Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / BrokebackMountain

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompletelyDifferentTitle: in Latin America the film is named ''Secreto en la Montaña'' (Secret in the Mountain) and in Spain the film is named ''En Terreno Vedado'' (On Off-limits Ground).

to:

* CompletelyDifferentTitle: in In Latin America America, the film is named titled ''Secreto en la Montaña'' (Secret in the Mountain) Mountain), and in Spain Spain, the film is named ''En Terreno Vedado'' (On Off-limits Ground).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CaliforniaDoubling: The movie is set in Wyoming, but it was filmed almost entirely in the Canadian Rockies in southern Alberta.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->"Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs a gay-cowboymovie]]!"

to:

--->"Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs a gay-cowboymovie]]!"gay-cowboy movie]]!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->"Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with a gay-cowboy movie!"

to:

--->"Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs a gay-cowboy movie!"gay-cowboymovie]]!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiedDuringProduction: Editor Geraldine Peroni (best known for working with Creator/RobertAltman) passed away before she could finish her work on this film. It was completed by her former assistant editor Dylan Tichenor (later of ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' fame). Both were then nominated for the UsefulNotes/{{BAFTA}} for Best Editing.

to:

* DiedDuringProduction: Editor Geraldine Peroni (best known for working with Creator/RobertAltman) passed away before she could finish her work on this film. It was completed by her former assistant editor Dylan Tichenor (later of ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' fame). Both were then nominated for the UsefulNotes/{{BAFTA}} MediaNotes/{{BAFTA}} for Best Editing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompletelyDifferentTitle: in Latin America the film is named ''Secreto en la Montaña'' (Secret in the Mountain) and in Spain the film is named ''En Terreno Vedado'' (On Off-limits Ground).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NamesTheSame: Brooklynn Proulx, who plays Jenny at age four, is not actually related to the author Annie Proulx.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorPreferredAdaptation: Annie Proulx approved of the film, saying that Heath Ledger was exactly as she'd pictured Ennis.

to:

* CreatorPreferredAdaptation: CreatorChosenCasting: Annie Proulx approved sent both stars an original, autographed copy of her story. When she signed the film, saying copy to Creator/JakeGyllenhaal, she wrote "To Jake..." but when she signed the copy she had intended to give to Creator/HeathLedger, she signed it "To Ennis". After writing out her personal message, she realized what she had done, and decided to let it be. At a private screening at Arclight in Hollywood, California, she reflected that Heath Ledger really was exactly as she'd pictured Ennis.Ennis. She left the signed copy that way, because she had felt the actor embodied Ennis in every way she had imagined him.

Added: 336

Removed: 338

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS has renamed Author Existence Failure to Died During Production. Entry changed accordingly.


* AuthorExistenceFailure: Editor Geraldine Peroni (best known for working with Creator/RobertAltman) passed away before she could finish her work on this film. It was completed by her former assistant editor Dylan Tichenor (later of ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' fame). Both were then nominated for the UsefulNotes/{{BAFTA}} for Best Editing.


Added DiffLines:

* DiedDuringProduction: Editor Geraldine Peroni (best known for working with Creator/RobertAltman) passed away before she could finish her work on this film. It was completed by her former assistant editor Dylan Tichenor (later of ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' fame). Both were then nominated for the UsefulNotes/{{BAFTA}} for Best Editing.

Changed: 10

Removed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NasalTrauma: While filming the reunion, Jake's nose was nearly broken from Heath kissing him so hard.



** When Gus Van Sant was going to direct, he offered Creator/MattDamon the role of Ennis. He turned it down, saying:

to:

** When Gus Van Sant Creator/GusVanSant was going to direct, he offered Creator/MattDamon the role of Ennis. He turned it down, saying:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigNameFan: One of Creator/DanielDayLewis' favourite films. After Creator/HeathLedger's death, he dedicated his SAG Award for ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' to Heath's memory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry =McMurtry= bought the screen adaptation rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.

to:

* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry =McMurtry= [=McMurtry=] bought the screen adaptation rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry [McMurtry] bought the screen adaptation rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.

to:

* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry [McMurtry] =McMurtry= bought the screen adaptation rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry McMurtry bought the screen rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.

to:

* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry McMurtry [McMurtry] bought the screen adaptation rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Screenwriters Diana Ossana and Larry McMurtry bought the screen rights just days after the short story was published in October 1997 (Annie Proulx strongly doubted that the story would work as a film, but she agreed to let them attempt it), and they completed the screenplay within a few months. After passing from one production team to the next (and being known as "the greatest un-produceable screenplay" going around) for six years, filming finally began in spring 2004, and the film was released nearly two years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NasalTrauma: While filming the reunion, Gyllenhaal's nose was nearly broken from Ledger kissing him so hard.

to:

* NasalTrauma: While filming the reunion, Gyllenhaal's Jake's nose was nearly broken from Ledger Heath kissing him so hard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NasalTrauma: While filming the reunion, Gyllenhaal's nose was nearly broken from Ledger kissing him so hard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwardCategoryFraud: The film gives a lot of screentime to both Creator/HeathLedger's and Creator/JakeGyllenhaal's characters, as the film covers their romance and how their lives drift off in parallel fashion during their years apart. As such, one could argue that Ennis and Jack are equally important to the story as protagonists. However, Ledger was put in the Leading Actor category, and Gyllenhaal in the Supporting Actor category, all through the awards season, because Ledger's character has just a bit more emphasis and the two actors didn't have to compete against each other.

to:

* AwardCategoryFraud: The film gives a lot of screentime to both Creator/HeathLedger's and Creator/JakeGyllenhaal's characters, as the film covers their romance and how their lives drift off in parallel fashion during their years apart. As such, one could argue that Ennis and Jack are equally important to the story as protagonists. However, Ledger was put in the Leading Actor category, and Gyllenhaal in the Supporting Actor category, category (despite him actually having more lines of dialogue), all through the awards season, because Ledger's character has just a bit more emphasis and the two actors didn't have to compete against each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActorInspiredElement: When Ennis finds his and Jack's shirts hanging in their childhood closet, Ennis's is tucked inside Jack's. At the end [[spoiler:when Ennis takes them home]], they are reversed. This was Creator/HeathLedger's idea.

to:

* ActorInspiredElement: When Ennis finds his and Jack's shirts hanging in their childhood closet, Ennis's is tucked inside Jack's. At the end [[spoiler:when Ennis takes them home]], they are reversed. This was Creator/HeathLedger's idea. Years later, when Annie Proulx was writing the libretto for the opera adaptation of her story, she included the stage direction of Ennis reversing the shirts before hanging them up.

Added: 586

Changed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example. Fixed indentation issues. Added Creator links. Fixed spoiler markup.


* ActingInTheDark: Creator/AnneHathaway claims she doesn't know if Lureen [[spoiler: is lying when she tells Ennis how Jack died]]. There were two takes filmed with differing motivations, and parts from both of them were edited together in the final film.
* ActorInspiredElement: When Ennis finds his and Jack's shirts hanging in their childhood closet, Ennis's is tucked inside Jack's. [[spoiler: At the end when Ennis takes them home]], they are reversed. This was Heath Ledger's idea.

to:

* ActingInTheDark: Creator/AnneHathaway claims she doesn't know if Lureen [[spoiler: is lying when she tells Ennis how [[spoiler:how Jack died]]. There were two takes filmed with differing motivations, and parts from both of them were edited together in the final film.
* ActorInspiredElement: When Ennis finds his and Jack's shirts hanging in their childhood closet, Ennis's is tucked inside Jack's. [[spoiler: At the end when [[spoiler:when Ennis takes them home]], they are reversed. This was Heath Ledger's Creator/HeathLedger's idea.



* AwardCategoryFraud: The film gives a lot of screentime to both Creator/HeathLedger's and Creator/JakeGyllenhaal's characters, as the film covers their romance and how their lives drift off in parallel fashion during their years apart. As such, one could argue that Ennis and Jack are equally important to the story as protagonists. However, Ledger was put in the Leading Actor category, and Gyllenhaal in the Supporting Actor category, all through the awards season, because Ledger's character has just a bit more emphasis and the two actors didn't have to compete against each other.



* BeamMeUpScotty: The film's SignatureLine is "I wish I ''knew how to'' quit you.", not "I wish I could quit you." or "I can't quit you.".

to:

* BeamMeUpScotty: The film's SignatureLine is "I wish I ''knew how to'' quit you.", you", not "I wish I could quit you." you" or "I can't quit you."."



