Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / MyLittlePonyEquestriaGirls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer is Princess Celestia's daughter]]
Both have an affinity for the sun. If canon, however, this is very highly to be revealed, until the finale of Equestria Girls, unless a remorseful Sunset were to return to Equestria with Twilight. Que heartwarming moment, as her mother embraces her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jossed. In North America, the movie screened without leading promos.[[note]] This is because Hasbro didn't circulate it via the standard Hollywood method; they instead used a distribution service that essentially rents out single rooms of cinemas for single showings. Although this method is most common for independent films that ''don't'' get picked up by a major studio, it has been known to happen with cartoons: {{Disney}} does this with its less-popular Creator/StudioGhibli films (like ''Tales From Earthsea'' or ''The Wind Rises'') that they are contractually-obligated to screen in cinemas but don't want to drop tens of millions of dollars on traditional distribution. Creator/{{Funimation}} does it with their theatrical movies as well.[[/note]] EQG was DirectToDVD (or just aired on TV) everywhere else.

to:

* Jossed. In North America, the movie screened without leading promos.[[note]] This is because Hasbro didn't circulate it via the standard Hollywood method; they instead used a distribution service that essentially rents out single rooms of cinemas for single showings. Although this method is most common for independent films that ''don't'' get picked up by a major studio, it has been known to happen with cartoons: {{Disney}} Creator/{{Disney}} does this with its less-popular Creator/StudioGhibli films (like ''Tales From Earthsea'' or ''The Wind Rises'') that they are contractually-obligated to screen in cinemas but don't want to drop tens of millions of dollars on traditional distribution. Creator/{{Funimation}} does it with their theatrical movies as well.[[/note]] EQG was DirectToDVD (or just aired on TV) everywhere else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The idea being similar to {{Ponyo}}, where the more of the elements they use, the more pony-like they become and thus risk blowing their already rather flimsy cover. Thus we get a clever little tie-in to the ideas of the original.

to:

The idea being similar to {{Ponyo}}, Anime/{{Ponyo|On The Cliff By The Sea}}, where the more of the elements they use, the more pony-like they become and thus risk blowing their already rather flimsy cover. Thus we get a clever little tie-in to the ideas of the original.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer was human originally]]
* She was able to set up a permanent life in that world. Assuming she was born as a pony, this would require learning all kinds of cultural things as well as learning how to write with her hands - all on her own, without drawing attention to herself by acting as weird as Twilight does.
* Other than Princess Celestia, there doesn't seem to be any pony in Equestria who misses her. She has no family in either world.
* Even after she is reformed, she feels more at home at CHS (a place where everyone hates her) than Canterlot (a place where nobody knows who she is - or at worst remembers her as a brat rather than a raging she-demon - and she has her magic).
All circumstantial, but maybe we shouldn't be looking for Sunset's human counterpart, and instead for her ''pony'' counterpart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The EG universe is not an actual world - it's a mirror-based dimensional prison for Equestria.]]
(Found on reddit)
Nobody ages in this universe - Starswirl banished the Sirens there hundreds of years ago, Sunset ran away there at least three years ago, (Since she won the crowning election three years in a row), yet when Twilight arrives they're all teenagers the same age. Nobody's gone anywhere, nobody's graduated - they're all stuck in the same high school town forever.
* It could be Narnia-esque? Time flows super slow in comparison to time spent in Equestria?
** Possibly - but Narnia also has its' own diverse territories and unique populations, which the EG world doesn't seem to have. Also, if time moved slower or quicker than in Equestria, it would be impossible to keep track of the Moon cycles which dictated when the mirror portal would open/close.
*** What if time only flows while the mirror is open? So you can go there and come back in 3 days and everything seems normal, but from the EQG side the portal is always open and if you miss your window you come back and suddenly it's 3 years later.

**** I like that theory! That would also mean [[spoiler since Twilight modified the portal to always be open,]] time will start flowing normally in the EG universe - will still be an effective prison?

The only characters unique to the EG world are people who are banished from Equestria. Everyone else is just a reflection of someone who exists in Equestria already.

Whatever change a true Equestrian sets in place, all the reflected EG citizens go along with unquestioningly - even the adults. Sunset Shimmer convinced everyone she was in charge of their school before ever getting Twilight's tiara. When both Twilight and the Sirens started singing their campaigns in the cafeteria, the rest of the school immediately started going along with it - regardless of whether or not magic was involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: There will be a crossover at some point with LittlestPetShop.]]

to:

[[WMG: There will be a crossover at some point with LittlestPetShop.''WesternAnimation/LittlestPetShop2012''.]]



