Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekVoyagerS4E8YearOfHell

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OpenAirDriverLaunchingOnJuly09: In the final battle, the ''Voyager'' has it's bridge opened up and a makeshift forcefield keeping Janeway inside. Janeway decides to ram the timeship, which causes time to revert to before the ship came to be in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrutalHonesty: Janeway says they need to leave the nebula before their repairs are complete. Only Seven [[WhatTheHellHero voices what everyone's thinking]], and it told off for it later by Tuvok.

to:

* BrutalHonesty: Janeway says they need to leave the nebula before their repairs are complete. Only Seven [[WhatTheHellHero voices what everyone's thinking]], and it is told off for it later by Tuvok.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItsALongStory: Seven knows about Zephram Cochrane's vessel ''The Phoenix'' [[Film/StarTrekFirstContact because the Borg were present during those events]]. “It’s a complicated story.”

to:

* ItsALongStory: Seven knows about Zephram Cochrane's vessel ''The Phoenix'' [[Film/StarTrekFirstContact because the Borg were present during those events]]. “It’s a complicated story.” Since this episode took place before Voyager had re-established contact with the Federation, it's understandable that they wouldn't be aware of those events.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CaptainNemoCopy: A man of culture who isolates himself and his crew from the outside world, driven by a quest that wrecks destruction on them all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VoodooShark: Annorax and his crew are ageless due to their ship's temporal shields, which protect them from the flow of time. It doesn't stop them from eating and breathing, which doesn't have to deal with time because [[CallingYourAttacks FLASHBOMB]]!

to:

* VoodooShark: Annorax and his crew are ageless due to their ship's temporal shields, which protect them from the flow of time. It doesn't stop them from eating and breathing, which doesn't have to deal with time because [[CallingYourAttacks FLASHBOMB]]!breathing.

Added: 1935

Changed: 608

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BookEnds: The two-parter started with Voyager coming across an aggressive but underpowered Krenim ship trying to bully Voyager while [[BoisterousWeakling lacking any sort of weaponry to back it up]]. After Annorax figured out how to restore most of the Krenim Imperium the timeline shift showed Voyager being pounded on by a much nastier ship, with Janeway commenting that they have been dealing with these attacks for weeks now. After the timeship is destroyed the timeline resets to Day One where Voyager comes across an authoritative Krenim ship but with moderate policies, simply warning them of local threats before allowing them to pass.



* CripplingOverspecialization: The Krenim timeship is immune to conventional weapons fire because its shields keep it outside the space-time continuum, an OutsideContextProblem. When the time core is disabled, the ship becomes a GlassCannon.

to:

* CripplingOverspecialization: CripplingOverspecialization:
**
The Krenim timeship is immune to conventional weapons fire because its shields keep it outside the space-time continuum, an OutsideContextProblem. When the time core is disabled, the ship becomes a GlassCannon.GlassCannon.
** The WaveMotionGun on the ship has no other setting besides "erase from existence," which means no matter how precise their target the results are always taking a sledgehammer to the timeline.
* CriticalStaffingShortage: With several dozen crewmembers dead already from the Krenim attacks, Part 1 ends with significant damage to Voyager's basic systems to where it can't support everyone anymore. Janeway orders most of the crew to escape pods to find help.



* OutsideContextProblem: The Krenim, and specifically the timeship and their temporal-based weapons. Janeway and the ''Voyager'' crew have no idea what is causing the temporal shockwaves, let alone that they are a weapon, and have no defenses against the Krenim’s temporal torpedoes until near the end of Part I. This defense, however, serves to attract the timeship itself to target ''Voyager'' for temporal destruction...

to:

* OutsideContextProblem: OutsideContextProblem:
**
The Krenim, and specifically the timeship and their temporal-based weapons. Janeway and the ''Voyager'' crew have no idea what is causing the temporal shockwaves, let alone that they are a weapon, and have no defenses against the Krenim’s temporal torpedoes until near the end of Part I.
** The timeshield they developed ended up [[RippleEffectProofMemory protecting them from another timeline alteration]] from Annorax, which in turn throws off all their calculations to where the Krenim fleet are cargo transports instead of warships.
This defense, however, serves to attract the timeship itself Annorax to target ''Voyager'' for temporal destruction...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseShips: Contrary to what Paris seems to think, compartmentalizing a ship via transverse bulkheads did not originate with the ''Titanic'', having been invented in China in the 5th century AD and having become near-universal in Western ships as well a century before ''Titanic''. It's also ridiculous that Starfleet vessels wouldn't '''already''' have such compartmentalization.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* FakeBetterAlternateTimeline: Double example. A Krenim named Annorax had previously tried to win the Krenim war against the Rilnar by removing the latter from history. This caused a plague that would have been averted by the presence of Rilnar DNA in the Krenim genome. Annorax attempted to fix that with another temporal incursion, causing the disappearance of his home colony and his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HairMemento: All Annorax has left of his wife is a lock of her hair.


