History YMMV / IKnowWhoKilledMe

* CriticalBacklash: Despite sweeping Razzies the following year after the film, the film received some reevaluations along with special screenings during the late 2010s/early 2020s, and developed somewhat a cult following. Some critics appreciate its giallo-inspired surrealism, and intriguing premise that reflects Lindsay Lohan's real-life plight. People blamed the movie's failure on the backlash from tabloids around the actress's fallout at that time.
* CultClassic

* CriticalBacklash: Despite sweeping Razzies the following year after the film, the film received some reevaluations along with special screenings during the late 2010s/early 2020s, and developed somewhat a cult following. Some critics appreciate its giallo-inspired, surrealism, and intriguing premise that reflects Lindsay Lohan's real-life plight. People blamed the movie's failure on the backlash from tabloids around the actress's fallout at that time.

* FauxSymbolism: All around, particularly the overuse of [[ColorCodedForYourConvenience the colors red and blue]].

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: The color coding is already mentioned, but the real deal goes to the owls. Owl is on a branch, owl is the school mascot, owl pops up in a creepy mirror, etc.

* SpiritualSuccessor: This movie could be considered as a much darker version of ''Film/{{The Parent Trap|1998}}''.

* SpiritualSuccessor: This movie could be considered as a much darker version of ''Film/TheParentTrap.''

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: The color coding is already mentioned, but the real deal goes to the owls. Owl is on a branch, owl is the school mascot, owl pops up in a creepy mirror, etc.

* {{Narm}}: "Let's win this one for ''Jennifer Toland''!"

* SpiritualSuccessor: This movie could be considered a much darker version of ''Film/TheParentTrap.''

* SpiritualSuccessor: This movie could be considered a much darker version of The Parent Trap.

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: The color coding is already mentioned, but the real deal goes to the owls. Owl is on a branch, owl is the school mascot, owl pops up in a creepy mirror, etc.

* NauseaFuel: The torture scenes, especially the one involving dry ice.

* NauseaFuel: The movie poster. The awkward, period-like placing of the blood on Lindsay's thigh is nauseating.

* FridgeLogic: Meta-example: Why have a picture of Ali Lohan when there's enough pictures of Lindsay at about the same age?
** Neither Dakota nor anyone tries to compare scars, moles, etc. that Aubrey had with Dakota, which would have alerted everyone to the twin concept pretty quick.
* FridgeBrilliance: Why doesn't Dakota tell the cops to call the strip club where she works to confirm her identity? Since she is Aubrey's twin, that means she is underage, therefore the club owner would most likely go along with the "That woman's crazy" theory if the police interrogated her.
** Better yet, the police could have checked to see if a woman named Virginia Sue Moss died around the time Dakota said she did, or could have checked out Dakota's apartment. But that would be too easy.
** How about: 1. Nobody in the hospital told Susan her baby had died. 2. Nobody in the hospital noticed that the family whose baby died left the hospital with a baby. 3. Nobody in the hospital noticed that Virginia Sue Moss was missing a twin.
* NightmareFuel / NauseaFuel: The torture scenes are pretty horrifying, but the dry ice scene is definitely the most frightening and nauseating.
** The movie poster. The awkward, period-like placing of the blood on Lindsay's thigh is nauseating.

* SoBadItsHorrible: Often considered the film that most seriously hurt Lindsay Lohan's career.

* HighOctaneNightmareFuel / NauseaFuel: The torture scenes are pretty horrifying, but the dry ice scene is definitely the most frightening and nauseating.

* FridgeBrilliance: Foolishly averted. Deleted materials were to show that the entire plot was merely a fiction piece written by Aubrey as a project, which would have handily explained the numerous plot holes, stupid contrivances and pointless symbolism littered about the film.
** An actual example is related to an often quoted apparent plot hole: Why doesn't Dakota tell the cops to call the strip club where she works to confirm her identity? Since she is Aubrey's twin, that means she is underage, therefore the club owner would most likely go along with the "That woman's crazy" theory if the police interrogated her.

*** And again, it could have all been {{hand wave}}d away if they'd just kept the "well, a kid wrote it" concept.

* HighOctaneNightmareFuel: The torture scenes are pretty horrifying, espeically the dry ice one.
* NauseaFuel: Two words: [[HighOctaneNightmareFuel Dry Ice]].

* [[{{DarthWiki/Ptitlew9bltta3dv6n}} So Bad It's Horrible]]: This film was critically panned and was nominated for several Razzies after all.

* SoBadItsHorrible: This film was critically panned and was nominated for several Razzies after all.

* [[DarthWiki SoBadIt'sHorrible]]: The film tanked at the box office and won no less than ''eight'' Razzies, including Worst Picture.

* [[DarthWiki SoBadIt'sHorrible]]: The film tanked at the box office and won ''eight'' several Razzies, including Worst Picture.

* NauseaFuel: Two words: [[HighOctaneNightmareFuel Dry Ice]].