Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekEnterpriseS04E18InAMirrorDarkly

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Tuckerization}}: According to Mike Sussman, Admiral Black gets his name from Chris Black (a writer and producer during the show's first three seasons).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StabTheScorpion: Played with; when T'Pol tells Trip how she set him up, he slams his hand into the wall next to her. Turns out he's activating the intercom to let the Captain know the repairs have been completed.

to:

* StabTheScorpion: Played with; when T'Pol tells Trip how she set him up, [[WallPinOfLove he slams his hand into the wall next to her.her]]. Turns out he's activating the intercom to let the Captain know the repairs have been completed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeWhoMustNotBeSeen: The oft-mentioned Admiral Gardner finally makes an appearance. So it's He Who Must Not Be Seen In This Timeline.

to:

* HeWhoMustNotBeSeen: The oft-mentioned Admiral Gardner finally makes an appearance. So it's He Who Must Not Be Seen In This Our Timeline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeautyIsNeverTarnished: Averted; T'Pol gets slashed across the face during her KnifeFight with Hoshi--who plays it straight, as she takes a punch to the face but doesn't have a bruise to show for it.

to:

* BeautyIsNeverTarnished: Averted; Zigzagged; T'Pol gets slashed across the face during her KnifeFight with Hoshi--who plays it straight, as she Hoshi, who takes a punch to the face but doesn't have a bruise to show for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Archer:''' Great men are not peacemakers; great men are conquerors!

to:

-->'''Archer:''' Great men are not peacemakers; great ''peacemakers''. Great men are conquerors!'''[[SuddenlyShouting CONQUERORS]]''' !
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodIsNotNice: T'Pol is the least evil main character, but that doesn't stop her from brainwashing Trip to commit sabotage so he gets tortured in her place. Shouldn't have made that ''pon farr'' quip, Trip.

to:

* GoodIsNotNice: T'Pol is the least evil main character, but that doesn't stop her from brainwashing Trip to commit sabotage so he gets tortured in her place. Shouldn't have made that ''pon farr'' quip, Trip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope deprecated per TRS


* FamousLastWords:
** "I'll buy you as much time as I can. Get out of here, now!" - Captain Forrest
** "I've failed you, captain." - Major Reed (probably)
** "Once we put down the rebellion, I'll expand the Empire throughout ... [[KilledMidSentence throughout]] ..." - Captain Archer (probably)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating; deleting and renaming wicks as appropriate


* AirVentEscape: In Part 2, Slar the [[TheReptilians Gorn]] slave master hides in the Jeffries tubes, committing acts of sabotage to force the crew to give him a shuttle to escape. Instead, Archer hunts him down with a team of [=MACOs=].

to:

* AirVentEscape: In Part 2, Slar the [[TheReptilians [[LizardFolk Gorn]] slave master hides in the Jeffries tubes, committing acts of sabotage to force the crew to give him a shuttle to escape. Instead, Archer hunts him down with a team of [=MACOs=].



** When the slave Archer is torturing tells him that the saboteur is a [[TheReptilians Gorn]], Archer's expression clearly emotes his worry. Even in the Mirror Universe, they are notorious for their ferociousness.

to:

** When the slave Archer is torturing tells him that the saboteur is a [[TheReptilians [[LizardFolk Gorn]], Archer's expression clearly emotes his worry. Even in the Mirror Universe, they are notorious for their ferociousness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Archer:''' I wonder how history would have played out if Cochrane hadn't turned the tables on your [[WrittenByTheWinners invasion force]]. Humans might be your slaves instead of the other way around.

to:

--->'''Archer:''' [[DoubleBlindWhatIf I wonder how history would have played out out]] if Cochrane hadn't turned the tables on your [[WrittenByTheWinners invasion force]]. [[EvilCannotComprehendGood Humans might be your slaves slaves]] instead of the other way around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Speaking of which, what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]? [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi "IT'S A TRAP!"]]
* SigilSpam: The Empire's Earth with a dagger through it logo is ''everywhere''.
* SinkTheLifeBoats: The Tholians fire on the escape pods as they break through their energy web. There are only 47, but that's enough to allow a Part Two.

to:

* ShoutOut: WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Speaking of which, what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]? [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi "IT'S "[[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi IT'S A TRAP!"]]
TRAP!]]"
* SigilSpam: The Empire's Earth with a dagger through it "Earth-with-a-dagger-through-it" logo is ''everywhere''.
* SinkTheLifeBoats: The Tholians fire on the escape pods as they break through their energy web. There are only 47, 47 survivors, but that's enough to allow a Part Two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: Mirror-Archer is baffled and enraged that his prime counterpart is legendary for being a peaceful explorer instead of a conqueror.


