History YMMV / PeanutButterGamer

* HePannedItNowHeSucks:
** His review of ''VideoGame/SonicHeroes'' is basically a repeat of what a lot of critics of the series have already said for years, such as the characters speaking too much and how having Sonic as the sole playable character would be an "improvement".
** To a lesser extent, his ''VideoGame/MySims'' reviews. While most people aren't complaining (mostly because the series is ''really'' obscure compared to its [[VideoGame/TheSims parent series]]), those who did play the ''My Sims'' and ''enjoyed'' it were quick to criticize Peebs for being nitpicky and not paying attention to the game's positive merits, like the fun, interesting characters and cute aesthetic. [[http://fanbun.tumblr.com/post/143723672096/fuckyeahmysims-currentlyacceptingcuddles This post]], while not mentioning PBG by name, weighs in on the matter in more detail.

** In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of Creator/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This became somewhat less funny to watch in hindsight after [=ProJared=] was accused of cheating on his wife.

** In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of LetsPlay/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This became somewhat less funny to watch in hindsight after [=ProJared=] was accused of cheating on his wife.

** “I can hear birds.” [[label:Explanation]] During his “Top Worst 3ds Games,” he reviews the video game of ''Series/PowerRangersMegaforce'' and he points out how Troy blurts this out constantly. [[/labelnote]]

** “I can hear birds.” [[label:Explanation]]During his “Top Worst 3ds Games,” he reviews the video game of ''Series/PowerRangersMegaforce'' and he points out how Troy blurts this out constantly. [[/labelnote]]

** "I apologize for that!"[[labelnote:Explanation]] A line from his ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaCDIGames Link: The Faces of Evil]]'' review, in reaction to the WebAnimation/YouTubePoop he made for the video. Appropriately, it became a meme in [=YouTube=] Poop itself, often used as an apology for A. a particularly [[CrossesTheLineTwice line-crossing joke]] B. use of an overused meme, or C. as LampshadeHanging for StylisticSuck moments.[[/labelnote]]

* CriticalResearchFailure: In "The Best & Worst of Rip-offs", while PBG was able to correct himself in regards to ''VideoGame/DisneysExtremeSkateAdventure'' within the same video, initially thinking it was just [[SugarWiki/NoProblemWithLicensedGames an exceptionally well-done]] [[FollowTheLeader imitation]] of the ''VideoGame/TonyHawkProSkater'' series before finding out at the last minute that it was made by the same developers and built off of the game engine of ''Pro Skater 4'', one error was left in the video: Among the various knock-offs of ''VideoGame/PokemonGo'' he lists, he includes ''VideoGame/HarryPotterWizardsUnite''...which was ''also'' developed by Niantic and used the same exact technology that ''Pokémon GO'' does.

** In Part 3 of his review of the ''Series/TheSuperMarioBrosSuperShow'', PBG does a sketch where he tries to introduce a celebrity cameo, only for some random weirdo (also played by PBG) to appear instead. The celebrity Peebs was expecting? Creator/ChrisPratt, who has now been cast as Mario himself in the upcoming animated movie! Peebs even played the clip in question during his reaction video to the September 2021 WebVideo/NintendoDirect that announced the cast for the Mario movie.

** In his "Top 10 Suckiest Enemies in Video Games" video, PBG said this: "Usually I don't talk about the [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaCDiGames Zelda CD-i games]]. Like Nintendo, I just prefer to pretend like they never existed.” Two years later, he did a video on ''The Faces of Evil'' for Zelda Month. And then he did ''The Wand of Gamelon'' for the following Zelda Month.

** In Part 3 of his review of the ''WesternAnimation/TheSuperMarioBrosSuperShow'', PBG does a sketch where he tries to introduce a celebrity cameo, only for some random weirdo (also played by PBG) to appear instead. The celebrity Peebs was expecting? Chris Pratt, who has now been cast as Mario himself in an upcoming movie!

* JustHereForGodzilla: PBG's main focus is his 'Review?' videos, but, as shown well on this very wiki, many fans prefer his various Hardcore series'.

%%**"I pressed it to jump!" (from [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_I5bQCwuXxQ&t=7m40s episode 16]] of his ''[[VideoGame/DonkeyKongCountry2DiddysKongQuest Donkey Kong Country 2]]'' Let's Play) has become this.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of LetsPlay/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This became somewhat less funny to watch in hindsight after [=ProJared=] was accused of cheating on his wife.