History YMMV / PixelPinkie

* ClicheStorm: Two girls, and a LiteralGenie's wishes [[HilarityEnsues causing shenanigans]]? [[SoOkayItsAverage Passable]]. But an entire show where each episode is ''nothing'' but said plot with little to no variety? Not so much.

* AssPull: [[spoiler:The finale reveals that genies can only grant a certain (but ''never'' specified) number of wishes and once those wishes run out, the genie moves on to another phone, which was a plot point that is never alluded to in past episodes since wishes were hitherto believed to be unlimited.]]

* {{Narm}}: The [[LimitedAnimation choppy Flash animation]], the [[DullSurprise stiff acting]], and [[VocalDissonance odd voice direction]] (to the point that a male salesclerk was voiced by [[LarynxDissonance a woman doing the deepest voice she can muster]] in the ''first episode'') makes the cartoon a little hard to take seriously.

* IdiotPlot: Many of the conflicts in each episode hinge upon Nina prefacing her sentence with a rhetorical "I wish", only for her to somehow keep forgetting that Pixel Pinkie is a LiteralGenie. But if Nina learns her lesson to not make that same mistake again, then it would render the entire point of the show moot, so each episode ''has'' to start with Nina carrying the IdiotBall. And that's ''only'' when the show decides to stick to formula and not have Pixel Pinkie materialise random things that Nina off-handedly implied without saying "I wish" just for the sake of ensuing hi-jinks.

* AssPull: [[spoiler:The finale reveals that genies can only grant a certain (but ''never'' specified) number of wishes and once those wishes run out, the genie moves on to another phone, which was a plot point that is never alluded to in past episodes in which wishes are hitherto believed to be unlimited.]]

* UncannyValley:
** It looks as if Anni's head is about to fall off, given the position of her neck.
** Clone!Nina in "Clones R Us", ''especially'' after Pixel Pinkie decides to take control of it.

* {{Narm}}: The [[LimitedAnimation choppy Flash animation]] combined with [[DullSurprise stiff acting]] and [[VocalDissonance unfitting voices]] (to the point that a male salesclerk was voiced by [[LarynxDissonance a woman doing the deepest voice she can muster]] in the ''first episode'') makes the entire cartoon hard to take seriously.
* ReviewsAreTheGospel: WebVideo/TheMysteriousMrEnter reviewed one single episode ("Clones R Us") from the entire series, yet it made everyone else voicing their less-than-positive opinions about the cartoon. For reference, the show had already ended two years prior to Enter's review in 2014[[labelnote:*]]At the time, however, reruns were rampant in its origin country[[/labelnote]].

* SoBadItsGood: There are those that seem to watch the cartoon ''because'' of its shortcomings which lead to unintentional hilarity.