* CreatorBacklash: [[http://leegoldberg.typepad.com/a_writers_life/2008/10/fanfic-makes-proulx-regret-writing-brokeback-mountain.html Annie Proulx has expressed regret over the story]], if only for fans who send "[[FanFic ghastly manuscripts]] and [[RuleThirtyFour pornish rewrites]] of the story to me, expecting me to reply with praise and applause for [[FixFic 'fixing' the story...]]".

to:

* CreatorBacklash: [[http://leegoldberg.typepad.com/a_writers_life/2008/10/fanfic-makes-proulx-regret-writing-brokeback-mountain.html Annie Proulx has expressed regret over the story]], if only for fans who send "[[FanFic ghastly manuscripts]] and [[RuleThirtyFour pornish rewrites]] of the story to me, expecting me to reply with praise and applause for [[FixFic 'fixing' the story...]]".]]"



* DeletedScene: They filmed a sequence where Jack and Ennis help a group of hippies get their car out of a river. WordOfGod was that they wanted to show Jack and Ennis in a heroic situation. The sequence was disliked by nearly everyone - as it doesn't appear in the original story or the screenplay - and got cut from the final film.

to:

* DeletedScene: They filmed a sequence where Jack and Ennis help a group of hippies get their car out of a river. WordOfGod was that they wanted to show Jack and Ennis in a heroic situation. The sequence was disliked by nearly everyone - as everyone--as it doesn't appear in the original story or the screenplay - and screenplay--and got cut from the final film.



* FakeAmerican: Heath Ledger (Australian) as Ennis.

to:

* FakeAmerican: Heath Ledger (Australian) Australian Creator/HeathLedger as Ennis.



* NeverWorkWithChildrenOrAnimals: Creator/AngLee had already sworn off ever making another movie featuring sheep after horrible experiences making ''Film/SenseAndSensibility''... and apparently they were even worse here.
* PlayingAgainstType: Creator/AnneHathaway as Lureen; this was one of several roles that moved her away from the ContractualPurity reputation she had at the time. Anne's agent even decided not to mention her work in ''Film/ThePrincessDiaries'' or ''Film/EllaEnchanted'', and introduced her to Ang Lee as a New York City Broadway actress. He hadn't seen any of her work beforehand and cast her based on her audition.
* RomanceOnTheSet: Heath Ledger and Michelle Williams fell in love on the set, and their daughter Matilda was born just before the film premiered.

to:

* NeverWorkWithChildrenOrAnimals: Creator/AngLee had already sworn off ever making another movie featuring sheep after horrible experiences making ''Film/SenseAndSensibility''... and apparently ''Film/SenseAndSensibility''. Apparently, they were even worse here.
* PlayingAgainstType: Creator/AnneHathaway as Lureen; this Lureen. This was one of several roles that moved her away from the ContractualPurity reputation she had at the time. Anne's agent even decided not to mention her work in ''Film/ThePrincessDiaries'' or ''Film/EllaEnchanted'', and introduced her to Ang Lee Creator/AngLee as a New York City Broadway actress. He hadn't seen any of her work beforehand and cast her based on her audition.
* RomanceOnTheSet: Heath Ledger Creator/HeathLedger and Michelle Williams Creator/MichelleWilliams fell in love on the set, and their daughter Matilda was born just before the film premiered.



-->Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with a gay-cowboy movie!

to:

-->Gus, --->"Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with a gay-cowboy movie!movie!"

Changed: 48

Removed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigNameFan: One of Creator/DanielDayLewis' favourite films. After Creator/HeathLedger's death, he dedicated his SAG Award
for ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' to Heath's memory.

to:

* BigNameFan: One of Creator/DanielDayLewis' favourite films. After Creator/HeathLedger's death, he dedicated his SAG Award
Award for ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' to Heath's memory.

Added: 924

Changed: 1547

Removed: 182

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActingInTheDark: Anne Hathaway claims she doesn't know if Lureen [[spoiler: is lying when she tells Ennis how Jack died]]. There were two takes filmed with differing motivations, and parts from both of them were edited together in the final film.

to:

* ActingInTheDark: Anne Hathaway Creator/AnneHathaway claims she doesn't know if Lureen [[spoiler: is lying when she tells Ennis how Jack died]]. There were two takes filmed with differing motivations, and parts from both of them were edited together in the final film.



