Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Theatre / Hamilton

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Despite not actually appearing in the musical, UsefulNotes/JohnAdams is mocked whenever whenever he is mentioned. Alexander Hamilton says that he "doesn't have a real job" as vice-president, Thomas Jefferson says that he and his administration as president is "in traction", and King George eagerly anticipates the American public eating him alive for being so much smaller as a political figure than George Washingon. The rap that Miranda wrote for Hamilton taking down [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDjvRGjIICQ Adams]], which was cut for time, is available on Website/YouTube.

to:

** Despite not actually appearing in the musical, UsefulNotes/JohnAdams is mocked whenever whenever he is mentioned. Alexander Hamilton says that he "doesn't have a real job" as vice-president, Thomas Jefferson says that he and his administration as president is "in traction", and King George eagerly anticipates the American public eating him alive for being so much smaller as a political figure than George Washingon.Washington. The rap that Miranda wrote for Hamilton taking down [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDjvRGjIICQ Adams]], which was cut for time, is available on Website/YouTube.



** George Eacker is a rude, condescending jackass who slanders Hamilton after the release of the Reynolds Pamphlet, leading to a conflict with Hamilton's son Philip. When their dispute ecalates into a duel, [[spoiler:Eacker cheats and fires at the count of seven instead of waiting for the count to be finished, shooting Philip in the back and killing him]].

to:

** George Eacker is a rude, condescending jackass who slanders Hamilton after the release of the Reynolds Pamphlet, leading to a conflict with Hamilton's son Philip. When their dispute ecalates escalates into a duel, [[spoiler:Eacker cheats and fires at the count of seven instead of waiting for the count to be finished, shooting Philip in the back and killing him]].



** "My Shot" combines this with IWantSong for Hamilton and his friends, because they use it to introduce themselvs and what they want at the same time.

to:

** "My Shot" combines this with IWantSong for Hamilton and his friends, because they use it to introduce themselvs themselves and what they want at the same time.



* SmallNameBigEgo: Jefferson would like everyone to know it's all about him, even when it comes down to comprimising his goals for realpolitik. The nicest thing he says in the aftermath of Hamilton's death is that his financial system was genius... and Jefferson smugly states he tried to remove it anyway.

to:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Jefferson would like everyone to know it's all about him, even when it comes down to comprimising compromising his goals for realpolitik. The nicest thing he says in the aftermath of Hamilton's death is that his financial system was genius... and Jefferson smugly states he tried to remove it anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RashomonStyle: The creative team effectively utilizes this with Eliza and Angelica's respective back-to-back solos "Helpless" and "Satisfied." First Eliza describes meeting Alexander and their entire courtship leading up to their wedding. As Eliza's sister Angelica provides a wedding toast, the stage "rewinds" and we witness the same time period from Angelica's point of view, giving new insight to nearly every moment in Eliza's song.

Added: 26

Changed: 154

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AstonishinglyAppropriateInterruption: In the following line, the word subject to CurseCutShort is a swear word that, when used as a verb, can be slang for "having sex with":
-->'''James Reynolds' letter to Hamilton:''' See, that was my wife you decided to- ''FUUU-''

to:

* AstonishinglyAppropriateInterruption: In the following line, line from "Say No to This", the word subject to a CurseCutShort is a swear word that, when used as a verb, can be slang for "having sex with":
having sex:
-->'''James Reynolds' letter to Hamilton:''' See, that was my wife who you decided to- ''FUUU-'' to-\\
'''Hamilton''': ''Fuuuu—''



** From "The Adams Administration": "Sit down, John, you fat motherf-- [[SoundEffectBleep bleep]]!"[[note]]Behind the bleep, Miranda is saying "you fat mother''fuckstick''"[[/note]]
** In "Say No To This", an F-bomb in Reynolds' [[spoiler: blackmail]] letter is cut off by Hamilton's groan of horror and Reynolds' own cheerful "uh-oh!" (however, in the workshop recording, it's an uninterrupted [[PrecisionFStrike "FUCK!"]] on Ham's part, cementing the double meaning even more. When Burr reads the same letter in "We Know", the curse is cut off in both versions by Jefferson's combination FlatWhat[=/=]BigWhat.
** In the recording released on Disney+ and on the clean version of the cast album, all the F-bombs are censored out.

to:

** From "The Adams Administration": "Sit down, John, you fat motherf-- [[SoundEffectBleep bleep]]!"[[note]]Behind mother--([[SoundEffectBleep bleep]])!"[[note]]Behind the bleep, Miranda is saying "you saying, "You fat mother''fuckstick''"[[/note]]
mother''fuckstick!''"[[/note]]
** In "Say No To This", an F-bomb in Reynolds' [[spoiler: blackmail]] letter is cut off by Hamilton's [[AstonishinglyAppropriateInterruption well-timed]] groan of horror and Reynolds' own cheerful "uh-oh!" (however, in the workshop recording, it's an uninterrupted [[PrecisionFStrike "FUCK!"]] on Ham's part, cementing the double meaning even more. more). When Burr reads the same letter in "We Know", the curse is cut off in both versions by Jefferson's combination FlatWhat[=/=]BigWhat.
FlatWhat[=/=]BigWhat.
** In the recording released on Disney+ and on the clean version of the cast album, all the F-bombs are censored out.censored.