[[caption-width-right:350:[[Series/That70sShow "How about you beam my foot to the bridge and I'll create a temporal disturbance in]] [[JustForFun/That70sShow your ass!"]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:[[Series/That70sShow "How about you beam my foot to the bridge and I'll create a temporal disturbance in]] [[JustForFun/That70sShow [[JustForFun/FootInYourAss your ass!"]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed the namespae; FootInYourAss is not a valid namespace


[[caption-width-right:350:[[Series/That70sShow "How about you beam my foot to the bridge and I'll create a temporal disturbance in]] [[FootInYourAss/That70sShow your ass!"]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:[[Series/That70sShow "How about you beam my foot to the bridge and I'll create a temporal disturbance in]] [[FootInYourAss/That70sShow [[JustForFun/That70sShow your ass!"]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VestigalEmpire: When Annorax first built the weapon ship, the glory days of the Krenim were long behind them and he used it on their greatest enemy in an attempt to restore the Imperium to power.

to:

* VestigalEmpire: VestigialEmpire: When Annorax first built the weapon ship, the glory days of the Krenim were long behind them and he used it on their greatest enemy in an attempt to restore the Imperium to power.



* WildCard: ''Voyager'' for Annorax; because she arrived unexpectedly from such a far away sector and is generating her own temporal field, it's impossible to predict her effect on the timeline.

to:

* WildCard: ''Voyager'' for Annorax; because she arrived unexpectedly from such a far away sector and is generating her own temporal field, it's impossible to predict her effect on the timeline. Annorax initially considered the ship to be a minor element, but when the temporal shields throw off his latest incursion, he decides to take a closer look.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** After achieving a 98% restoration, a result they had never witnessed in ''200 years'' of trying, Obrist argues that they should dismantle the weapon and return to their people. But Annorax is determined to keep going until his homeworld is restored.

Added: 198

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallNameBigEgo: The initial Krenim attack on Voyager is brushed off because the Krenim in that timeline have limited warp and weapons capability, despite his arrogant posturing, but that timeline only lasts a few days before Annorax’s next major temporal incursion.

to:

* SmallNameBigEgo: The initial Krenim attack on Voyager is brushed off because the Krenim in that timeline have limited warp and weapons capability, despite his arrogant posturing, but that timeline only lasts a few days before Annorax’s Annorax's next major temporal incursion.



* SpaceClouds: A crippled ''Voyager'' hides inside a nebula so dense that it produces a visible fog inside the ship’s corridors. Captain Janeway even orders the hull breaches sealed to avoid having an "indoor nebula." One would think she'd be more concerned about all the air escaping...

to:

* SpaceClouds: A crippled ''Voyager'' hides inside a nebula so dense that it produces a visible fog inside the ship’s ship's corridors. Captain Janeway even orders the hull breaches sealed to avoid having an "indoor nebula." One would think she'd be more concerned about all the air escaping...



* VestigalEmpire: When Annorax first built the weapon ship, the glory days of the Krenim were long behind them and he used it on their greatest enemy in an attempt to restore the Imperium to power.



'''Captain Janeway:''' With all due respect, unless you’ve got [[CompensatingForSomething something a little bigger in your torpedo tubes]] I’m not turning around.

to:

'''Captain Janeway:''' With all due respect, unless you’ve got [[CompensatingForSomething something a little bigger in your torpedo tubes]] I’m I'm not turning around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Unfortunately, the temporal shield also prevents the damage to Voyager and her crew from being "healed" from the reset.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The ForWantOfANail condition still applies. Even if Annorax builds a "second" (original) timeship, the complexities of the time-line do not guarantee a repeat of the past events.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Janeway also asks this when Chakotay first suggests the idea of abandoning the ship - sure, a bunch of escape pods and shuttles could probably sneak through Krenim space much easier than the starship itself, but those pods and shuttles would have a distinct disadvantage with weapons and shields, and, even if they did make it through to the other side, what would they do without Voyager's resources going forward in their journey home? Even Chakotay acknowledges that he didn't like the idea, but he had a duty to suggest it all the same.

Added: 621

Changed: 346

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be all of season 4, and wasn't going to involve a ResetButton, and would have involved a more general conflict with the Krenim, rather than a single time-ship. The departure of Kes also means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. Although the former, at least, is explainable by Kes altering the timeline. What is not, however, is how, the Year of Hell went from ''Constant attacks by the Krenim'' as stated in Before and After, to ''dealing with a single timeship''.

to:

* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be all of season 4, and wasn't going to involve a ResetButton, and would have involved a more general conflict with the Krenim, rather than a single time-ship. The departure of Kes also means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. Although the former, at least, is explainable by Kes altering the timeline. What is not, however, is how, the Year of Hell went from ''Constant attacks by the Krenim'' as stated in Before and After, to ''dealing with a single timeship''.timeship'' (although that could be explained by the fact that, without Seven around, ''Voyager'' likely never devised the temporal shield in that timeline -- meaning that Annorax's calculations were never thrown off, the Krenim just got stronger with each incursion and Annorax himself never had any reason to go after ''Voyager'').



