Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / TheDresdenFiles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The reaction of the bulk of the book fans when the show started.

Changed: 2

Removed: 350

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved YMMV tropes to here


* AdaptationDecay: To the point where it was pretty much InNameOnly.



* BreakoutCharacter: Bob, who in the books was a talking skull whose sole purpose was exposition and comic relief, whereas in the show he's an angsty ghost with a backstory. YourMileageMayVery as to whether this was a good or bad change. See below.
* BrokenBase: The fandom is vehemently torn over whether Book Bob is better than TV Bob, and generally over whether the show is a good adaptation of the books.

to:

* BreakoutCharacter: Bob, who in the books was a talking skull whose sole purpose was exposition and comic relief, whereas in the show he's an angsty ghost with a backstory. YourMileageMayVery YourMileageMayVary as to whether this was a good or bad change. See below.
* BrokenBase: The fandom is vehemently torn over whether Book Bob is better than TV Bob, and generally over whether the show is a good adaptation of the books.
below.



* {{Discontinuity}}: For many book fans. Others just pretend it's an AlternateUniverse.



* TooGoodToLast: Damn you, SyFy.....

Added: 156

Changed: 8

Removed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Discontinuity'': For many book fans. Others just pretend it's an AlternateUniverse.

to:

* ''Discontinuity'': {{Discontinuity}}: For many book fans. Others just pretend it's an AlternateUniverse.



* LighterandSofter: Than the books, which had scarier villains, darker themes and more death and pain. But in its defense, it was still on its first season.



* SofterandLighter: Than the books. Though in it's defense, it was still on its first season.

Added: 1470

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDecay: To the point where it was pretty much InNameOnly.
* AdaptationDyeJob: Murphy goes from blonde in the books to brunette in the show, while Susan goes from brunette to blonde.



* BreakoutCharacter: Bob, who in the books was a talking skull whose sole purpose was exposition and comic relief, whereas in the show he's an angsty ghost with a backstory. YourMileageMayVery as to whether this was a good or bad change. See below.
* BrokenBase: The fandom is vehemently torn over whether Book Bob is better than TV Bob, and generally over whether the show is a good adaptation of the books.



* ''Discontinuity'': For many book fans. Others just pretend it's an AlternateUniverse.
* EvilUncle: Justin, who was just an EvilMentor in the books.



* GirloftheWeek: Harry has these, a stark contrast to his book counterpart.



* InNameOnly: Harry, Murphy, Morgan, Bob and Ancient Mai share the same names as their book counterparts, but otherwise their characters are completely different. Same with the show itself - it has the same name as the books, but the plot and concept have been changed.



** In the books he carries a magically reinforced staff and blasting rod. In the show he has..... [[EpicFail a hockey stick and a drumstick.]]



* RaceLift: Short, blonde Irish Karrin Murphy became Connie Murphy in favour of a Cuban-American actress. It works. Susan Rodriguez goes the opposite direction, switching from a tall, Hispanic woman to a short (Well, shorter than Dresden), blonde woman.

to:

* RaceLift: Short, blonde Irish Karrin Murphy became Connie Murphy in favour of a Cuban-American actress. It works. Susan Rodriguez goes the opposite direction, switching from a tall, Hispanic woman to a short (Well, shorter than Dresden), blonde woman. Morgan goes from old white guy to youngish black man.


Added DiffLines:

* ShallowLoveInterest: Arguably, Susan, since she doesn't have much of a purpose, like she did in the books.


Added DiffLines:

* SofterandLighter: Than the books. Though in it's defense, it was still on its first season.


Added DiffLines:

* TooGoodToLast: Damn you, SyFy.....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adaption Displacement is when no one knows it was something else first, what you describe is In Name Only. Also both tropes are YMMY and don\'t belong on the main page. And I would argue that the series is actually more close to the source material than people realize.