Added DiffLines:

* NoSenseOfPersonalSpace: Archer loves to get up in people's grills when he's snarling threats.


Added DiffLines:

* SigilSpam: The Empire's Earth with a dagger through it logo is ''everywhere''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope's getting cut.


* SinkTheLifeBoats: The Tholians fire on the escape pods as they break through their energy web. There are only [[The47Society 47 survivors]], but that's enough to allow a Part Two.

to:

* SinkTheLifeBoats: The Tholians fire on the escape pods as they break through their energy web. There are only [[The47Society 47 survivors]], 47, but that's enough to allow a Part Two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: References 1 Corinthians 13:12 in Literature/TheBible.

Added: 215

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fate of Archer and Reed was left [[NotQuiteDead deliberately ambiguous as well]], so they'd be available for future Mirror Universe episodes [[CutShort that were never made.]]

to:

** The fate of Archer and Reed was left [[NotQuiteDead deliberately ambiguous as well]], so they'd be available for future Mirror Universe episodes [[CutShort that were never made.]]made]].
*** Spin-off media would establish that Reed survived with disfiguring injuries while a clone of Archer was created to exploit his tactical expertise, only for Archer's clone to defect to the Rebellion against Sato.

Added: 61

Removed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
there is no "no"


* BigNo: Soval does this as ''Avenger'' is destroyed.


Added DiffLines:

* SkywardScream: Soval does this as ''Avenger'' is destroyed.

Added: 2497

Changed: 1508

Removed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigNo: Soval does this as ''Avenger'' is destroyed.



* DoomedByCanon: The rebellion against the Terran Empire will inevitably fail, as it's still going strong a hundred years later.

to:

* DoomedByCanon: DoomedByCanon:
**
The rebellion against the Terran Empire will inevitably fail, is locked into inevitable failure, as it's the Empire is still going strong a hundred years later.later. Still, there's enough of a rebellion hanging on by [[Series/StarTrekDiscovery Emperor Georgiou's era]] that "the Firewolf" (mirror-Voq) and Mirror-Sarek are still a thorn in the side of the Empire.
** Conversely, the Terran Empire is bolstered by the addition of the ''Defiant'', but by the 23rd century in ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery'', its strength is referred to as being stagnant "painted rust" and a "facade". By the era of ''[[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine DS9]]'' a hundred years after that, the Empire has collapsed and is long gone after conquest by the Klingon-Cardassian Alliance and the mirror Bajorans.



* FakeShemp: The new footage shot for the MirrorUniverse reimagining of ''[[Film/StarTrekFirstContact First Contact]]'''s ending features an obvious stand-in for Creator/JamesCromwell as Mirror-Cochrane, whose face is carefully never shown to the camera in the clips not lifted directly from the film. The order to board the Vulcans' ship and take everything is also bellowed by one of the mob, and not Cochrane.



** "I'll buy you as much time as I can. Get out of here, now!" Captain Forrest
** "I've failed you, captain." Major Reed (probably)
** "Once we put down the rebellion, I'll expand the Empire throughout... [[KilledMidSentence throughout]]..." Captain Archer (probably)

to:

** "I'll buy you as much time as I can. Get out of here, now!" - Captain Forrest
** "I've failed you, captain." - Major Reed (probably)
** "Once we put down the rebellion, I'll expand the Empire throughout... throughout ... [[KilledMidSentence throughout]]...throughout]] ..." - Captain Archer (probably)



* NewPowersAsThePlotDemands: The I.S.S ''Enterprise'' has a Suliban CloakingDevice, a TractorBeam and {{Escape Pod}}s, all required by the plot. Presumably the Terran Empire doesn't have moral qualms about [[ForgottenPhlebotinum acquiring and exploiting alien technology]].

to:

* NewPowersAsThePlotDemands: NewPowersAsThePlotDemands:
**
The I.S.S ''Enterprise'' has a Suliban CloakingDevice, a TractorBeam and {{Escape Pod}}s, all required by the plot. Presumably the Terran Empire doesn't have moral qualms about [[ForgottenPhlebotinum acquiring and exploiting alien technology]].technology]].
** The Tholians also gain the ability to spin a web around a ship in moments, whereas two of their vessels had to take their time constructing one around the ''Enterprise'' in the Original Series.



