Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SillyReasonForWar

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''StarTrek'' ExpandedUniverse novel ''I, Q'' told of a war between the Q and another race of similarly omnipotent beings. These two impossibly advanced species both admitted the real reason for their catyclysmic conflict was 'there's something about you that just really pisses us off'.
** And near fourth-wall breaking [[GenreSavvy Genre Savviness]]: they're both aware enough to realize that in their reality every race ''always'' manages to get balanced out by some other race which exists to be an opposing force and source of plot. If they made up with their obvious opposite numbers, it would inevitably lead to a serious threat to both of them showing up.

to:

* The ''StarTrek'' ExpandedUniverse novel ''I, Q'' told of a war between the Q and another race of similarly omnipotent beings. beings, the M. These two [[SufficientlyAdvancedAlien impossibly advanced species species]] both admitted the real reason for their catyclysmic conflict was 'there's "there's just something about you that just really pisses us off'.
me off." The war itself is kicked off when one of them blurts out, "Your mother!"; nobody now knows who said it or who it was directed at.
** And near [[BreakingTheFourthWall fourth-wall breaking breaking]] [[GenreSavvy Genre Savviness]]: they're both aware enough to realize that in their reality every race ''always'' manages to get balanced out by some other race which exists to be an opposing force and source of plot. If they made up with their obvious opposite numbers, it would inevitably lead to a serious threat to both of them showing up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** So, the true Beholder is really a mirror?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:332:'''[[color:purple:Green!]]''' ''[[color:green:Purple!]]'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:332:'''[[color:purple:Green!]]''' ''[[color:green:Purple!]]'']]
[[caption-width-right:332:'''[[color:purple:Green!]]''']]
[[caption-width-right:332:''[[color:green:Purple!]]'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The conflict between the Federation and the Revolutionaries in RType Tactics: Operation Bitter Chocolate, thank to the newly found ExcusePlot. The reason they fight each other is nothing else but the dispute over the Force Device weapon system with the R-Fighters. Still, they both fight the real evil against them both - [[EldritchAbomination the Bydo]].

to:

* The conflict between the Federation and the Revolutionaries in RType Tactics: Tactics II: Operation Bitter Chocolate, thank to the newly found ExcusePlot. The reason they fight each other is nothing else but the dispute over the Force Device weapon system with the R-Fighters. Still, they both fight the real evil against them both - [[EldritchAbomination the Bydo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The conflict between the Federation and the Revolutionaries in RType Tactics: Operation Bitter Chocolate, thank to the newly found ExcusePlot. The reason they fight each other is nothing else but the dispute over the Force Device weapon system with the R-Fighters. Still, they both fight the real evil against them both - [[EldritchAbomination the Bydo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''{{Discworld/Jingo}}'', two smaller nations nominally claimed by the Klatchian empire had only recently eased off on a centuries-old war, having run out of rocks to throw. The reason for the conflict is a one-word difference in their holy book, which one country translates as "man" and the other translates as "god". This trope is applicable because the difference between the two words, in Klatchian script, comes down to how a single dot is positioned over one letter ... and it ''especially'' applies if, as heretical theologians suggest, the dot is actually a bit of fly poo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The [[MeaningfulName Pastry War]] of 1838. A Franco-Mexican war that expanded to include Great Britain and United States. During the course of the conflict, France captured almost the entire Mexican fleet, the Republic of Texas moved further into the orbit of the USA and former Mexican dictator Santa Anna was wounded in a clash with Mexican soldiers, paving the way for him to return to power. In the end, the British intervened and force Mexico to pay France the 600'000 pesos compensation the latter had demanded in the first place. Compensation for what, you may ask? [[SeriousBusiness The property of a French baker in Mexico being damaged by Mexican army officers.]]