* AdaptationDisplacement: Oh so much, that most of it is InNameOnly, along with the concept, which is pretty general as it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDisplacement: Oh so much, that most of it is InNameOnly, along with the concept, which is pretty general as it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenHero: Harry is feared and hated by his own kind and distrusted by normals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCommandments: The Seven Laws of Magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HauntedFetter: Bob is bound to his skull.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AffectionateNickname: Harry calls Hrothbert of Bainbridge 'Bob'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Beam-O-War: Fired from Harry's trusty hockey-stick.

to:

* Beam-O-War: BeamOWar: Fired from Harry's trusty hockey-stick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Beam-O-War: Fired from Harry's trusty hockey-stick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeHelpTheHelpless: Harry does what he does 'Because I can.'

to:

* WeHelpTheHelpless: Harry does what he does 'Because I can.''
* YouHaveToBelieveMe: Harry says this a ''lot'' to both wizards and mundanes. Mostly they don't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IsThatWhatTheyreCallingItNow: Bob's reaction to Harry's attempt to explain why he kissed Murphy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.

to:

* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.humans.
* WeHelpTheHelpless: Harry does what he does 'Because I can.'

Changed: 241

Removed: 856

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Law examples are not to be listed on a works main page, not a subversion/double subversion, and what examples of Idiot Ball were you thinking of?


* YouFailLawForever: Several people are arrested or threatened with arrest for murder in cases where a conviction would be impossible, because the victims were killed via supernatural means. For example, the killer in "Hair of the Dog" is poisoning werewolves by getting them to inhale powdered silver. No coroner in the country would testify that cardiac arrest was caused by breathing in powdered silver.



* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Harry. Lampshaded and double-subverted in "Rules of Engagement":
** Lampshaded when Bob grills Harry on why he is still involved in the case, even though he's not being paid, the murder victim has turned out to be a demon, and the girl he's trying to save gave him a TapOnTheHead rather than be rescued.
** Subverted when it turns out that Harry's meddling has an actually been making things worse.
** Double-subverted when he puts everything right in the end.

to:

* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Harry. Lampshaded and double-subverted in "Rules of Engagement":
** Lampshaded when
Engagement": Bob grills Harry on why he is still involved in the case, even though he's not being paid, the murder victim has turned out to be a demon, and the girl he's trying to save gave him a TapOnTheHead rather than be rescued.
** Subverted when it turns out that Harry's meddling has an actually been making things worse.
** Double-subverted when he puts everything right in the end.
rescued.



* IdiotBall: Murphy seems to catch it on a regular basis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouFailLawForever: Several people are arrested or threatened with arrest for murder in cases where a conviction would be impossible, because the victims were killed via supernatural means. For example, the killer in "Hair of the Dog" is poisoning werewolves by getting them to inhale powdered silver. No coroner in the country would testify that cardiac arrest was caused by breathing in powdered silver.



* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Harry. Lampshaded and double-subverted in "Rules of Engagement":
** Lampshaded when Bob grills Harry on why he is still involved in the case, even though he's not being paid, the murder victim has turned out to be a demon, and the girl he's trying to save gave him a TapOnTheHead rather than be rescued.
** Subverted when it turns out that Harry's meddling has an actually been making things worse.
** Double-subverted when he puts everything right in the end.



* IdiotBall: Murphy seems to catch it on a regular basis.



* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.

to:

* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompositeCharacter: Creator Robert Wolfe said that Morgan was intended to be a blend of his book self and Michael as 'the badass with a sword'. Similarly, Bob is an mix of his book self, Ebenezar and Thomas by being Harry's teacher and only remaining 'family'. Ancient Mai is a composite of the entire White (High) Council.

to:

* CompositeCharacter: Creator Robert Wolfe said that Morgan was intended to be a blend of his book self and Michael as 'the badass with a sword'. Similarly, Bob is an mix of his book self, Ebenezar and Thomas by being Harry's teacher and only remaining 'family'. Ancient Mai is a composite of the entire White (High) Council. Bianca also fulfills Thomas's role of sympathetic vampire, Lara's role of sexy head vamp and Susan's as doomed vampire love interest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: Harry rarely gets through a case without suffering grievous bodily harm, not to mention Bob the cursed soul.

Added: 121

Changed: 59

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SealedEvilInACan: Every other villain.

to:

* SealedEvilInACan: Every other villain.villain - and the hero's sidekick. Bob is a damned and cursed soul.



* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.

to:

* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp, which in the novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.humans.
* TheWoobie: Harry rarely gets through a case without suffering grievous bodily harm, not to mention Bob the cursed soul.

Changed: 1465

Removed: 2225

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing some tropes which don\'t fit the series, and Morgan does not qualify as a Race Lift. I too was heavily under the \"He is white in the novels\" impression, but it was never actually made explicitly clear what he looks like, or even what his ancestry is (From which we can make a logical deduction).