* NotQuiteDead: We don't actually ''see'' Reed and Archer dead; this was so they could be brought back in future MirrorUniverse episodes [[WhatCouldHaveBeen if required]].

to:

* NotQuiteDead: We don't actually ''see'' Reed and Archer dead; this was so they could be brought back in future MirrorUniverse episodes [[WhatCouldHaveBeen if required]]. The series got CutShort before that could happen.



* PerpetualFrowner: Archer

to:

* PerpetualFrowner: ArcherArcher.
* PlotArmor: Zig-zagged. At the end of Part 1, with the I.S.S. ''Enterprise'' being destroyed, the Tholians resort to [[SinkTheLifeboats shooting the escape pods]] (along with a couple more crashing into their energy web), but all of the main characters survive to take control of the ''Defiant''. On the other hand, as Part 2 proceeds, first Mirror-Reed and later Mirror-Archer face likely deaths, and Mirror-T'Pol and Mirror-Phlox end up slated for execution. They are ultimately left in a state of UncertainDoom, as the series was cancelled and CutShort before any other MirrorUniverse episodes could continue the story.



* PunctuatedPounding: Archer bouncing Forrest off the walls of his cell in retaliation for his TheReasonYouSuckSpeech. "Then why -- are you -- in the brig?"

to:

* PunctuatedPounding: Archer bouncing Forrest off the walls of his cell in retaliation for his TheReasonYouSuckSpeech. TheReasonYouSuckSpeech.
-->
"Then why -- are you -- in the brig?"



* SanitySlippage: After reading of his more successful alternate universe self, Archer is goaded by {{hallucinations}} of this other Archer into increasingly reckless actions.
* SavedByCanon: Obviously the Terran Empire won't be overthrown, as it's still going strong (despite sporadic rebellions) in ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' and ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
* SceneryPorn: When the boarding party enter the ''Defiant'' bridge and boot up the computer, the camera pans lovingly over every station as they power up and all the TOS bridge sound effects come in one-by-one.

to:

* SanitySlippage: After reading of his more successful alternate universe self, Archer is goaded by {{hallucinations}} of this other Archer into increasingly reckless actions.
actions. It's also possible that ''ten hours straight'' in an agony booth played a role in this, along with him not being particularly stable to begin with.
* SavedByCanon: Obviously the Terran Empire won't be overthrown, overthrown (yet), as it's still going strong (despite strong, despite sporadic rebellions) rebellions, in ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' and ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''. That said, by [[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine the 24th century]], it will have long since collapsed and been conquered.
* SceneryPorn: When the boarding party enter the ''Defiant'' bridge and boot up the computer, the camera pans lovingly over every station as they power up and all the TOS bridge sound effects come in on one-by-one.



* SkywardScream: Soval does this as ''Avenger'' is destroyed.



* StockFootage from ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact'' is cleverly intercut with episode footage in the teaser when Zephram Cochrane murders the Vulcan emissary. Also used in the special TitleSequence with news footage and scenes from movies and other Trek episodes are used to show that HumansAreWarriors.

to:

* StockFootage from ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact'' is cleverly intercut with episode footage in the teaser when Zephram Mirror Zefram Cochrane murders the Vulcan emissary. Also used in the special TitleSequence with news footage and scenes from movies and other Trek episodes are used to show that HumansAreWarriors.



* VehicularTurnabout: The Tholians steal the Defiant, only to have it stolen again by the Terran Empire.

to:

* VehicularTurnabout: The Tholians steal the Defiant, ''Defiant'', only to have it stolen again by the Terran Empire.