* BigNameFan: One of Daniel Day Lewis's favourite films. After Heath Ledger's death, he dedicated his SAG Award for ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' to Heath's memory.

to:

* BigNameFan: One of Daniel Day Lewis's Creator/DanielDayLewis' favourite films. After Heath Ledger's Creator/HeathLedger's death, he dedicated his SAG Award Award
for ''Film/ThereWillBeBlood'' to Heath's memory.memory.
* CastTheRunnerUp: Creator/AnneHathaway was sent the script with the role of Alma in mind. But when she read it, she decided she'd rather audition for Lureen instead.



* EnforcedMethodActing: In order to get into character and really show Alma's anguish over Ennis's infidelity with Jack, Creator/MichelleWilliams asked Creator/HeathLedger, who she was dating at the time, and Creator/JakeGyllenhaal to make out behind the camera so her emotional anguish would be realistic. When they weren't passionate enough, she yelled at them.

to:

* DeletedScene: They filmed a sequence where Jack and Ennis help a group of hippies get their car out of a river. WordOfGod was that they wanted to show Jack and Ennis in a heroic situation. The sequence was disliked by nearly everyone - as it doesn't appear in the original story or the screenplay - and got cut from the final film.
* EnforcedMethodActing: In order to get into character and really show Alma's anguish over Ennis's Ennis' infidelity with Jack, Creator/MichelleWilliams asked Creator/HeathLedger, who she was dating at the time, and Creator/JakeGyllenhaal to make out behind the camera so her emotional anguish would be realistic. When they weren't passionate enough, she yelled at them.



* NeverWorkWithChildrenOrAnimals: Ang Lee had already sworn off ever making another movie featuring sheep after horrible experiences making ''Film/SenseAndSensibility''... and apparently they were even worse here.

to:

* NeverWorkWithChildrenOrAnimals: Ang Lee Creator/AngLee had already sworn off ever making another movie featuring sheep after horrible experiences making ''Film/SenseAndSensibility''... and apparently they were even worse here.



* PlayingGertrude: Heath Ledger was only four years older than Kate Mara, who played his daughter as a teenager. Granted he's supposed to be in his forties at this point in the film.



** They filmed a sequence where Jack and Ennis help a group of hippies get their car out of a river. WordOfGod was that they wanted to show Jack and Ennis in a heroic situation. The sequence was disliked by nearly everyone - as it doesn't appear in the original story or the screenplay - and got cut from the final film.
** Mark Wahlberg and Joaquin Phoenix were considered for the leads in the film. Although the former was interested, he found the script too sexually graphic, and turned it down. Joseph Gordon Levitt was also heavily considered for the role of Ennis.
** Anne Hathaway was sent the script with the role of Alma in mind. But when she read it, she decided she'd rather audition for Lureen instead.

to:

** They filmed a sequence where Jack Creator/MarkWahlberg and Ennis help a group of hippies get their car out of a river. WordOfGod was that they wanted to show Jack and Ennis in a heroic situation. The sequence was disliked by nearly everyone - as it doesn't appear in the original story or the screenplay - and got cut from the final film.
** Mark Wahlberg and Joaquin Phoenix
Creator/JoaquinPhoenix were considered for the leads in the film. Although the former was interested, he found the script too sexually graphic, and turned it down. Joseph Gordon Levitt Creator/JosephGordonLevitt was also heavily considered for the role of Ennis.
** Anne Hathaway When Gus Van Sant was sent the script with going to direct, he offered Creator/MattDamon the role of Alma in mind. But when she read it, she decided she'd rather audition Ennis. He turned it down, saying:
-->Gus, I did [[Film/TheTalentedMrRipley a gay movie]], then [[Film/AllThePrettyHorses a cowboy movie]]. I can't follow it up with a gay-cowboy movie!
** Other actors considered
for Lureen instead.the leads were Creator/BenAffleck, Creator/BillyCrudup, Creator/ColinFarrell and Creator/JoshHartnett.
** Creator/JosephFiennes loved the project so much that he met with three different directors, attached at various times, about starring in the film.
** Creator/JoelSchumacher was attached to direct at one stage.
----

Top