[[WMG: The Changeling Kingdom is in this world is modeled as a real life aggressive nation, the likes of North Korea.]]

to:

[[WMG: The Changeling Kingdom is in this world is modeled as a real life aggressive nation, the likes of North Korea.UsefulNotes/NorthKorea.]]



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The [[MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic Pony Universe]] and the [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyEquestriaGirls EQG Universe]] has a similiar Situation as what is found in [[spoiler: KevinAndKell]]]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic Pony Universe]] and the [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyEquestriaGirls EQG Universe]] has a similiar Situation as what is found in [[spoiler: KevinAndKell]]]]Webcomic/KevinAndKell]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And they have a whirlwind InterspeciesRomance which leads to him going back to Equestria with her and becoming a pony. Hey, that should make it popular with [[FurryFandom some fans]].

to:

And they have a whirlwind InterspeciesRomance which leads to him going back to Equestria with her and becoming a pony. Hey, that should make it popular with [[FurryFandom [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom some fans]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to have been attracted— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him having [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, including pretty much her first few minutes in the school, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a convenient coincidence but everything else was down to them.

to:

** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to have been attracted— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him having [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe [[BecauseYouWereNiceToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, including pretty much her first few minutes in the school, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a convenient coincidence but everything else was down to them.

Added: 668

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Above here is a different troper assuming that when Celestia said that the Magic Mirror portal only opens once every thirty Moons for three days at a time, it means two and a half years. Leaving aside the fact that Earth's moon cycle is '''''not''''' 30 days (it's ~29½, 30 of which translates to 885 days, one calendar month less than people assume), there's still one question left unasked – Has there ever been ''any indication whatsoever'' that Equestria's moon cycle (or the EQG-verse's) is anything like Earth's? Considering that the moon over Equestria seems to always be full, does it even ''have'' a moon cycle as we would know it?

to:

Above here is a different troper assuming that when Celestia said that the Magic Mirror portal only opens once every thirty Moons for three days at a time, it means two and a half years. Leaving aside the fact that Earth's moon cycle is '''''not''''' 30 days (it's ~29½, 30 of which translates to 885 days, one calendar month less than people assume), there's still one question left unasked -- Has there ever been ''any indication whatsoever'' that Equestria's moon cycle (or the EQG-verse's) is anything like Earth's? Considering that the moon over Equestria seems to always be full, does it even ''have'' a moon cycle as we would know it?


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:The human-equivalents to ponies are not just alternate universe counterparts -- they're ''reincarnations''!]]
From a comment made by human!Applejack in the Annual 2013 comic book: "Somehow I feel like we were already friends, long before we even met!" The mirror doesn't just send Twilight to an different world, but also somewhat in the future or at least a different timeline, and all the characters she meets reminding her of a pony she knows is because they are the reincarnations of her friends. Hence why they connect so easily, and why the Magic of Friendship responds to them -- they were already the bearers of the Elements of Harmony in a previous life.

Added: 622

Changed: 523

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer and Inkwell]]
Inkwell (from IDW's Micro-Series #8) was certainly teaching at the Canterlot academy while Sunset Shimmer was a student, since as of Twilight Sparkle's time she taught a lot of the parents of the current students. What if Sunset Shimmer recognized Inkwell's knowledge and power, and respected her for it, eagerly learning from her -- and Princess Celestia praised Sunset for it, talking of how her ability to see Inkwell for what she really was showed that Sunset was much better than other ponies her age? This would be no small contributing factor to Sunset's aloofness and ambition...







to:

* Simultaneously confirmed and Jossed. ''Rainbow Rocks'' began with the Dazzlings noticing the final battle of the first movie and heading for the school to see how they could use it. The whole magical rainbow and roaring thunder were unmistakable, and probably caught on video, too; so why didn't the authorities, the media, etc. respond to it?




to:

* Exactly how much military strategy do you think Princess Celestia teaches her personal students before the eighth grade? Sunset Shimmer probably actually thought it would work.

Changed: 755

Removed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mostly Jossed. [[spoiler:There is no magic in the human world, and only through the crown/Element of Magic does it actually occur. That said, the implications of the simple aspect of friendship and restoring the friendship that the human versions of her friends had lost because of Sunset is all there.]]

to:

* Mostly Jossed. [[spoiler:There is no magic in the human world, and only through the crown/Element of Magic does it actually occur. That said, However, the implications of the simple aspect of friendship and restoring the friendship that the human versions of her friends had lost because of Sunset is all there.]]
*Retoractively confirmed by the second movie. [[spoiler: Sunset Shimmer's actions have premanently introduced Equestrian magic into the human world. The Humane Five can shapeshift between human and anthropony forms and the Dazzlings now have enough power to initiate their EvilPlan.]]



