Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / ThirteenReasonsWhy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The lead-up to her parents finding her is... heartbreaking. You hear Mrs. Baker, asking Hannah about the water leaking from under the door and jokingly commenting about it, but when she opens the door, her face just... drops. There's no scream or terror at first -- just her quietly processing what happened with [[RapidFireNo a flurry of]] [[LittleNo small "no"s]] as she carefully approaches the tub and tries to pull Hannah out, all while telling her she's going to be okay before crying out for her husband, all while still telling Hannah's lifeless body that she's okay]][[note]]She is basically in denial, and is trying to convince herself that Hannah is still alive[[/note]]. Mr. Baker's reaction is ''worse'', as he just tries to grab his daughter before his wife tells him to go call an ambulance. Just...[[AdultFear every parent's fear of finding their children dead]].

to:

** The lead-up to her parents finding her is... heartbreaking. You hear Mrs. Baker, asking Hannah about the water leaking from under the door and jokingly commenting about it, but when she opens the door, her face just... drops. There's no scream or terror at first -- just her quietly processing what happened with [[RapidFireNo a flurry of]] [[LittleNo small "no"s]] as she carefully approaches the tub and tries to pull Hannah out, all while telling her she's going to be okay before crying out for her husband, all while still telling Hannah's lifeless body that she's okay]][[note]]She is basically in denial, and is trying to convince herself that Hannah is still alive[[/note]]. Mr. Baker's reaction is ''worse'', as he just tries to grab his daughter before his wife tells him to go call an ambulance. Just...[[AdultFear [[OutlivingOnesOffspring every parent's fear of finding their children dead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The lead-up to her parents finding her is... Heartbreaking. You hear Mrs. Baker, asking Hannah about the water leaking from under the door and jokingly commenting about it, but when she opens the door, her face just... drops. There's no scream or terror at first: Just her quietly processing what happened with [[LittleNo small no's]] as she carefully approaches the tub and tries to pull Hannah out, all while telling her she's going to be okay [[DespairEventHorizon before crying out for her husband and still telling Hannah's lifeless body that she's okay]][[note]]She is basically in denial, and is trying to convince herself that Hannah is still alive[[/note]]. Mr. Baker's reaction is ''worse'', as he just tries to grab his daughter and just gets told by Mrs. Baker to go call an ambulance. Just... [[AdultFear every parent's fear of finding their children dead]].

to:

** The lead-up to her parents finding her is... Heartbreaking.heartbreaking. You hear Mrs. Baker, asking Hannah about the water leaking from under the door and jokingly commenting about it, but when she opens the door, her face just... drops. There's no scream or terror at first: Just first -- just her quietly processing what happened with [[RapidFireNo a flurry of]] [[LittleNo small no's]] "no"s]] as she carefully approaches the tub and tries to pull Hannah out, all while telling her she's going to be okay [[DespairEventHorizon before crying out for her husband and husband, all while still telling Hannah's lifeless body that she's okay]][[note]]She is basically in denial, and is trying to convince herself that Hannah is still alive[[/note]]. Mr. Baker's reaction is ''worse'', as he just tries to grab his daughter and just gets told by Mrs. Baker before his wife tells him to go call an ambulance. Just... [[AdultFear every parent's fear of finding their children dead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking Not So Different per TRS as it is now a disambig.


** Even ''worse'' is the flashback: After Hannah drops her note to Zach, deducing that [[NotSoDifferent he's lonely like she (and by some extent, majority of the school) is]], she watches Zach go through the small rack-bag and pull out the note and begins to read it out of the class. When she slowly follows him, she 'sees' him ''ripping the note'']]. Hannah's reaction well...it's [[BrokenBird like everything else that she's endured.

to:

** Even ''worse'' is the flashback: After Hannah drops her note to Zach, deducing that [[NotSoDifferent he's lonely like she (and by some extent, majority of the school) is]], is, she watches Zach go through the small rack-bag and pull out the note and begins to read it out of the class. When she slowly follows him, she 'sees' him ''ripping the note'']]. Hannah's reaction well...it's [[BrokenBird like everything else that she's endured.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** His emotional breakdown in the hallway is heartwrenching to witness. Dylan Minnette's raw emotion in his performance makes the scene all the more tragic.
-->'''Clay:''' What the fuck? What the actual fuck are you thinking?!
-->'''Principal Bolan:''' Clay, would you take a seat in my office, please?
-->'''Clay:''' No, I will not "take a seat in your office"! You think this is the way to make us safe? You know what would make me feel safe? Not having to go to a school with metal detectors, or video cameras, or ''armed fucking guards!''
-->(students start to gather around)
-->'''Principal Bolan:''' (stutters) Uh, there's still class, folks. The bell has not rung yet.
-->'''Clay:''' No, you are killing us! You are killing us! Don't you get that?! You made a drill with gunshots, and hammer down the door, to prepare us for what exactly? For how what it feels like to be hunted? To practice getting ready to die? To make us afraid for our lives? We already know how that feels! You're scaring us to death! Every day! Every day! ''Every day!''
-->'''Officer:''' Son...
-->'''Clay:''' '''''I AM NOT YOUR GODDAMN SON! GET THE FUCK AWAY FROM ME!''''' We're children! We're kids! We should be living our fucking lives instead of practicing how to cheat death! Because you know what?! Everybody fucking dies! ''Everybody dies!'' So please! Please, let us live!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Sheri, discussing her assault while at the juvenile detention facility, by a guard who allegedly "had a reputation.

to:

*** Sheri, discussing her assault while at the juvenile detention facility, by a guard who allegedly "had a reputation.reputation".



*** Made even worse at the fact that all of the confessions (minus Jessica) are more than likely [[ImagineSpot Imagine Spots]].

to:

*** Made even worse at the fact that all of the confessions (minus Jessica) are more than likely [[ImagineSpot Imagine Spots]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Crosses over with NightmareFuel, but the entire scene with Montgomery and his friends assualting Tyler in the bathroom, culminating in raping him with a mop handle. The complete lack of shame of the attackers and the extent of the physical and mental trauma just make it worse.

to:

** Crosses over with NightmareFuel, but the entire scene with Montgomery and his friends assualting Tyler in the bathroom, culminating in raping him with a mop handle. Despite Tyler having a kinder attitude and apologizing for his actions, he has his head brutally bashed against the mirror (hard enough to break it), the sink (multiple times), his head dunked in the toilet all before the actual rape happens (and he’s still apologizing as this happens) The complete lack of shame of the attackers and the extent of the physical and mental trauma just make it worse.worse. MsMojo even ranked it as the most heartbreaking scene in the entire show.



** Tyler even told his rape by Monty to Bryce who is shocked speechless and genuinely apologizes to him for the pain Monty caused him.

to:

** Tyler even told his rape by Monty to Bryce who is [[EvenEvilHasStandards shocked speechless and genuinely apologizes to him for the pain Monty caused him.him]].



** Even if he was still scummy especially to Zach his quote "I want to change but the world won't let me" ''can'' be heartwrenching.
** Hell some of his last words. While he ''really'' shouldn't have been spiteful to Zach (which caused his death afterwards) he also lashes out at Jessica who was one of the people he genuinely wanted to make amends with. The pain in his voice is visible.
* Bryce's mother grieving. She never excuses Bryce's actions but Bryce is still her son. His funeral being crashed didn't help.

to:

** Even if he was still scummy especially to Zach (and to a much lesser extent Clay) his quote "I want "I’m trying to change be better but the this fucking world won't let me" ''can'' be heartwrenching.
** Hell some of his last words. While he ''really'' shouldn't have been spiteful to Zach (which caused his death afterwards) afterwards), it could be seen a stronger somewhat understandable considering Zach beat him within an inch of his life, left him for dead and Bryce’s was in extreme pain. But then he also lashes out at Jessica who was one of the people he genuinely wanted to make amends with. The pain in his voice is visible.
* Bryce's mother grieving. She never excuses Bryce's actions but Bryce is still her son. Despite the two improving their relationship and showing how much they truly loved each other, his son is murdered (and she knows it happened brutally too as she is told about the blood on the ground). His funeral being crashed didn't help.



* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was.

to:

* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic homophobic, abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Something worthy to note, though, is that when Hannah was leaving the building, light could be seen from outside, implying that she was in Heaven. But when Monty is leaving the building, it is dark outside, implying that he is going to Hell to be punished for his actions. Not that he doesn't deserve it, but it is still pretty creepy to think about it.

to:

** Something worthy to note, though, is that when Hannah was leaving the building, light could be seen from outside, implying that she was in Heaven. But when Monty is leaving the building, it is leaves, it's dark outside, outside (minus the street lights being on), implying that he is going to Hell to be punished for his actions. Not that he doesn't deserve it, but it is still pretty creepy to think about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Grace Saif (Ani) having to delete her social media after being harassed by fans and viewers who disliked her character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from fans, with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.

to:

* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from fans, with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption.character. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Mrs. Baker''': No mater how many reasons there might be "Why", there are '''''always''''' more "Why Not"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Something worthy to note, though, is that when Hannah was leaving the building, light could be seen from outside, implying that she was in Heaven. But when Monty is leaving the building, it is dark outside, implying that he is going to Hell to be punished for his actions. Not that he doesn't deserve it, but it is still pretty creepy to think about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was (and if he wasn't terrible himself).

to:

* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was (and if he wasn't terrible himself).
was.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder]]
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* Dean Foundry (who was revealed in the penultimate episode to be gay) showing empathy for Justin's death , mentioning how he lost many friends because of the AIDS epidemic. Watching a young man killed by the disease must have really brought him back to that time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Though in his Estella's case, there is a tragedy as she admits to Tyler, while she will never be able to forgive Monty for what he did to him, she still loved her brother, and misses him.

to:

** Though in his Estella's [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes sister Estella's]] case, there is a tragedy as she admits to Tyler, while she will never be able to forgive Monty for what he did to him, she still loved her brother, and misses him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Disgusting as it is, some of the jocks, particularly Diego, even after learning his deeds as a rapist, still try to honor Monty, all of them wearing his jersey. Clay, rightfully so, loses his shit at seeing this.
** Though in his Estella's case, there is a tragedy as she admits to Tyler, while she will never be able to forgive Monty for what he did to him, she still loved her brother, and misses him.


Added DiffLines:

* Clay and Jess, essential the two great loves of Justin's life, sitting together, with clasped hands, in silence before his casket.

Added: 714

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Clay's gradual mental erosion, to the point that after having a mental breakdown after the ill timed code red shooter drill at skill, he is restrained and boud to a bed in a psychiatric facility. Watching Clay, after an orderly forgot to release him from his restraints, admit that he defecated in his hospital bed while sobbing is one of the lowest points in the series.

to:

* Clay's gradual mental erosion, to the point that after having a mental breakdown after the ill timed code red shooter drill at skill, he is restrained and boud bound to a bed in a psychiatric facility. Watching Clay, after an orderly forgot to release him from his restraints, admit that he defecated in his hospital bed while sobbing is one of the lowest points in the series.series.
* Winston's last dance with 'Monty'. At the prom, he turns and sees Monty beckoning him over. The two dance together and Monty tells him they could never have danced together and Winston tells him that he loves him. Monty reminds him that they didn't really know each other and he wouldn't have let Winston love him. Winston tells him he didn't even get a chance and the two embrace, before Monty walks away. We get a glimpse here of who Monty could've been if he hadn't been so broken and twisted. Just a boy who wanted to be loved.
** It helps that the framing of the scene, particularly with Monty walking out the doors as Winston watches, is shockingly similar to Hannah leaving Clay after her memorial service.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Clay's gradual mental erosion, to the point that after having a mental breakdown after the ill timed code red shooter drill at skill, he is restrained and boud to a bed in a psychiatric facility. Watching Clay, after an orderly forgot to release him from his restraints, admit that he defecated in his hospital bed while sobbing is one of the lowest points in the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Season 4]]
* Justin's death. After four seasons of watching him try to redeem himself and seeing him finally get his life on track with getting sober plans for college, it's revealed that he picked up HIV while living on the streets. He refused to get tested out of shame, and it developed into AIDS that killed him. He spends weeks in the hospital on a ventilator as all of his friends come say goodbye.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The subplot about Tony's family. Due to Tony testifying making it harder for Bryce, Bryce's father rats on the Padillas and ICE takes everyone but Tony and his little sister Graciela from the family to a detention center. They are deported and Tony has to send Graciela to an aunt and uncle so she would be safe. Accentuated by Tony and Graciela standing in front of the mirror next to each other, saying the names of their parents and their brothers as they appear behind them in the mirror.