* CoconutSuperpowers: Rather noticeably, especially if you read the books. Except for a few offensive spells, nearly all of the magic Harry is seen doing is revisiting the scene of the crime in several ways (i.e. the mirror trick in The Hair of the Dog), which can easily be done by using normal cameras. Pretty much all supernatural creatures are seen as humans, '''including''' the toad demon from ''Storm Front'', who goes from being some sort of amphibian nightmare to a brawny human thug who looks funny, and Bob, who is pretty much only seen in human form, never as the talking skull from the books. The rare occasion a supernatural creature is shown, it is oftentimes poorly animated. Sheesh, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason Harry has a drumstick and a hockey stick instead of a blasting rod and a staff is because there was no budget for props.
** He does actually wear the bathrobe, and, with the exception of his duster, most of his clothes are on the raggedy side.

to:

\n* CoconutSuperpowers: Rather noticeably, especially if you read BehindTheBlack: [[EnforcedTrope Literally]]. In the books. Except for a few offensive spells, nearly all of DVD commentary the magic Harry is seen doing is revisiting the scene of the crime in several ways (i.e. the mirror trick in The Hair of the Dog), which can easily be done by using normal cameras. Pretty much all supernatural creatures are seen as humans, '''including''' the toad demon from ''Storm Front'', who goes from creators explicitly state that, with regards to how Morgan appears and disappears without being some sort of amphibian nightmare to a brawny human thug who looks funny, noticed, "the editor likes him" and Bob, who is pretty much only seen in human form, never as the talking skull cuts away from the books. The rare occasion a supernatural creature is shown, it is oftentimes poorly animated. Sheesh, I wouldn't him whenever he needs to not be surprised if the reason Harry has a drumstick and a hockey stick instead of a blasting rod and a staff is because there was no budget for props.
** He does actually wear the bathrobe, and, with the exception of his duster, most of his clothes are on the raggedy side.
seen.



* ConspicuousCGI: A certain dragon...

to:

* ConspicuousCGI: A certain dragon...dragon. The DVD commentary admits that it looks exceptionaly clumsy when it tries to move, but they figure that, given the time ''and'' budget constraints, it looks acceptable.



* FakeBrit: Terrence Mann as Bob. In the DVD commentary for the series, Mann jokes that he and Blackthorne swapped accents as soon as the cameras started running.

to:

* FakeBrit: Terrence Mann as Bob. In the DVD commentary for the series, Mann the creators jokes that he and Blackthorne swapped accents as soon as the cameras started running.



* HeyItsThatGuy: [[{{Farscape}} Claudia]] [[StargateSG1 Black]] guest stars in one episode. And for you theatre fans, Terrence Mann was the Elvis-esque Rum Tum Tugger in the original Broadway cast of ''{{Cats}}'', Javert in the original Broadway cast of ''[[{{Theatre/ptitlenjisnv3p}} Les Misérables]]'', Beast in the original Broadway cast of ''BeautyAndTheBeast'', as well as Larry in the movie version of ''AChorusLine''.



** Force of habit, maybe?
* InstantAwesomeJustAddDragons: Averted by cheap CGI effects.

to:

** Force of habit, maybe?
* InstantAwesomeJustAddDragons: Averted by cheap CGI effects.InstantAwesomeJustAddDragons



* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Unlike many other dragons (including the only one seen in the books), they are room-sized creatures made entirely from CGI...

to:

* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Unlike many other dragons (including the only one seen in the books), they are room-sized Immortal, shapeshifting creatures made entirely from CGI...who breathe green fire.