-->'''Hamilton''': I've always considered you a friend.
-->'''Burr''': I don't see why that has to end.
-->'''Hamilton''': You changed parties to run against my father-in-law!

to:

-->'''Hamilton''': --->'''Hamilton''': I've always considered you a friend.
-->'''Burr''': --->'''Burr''': I don't see why that has to end.
-->'''Hamilton''': --->'''Hamilton''': You changed parties to run against my father-in-law!



** [[spoiler: During Philip's duel:]] "''[[IronicEcho One two three four]]'' ''[[spoiler:five six seven-"]]'' [[spoiler: BOOM!]]
** Burr provides a line in "The World Was Wide Enough" which shifts the audience's perspective on his duel with Hamilton: [[spoiler: This man will not make an orphan of my daughter.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: During Philip's duel:]] "''[[IronicEcho One two three four]]'' ''[[spoiler:five six One, two, three, four,]]'' ''[[spoiler:five, six, seven-"]]'' [[spoiler: BOOM!]]
** Burr provides a line in "The World Was Wide Enough" which shifts the audience's perspective on his duel with Hamilton: [[spoiler: This [[spoiler:"This man will not make an orphan of my daughter.]]"]]



** When Angelica returns during “The Reynolds Pamphlet” Alexander assumes she has come to help and support him. To which she bluntly responds [[spoiler: “I’m not here for you” and proceeds to chew him out.]]

to:

** When Angelica returns during “The Reynolds Pamphlet” Pamphlet”, Alexander assumes she has come to help and support him. To which [[spoiler:To this, she bluntly responds [[spoiler: “I’m not here for you” and proceeds to chew him out.]]



** After Hamilton candidly admits his infidelity in the Reynolds Pamphlet, he knows his political career will never recover; Angelica's arrival in New York seems like an opportunity for some sympathy. But Angelica delivers a stinging rebuke instead--she's not there to soothe Alex, she's there to comfort her devastated younger sister, whom Hamilton has just publicly humiliated.

to:

** After Hamilton candidly admits his infidelity in the Reynolds Pamphlet, he knows his political career will never recover; recover. Angelica's arrival in New York seems like an opportunity for some sympathy. But Angelica sympathy, but she delivers a stinging rebuke instead--she's not there to soothe Alex, she's there to comfort her devastated younger sister, whom Hamilton has just publicly humiliated.



'''God I hope you're satisfied'''
** Eliza herself has a whole song, "Burn", where she calls Hamilton out (albeit in absence) for not only humiliating her but straight up breaking her heart; she burns their correspondence, including the letters he wrote when courting her, and declares "You forfeit all rights to my heart/You forfeit the place in our bed/You'll sleep in your office instead," effectively ending their relationship and cutting him out of her life.

to:

'''God '''God, I hope you're satisfied'''
** Eliza herself has a whole song, "Burn", where she calls Hamilton out (albeit in absence) for not only humiliating her but straight up breaking her heart; she heart. She burns their correspondence, including the letters he wrote when courting her, and declares "You forfeit all rights to my heart/You forfeit the place in our bed/You'll sleep in your office instead," effectively ending their relationship and cutting him out of her life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Aaron Burr, Sir", Hamilton asks, "If you stand for nothing, Burr, what'll you fall for?". It takes Burr half the play to find what he wants: he wants to be in the room where it happens.

to:

** In "Aaron Burr, Sir", Hamilton asks, "If you stand for nothing, Burr, what'll what will you fall for?". It takes Burr half the play to find what he wants: he wants to be in the room where it happens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcWords: ''Many.'' Parts "Non-Stop" and most of Hamilton's part of "The World Was Wide Enough" are composed entirely of the many ArcWords clashing.

to:

* ArcWords: ''Many.'' Parts of "Non-Stop" and most of Hamilton's part of "The World Was Wide Enough" are composed entirely of the many ArcWords recurring words and phrases of the musical clashing.



** "He/I will never be satisfied," for obsession of any kind. "Satisfied" and satisfaction in general are recurrent -- duels are resolved when one party is satisfied, etc., but the word is used to refer first to Alexander and Angelica's shared restlessness. Later, Angelica sings "God, I hope you're satisfied!" to call him out on publishing the Reynolds Pamphlet.

to:

** "He/I will never be satisfied," for obsession of any kind. "Satisfied" and satisfaction in general are recurrent -- duels are resolved when one party is satisfied, etc., but the word is used to refer first to Alexander and Angelica's shared restlessness. Later, Angelica sings sings, "God, I hope you're satisfied!" to call him out on publishing the Reynolds Pamphlet.



** "The world will never be the same" and "Look around at how lucky we are to be alive right now" for the excitement of the revolution.
** "Wait for It" and "The Room Where It Happens" referring to Burr's ambitions.

to:

** "The world will never be the same" and "Look around at how lucky we are to be alive right now" for the excitement of the revolution.
** "Wait for It" it" and "The Room Where It Happens" room where it happens" referring to Burr's ambitions.