It'll be an epic genre reconstruction of high school dramas, and every dinky high school trope, cliché and stereotype.
from what I understand from the second trailer, the importance of the high school dance is justified. which gives off the impression they know what they are doing.
* Confirmed on the latter: it does little to deconstruct the typical high school drama.
** Instead of a reconstruction, it actually plays it almost [[ClicheStorm painfully straight]].

to:

It'll be an epic genre reconstruction of high school dramas, and every dinky high school trope, cliché and stereotype.
from what I understand from
stereotype. From the second trailer, the importance of the high school dance is justified. which gives off the impression they know what they are doing.
* Confirmed on the latter: it does little to deconstruct the typical high school drama.
**
drama and Instead of a reconstruction, it actually plays it almost [[ClicheStorm painfully straight]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, with Twilight now being able to jump through the portal any time due to the fact that she can open it with the book on her side of the portal, the first half of this WMG is fully possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a convenient coincidence but everything else was down to them.

to:

** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— have been attracted— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him having [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, including pretty much her first few minutes in the school, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a convenient coincidence but everything else was down to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a ConvenientCoincidence but everything else was down to them.

to:

** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness to overlook that and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a ConvenientCoincidence convenient coincidence but everything else was down to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness toi overlook that and/...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a ConvenientCoincidence but everything else was down to them.

to:

** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness toi to overlook that and/...and...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a ConvenientCoincidence but everything else was down to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the HotGuyNerdyGirl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical HotNerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part.

to:

** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the HotGuyNerdyGirl Hot Guy and Nerdy Girl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical HotNerd Hot Nerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part.
part. Add in her being consistently {{Adorkable}}, which would and ''did' continue to increase his interest in her, and his willingness toi overlook that and/...yeah. This happened more or less on it's own in universe. The fact that he was around might be something of a ConvenientCoincidence but everything else was down to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** Unlikely, as she is also attracted, or seems to be— however briefly— to the pony counterpart of Flash. However aside from two brief cameos since, one in the show and once in the comic, and only once out of those two is Twilight anywhere near him, there is no indication that this interest lasted. However she is positively ''giddy'' when she finds out Human!Flash was asking about her. So it may be more a case that Twilight became attracted to Flash due in part to him [[BecauseYouWereKindToMe helped her out repeatedly]] during the film, or else she, like Spike, is completely without care for someone's species. This actually makes a certain amount of sense, when you consider that aside from Spike's crush on Rarity, there are hints that Discord was interested in Celestia in the finale to Season 4 and she certainly didn't seem to object when he gave her those flowers. We also know that Minotaurs are some form of pony hybrid in the show, so InterspeciesRomance probably isn't a taboo in Equestria. So Twilight probably was genuinely attracted to him on her own, rather than any kind of 'instinct' built into her new body. After all, had that been the case, she would have immediately known how to be human, instead of being so awkward in the new body she found herself in. Plus, the HotGuyNerdyGirl trope may also fit here, since Flash is the typical good looking guy, and who happens to be the lead in a band, while Twilight is the typical HotNerd girl, with an emphasis on the nerd part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Jossed. The first time we see the book in ''Rainbow Rocks'' it's acquired a thick layer of dust, indicating that even though Sunset kept the book for whatever reason, she probably hadn't touched it in all the time that she was gone until the Sirens showed up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** The one seen in ''Reflections'' in the IDW comic is stated to be the ''prototype'' of the mirror later used in Equestria Girls, which makes one wonder why either Celestia or Starsiwrl had the second one made.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's the most likely explanation as to why the normally serious Twilight Sparkle would crush of Flash Sentry despite the InterspeciesRomance implications: being put not just in a human body, but the body of a human teenage girl has seriously affected her judgement. Since so little is known about the exact process leading to the pony-to-human transformation (was is it a built-in property of the mirror, or one of the whole world?) it could just as well be an unintended side effect, or an actual feature to allow better mingling in the new world (since the portal only open for 3 days every 30 moons, ending up stuck for a long time is quite likely).


to:

It's the most likely explanation as to why the normally serious Twilight Sparkle would crush of on Flash Sentry despite the InterspeciesRomance implications: being put not just in a human body, but the body of a human teenage girl has seriously affected her judgement. Since so little is known about the exact process leading to the pony-to-human transformation (was is it a built-in property of the mirror, or one of the whole world?) it could just as well be an unintended side effect, or an actual feature to allow better mingling in the new world (since the portal only open for 3 days every 30 moons, ending up stuck for a long time is quite likely).