* PragmaticAdaptation: In the treatment of Bob, at least, who here is a GhostlyAdvisor with the ability to visibly manifest (which works much better for a TV audience).
* RaceLift: Murphy, in favour of a Latina actress. It works. Susan goes the opposite way.
** Morgan is Scottish, and, if the comics are to be believed, looks it. [[ScaryBlackMan Not so in here.]]
* ScaryBlackMan: Morgan. Not in the books.
** However, its worthy of noticing that while in the TV series Morgan might be a ScaryBlackMan, he often acts a great deal more reasonable than his InspectorJavert literary counterpart. In “Walls” he is actually rather considerate and gentle in his own way and in “Storm Front” near the ending he actually shows amusement when dealing with Harry, even returning Harry’s sarcastic quip with “class dismissed” and a smirk. Some might harshly argue that this is CharacterDerailment of the worst kind, but this also gives him, in this troper’s mind, a far more humanizing element and firmly positions Morgan as a morally decent man whose’s side might not be as forgiving or compassionate as the BigGood normally is seen as

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: In the treatment of Bob, at least, who here is a GhostlyAdvisor with original pilot Bob was, as in the ability to visibly manifest (which works much better books, merely a talking skull. When it was determined that this simply would not work for a TV audience).
audience they cast an actual actor and re-wrote his backstory (Now a ghost instead of spirit of intellect) so that he and Hary could have face-to-face conversations.
* RaceLift: Murphy, Short, blonde Irish Karrin Murphy became Connie Murphy in favour of a Latina Cuban-American actress. It works. Susan Rodriguez goes the opposite way.
** Morgan is Scottish, and, if the comics are
direction, switching from a tall, Hispanic woman to be believed, looks it. [[ScaryBlackMan Not so in here.]]
a short (Well, shorter than Dresden), blonde woman.
* ScaryBlackMan: Morgan. Not in the books.\n** However, its worthy of noticing that while in the TV series Morgan might be a ScaryBlackMan, he often acts a great deal more reasonable than his InspectorJavert literary counterpart. In “Walls” he is actually rather considerate and gentle in his own way and in “Storm Front” near the ending he actually shows amusement when dealing with Harry, even returning Harry’s sarcastic quip with “class dismissed” and a smirk. Some might harshly argue that this is CharacterDerailment of the worst kind, but this also gives him, in this troper’s mind, a far more humanizing element and firmly positions Morgan as a morally decent man whose’s side might not be as forgiving or compassionate as the BigGood normally is seen as



* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp. In the novels, this would be '''massive''' {{Squick}}, since Reds are [[spoiler:ugly human-size bat monsters that wear "flesh masks"]]. Whether this is AdaptationDecay or part of the PragmaticAdaptation is [[{{YMMV}} up to individual tastes]].

to:

* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp. In Vamp, which in the novels, this would be '''massive''' {{Squick}}, since Reds are [[spoiler:ugly human-size bat monsters that wear "flesh masks"]]. Whether this is AdaptationDecay or part of the PragmaticAdaptation is [[{{YMMV}} up to individual tastes]].novels have a more violent and predatory relationship with humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** However, its worthy of noticing that while in the TV series Morgan might be a ScaryBlackMan, he often acts a great deal more reasonable than his InspectorJavert literary counterpart. In “Walls” he is actually rather considerate and gentle in his own way and in “Storm Front” near the ending he actually shows amusement when dealing with Harry, even returning Harry’s sarcastic quip with “class dismissed” with a smirk. Some might harshly argue that this is CharacterDerailment of the worst kind, but this also gives him, in this troper’s mind, a far more humanizing element and firmly positions Morgan as a morally decent man whose’s side might not be as forgiving or compassionate as the BigGood normally is seen as

to:

** However, its worthy of noticing that while in the TV series Morgan might be a ScaryBlackMan, he often acts a great deal more reasonable than his InspectorJavert literary counterpart. In “Walls” he is actually rather considerate and gentle in his own way and in “Storm Front” near the ending he actually shows amusement when dealing with Harry, even returning Harry’s sarcastic quip with “class dismissed” with and a smirk. Some might harshly argue that this is CharacterDerailment of the worst kind, but this also gives him, in this troper’s mind, a far more humanizing element and firmly positions Morgan as a morally decent man whose’s side might not be as forgiving or compassionate as the BigGood normally is seen as
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** However, its worthy of noticing that while in the TV series Morgan might be a ScaryBlackMan, he often acts a great deal more reasonable than his InspectorJavert literary counterpart. In “Walls” he is actually rather considerate and gentle in his own way and in “Storm Front” near the ending he actually shows amusement when dealing with Harry, even returning Harry’s sarcastic quip with “class dismissed” with a smirk. Some might harshly argue that this is CharacterDerailment of the worst kind, but this also gives him, in this troper’s mind, a far more humanizing element and firmly positions Morgan as a morally decent man whose’s side might not be as forgiving or compassionate as the BigGood normally is seen as
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StarCrossedLovers: Part of Bob's backstory.