** "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story", repeated throughout the show, is the central theme of the play.

to:

** "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story", lives, who dies, who tells your story?", repeated throughout the show, is the central theme of the play.



** In "Aaron Burr, Sir", Hamilton asks "if you stand for nothing, Burr, what will you fall for?". It takes Burr half the play to find what he wants: he wants to be in [[TitleDrop the room where it happens]].
** To Hamilton, in "Non-Stop", Burr asks "How do you write like you're running out of time? ''Are'' you running out of time?"

to:

** In "Aaron Burr, Sir", Hamilton asks "if asks, "If you stand for nothing, Burr, what will what'll you fall for?". It takes Burr half the play to find what he wants: he wants to be in [[TitleDrop the room where it happens]].
happens.
** To Hamilton, in "Non-Stop", Burr asks asks, "How do you write like you're running out of time? ''Are'' you running out of time?"



* ForeignCussWord: In "Aaron Burr, Sir," Lafayette's section has him say "Tell the King 'Casse toi!'" "Casse toi" is roughly equivalent to "fuck off." "Casse toi" also addresses the king as a peer, not as an authority figure.

to:

* ForeignCussWord: In "Aaron Burr, Sir," Lafayette's section has him say "Tell the King King, 'Casse toi!'" "Casse toi" is roughly equivalent to "fuck off." "Casse toi" also addresses the king as a peer, not as an authority figure.



** "Eliiiiiiiza..."

to:

** "Eliiiiiiiza..."E-liiiiiii-za..."



* RunningGag: The many rhymes used alongside the phrase, "Burr, sir."

to:

* RunningGag: The many rhymes used alongside the phrase, phrase "Burr, sir."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Narrator''': ''And me, I'm the damn fool who shot him.''[[note]]Aaron Burr, who will fatally duel Hamilton and live to regret it.[[/note]]

to:

-->'''Narrator''': ''And me, me? I'm the damn fool who shot him.''[[note]]Aaron him!''[[note]]Aaron Burr, who will fatally duel Hamilton and live to regret it.[[/note]]



* TheReveal: "Alexander Hamilton" is introduced by a man asking how a "bastard orphan, son of a whore and a Scotsman" can grow up and become a national hero, followed by the same man narrating Hamilton's early life with help from the rest of the cast. After Hamilton has introduced himself to the audience, the cast reveal their relationships with him. Last of all, the narrator reveals his identity as well as Hamilton's future in one single line:
--> '''Narrator:''' And me? ''I'm the damn fool that '''shot him!''' ''

to:

* TheReveal: "Alexander Hamilton" is introduced by a man asking how a "bastard orphan, son of a whore and a Scotsman" can grow up and become a national hero, followed by the same man narrating Hamilton's early life with help from the rest of the cast. After Hamilton has introduced himself to the audience, the cast reveal their relationships with him. Last of all, him, culminating with the narrator reveals revealing his identity as well as and Hamilton's future ultimate fate in one a single line:
--> '''Narrator:''' And me? ''I'm the damn fool that '''shot him!''' ''him!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguously Brown wick cleaning. Characters are of the same ethnicity as the actors that play them.


* BlackVikings: Interestingly, the play makes no effort at all to match the ethnicity of its actors and actresses to those of the historical figures they play, to the point that in the televised version, a trio of three ''sisters'' have [[AmbiguouslyBrown at minimum]] two ethnicities between them.

to:

* BlackVikings: Interestingly, the play makes no effort at all to match the ethnicity of its actors and actresses to those of the historical figures they play, to the point that in the televised version, a trio of three ''sisters'' have [[AmbiguouslyBrown at minimum]] minimum two ethnicities between them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy were not Philip and Catherine Schuylers' only children, just the three oldest. There were actually 15 kids in total, though seven died in infancy. The three surviving sons would have been children in the beginning of the play, and the youngest daughter would still have been an infant. Lin-Manuel Miranda had forgotten about the brothers' existence when he wrote Angelica's line "My father has no sons," but even after he realized his mistake, he kept it to enforce the theme of Angelica being the dutiful eldest daughter.

to:

*** Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy were not Philip and Catherine Schuylers' only children, just the three oldest. There were actually 15 kids in total, though seven died in infancy. The three surviving sons would have been children in the beginning of the play, and the youngest daughter would still have been an infant. Lin-Manuel Miranda had forgotten about the brothers' existence when he wrote Angelica's line "My father has no sons," sons", but even after he realized his mistake, he kept it to enforce the theme of Angelica being the dutiful eldest daughter.



*** In real life, it was future president James Monroe who led the investigation into the Reynolds affair against Hamilton, with Jefferson working on the matter behind the scenes. However, Monroe doesn't fit into the rest of the narrative, so the already-established James Madison joins Jefferson and Burr instead. As a side effect of this, the musical also skips over the almost-duel that occurred between Monroe and Hamilton - a duel that was only prevented due to the intervention of, of all people, [[{{Irony}} Aaron Burr]].

to:

*** In real life, it was future president James Monroe who led the investigation into the Reynolds affair against Hamilton, with Jefferson working on the matter behind the scenes. However, Monroe doesn't fit into the rest of the narrative, so the already-established James Madison joins Jefferson and Burr instead. As a side effect of this, the musical also skips over the almost-duel that occurred between Monroe and Hamilton - -- a duel that was only prevented due to the intervention of, of all people, [[{{Irony}} Aaron Burr]].



