Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / EnhancedInterrogationTechniques

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/{{Homeworld}}'', the cutscene for the third mission describes the results of an interrogation of a Taiidan frigate captain, captured in the orbit of the destroyed Kharak. After revealing to the player the information gleaned from the interrogation, the voiceover calmly states that the officer did not survive the interrogation. Considering that the Kushans have just witnessed their planet's destruction at the hands of the Taiidan, the outcome of the interrogation is understandable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Patrick Robinson's ''USS Seawolf'', [[ChineseWithChopperSupport PLA soldiers]] resort to, among other things, beating TheCaptain and waterboarding his [[NumberTwo executive officer]] [[spoiler:(who happens to be the President's son)]] to elicit info on the titular submarine.

to:

* In Patrick Robinson's ''USS Seawolf'', [[ChineseWithChopperSupport [[UsefulNotes/ChineseWithChopperSupport PLA soldiers]] resort to, among other things, beating TheCaptain and waterboarding his [[NumberTwo executive officer]] [[spoiler:(who happens to be the President's son)]] to elicit info on the titular submarine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[Literature/KnownSpace A Gift From Earth]]'', by Creator/LarryNiven, the authorities don't use physical torture because it would ruin the suspect's use to the body banks. Instead, they use sensory deprivation.

to:

* In ''[[Literature/KnownSpace A Gift From Earth]]'', ''Literature/AGiftFromEarth'', by Creator/LarryNiven, the authorities don't use physical torture because it would ruin the suspect's use to the body banks. Instead, they use sensory deprivation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Averted in ''Series/HawaiiFive0'', where [=McGarrett=] remembers coming to Guantanamo Bay and, against his superiors' wishes, treats a prisoner with respect, allowing him to pray, bringing him food (even apologizing for the food not being halal) and water. Eventually, it pays off, when the prisoner calls him years later and informs him of a terrorist plot in Honolulu. In the flashback, other guards claim that the prisoners are their enemies and should be treated as such, with one stating that they were able to use torture to obtain intel on two possible attacks. [=McGarrett=] counters by saying that tortured people will say anything to stop the torture, whether it's true or not. A little bit of respect goes a long way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WillSmith's character in ''Film/WildWildWest'' uses the DramaticGunCock to force an impostor to reveal himself. The scene is played for laughs. To be fair, it's a dude ''impersonating the president'' who has failed to answer several direct questions about who he is.

to:

* WillSmith's Creator/WillSmith's character in ''Film/WildWildWest'' uses the DramaticGunCock to force an impostor to reveal himself. The scene is played for laughs. To be fair, it's a dude ''impersonating the president'' who has failed to answer several direct questions about who he is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Discworld/NightWatch'', Vimes is flung to the past where PoliceBrutality is ''scientific'', thanks to Captain Swing's system of "craniometrics". Dr. Lawn mentions that one prisoner wound up with fingers pointing entirely the wrong way. When Vimes and his men invade Swing's headquarters, they find a simple chair next to a rack of hammers... oh, and then there's the ginger-beer trick. Vimes ''fakes'' this one to terrify a confession out of a suspect, and later terrifies a clerk with a long metal ruler, and [[{{Fingore}} his own desk drawer]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is done because TortureAlwaysWorks, but it would be [[MoralDissonance unbecoming]] for our heroes to get their hands dirty with a JackBauerInterrogationTechnique. So instead, they use alternative techniques, usually psychological. They make death threats, point around loaded guns, and use things like sleep deprivation. Beatings may or may not apply depending on [[NoHoldsBarredBeatdown how they're depicted]]. The most common, though, are probably the DramaticGunCock and HighAltitudeInterrogation.

to:

This is done because TortureAlwaysWorks, but it would be [[MoralDissonance unbecoming]] for our heroes to get their hands dirty with a JackBauerInterrogationTechnique. So instead, they use alternative techniques, usually psychological. They make death threats, point around loaded guns, and use things like sleep deprivation. Beatings may or may not apply depending on [[NoHoldsBarredBeatdown how they're depicted]]. And sometimes, the tortures may be exacted on [[ForcedToWatch someone else]]. The most common, though, are probably the DramaticGunCock and HighAltitudeInterrogation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's a recurring point in ''Series/BurnNotice'' that physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses, "non-violent" methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.)

to:

* It's a recurring point in ''Series/BurnNotice'' that physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses, "non-violent" methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.) As the narration puts it, at that point the thought process of the person being interrogated goes "If he's willing to do that to himself, what is he going to do to ''me?!"'')
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Films/TheForceAwakens'': One of Kylo Ren's signature abilities involves using the Force to invade his victims' minds. He uses it in two separate interrogations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Films/TheForceAwakens'': One of Kylo Ren's signature abilities involves using the Force to invade his victims' minds. He uses it in two separate interrogations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The focal point of the ''LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit'' episode ''Harm''.

to:

* The focal point of the ''LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit'' ''Series/LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit'' episode ''Harm''."Harm".