to:

* StarCrossedLovers: Part of Bob's backstory.backstory.
* VampiresAreSexGods: In the series, Harry has a sexual relationship with a Red Court Vamp. In the novels, this would be '''massive''' {{Squick}}, since Reds are [[spoiler:ugly human-size bat monsters that wear "flesh masks"]]. Whether this is AdaptationDecay or part of the PragmaticAdaptation is [[{{YMMV}} up to individual tastes]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicTool: Harry uses a drumstick/wand ''exactly'' like a sonic screwdriver form ''DoctorWho''.

to:

* MagicTool: Harry uses a drumstick/wand ''exactly'' like a sonic screwdriver form from ''DoctorWho''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeyItsThatGuy: [[{{Farscape}} Claudia]] [[StargateSG1 Black]] guest stars in one episode. And for you theatre fans, Terrence Mann was the Elvis-esque Rum Tum Tugger in the original Broadway cast of ''{{Cats}}'', Javert in the original Broadway cast of ''LesMiserables'', Beast in the original Broadway cast of ''BeautyAndTheBeast'', as well as Larry in the movie version of ''AChorusLine''.

to:

* HeyItsThatGuy: [[{{Farscape}} Claudia]] [[StargateSG1 Black]] guest stars in one episode. And for you theatre fans, Terrence Mann was the Elvis-esque Rum Tum Tugger in the original Broadway cast of ''{{Cats}}'', Javert in the original Broadway cast of ''LesMiserables'', ''[[{{Theatre/ptitlenjisnv3p}} Les Misérables]]'', Beast in the original Broadway cast of ''BeautyAndTheBeast'', as well as Larry in the movie version of ''AChorusLine''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScaryBlackMan: Morgan. [[RaceLift Not in the books]].

to:

* ScaryBlackMan: Morgan. [[RaceLift Not in the books]].books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Force of habit, maybe?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoconutSuperpowers: The TV series has this. Rather noticeably, especially if you read the books. Except for a few offensive spells, nearly all of the magic Harry is seen doing is revisiting the scene of the crime in several ways (i.e. the mirror trick in The Hair of the Dog), which can easily be done by using normal cameras. Pretty much all supernatural creatures are seen as humans, '''including''' the toad demon from ''Storm Front'', who goes from being some sort of amphibian nightmare to a brawny human thug who looks funny, and Bob, who is pretty much only seen in human form, never as the talking skull from the books. The rare occasion a supernatural creature is shown, it is oftentimes poorly animated. Sheesh, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason Harry has a drumstick and a hockey stick instead of a blasting rod and a staff is because there was no budget for props.

to:

* CoconutSuperpowers: The TV series has this. Rather noticeably, especially if you read the books. Except for a few offensive spells, nearly all of the magic Harry is seen doing is revisiting the scene of the crime in several ways (i.e. the mirror trick in The Hair of the Dog), which can easily be done by using normal cameras. Pretty much all supernatural creatures are seen as humans, '''including''' the toad demon from ''Storm Front'', who goes from being some sort of amphibian nightmare to a brawny human thug who looks funny, and Bob, who is pretty much only seen in human form, never as the talking skull from the books. The rare occasion a supernatural creature is shown, it is oftentimes poorly animated. Sheesh, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason Harry has a drumstick and a hockey stick instead of a blasting rod and a staff is because there was no budget for props.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:


* CoconutSuperpowers: The TV series has this. Rather noticeably, especially if you read the books. Except for a few offensive spells, nearly all of the magic Harry is seen doing is revisiting the scene of the crime in several ways (i.e. the mirror trick in The Hair of the Dog), which can easily be done by using normal cameras. Pretty much all supernatural creatures are seen as humans, '''including''' the toad demon from ''Storm Front'', who goes from being some sort of amphibian nightmare to a brawny human thug who looks funny, and Bob, who is pretty much only seen in human form, never as the talking skull from the books. The rare occasion a supernatural creature is shown, it is oftentimes poorly animated. Sheesh, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason Harry has a drumstick and a hockey stick instead of a blasting rod and a staff is because there was no budget for props.
** He does actually wear the bathrobe, and, with the exception of his duster, most of his clothes are on the raggedy side.

Top