** Washington's first verse in "Right Hand Man" uses alliteration as part of a shoutout to ''Theatre/ThePiratesOfPenzance''.

to:

** Washington's first verse in "Right Hand Man" uses alliteration as part of a shoutout shout-out to ''Theatre/ThePiratesOfPenzance''.



%%** Aaron Burr exchanges love letters with Theodosia while she’s still Theodosia Bartow Prevost; married to a British officer and not him.%% This trope isn't just "love letters exist"; it's the letters later being use as evidence

to:

%%** Aaron Burr exchanges love letters with Theodosia while she’s she's still Theodosia Bartow Prevost; married to a British officer and not him.%% This trope isn't just "love letters exist"; it's the letters later being use as evidence



---> '''Hamilton:''' I imagine death so much it feels more like a memory. When's it going to get me? In my sleep? Seven feet ahead of me?
** A more minor example, but 9. It's Philip's age in "Take a Break," the number he and Eliza count to in French, and the number counted to before ten in any on-screen dueling.

to:

---> '''Hamilton:''' --->'''Hamilton:''' I imagine death so much it feels more like a memory. When's it going to get me? In my sleep? Seven feet ahead of me?
** A more minor example, but 9. It's Philip's age in "Take a Break," Break", the number he and Eliza count to in French, and the number counted to before ten in any on-screen dueling.



** "Look around, look around, at how lucky we are to be alive right now" is repeated several times. At first, the first part of it is sung by Angelica, talking about how revolution is happening and they're lucky to be in New York to see it happen. Later it is sung by Eliza, regarding how they are at war and she and Hamilton are lucky to not be dead, and later it is sung by Hamilton, echoing the first meaning about how lucky they(he) are(is) to be involved in the birth of a new nation, and then it crops back up again in ''It's Quiet Uptown'' when Hamilton and Eliza are reconciling.
** "Helpless," Eliza's adoration for Hamilton, but it later means her helplessness to keep her with him, Maria's helplessness against her husband, and Alexander's own helplessness to stop his affair.

to:

** "Look around, look around, at how lucky we are to be alive right now" is repeated several times. At first, the first part of it is sung by Angelica, talking about how revolution is happening and they're lucky to be in New York to see it happen. Later it is sung by Eliza, regarding how they are at war and she and Hamilton are lucky to not be dead, and later it is sung by Hamilton, echoing the first meaning about how lucky they(he) are(is) to be involved in the birth of a new nation, and then it crops back up again in ''It's "It's Quiet Uptown'' Uptown" when Hamilton and Eliza are reconciling.
** "Helpless," "Helpless", Eliza's adoration for Hamilton, but it later means her helplessness to keep her with him, Maria's helplessness against her husband, and Alexander's own helplessness to stop his affair.



** "1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9..." References to dueling...[[{{Foreshadowing}} and to Hamilton's son]].
** "History has its eyes on you," references to the prospect of a legacy.

to:

** "1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9..." References to references dueling...[[{{Foreshadowing}} and to Hamilton's son]].
** "History has its eyes on you," you" references to the prospect of a legacy.



*** "the room where it happen(ed)" is also used to refer to the scene of Hamilton's infidelity.
** "Wait" in general is used repeatedly. Hamilton's "just you wait" mantra contrasting with Burr's "wait for it." [[spoiler:And at the end when they switch philosophies for the duel it ends tragically. Burr's final "WAIT" comes too late.]]
** "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story," repeated throughout the show, is the central theme of the play.

to:

*** "the "The room where it happen(ed)" is also used to refer to the scene of Hamilton's infidelity.
** "Wait" in general is used repeatedly. Hamilton's "just you wait" mantra contrasting with Burr's "wait for it." it". [[spoiler:And at the end when they switch philosophies for the duel it ends tragically. Burr's final "WAIT" comes too late.]]
** "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story," Story", repeated throughout the show, is the central theme of the play.



* ArtisticLicenseLaw: As mentioned on [[http://genius.com/Lin-manuel-miranda-non-stop-lyrics Genius]], both Hamilton and Burr do this in "Non-Stop:"

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: As mentioned on [[http://genius.com/Lin-manuel-miranda-non-stop-lyrics Genius]], both Hamilton and Burr do this in "Non-Stop:""Non-Stop":



-->"Like the scripture says 'Everyone shall sit under their own vine and fig tree and no one shall make them afraid.'"

to:

-->"Like the scripture says says, 'Everyone shall sit under their own vine and fig tree and no one shall make them afraid.'"