* WhamShot: TheTeaser features that heartwarming scene from the end of ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''. The Vulcan ship lands in Montana, the captain greets Zefram Cochrane with a salute and "Live long and prosper", Cochrane tries but fails to return the salute...and then he pulls out a gun and shoots the Vulcan. Welcome to the MirrorUniverse!
* WhyDontYouJustShootHim: Reed regarding Forrest after Archer takes the ship, and T'Pol regarding Archer after Forrest takes it back. Both turn out to be aware of this.
** It's implied that Archer is worried that killing Forrest will turn Hoshi against him, while Forrest can't kill Archer because the Emperor has already endorsed ThePlan that Archer proposed (he does try to arrange Archer's death during a combat mission however).
** In "Part 2" Archer says he'd airlock T'Pol for her 'betrayal', but as he's suffering from CriticalStaffingShortage (47 to run a ship that needs 400) he can't afford to.

to:

* WhamShot: TheTeaser features that heartwarming scene from the end of ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''. The Vulcan ship lands in Montana, the captain greets Zefram Cochrane with a salute and "Live long and prosper", Cochrane tries but fails to return the salute...salute ... and then he pulls out a gun and shoots the Vulcan. Welcome to the MirrorUniverse!
* WhyDontYouJustShootHim: WhyDontYouJustShootHim:
**
Reed regarding Forrest after Archer takes the ship, and T'Pol regarding Archer after Forrest takes it back. Both turn out to be aware of this.
** *** It's implied that Archer is worried that killing Forrest will turn Hoshi against him, while Forrest can't kill Archer because the Emperor has already endorsed ThePlan that Archer proposed (he does try to arrange Archer's death during a combat mission however).
** In "Part 2" Part 2, Archer says he'd airlock T'Pol for her 'betrayal', "betrayal", but as he's suffering from CriticalStaffingShortage (47 to run a ship that needs 400) he can't afford to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeehiveBarrier: The Tholians are able to demonstrate a complete web in this episode. Unlike in "The Tholian Web", where there were two of them forming a large web around an immobilized ship, here a half-dozen are able to assemble a complete web around a smaller ship in under a minute. Once complete, the gaps in the web fill up with energy, blocking outbound fire while allowing the Tholians to fire through it with impunity. Some of the escape pods trying to get out are sliced apart by the strands. It also collapses onto the ''Enterprise'', destroying it. The Tholians also create a flat barrier blocking the ''Defiant'' spacedock, but Archer just blows up their ships to neutralize it.

to:

* BeehiveBarrier: The Tholians are able to demonstrate a complete web in this episode. Unlike in "The Tholian Web", where there were two of them forming a large web around an immobilized ship, here a half-dozen are able to assemble a complete web around a smaller ship in under a minute. Once complete, the gaps in the web fill up with energy, blocking outbound fire while allowing the Tholians to fire through it with impunity. Some of the escape pods trying to get out are [[DeadlyForceField sliced apart by the strands.strands]]. It also collapses onto the ''Enterprise'', destroying it. The Tholians also create a flat barrier blocking the ''Defiant'' spacedock, but Archer just blows up their ships to neutralize it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IfIWantedYouDead: Archer realizes that Trip wasn't the saboteur, because with his engineering skills he could have done a much better job of it. He [[EurekaMoment figures out the rest]] when Hoshi comments that T'Pol was looking over his shoulder during the installation of the cloak.

Changed: 41

Removed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Speaking of which, what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]?
--->"IT'S A TRAP!"

to:

* ShoutOut: WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Speaking of which, what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]?
--->"IT'S
up]]? [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi "IT'S A TRAP!"TRAP!"]]

Changed: 363

Removed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut:
** WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''.
** And speaking of ''Franchise/StarWars'', what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]?
---> "IT'S A TRAP!"

to:

* ShoutOut:
**
ShoutOut: WordOfGod says the I.S.S. ''Avenger'' is named after the Imperial Star Destroyer from ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''.
** And speaking
''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Speaking of ''Franchise/StarWars'', which, what does Reed shout when he realizes that the Gorn [[LuredIntoATrap set him and his men up]]?
---> "IT'S --->"IT'S A TRAP!"

Added: 202

Removed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RebelRelaxation: Averted; Archer wears his collar buttoned up (unlike in the normal universe) to show his more uptight nature. However he does do the requisite SlouchOfVillainy in the captain's chair.


Added DiffLines:

* RebelRelaxation: Averted; Archer wears his collar buttoned up (unlike in the normal universe) to show his more uptight nature. However he does do the requisite SlouchOfVillainy in the captain's chair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HighCollarOfDoom: A subtle version -- Archer wears his collar buttoned up, unlike in the normal universe, to show his more uptight nature.

to:

* HighCollarOfDoom: A subtle version -- RebelRelaxation: Averted; Archer wears his collar buttoned up, unlike up (unlike in the normal universe, universe) to show his more uptight nature.nature. However he does do the requisite SlouchOfVillainy in the captain's chair.