* WholePlotReference: At least the portion set aboard the Krenim temporal weapon ship is this to ''Literature/TwentyThousandLeaguesUnderTheSea''. Referenced in the name Annorax, TheNarrator of the aforementioned novel.

to:

* WholePlotReference: At least the portion set aboard the Krenim temporal weapon ship is this to ''Literature/TwentyThousandLeaguesUnderTheSea''. Referenced in the name Annorax, Annorax -- an anagram of Aronnax, TheNarrator of the aforementioned novel.


Added DiffLines:

* YouCantGoHomeAgain: Annorax can't, because his home no longer exists -- he accidentally {{Ret Gone}}d it two hundred years ago, along with his wife and children. He's been desperately trying to correct that mistake ever since, without success.[[note]] And even if he somehow managed it, he ''still'' wouldn't have a family to go back to, as they'd be long dead by now. Whether he would retire satisfied that they got to live out their lives, or continue to rant and rave at time for keeping them from him, we'll never know.[[/note]] In the end, however, history is changed so that he never left home in the first place.

Added: 193

Changed: 477

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AchievementsInIgnorance: The temporal shields make ''Voyager'' immune to the changes caused by the Timeship when the crew didn't even know that was a threat they needed to be protected from.



%% * TheDeterminator: Janeway and Annorax.

to:

%% * TheDeterminator: Janeway and Annorax.Annorax are each, in their way, determined to protect their people, but Janeway's actions are all defensive and focused on a clear threat where Annorax is consumed by an obsession that drives him to eliminate innocents in the name of restoring one specific person.



* DoctorsOrders: Averted -- using a precedent well-established in ''Franchise/StarTrek'' continuity, the Doctor tries to relieve Janeway on medical grounds. She refuses, pointing out that he has no means of enforcing the order given that the brig is destroyed, the internal forcefields are offline, and ''Voyager'' no longer has a security team.

to:

* DoctorsOrders: Averted -- using a precedent well-established in ''Franchise/StarTrek'' continuity, the Doctor tries to relieve Janeway on medical grounds. She refuses, pointing out grounds, but Janeway counters that he has no means of enforcing the order given way to enforce that the brig is destroyed, the internal forcefields are offline, and ''Voyager'' no longer has a security team.order.



* HeroicSacrifice: Janeway crashes ''Voyager'' into the timeship in the hope that the timeline will revert to normal.

to:

* HeroicSacrifice: Janeway crashes ''Voyager'' into the timeship in the hope that the destruction of the ship will cause the timeline will to revert to normal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDeterminator: [[NotSoDifferent Janeway and Annorax]].

to:

%% * TheDeterminator: [[NotSoDifferent Janeway and Annorax]].Annorax.



* NotSoDifferent: Annorax compares his attempts to restore his original timeline to ''Voyager's'' journey home, in an attempt to sway Chakotay.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: Annorax compares his attempts to restore his original timeline to ''Voyager's'' journey home, in an attempt to sway Chakotay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AndThenWhat: Brought up by Janeway when the Doctor tries to relieve her of duty due to her potential PTSD, as she forces him to acknowledge that the ship doesn’t have the resources to keep her confined even if they would go through with that order.


Added DiffLines:

* SmallNameBigEgo: The initial Krenim attack on Voyager is brushed off because the Krenim in that timeline have limited warp and weapons capability, despite his arrogant posturing, but that timeline only lasts a few days before Annorax’s next major temporal incursion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* AttackPatternAlpha

to:

%%* AttackPatternAlpha* AttackPatternAlpha: In this case, Janeway orders Attack Pattern Omega.



%%* DamageControl

to:

%%* DamageControl* DamageControl: With only a skeleton crew on board, their entire time is spent fixing repairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie:[[SecondLawOfMetafictionalThermodynamics Surprisingly averted]] despite the [[ResetButtonSuicideMission inbuilt]] ResetButton, and the alternate timeline of "Before And After" in which both [[SacrificialLion Janeway and B'Elanna]] were killed during the Year of Hell. At most, two Nihydron vessels are erased during the climactic battle, but it's unclear whether the two crewmembers (B'Elanna and Harry) assigned to work with the Nihydron are actually on-board those ships.

to:

* AnyoneCanDie:[[SecondLawOfMetafictionalThermodynamics AnyoneCanDie: [[SecondLawOfMetafictionalThermodynamics Surprisingly averted]] despite the [[ResetButtonSuicideMission inbuilt]] ResetButton, and the alternate timeline of "Before And After" in which both [[SacrificialLion Janeway and B'Elanna]] were killed during the Year of Hell. At most, two Nihydron vessels are erased during the climactic battle, but it's unclear whether the two crewmembers (B'Elanna and Harry) assigned to work with the Nihydron are actually on-board those ships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PreMortemOneLiner: Just before [[RammingAlwaysWorks crashing Voyager into the timeship]], Janeway declaims rhetorically, "Time's up!"

to:

* PreMortemOneLiner: Just before [[RammingAlwaysWorks crashing Voyager ''Voyager'' into the timeship]], Janeway declaims rhetorically, "Time's up!"