--> '''James Reynolds' letter to Hamilton''': See, that was my wife you decided to- ''FUUU-''

to:

--> '''James -->'''James Reynolds' letter to Hamilton''': Hamilton:''' See, that was my wife you decided to- ''FUUU-''



--> Sitting there useless as two shits\\

to:

--> Sitting -->Sitting there useless as two shits\\



* AttackAttackRetreatRetreat: Played with (and also PlayedForLaughs) with the Battle of Monmouth. Washington keeps saying "attack!", while [[DirtyCoward Charles Lee]] keeps saying "retreat!". [[HilarityEnsues This disorganized retreat and lack of order is what causes the Battle of Monmouth to be such a shit-show.]]

to:

* AttackAttackRetreatRetreat: Played with (and also PlayedForLaughs) with during the Battle of Monmouth. Washington keeps saying "attack!", while [[DirtyCoward Charles Lee]] keeps saying "retreat!". [[HilarityEnsues [[PlayedForLaughs This disorganized retreat and lack of order is what causes the Battle of Monmouth to be such a shit-show.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlessedWithSuck: Jefferson, you've won -- you're gonna be President! "Hurray!" And the guy you ran against is gonna be your Vice-President! "NOOOOO!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now YMMV


* AluminumChristmasTrees: Viewers might be forgiven for assuming that the joking between Elizabeth and Angelica about old-timey {{polyamory}} was entirely invented for the show. Not quite. In a letter to Eliza, she [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angelica_Schuyler_Church#Correspondence_and_personal_life apparently wrote]], "If you were as generous as the old Romans, you would lend [Alexander] to me for a little while."
** Related to this character running gag, in "Take a Break", Angelica over-analyses the grammar of Hamilton's letter and wonders whether his misplaced comma in the phrase "My dearest, Angelica" hints at feelings of romantic affection. This didn't ''exactly'' happen in real life; however, the reverse actually did, in which Hamilton joked that a misplaced comma in a letter by Angelica hinted that ''she'' was attracted to ''him''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The musical follows the life of UsefulNotes/AlexanderHamilton, the United States' first Secretary of the Treasury. Beginning with his arrival in the United States (after writing his way out of his miserable, impoverished situation in the Caribbean), it tracks his rise to power through UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution and early days of UsefulNotes/AntebellumAmerica, and his [[ForegoneConclusion inevitable fall]].

to:

The musical follows the life of UsefulNotes/AlexanderHamilton, the United States' first Secretary of the Treasury. Beginning with his arrival in the United States (after writing his way out of his miserable, impoverished situation in the Caribbean), it tracks his rise to power through UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution and the early days of UsefulNotes/AntebellumAmerica, and as well as his [[ForegoneConclusion inevitable fall]].



Inspired by the play, a variety of pop, hip-hop and R&B artists collaborated with Lin-Manuel Miranda to create ''Music/TheHamiltonMixtape'', which was released December 2, 2016, and contains demos, remixes, and covers from ''Hamilton'''s soundtrack. One year later, Miranda announced ''Music/TheHamildrops,'' a monthly release of Hamilton-related content; the first such "drop" was released December 15, 2017.

to:

Inspired by the play, a variety of pop, hip-hop and R&B artists collaborated with Lin-Manuel Miranda to create ''Music/TheHamiltonMixtape'', which was released December 2, 2016, and contains demos, remixes, and covers from ''Hamilton'''s soundtrack. One year later, Miranda announced ''Music/TheHamildrops,'' a monthly release series of Hamilton-related content; monthly-released ''Hamilton''-related content born from a scrapped second mixtape; the first such "drop" was released "drops" occurred from December 15, 2017.
2017 to December 2018.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PeriodPieceModernLanguage: The show forgoes any attempt at properly capturing the language at the time of its [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution American Revolutionary War setting]] by using modern rap, hip hop, R&B, and pop musical and sentence structure for its songs and script. The only character who speaks in period-appropriate language is Samuel Seabury in "Farmer Refuted", who is immediately owned by Hamilton's more complex verses in their CounterpointDuet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Names The Same is no longer a trope


* NamesTheSame: By virtue of this being Colonial America, many characters share names.
** Hamilton's father in law, brother in law, oldest son, youngest son, and at least one of his nephews by marriage[[note]]Angelica's oldest child[[/note]] were all named Philip. Justified, since three out of five were named for Philip Schuyler, and Philip Hamilton the Second was named for Philip Hamilton the First.
** James Madison and James Reynolds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the second cabinet battle, Jefferson argues that America needs to send troops and fight on behalf of the French revolutionaries and ends up disgusted when Hamilton argues that they should stay neutral despite how much help Lafayette gave them. Ironically, while Jefferson used his personal power to aid Lafayette and the revolutionaries as much as he could, the idea that America itself should stay neutral in the French Revolution was one of the few things the two men ever agreed on in their entire lives, albeit they went about it differently[[note]]Hamilton wanted Washington to declare neutrality, but Jefferson argued that the President, having the power to declare war, didn't have the power to "declare peace"; essentially, he wanted to stay neutral without outright staying it[[/note]].

to:

** In the second cabinet battle, Jefferson argues that America needs to send troops and fight on behalf of the French revolutionaries and ends up disgusted when Hamilton argues that they should stay neutral despite how much help Lafayette gave them. Ironically, while Jefferson used his personal power to aid Lafayette and the revolutionaries as much as he could, the idea that America itself should stay neutral in the French Revolution was one of the few things the two men ever agreed on in their entire lives, albeit they went about it differently[[note]]Hamilton differently.[[note]]Hamilton wanted Washington to declare neutrality, but Jefferson argued that the President, having the power to declare war, didn't have the power to "declare peace"; essentially, he wanted to stay neutral without outright staying it[[/note]].saying it.[[/note]]



*** In the deleted Cabinet Battle #3 (from the mix-tape), Madison is the one that stops the debate about slavery simply by quoting the Constitution's clause stating that it was already set for 1808, and that they won't debate it any more[[note]]On a historical note, who succeeded Jefferson as president? None other than James Madison himself[[/note]].

to:

*** In the deleted Cabinet Battle #3 (from the mix-tape), Madison is the one that stops the debate about slavery simply by quoting the Constitution's clause stating that it was already set for 1808, and that they won't debate it any more[[note]]On more.[[note]]On a historical note, who succeeded Jefferson as president? None other than James Madison himself[[/note]].himself.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwLookTheyReallyDoLoveEachOther: Used for the absolute heartbreaking scene of Phillip's death. Having not spoken since Alexander's affair with Reynolds, Eliza takes his hand after learning of their son's death. She resolved to preserve what remains of their story, having previously burned their letters.

Added: 578

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmugSnake: Jefferson oh so much, especially in "The Reynolds Pamphlet" and after becoming president.

to:

* SmugSnake: SmugSnake:
** King George is characterized as an abusive boyfriend to the United States. He initially takes the tone of a scolding parent at the colonies' rebellion, characterizing the American Revolution as a child's tantrum with no credible chance at success. He gets a second number after the Revolution succeeds, this time characterizing the American leadership as wholly unprepared for actually ''ruling'' their new nation, and that he'll be ready to take them back once they inevitably fail.
**
Jefferson oh so much, especially in "The Reynolds Pamphlet" and after becoming president.

Added: 1071

Changed: 679

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: To [[http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2015/09/24/hamilton_s_hip_hop_references_all_the_rap_and_r_b_allusions_in_lin_manuel.html?wpsrc=sh_all_dt_tw_top many hip-hop songs]], as well as to ''Theatre/TheLastFiveYears'', ''Theatre/ThePiratesOfPenzance'', ''Theatre/SouthPacific'', and, naturally, Theatre/SeventeenSeventySix. As well as [[Theatre/{{Macbeth}} a Scottish tragedy]] that Hamilton would [[TheScottishTrope rather not name.]] The show also includes numerous shout-outs to ''Series/TheWestWing'', including Lin-Manuel Miranda tending to put on his coat Martin Sheen style while performing as Hamilton. See [[ShoutOut/{{Hamilton}} the shout-out page]] for more details.

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
**
To [[http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2015/09/24/hamilton_s_hip_hop_references_all_the_rap_and_r_b_allusions_in_lin_manuel.html?wpsrc=sh_all_dt_tw_top many hip-hop songs]], as well as to ''Theatre/TheLastFiveYears'', ''Theatre/ThePiratesOfPenzance'', ''Theatre/SouthPacific'', and, naturally, Theatre/SeventeenSeventySix. As well as [[Theatre/{{Macbeth}} a Scottish tragedy]] that Hamilton would [[TheScottishTrope rather not name.]] The show also includes numerous shout-outs to ''Series/TheWestWing'', including Lin-Manuel Miranda tending to put on his coat Martin Sheen style while performing as Hamilton. See [[ShoutOut/{{Hamilton}} the shout-out page]] for more details.details.
** Washington's goodbye song, "One Last Time", states that the ill Founding Father is going to {{Heaven}} and wishes him well. First, Washington himself ponders about wanting to "sit under [his] own vine and fig tree", which is a biblical metaphor for Heaven. Then, the whole ensemble sings that "George Washington is going home". This idea was taken from ''Art/TheApotheosisOfWashington''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigFinaleCrowdSong: The play's final number "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story" centers around Eliza, the title character's widow, working and publishing stories to ensure that her husband's legacy lives on; but it also explains what happened with the surviving characters after Hamilton's death: Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Angelica, even Aaron Burr.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallNameBigEgo: Jefferson would like everyone to know it's all about him, even when it comes down to comprimising his goals for realpolitik. The nicest thing he says in the aftermath of Hamilton's death is that his financial system was genius... and Jefferson tried to remove it, anyway.

to:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Jefferson would like everyone to know it's all about him, even when it comes down to comprimising his goals for realpolitik. The nicest thing he says in the aftermath of Hamilton's death is that his financial system was genius... and Jefferson smugly states he tried to remove it, it anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Jefferson would like everyone to know it's all about him, even when it comes down to comprimising his goals for realpolitik. The nicest thing he says in the aftermath of Hamilton's death is that his financial system was genius... and Jefferson tried to remove it, anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


* BigBadSlippage: Burr doesn't start off the musical as bad, or even much antagonistic towards Alexander, with their relationship being VitriolicBestBuds at worst. Yes, they butt heads often but they remain amicable. It isn't until "The Election of 1800" where Hamilton endorses Jefferson over Burr that the latter completes his transformation into the main antagonist.

to:

* BigBadSlippage: Burr doesn't start off the musical as bad, or even much antagonistic towards Alexander, with their relationship being VitriolicBestBuds at worst. Yes, they butt heads often but they remain amicable. It isn't until "The Election of 1800" where Hamilton endorses Jefferson over Burr that the latter completes his transformation into the main antagonist.antagonist, triggering an increasing cold war of slights and backhanded deals that culminates in a duel.