Added: 357

Changed: 142

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThisIsGonnaSuck: T'Pol realizes Archer is DrunkWithPower during his speech aboard the ''Avenger'', and that he'll likely destroy Vulcan if he becomes Emperor.

to:

* ThisIsGonnaSuck: ThisIsGonnaSuck:
** When the slave Archer is torturing tells him that the saboteur is a [[TheReptilians Gorn]], Archer's expression clearly emotes his worry. Even in the Mirror Universe, they are notorious for their ferociousness.
**
T'Pol realizes Archer is DrunkWithPower during his speech aboard the ''Avenger'', and that he'll likely destroy Vulcan if he becomes Emperor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilVersusEvil: Mirror Archer has to contend with a Gorn slave-master who stowed away on the ''Defiant'' when his crew took it over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the year 2155, however, things aren't going well for the Terran Empire, which is facing a successful rebellion among the alien races they've conquered. On the [=ISS=] ''Enterprise'', First Officer Jonathan Archer hopes to repeat history with a raid into Tholian space. The Tholians have opened a rift into a future AlternateTimeline from which they've seized the ''Constitution''-class starship [=USS=] ''Defiant''. With speed and firepower a hundred years in advance of anything in the Quadrant, and a database full of subversive ideals, the ''Defiant'' is a GameBreaker that could save the Terran Empire...or bring it to its knees.

to:

In the year 2155, however, things aren't going well for the Terran Empire, which is facing a successful rebellion among the alien races they've conquered. On the [=ISS=] ''Enterprise'', First Officer Jonathan Archer hopes to repeat history with a raid into Tholian space. The Tholians have opened a rift into a future AlternateTimeline AlternateUniverse from which they've seized the ''Constitution''-class starship [=USS=] ''Defiant''. With speed and firepower a hundred years in advance of anything in the Quadrant, and a database full of subversive ideals, the ''Defiant'' is a GameBreaker that could save the Terran Empire...or bring it to its knees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OtherMeAnnoysMe: Archer's reaction to his alternate universe self, though at the same time he is deeply envious of the success his counterpart enjoyed.

to:

* OtherMeAnnoysMe: Archer's reaction to his alternate universe self, self is one of utter disdain, though at the same time he is deeply envious of the success his counterpart enjoyed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ALighterShadeOfBlack: Forrest is one of the more honorable Terran Empire officers seen, even pulling a HeroicSacrifice by staying behind on the Enterprise to distract the Tholians and buy the rest of the crew enough time to escape.

to:

* ALighterShadeOfBlack: Forrest is one of the more honorable Terran Empire officers seen, even pulling a HeroicSacrifice by staying behind on the Enterprise ''Enterprise'' to distract the Tholians and buy the rest of the crew enough time to escape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ALighterShadeOfBlack: Forrest is one of the more honorable Terran Empire officers seen, even pulling a HeroicSacrifice by staying behind on the Enterprise to distract the Tholians and buy the rest of the crew enough time to escape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhamShot: TheTeaser features that heartwarming scene from the end of ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''. The Vulcan ship lands in Montana, the captain greets Zefram Cochrane with a salute and "Live long and prosper", Cochrane tries but fails to return the salute...and then he pulls out a gun and shoots the Vulcan. Welcome to the MirrorUniverse!

Added: 427

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: On one hand, Soval and the rebels die and the ''Defiant'' makes it to Earth, ensuring [[Recap/StarTrekS2E4MirrorMirror another]] [[Recap/StarTrekDiscoveryS1E10DespiteYourself century]] of Terran hegemony. On the other hand, [[TheCaligula Archer]] is defeated, so he won't be able to wipe out Vulcan as T'Pol had feared. Only time will tell whether [[TheChessmaster Empress Sato]] is any better than he was.



-->'''Forrest:''' You really think Admiral Black would place a spy on ''my'' ship, then tell me who it is?

to:

-->'''Forrest:''' You really think the Admiral Black would place a spy on ''my'' ship, and then tell me ''me'' who it is?

Top