Removed: 1268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if he ''was'' in love with her, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send the girl over and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but [[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).
*** An interesting alternate explanation for Troy's stupidity is provided by the Egyptian account of the story: the Egyptians record an Anatolian prince making off with a Greek queen (sound familiar?) taking a detour in Egypt before heading for Anatolia. The prince was hauled before the pharaoh, who told him off for kidnapping and sent him packing, but kept the queen in Egypt until she could be returned to Greece. The reason that the Trojans didn't end things by sending Helen is that they didn't have her in the first place, making the whole war a ShaggyDogStory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if he ''was'' in love with her, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but [[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).

to:

** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if he ''was'' in love with her, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl over and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but [[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if they ''did'' love each other, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but [[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).

to:

** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if they ''did'' he ''was'' in love each other, with her, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but [[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if they ''did'' love each other, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but especially Hera).

to:

** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if they ''did'' love each other, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but especially Hera).[[JerkassGods especially]] [[WomanScorned Hera]]).

Added: 903

Changed: 711

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Armenian legend ''AraTheHandsome'', Queen Semiramis of Assyria goes to war with Armenia because King Ara refused to marry her, so she wanted him [[IWantThemAlive brought back to her alive.]]

to:

** On the other hand, none of this explains why Paris refused to send Helen back. A ten-year siege is an awful lot to suffer for one man's desire to bone a hot chick, even if he ''is'' the prince (and even if they ''did'' love each other, which may or may not be supported by the text and didn't really matter in any case). One imagines that after a few ''months'' at most the entire royal court would be after Paris to just send over the girl and have done with it. Of course, the real message of the story is "don't side with the wrong goddess;" no doubt Eris handed an IdiotBall to the Trojans after Paris chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena (but especially Hera).
*** An interesting alternate explanation for Troy's stupidity is provided by the Egyptian account of the story: the Egyptians record an Anatolian prince making off with a Greek queen (sound familiar?) taking a detour in Egypt before heading for Anatolia. The prince was hauled before the pharaoh, who told him off for kidnapping and sent him packing, but kept the queen in Egypt until she could be returned to Greece. The reason that the Trojans didn't end things by sending Helen is that they didn't have her in the first place, making the whole war a ShaggyDogStory.
* In the Armenian legend ''AraTheHandsome'', Queen Semiramis of Assyria goes to war with Armenia because King Ara refused to marry her, her (besides being politically advantageous, Ara was, [[CaptainObvious as you might have guessed]], [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin handsome]]), so she wanted him [[IWantThemAlive brought back to her alive.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Recently, Israel and Lebanon started fighting over a tree that was near the border.

Removed: 407

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To be fair to the elves ([[RunningGag I know, I know]]), they live in trees and their entire civilization revolves around making things from nature's leavings rather than taking what they need from living plants and animals. When a bunch of stumpy, bearded drunks move in next door and start chopping down the local supply of pollen to make beds and swords, it's a legitimate threat to their way of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, Ben pulls a TakeAThirOption by accidently destroying the giant statue of their former united leader (while trying to paint it purple to stop the Blue Vs. Red war), turning both sides against HIM. The episode ends with the same little alien girl who wrote to Ben asking for help at the beginning, writing him a letter about how much she hates him now (but she does reveal that her world has finally found internal peace as they unify to against their new common enemy)

to:

** Well, Ben pulls a TakeAThirOption TakeAThirdOption by accidently accidentally destroying the giant statue of their former united leader (while trying to paint it purple to stop the Blue Vs. Red war), turning both sides against HIM. The episode ends with the same little alien girl who wrote to Ben asking for help at the beginning, writing him a letter about how much she hates him now (but she does reveal that her world has finally found internal peace as they unify to against their new common enemy)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The protagonists arrive to meet (or are visited by) at least two groups who are in a [[SeriousBusiness deadly serious]] conflict over what they (and likely the audience) perceive to be a trivial and petty difference or issue. Like what color scarf they wear, or whether toast should be eaten butter side up or down, or even body features such as which [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything half of their face is black and which is white]].

to:

The protagonists arrive to meet (or are visited by) at least two groups who are in a [[SeriousBusiness deadly serious]] conflict over what they (and likely the audience) perceive to be a trivial and petty difference or issue. Like what color scarf they wear, [[DrSeuss or whether toast should be eaten butter side up or down, down]], or even body features such as which [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything half of their face is black and which is white]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To be fair to the elves ([[RunningGag I know, I know]]), they live in trees and their entire civilization revolves around making things from nature's leavings rather than taking what they need from living plants and animals. When a bunch of stumpy, bearded drunks move in next door and start chopping down the local supply of pollen to make beds and swords, it's a legitimate threat to their way of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As you can guess from the above, this is often paired with AnAesop about how what we consider [[AMatterOfLifeAndDeath life and death]], irreconcilable differences [[BlueAndOrangeMorality must seem petty to aliens]], and maybe we should reconsider our intolerance. If [[{{Anvilicious}} poorly handled]], this can become a FantasticAesop about FantasticRacism when there are real and important differences between the groups that are actually worth hating someone over. Such as vampires drinking human blood to survive. Both overlap when the differences between feuding groups of elves or whatever ARE so tiny as to be irrelevant, as a metaphor for the fact that most human-on-human racism is about differences so tiny as to be irrelevant in the context at issue. Sex matters when making a baby, not when making bond trades or dinner. Skin color matters when choosing a lipstick, not when choosing a president or employee.

to:

As you can guess from the above, this is often paired with AnAesop about how what we consider [[AMatterOfLifeAndDeath life and death]], irreconcilable differences [[BlueAndOrangeMorality must seem petty to aliens]], and maybe we should reconsider our intolerance. If [[{{Anvilicious}} poorly handled]], this can become a FantasticAesop about FantasticRacism when there are real and important differences between the groups that are actually worth hating someone over. Such as vampires drinking human blood to survive. Both overlap when the differences between feuding groups of elves or whatever ARE so tiny as to be irrelevant, as a metaphor for the fact that most human-on-human racism is about differences so tiny as to be irrelevant in the context at issue. Sex matters when making a baby, not when making bond trades or dinner. Skin color matters when choosing a lipstick, not when choosing a president President or employee.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ditto for "president".


As you can guess from the above, this is often paired with AnAesop about how what we consider [[AMatterOfLifeAndDeath life and death]], irreconcilable differences [[BlueAndOrangeMorality must seem petty to aliens]], and maybe we should reconsider our intolerance. If [[{{Anvilicious}} poorly handled]], this can become a FantasticAesop about FantasticRacism when there are real and important differences between the groups that are actually worth hating someone over. Such as vampires drinking human blood to survive. Both overlap when the differences between feuding groups of elves or whatever ARE so tiny as to be irrelevant, as a metaphor for the fact that most human-on-human racism is about differences so tiny as to be irrelevant in the context at issue. Sex matters when making a baby, not when making bond trades or dinner. Skin color matters when choosing a lipstick, not when choosing a President or an employee.

to:

As you can guess from the above, this is often paired with AnAesop about how what we consider [[AMatterOfLifeAndDeath life and death]], irreconcilable differences [[BlueAndOrangeMorality must seem petty to aliens]], and maybe we should reconsider our intolerance. If [[{{Anvilicious}} poorly handled]], this can become a FantasticAesop about FantasticRacism when there are real and important differences between the groups that are actually worth hating someone over. Such as vampires drinking human blood to survive. Both overlap when the differences between feuding groups of elves or whatever ARE so tiny as to be irrelevant, as a metaphor for the fact that most human-on-human racism is about differences so tiny as to be irrelevant in the context at issue. Sex matters when making a baby, not when making bond trades or dinner. Skin color matters when choosing a lipstick, not when choosing a President president or an employee.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Human" is not a proper noun and should therefore not be capitalized.