* BlackVikings: Interestingly, the play makes no effort at all to match the ethnicity of it's actors and actresses to those of the historical figures they play, to the point that in the televised version, a trio of three ''sisters'' have [[AmbiguouslyBrown at minimum]] two ethnicities between them.

to:

* BlackVikings: Interestingly, the play makes no effort at all to match the ethnicity of it's its actors and actresses to those of the historical figures they play, to the point that in the televised version, a trio of three ''sisters'' have [[AmbiguouslyBrown at minimum]] two ethnicities between them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Do not cut examples without an edit reason at minimum. If the issue is their length, then trim them; do not remove them with no reason given


** Hercules Mulligan ''was'' a spy, but so was his slave Cato, who was AdaptedOut of the musical since it would be awkward to have John Laurens sing about abolition when one of his drinking buddies happens to own a slave. Also ironic is that the spy who was actually responsible for giving Washington the information necessary to win at Yorktown and thus end the war was not Mulligan but another slave named James Armistead.[[note]]Doubly ironic is that Armistead later added "Lafayette" to his name because of the Frenchman's tireless efforts to secure his freedom after the war, while in the play Lafayette's abolitionism remains implied at best.[[/note]]



%%* SirSwearsALot: Act One has Hercules Mulligan; Act Two has Philip.

to:

%%* * SirSwearsALot: Relative to the other characters at least; Act One has Hercules Mulligan; Act Two has Philip.


Added DiffLines:

* TheThemeParkVersion: ''Hamilton'' has been criticized in more than a few quarters for trafficking in [[https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2003/09/founders-chic/302773/ Founders' Chic]]"; merely repackaging familiar stereotypes about the founders (UsefulNotes/GeorgeWashington the HumbleHero[[note]]He was considerably ambitious personally and well aware of how famous he was but it was mainly decorum at the time that compelled him to put on a humble personality and airs of non-partisanship when he was in fact a major wheeler-dealer property owner[[/note]], UsefulNotes/ThomasJefferson the Hypocrite[[note]]Which is accurate but it's an accusation that few held against him at the time, and one which many others of his era were equally guilty of[[/note]], Aaron Burr, an usurping and ambitious man without loyalty[[note]]A portrayal that owes itself to slander printed against Burr by Hamilton and Jefferson, eliminating the fact that he played a key role in abolishing slavery in New York State, was the most pro-women's rights among the founders and founded a bank to help the immigrant and new settler cheap loans to get a start[[/note]]) that was criticized by historians [[https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/03/30/liberals-love-alexander-hamilton-but-aaron-burr-was-a-real-progressive-hero/ Nancy Isenberg]], [[https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/11/theater/hamilton-and-history-are-they-in-sync.html Sean Willentz]] among others. Most notably, the show cultivates sympathy for its protagonist, UsefulNotes/AlexanderHamilton, [[http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/culturebox/2016/04/a_hamilton_critic_on_why_the_musical_isn_t_so_revolutionary.html by arguing that he was an abolitionist based on highly selective interpretation of loose facts]], and prominently ignoring parts of history that belie that claim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hercules Mulligan ''was'' a spy, but so was his slave Cato, who was AdaptedOut of the musical since it would be awkward to have John Laurens sing about abolition when one of his drinking buddies happens to own a slave. Also ironic is that the spy who was actually responsible for giving Washington the information necessary to win at Yorktown and thus end the war was not Mulligan but another slave named James Armistead. Doubly ironic is that Armistead later added "Lafayette" to his name because of the Frenchman's tireless efforts to secure his freedom after the war, while in the play Lafayette's abolitionism remains implied at best.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And in both songs, Hamilton's first words to Washington are almost exactly the same: In "Right Hand Man", he says, "Your Excellency, you wanted to see me?" and in "One Last Time", it's "Mr. President, you asked to see me?"

to:

** *** And in both songs, Hamilton's first words to Washington are almost exactly the same: In "Right Hand Man", he says, "Your Excellency, you wanted to see me?" and in "One Last Time", it's "Mr. President, you asked to see me?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And in both songs, Hamilton's first words to Washington are almost exactly the same: In "Right Hand Man", he says, "Your Excellency, you wanted to see me?" and in "One Last Time", it's "Mr. President, you asked to see me?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
IUEO only


* AwesomeMcCoolname: ''Hercules Mulligan''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The real King George III was considered to be a fairly benevolent monarch for his time, and most of the repressive policies blamed on him were the doing of George's ministers and Parliament; in the play, however, he's a CardCarryingVillain tyrant. Given his LargeHam tendencies, this was likely done for RuleOfFunny.