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's the most likely explanation as to why the normally serious Twilight Sparkle would crush of Flash Sentry despite the InterspeciesRomance implications: being put not just in a human body, but the body of a human teenage girl has seriously affected her judgement. Since so little is known about the exact process leading to the pony-to-human transformation (was is it a built-in property of the mirror, or one of the whole world?) it could just as well be an unintended aftereffect, or an actual feature to allow better mingling in the new world (since the portal only open for 3 days every 30 moons, ending up stuck for a long time is quite likely.)


to:

It's the most likely explanation as to why the normally serious Twilight Sparkle would crush of Flash Sentry despite the InterspeciesRomance implications: being put not just in a human body, but the body of a human teenage girl has seriously affected her judgement. Since so little is known about the exact process leading to the pony-to-human transformation (was is it a built-in property of the mirror, or one of the whole world?) it could just as well be an unintended aftereffect, side effect, or an actual feature to allow better mingling in the new world (since the portal only open for 3 days every 30 moons, ending up stuck for a long time is quite likely.)

likely).

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The book Sunset uses to communicated with Twilight in ''Rainbow Rocks'' is how Sunset knew Twilight's crown would be ripe for the taking in the first movie]]
We see in ''Rainbow Rocks'' that Sunset Shimmer had a books she used to communicate with Princess Celestia. It was a two-way book, so Celestia could also write to her. If Celestia loved Sunset as much as the first movie implied, it is likely Celestia would regularly write to her and try to convince her to come home. It is likely Celestia wrote about how she would be visiting the Crystal Empire and told Sunset about the goings on in Equestria, such as Twilight's ascension. All Sunset would have to do is calculate when the portal would open and then make her move.

to:

[[WMG: The book Sunset uses to communicated communicate with Twilight in ''Rainbow Rocks'' is how Sunset knew Twilight's crown would be ripe for the taking in the first movie]]
We see in ''Rainbow Rocks'' that Sunset Shimmer had a books book she used to communicate with Princess Celestia. It was a two-way book, so Celestia could also write to her. If Celestia loved Sunset as much as the first movie implied, it is likely Celestia would probably regularly write to her and try to convince her to come home. It is likely Celestia wrote about how she would be visiting the Crystal Empire and told Sunset about the goings on in Equestria, such as Twilight's ascension. All Sunset would have to do is calculate when the portal would open and then make her move.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The book Sunset uses to communicated with Twilight in ''Rainbow Rocks'' is how Sunset knew Twilight's crown would be ripe for the taking in the first movie]]
We see in ''Rainbow Rocks'' that Sunset Shimmer had a books she used to communicate with Princess Celestia. It was a two-way book, so Celestia could also write to her. If Celestia loved Sunset as much as the first movie implied, it is likely Celestia would regularly write to her and try to convince her to come home. It is likely Celestia wrote about how she would be visiting the Crystal Empire and told Sunset about the goings on in Equestria, such as Twilight's ascension. All Sunset would have to do is calculate when the portal would open and then make her move.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also Jossed because Shining Armor does not appear at all in the Season 4 premier. In fact, IIRC he doesn't appear in Season 4 at all except for during the episode "Equestria Games".

to:

* Also Jossed because Shining Armor does not appear at all in the Season 4 premier. In fact, IIRC he doesn't appear in Season 4 at all except for during the episode episodes "Equestria Games".
Games" and "Twilight's Kingdom, Part 2".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Jossed: Sunset is clearly ordering Snips and Snails to do something with a wicked grin on her face, and we see her gather evidence on the team during a comic. Twilight's reactions to Luna's questioning don't imply guilt
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:In the "Story of Sunset Shimmer", [[http://derpibooru.org/379257 here,]] you can see a demonic figure in the magic mirror that freaks out Sunset Shimmer. The demon then possibly decided to possess her when Sunset got her crown, but even after Sunset was defeated, the demon was waiting for the right time to appear in front of Sunset to reveal her true identity.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:In the "Story "The Fall of Sunset Shimmer", [[http://derpibooru.org/379257 here,]] you can see a demonic figure in the magic mirror that freaks out Sunset Shimmer. out.]] The demon then possibly decided to possess her when Sunset got her crown, but even after Sunset was defeated, the demon was waiting for the right time to appear in front of Sunset to reveal her true identity.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:In the "Story of Sunset Shimmer", http://derpibooru.org/379257?scope=scpe90087ae08f365dc5a7b318cf4e32411706b0d5ea you can see a demonic figure in the magic mirror that freaks out Sunset Shimmer. The demon then possibly decided to possess her when Sunset got her crown, but even after Sunset was defeated, the demon was waiting for the right time to appear in front of Sunset to reveal her true identity.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:In the "Story of Sunset Shimmer", http://derpibooru.org/379257?scope=scpe90087ae08f365dc5a7b318cf4e32411706b0d5ea [[http://derpibooru.org/379257 here,]] you can see a demonic figure in the magic mirror that freaks out Sunset Shimmer. The demon then possibly decided to possess her when Sunset got her crown, but even after Sunset was defeated, the demon was waiting for the right time to appear in front of Sunset to reveal her true identity.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer had been in Equestria for at least a few hours before stealing Twilight's (her) crown.]]
How else would she have known about the situation? If we assume that the mirror only opens once every 2½


to:

[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer had been back in Equestria for at least a few hours before stealing Twilight's (her) crown.the Crown.]]
How else would could she have known enough about the situation? everything to do what she did? If we assume that the mirror only opens once every

2½ years (itself not a given), and we know that just under one year has passed between Celestia sending Twilight to Ponyville for the first time and Twilight's Ascension, then there's no way even a highly gifted pony like Sunset could have assessed the situation and come up with a plan that quickly… unless she actually came out of the mirror before the movie started and spent time milking Cadance's guards for information.

Added: 1516

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Many of the promotional material seems to suggest something completely different than what we actually saw, and the movie seems almost like it went through a sloppy editing job or had a very rushed script. (Brad, Sunset shimmer, the conflict with Twilight being framed for trashing the gym being solved within minutes...) There's probably some kind of data on WhatCouldHaveBeen out there but we haven't been able to see it yet for some reason.

to:

* Many of the promotional material seems to suggest something completely different than what we actually saw, and the movie seems almost like it went through a sloppy editing job or had a very rushed script. (Brad, Sunset shimmer, Shimmer, the conflict with Twilight being framed for trashing the gym being solved within minutes...) There's probably some kind of data on WhatCouldHaveBeen out there but we haven't been able to see it yet for some reason.



[[WMG: The Fandom has blown the "30 Moons" phrase WAY out of proportion, and probably got it wrong.]]
Above here is a different troper assuming that when Celestia said that the Magic Mirror portal only opens once every thirty Moons for three days at a time, it means two and a half years. Leaving aside the fact that Earth's moon cycle is '''''not''''' 30 days (it's ~29½, 30 of which translates to 885 days, one calendar month less than people assume), there's still one question left unasked – Has there ever been ''any indication whatsoever'' that Equestria's moon cycle (or the EQG-verse's) is anything like Earth's? Considering that the moon over Equestria seems to always be full, does it even ''have'' a moon cycle as we would know it?

Basically, we really don't know how time or calendar-reckoning works in Equestria, so we can't assume it's equivalent to what we know, even though some of the same terms are used. Thus, fans who state authoritatively that "30 Moons" is 2½ years could easily be flat-out wrong.

What does this matter? Well, fans got angry over this movie and its sequel (mentioned elsewhere) breaking this rule in sending ponies through the portal. However, there is no proof the writers have broken any rules – even the main show is ridiculously vague about how long a "moon" is.



** It could also be that putting the mirror there was Celestia's idea, reasoning that if Sunset popped out of the mirror unexpectedly, better she be met by a Princess who ''hadn't'' banished her, and could possibly talk her down.
*** This probably would have worked… but unfortunately, Sunset had the awful timing to show up when Celestia ''and'' Luna '''''and''''' the newly-ascended Twilight were all in town together.

to:

** It could also be that putting the mirror there was Celestia's idea, reasoning that if Sunset popped out of the mirror unexpectedly, better she be met by a Princess who ''hadn't'' banished her, her and who could possibly talk her down.
*** This plan probably would have worked… but unfortunately, Sunset Shimmer had the awful timing to show up when Celestia ''and'' Luna '''''and''''' the newly-ascended Twilight were all in town together.
together. Given Sunset's hangups on Princesshood, that had to hurt.


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Sunset Shimmer had been in Equestria for at least a few hours before stealing Twilight's (her) crown.]]
How else would she have known about the situation? If we assume that the mirror only opens once every 2½

Top