episode very bad, due to the horrific death of Chef, and also the episode was played too dramatic and darker than one would expect in South Park, especially by the ending.

* BrokenBase: While the episode got good reviews, the thing is that some considered very bad this episode, due to the horrific death of Chef, and also the episode was played too dramatic and darker than one would expect in South Park, especially by the ending.

* DesignatedHero: In this time, Cartman.

* CompleteMonster: William Connelly could be a good candidate for this territory, since obsession that he has for turn Jo into a pedophile is played very seriously, even worse, he does it and gets away scot-free. The worst part is that even Cartman, an infant terrible and sociopathic, hates him. While Connelly not wanting to kill the boys, he, however, does not seem to mind psychologically traumatizing children in order to get their "marlocks". While Connelly not wanting to kill the boys, he, however, does not seem to mind psychologically traumatizing children in order to get their "marlocks".