The protagonists will of course ask just why they're biased against, segregating, or even killing each other over something so asinine, and [[CantArgueWithElves they'll merrily answer]] that [[HumansAreBastards Humans kill each other over less]]. Like colored cloth on sticks, what pigment their skin has, which phrases they pray with, politics, and gender. No, the aliens killing each other over what color hat they wear are ''far'' [[CulturalPosturing above that kind of petty bickering.]]

to:

The protagonists will of course ask just why they're biased against, segregating, or even killing each other over something so asinine, and [[CantArgueWithElves they'll merrily answer]] that [[HumansAreBastards Humans humans kill each other over less]]. Like colored cloth on sticks, what pigment their skin has, which phrases they pray with, politics, and gender. No, the aliens killing each other over what color hat they wear are ''far'' [[CulturalPosturing above that kind of petty bickering.]]

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Everything.

to:

* Everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Seriously, just name one war that doesn't count.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Seriously, just name one war that doesn't count.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There's a beholder that's basically a beholder tree. Hardly practically identical


** The futile and pointless nature of this war is what drew the protoganist to it, as at the time (and throughout the book) he was pretty much looking for a war, any war, to die in

to:

** The futile and pointless nature of this war is what drew the protoganist protagonist to it, as at the time (and throughout the book) he was pretty much looking for a war, any war, to die in



* Any given Beholder in ''DungeonsAndDragons'' is engaged in a never-ending race war against any Beholders not of its breed, killing them on sight. Where this gets to be a "silly reason" is that differences between Beholder breeds are on the order of the skin being a slightly different shade of red, teeth being a slightly different length, or eyeball diameter not being the same -- nothing that's not a Beholder can even tell there ''are'' different breeds of Beholder.

to:

* Any given Beholder in ''DungeonsAndDragons'' is engaged in a never-ending race war against any Beholders not of its breed, killing them on sight. Where this gets to be a "silly reason" is While there are some varieties that differences between Beholder breeds are on the order of the skin being a slightly vastly different shade in terms of red, teeth being a slightly different length, or eyeball diameter not being the same -- nothing that's not a Beholder can appearance and philosophy, they will fight over any difference at all, even tell ones that anyone other than a beholder would never notice. Of course, there ''are'' different breeds of Beholder.is the true Beholder, whose form would clearly be the correct form for a beholder to have. Unfortunately, whenever any beholder sees it the thing looks exactly like them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[{{Warhammer40000}} Dis boyz 'ere propa orky!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, Ben pulls a TakeAThirOption by accidently destroying the giant statue of their former united leader (while trying to paint it purple to stop the Blue Vs. Red war), turning both sides against HIM. The episode ends with the same little alien girl who wrote to Ben asking for help at the beginning, writing him a letter about how much she hates him now (but she does reveal that her world has finally found internal peace as they unify to against their new common enemy)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In UseOfWeapons, part of the CultureSeries of sci-fi novels, one of the many, many, many military conflicts the protoganist took part in was an unending and brutal war on an ice planet. Ostensibly, the war was for control of the constantly shifting iceberg masses that made up the only land surface on the planet. But since these icebergs are inevitably destroyed/melt as they move towards the equator, no victory ever means anything for more than a few months, but the war continues on and on, as both sides had grown to hate the other too much to admit the whole thing was pointless...
** The futile and pointless nature of this war is what drew the protoganist to it, as at the time (and throughout the book) he was pretty much looking for a war, any war, to die in
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, the Ravenloft setting is something of a CrapsackWorld, which in some cases has been implied to be a sort of hell that exists to punish the wicked of other planes - one suspects that hating and fearing that which is different has almost become something of a defense mechanism for the average rank and file denizen.

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Kingdom of Loathing}}''. The Cola Wars were fought between the followers of [[BrandX Dyspepsi-Cola and Cloaca-Cola]]. The war between the Hippies and Frat Boys gets started over the (apparent) murder of an animal mascot.

to:

* ''{{Kingdom of Loathing}}''. The Cola Wars were fought between the followers of [[BrandX [[BlandNameProduct Dyspepsi-Cola and Cloaca-Cola]]. The war between the Hippies and Frat Boys gets started over the (apparent) murder of an animal mascot.

Top