to:

** The real King George III was considered to be a fairly benevolent monarch for his time, and most of the repressive policies blamed on him were the doing of George's ministers and Parliament; in the play, however, he's a CardCarryingVillain tyrant. Given his LargeHam tendencies, this was likely done for RuleOfFunny. In addition, he's usually portrayed as a PsychopathicManchild already in the throes of insanity; that didn't happen until after the War of Independence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArsonMurderAndAdmiration: In "The Room Where It Happens," Aaron Burr despite himself is impressed at the gambit that Alexander Hamilton implemented to get his votes. Hamilton asked to meet Jefferson and Madison for dinner, and offered for them to decide where the state capital and the national banks would be located. Jefferson and Madison realized that the location of the capital wouldn't matter. Burr's horrified that Alexander sold the state capital in exchange for that, but points out that while it was an uncool move, Alexander ended up getting more out of the deal. 

to:

* ArsonMurderAndAdmiration: In "The Room Where It Happens," Aaron Burr despite himself is impressed at the gambit that Alexander Hamilton implemented to get his votes. Hamilton asked to meet Jefferson and Madison for dinner, and offered for them to decide where the state capital and the national banks capital would be located. Jefferson and Madison realized accepted that it would be in the location south, between Virginia and Maryland, instead of the capital wouldn't matter. a northern urban center like New York or Boston. In exchange, he gets his central bank plan through. Burr's horrified that Alexander sold the state capital in exchange for that, but points out that while it was an uncool move, Alexander ended up getting more out of the deal. 
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A defining aspect of the musical is that this is all told through a blend of hip-hop, R&B, pop, and contemporary show tunes, which, like those of [[Theatre/InTheHeights Miranda's previous Broadway excursion]], will be [[SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic hard-pressed to leave your head]]. From the musical's origins in the late 2000s, Miranda pitched Hamilton as "someone [that] embodies hip-hop", stating that his story of rising from squalor through his writing is not dissimilar to the classic RagsToRiches tale integral to the genre.

to:

A defining aspect of the musical is that this is all told through a blend of hip-hop, R&B, pop, pop and contemporary show tunes, tunes which, like those of [[Theatre/InTheHeights Miranda's previous Broadway excursion]], will be [[SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic hard-pressed to leave your head]]. From the musical's origins in the late 2000s, Miranda pitched Hamilton as "someone [that] embodies hip-hop", stating that his story of rising from squalor through his writing is not dissimilar to the classic RagsToRiches tale integral to the genre.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheThemeParkVersion: ''Hamilton'' has been criticized in more than a few quarters for trafficking in [[https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2003/09/founders-chic/302773/ Founders' Chic]]"; merely repackaging familiar stereotypes about the founders (UsefulNotes/GeorgeWashington the HumbleHero[[note]]He was considerably ambitious personally and well aware of how famous he was but it was mainly decorum at the time that compelled him to put on a humble personality and airs of non-partisanship when he was in fact a major wheeler-dealer property owner[[/note]], UsefulNotes/ThomasJefferson the Hypocrite[[note]]Which is accurate but it's an accusation that few held against him at the time, and one which many others of his era were equally guilty of[[/note]], Aaron Burr, an usurping and ambitious man without loyalty[[note]]A portrayal that owes itself to slander printed against Burr by Hamilton and Jefferson, eliminating the fact that he played a key role in abolishing slavery in New York State, was the most pro-women's rights among the founders and founded a bank to help the immigrant and new settler cheap loans to get a start[[/note]]) that was criticized by historians [[https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/03/30/liberals-love-alexander-hamilton-but-aaron-burr-was-a-real-progressive-hero/ Nancy Isenberg]], [[https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/11/theater/hamilton-and-history-are-they-in-sync.html Sean Willentz]] among others. Most notably, the show cultivates sympathy for its protagonist, UsefulNotes/AlexanderHamilton, [[http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/culturebox/2016/04/a_hamilton_critic_on_why_the_musical_isn_t_so_revolutionary.html by arguing that he was an abolitionist based on highly selective interpretation of loose facts]], and prominently ignoring parts of history that belie that claim.
-->'''[[http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/culturebox/2016/04/a_hamilton_critic_on_why_the_musical_isn_t_so_revolutionary.html Lyra Monteiro]]:''' This is a way that writers of [[HollywoodHistory popular history]] (and some academic historians) represent the founders as [[CoolPeopleRebelAgainstAuthority relatable, cool guys]]. Founders Chic tends to really downplay the involvement of the Founding Fathers in slavery, and this play does that 100 percent. ... So the 12th line of the play where it’s mentioned, “he struggled and kept his guard up” is the line right after talking about slaves being slaughtered and carted away. But we have [[RiddleForTheAges no idea what Alexander Hamilton’s attitude]] toward slavery was when he was a boy growing up in the Caribbean. He worked on a slave ship. I mean, chances are probably pretty high that he was in favor of it; that was his livelihood. So few white people were opposed to slavery, especially white people in the Caribbean. It’s kind of bonkers to suggest that he was somehow suffering and feeling like slavery was an injustice at that time.

Top