to:

* The subplot about Tony's family. Due to Tony testifying making it harder for Bryce, Bryce's father rats on the Padillas and ICE takes everyone but Tony and his little sister Graciela Graciella from the family to a detention center. They Despite Tony doing everything he could and doing his best to pay for lawyers (even selling his famous red Mustang and to Bryce of all people), they are deported during the summer and Tony has to send Graciela Graciella to an aunt and uncle (which he references by saying a piece of his heart is in Arizona) so she would be safe. Accentuated by Tony and Graciela Graciella standing in front of the mirror next to each other, saying the names of their parents and their brothers as they appear behind them in the mirror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The song "The Night We Met" by Lord Huron is a tearfully bitter ode to a long lost lover and his unrequited feelings to her, just like Clay's realization he loved her.... but will never get the chance to tell Hannah that he was in love with her.

to:

* The song "The Night We Met" by Lord Huron is a tearfully bitter ode to a long lost lover and his unrequited feelings to her, just like Clay's realization he loved her.... but will never get the chance to tell Hannah that he was in love with her. It's made even worse when this song was used for [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=340hErriHlg Season 4's first teaser, bidding farewell to the cast for the final season]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** To those contemplating taking their lives, Reason 11 is always true.

Added: 382

Changed: 219

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* With the knowledge that Bryce was ''trying'' to make amends to the people he hurt in the past and that he was getting help from Mr. Porter, his death ''can'' be considered this. Emphasis on ''can''.
* Bryce's mother grieving. She never excuses Bryce's actions but Bryce is still her son.

to:

* With the knowledge that Bryce was ''trying'' to make amends to the people he hurt in the past and that he was getting help from Mr. Porter, his death ''can'' be considered this. this (the way he died being utterly cruel). Emphasis on ''can''.''can'' though.
** Even if he was still scummy especially to Zach his quote "I want to change but the world won't let me" ''can'' be heartwrenching.

** Hell some of his last words. While he ''really'' shouldn't have been spiteful to Zach (which caused his death afterwards) he also lashes out at Jessica who was one of the people he genuinely wanted to make amends with. The pain in his voice is visible.
* Bryce's mother grieving. She never excuses Bryce's actions but Bryce is still her son. His funeral being crashed didn't help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tyler even told his rape by Monty to Bryce who is shocked speechless and genuinely apologizes to him for the pain Monty caused him.

Added: 201

Changed: 32

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* With the knowledge that Bryce was ''trying'' to make amends to the people he hurt in the past and that he was getting help from Mr. Porter, his death ''can'' be considered this. Emphasis on ''can''.



* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was.

to:

* As terrible as he is, Monty getting a final rebuke (as in getting spat in his face) from his homophobic abusive father before being killed in his jail cell, is pretty disquieting. Considering his scenes with him being intimate with Winston are the only times on the show where he looked genuinely happy, one could wonder just how he would’ve turned out had he not been abused and shamed for who he was.
was (and if he wasn't terrible himself).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumb fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.

to:

* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumb fans]], fans, with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumb actually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.

to:

* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumb actually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumbactually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption.

to:

* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumbactually [[FanDumb actually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption. When an interviewer had him read the response of a fan who essentially said "I know you're a good person even though you play a monster", he actually started crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, Tyler showing Jessica the video he created before him attempting to shoot up the school dance. His facial expression is completely different to his season 3 version showing how broken and angry he is. He only says goodbye to three people in the video (his parents and Alex) further showing how alone he feels he is. To top it off Jessica crys during the video knowing the pain he was going through and likely knowing she had some role in rejecting him during the first two seasons.

to:

** Also, Tyler showing Jessica the video he created before him attempting to shoot up the school dance. His facial expression is completely different to his season 3 version showing how broken and angry he is. He only says goodbye to three people in the video (his parents and Alex) further showing how alone he feels he is. To top it off Jessica crys cries during the video knowing the pain he was going through and likely knowing she had some role in rejecting him during the first two seasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumbactually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character.

to:

* Justin Prentice (Bryce) got a lot of hate from viewers and [[FanDumbactually fans]], with many going as far as accusing him of being an actual rapist like his character.character with even Prentice himself saying that Bryce was beyond redemption.

Top