* WeComeInPeaceShootToKill: The Krenim Imperium's response to Voyager trying to negotiate a way through their space is just to shoot at them.

to:

* WeComeInPeaceShootToKill: The Krenim Imperium's response to Voyager ''Voyager'' trying to negotiate a way through their space is just to shoot at them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Meant to add this in.


* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be all of season 4, and wasn't going to involve a ResetButton, and would have involved a more general conflict with the Krenim, rather than a single time-ship. The departure of Kes also means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. Although the former, at least, is explainable by Kes altering the timeline.

to:

* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be all of season 4, and wasn't going to involve a ResetButton, and would have involved a more general conflict with the Krenim, rather than a single time-ship. The departure of Kes also means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. Although the former, at least, is explainable by Kes altering the timeline. What is not, however, is how, the Year of Hell went from ''Constant attacks by the Krenim'' as stated in Before and After, to ''dealing with a single timeship''.

Changed: 264

Removed: 439

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correction, it was supposed to be an ENTIRE SEASON, hence YEAR of Hell. It may have been slotted for the end of Season 3/beggining of Season 4 after that idea was scrapped though. Also, Kes altered time, so it didn't really retcon Before and After, although the lack of mention about her warning was a bit strange.


* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be at the end of Season 3, but "Scorpion" was put there instead. The departure of Kes means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. [[FridgeBrilliance However these changes can be explained]] by the constant alterations Annorax is making to the timeline.
** It would seem that this episode completely eliminates "[[{{Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS3E20BeforeAndAfter}} Before and After]]" from the show's storyline. That episode only happened because of the chroniton radiation Kes was exposed to during the Year of Hell. Since she left the ship before that happened, she was never exposed to the radiation, "Before and After" never happened, and she was never able to tell the crew what to prepare for.

to:

* RetCon: "Year of Hell" was originally meant to be at all of season 4, and wasn't going to involve a ResetButton, and would have involved a more general conflict with the end of Season 3, but "Scorpion" was put there instead. Krenim, rather than a single time-ship. The departure of Kes also means that it's Seven who deals with the chronoton torpedo; neither is there any mention of Kes' warning about the Krenim. [[FridgeBrilliance However these changes can be explained]] by Krenim. Although the constant alterations Annorax former, at least, is making to explainable by Kes altering the timeline.
** It would seem that this episode completely eliminates "[[{{Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS3E20BeforeAndAfter}} Before and After]]" from the show's storyline. That episode only happened because of the chroniton radiation Kes was exposed to during the Year of Hell. Since she left the ship before that happened, she was never exposed to the radiation, "Before and After" never happened, and she was never able to tell the crew what to prepare for.
timeline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Future's End established that Tom doesn't quite get his history right, so this is more Fridge Brilliance.


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Tom recalls the RMS ''Titanic'' as his inspiration for a series of transverse bulkheads. He then comments that, in theory, the ship could stay afloat even if half of the compartments were flooded. At no point did the designers claim this. The most they claimed was if a quarter of the compartments were flooded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Bears a slight resemblence" is not a Shout Out. It must be explicit.


** The central core of the Krenim temporal weapon ship bears a slight resemblance to the titular space station in ''Series/BabylonFive''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The central core of the Krenim temporal weapon ship bears a slight resemblance to the titular space station in ''Series/BabylonFive''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItsAllAboutMe: Annorax claims his time-alterations are to restore the Krenim Imperium to its former glory. But it's obvious he only really cares about bringing back his wife and homeworld, especially after he declares a 98% restored Imperium (with his wife's colony in the missing 2%) isn't good enough. Paris even notes that Annorax has reached a point where he appears to basically believe that Time has a ''grudge'' against him and is punishing him for his hubris by 'withholding' his wife.

to:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Annorax claims his time-alterations are to restore the Krenim Imperium to its former glory. But it's obvious he only really cares about bringing back his wife and homeworld, especially after he declares a 98% restored Imperium (with his wife's colony in the missing 2%) isn't good enough. Paris even notes that Annorax has reached a point where he appears to basically believe that Time itself has a ''grudge'' against him and is punishing him for his hubris by 'withholding' his wife.

Top