* ''{{Homeland}}'' has an interrogation scene after the prisoner has been deprived of sleep from sporadic DeathMetal blasts.

to:

* ''{{Homeland}}'' ''Series/{{Homeland}}'' has an interrogation scene after the prisoner has been deprived of sleep from sporadic DeathMetal blasts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's a recurring ;point in ''Series/BurnNotice'' that physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses, "non-violent" methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.)

to:

* It's a recurring ;point point in ''Series/BurnNotice'' that physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses, "non-violent" methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''ThePowerpuffGirls'', the people of Townsville get [[TheCollector Lenny Baxter]] [[InterrogationByVandalism to reveal where he has the girls by causing him to faint from the sight of kids removing the packaging from his collectibles.]]

to:

* In ''ThePowerpuffGirls'', ''WesternAnimation/ThePowerpuffGirls'', the people of Townsville get [[TheCollector Lenny Baxter]] [[InterrogationByVandalism to reveal where he has the girls by causing him to faint from the sight of kids removing the packaging from his collectibles.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Inverted in ''{{Metalocalypse}}'' with a scene of a teenage Dethklok fan being forced to listen to Dethklok's music at obscenely high volume as punishment for pirating the track on the internet; he suffers severe psychological damage and becomes a villain shortly afterward, and the torture scene isn't treated as anything but a torture scene. (Of course, for Metalocalypse, it's really par for the course.)

to:

* Inverted in ''{{Metalocalypse}}'' ''{{WesternAnimation/Metalocalypse}}'' with a scene of a teenage Dethklok fan being forced to listen to Dethklok's music at obscenely high volume as punishment for pirating the track on the internet; he suffers severe psychological damage and becomes a villain shortly afterward, and the torture scene isn't treated as anything but a torture scene. (Of course, for Metalocalypse, it's really par for the course.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The new ''[[Series/BattlestarGalacticaReimagined Battlestar Galactica]]'' likes this one, particularly the episode "Taking a Break From All Your Worries," including a particularly memorable scene involving the ever-present threat of airlocking.

to:

* The new ''[[Series/BattlestarGalacticaReimagined Battlestar Galactica]]'' ''Series/BattlestarGalactica2003'' likes this one, particularly the episode "Taking a Break From All Your Worries," including a particularly memorable scene involving the ever-present threat of airlocking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''JusticeLeague'' (with a crossover with ''WesternAnimation/BatmanBeyond'') the elderly Bruce Wayne pulls the captive Ghoul away from Batman (his younger self), who had been dangling the villain over the side of a building. "I can't believe I was ever that green," he scoffs. "''This'' is how you interrogate someone." Wayne hefts his cane and advances toward Ghoul. One fade-to-black later, the villain has confessed not only to the organization and capabilities of the Jokerz, but to being a bed-wetter until he was fourteen.

to:

* In ''JusticeLeague'' ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' (with a crossover with ''WesternAnimation/BatmanBeyond'') the elderly Bruce Wayne pulls the captive Ghoul away from Batman (his younger self), who had been dangling the villain over the side of a building. "I can't believe I was ever that green," he scoffs. "''This'' is how you interrogate someone." Wayne hefts his cane and advances toward Ghoul. One fade-to-black later, the villain has confessed not only to the organization and capabilities of the Jokerz, but to being a bed-wetter until he was fourteen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Named for the euphemism used by both the U.S. Government for forms of torture that don't leave marks or cause organ failure, and for ''Verschärfte Vernehmung'', [[GodwinsLaw which is what the Nazis called it when they did it and which translates to the same]]. Compare JackBauerInterrogationTechnique, TortureAlwaysWorks. See also WeHaveWaysOfMakingYouTalk, MaximumFunChamber.

to:

Named for the euphemism used by both the U.S. Government for forms of torture that don't leave marks or cause organ failure, and for ''Verschärfte Vernehmung'', [[GodwinsLaw which is what the Nazis called it when they did it and which translates to the same]]. Compare JackBauerInterrogationTechnique, InterrogationByVandalism, and TortureAlwaysWorks. See also WeHaveWaysOfMakingYouTalk, MaximumFunChamber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Hill:''' Don't you watch the news? Waterboarding's not torture. It's an advance interrogation technique.

to:

-->'''Hill:''' Don't you watch the news? Waterboarding's not torture. It's an advance advanced interrogation technique.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In an issue of Secret Avengers, Hill threatens to waterboard a terrorist. When he says that it would be torture, she replies:
-->'''Hill:''' Don't you watch the news? Waterboarding's not torture. It's an advance interrogation technique.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Zigzagged in ''Film/DickTracy''. When Tracy interrogates Mumbles, he tempts him with water drawn from a fancy cooler, knowing that Mumbles is thirsty. Eventually, Mumbles blurts out something that seems as incomprehensible as anything else he says, but Tracy accepts that as a statement. ''Much'' later in the film, after Tracy has been framed for murder, he again confronts Mumbles with the water cooler, which had a recorder hidden inside; he's then able to slow down the recording to get Mumbles' clearly heard confession, fingering Big Boy Caprice in Lips Manlis' murder. (This would have been inadmissible evidence the first time, but now that Tracy is himself under arrest and doing this without a superior's knowledge, he is able to find out who set him up by threating to let Big Boy hear it.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a subversion. The torture is in the guy thinking he\'ll got shot, not in whether he actually will.


* In ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', Harvey captures Thomas Schiff, one of the Honor Guard the Joker hired to help kill the Mayor, after seeing him wearing a name plate that reads Rachel Dawes. He takes Schiff to an alley, ties him to a chair, shoots a gun into a nearby dumpster to prove he isn't joking, and flips a coin. Tails, and Schiff would die if Schiff didn't start talking. [[spoiler:Subverted. The coin was double-headed.]]

to:

* In ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', Harvey captures Thomas Schiff, one of the Honor Guard the Joker hired to help kill the Mayor, after seeing him wearing a name plate that reads Rachel Dawes. He takes Schiff to an alley, ties him to a chair, shoots a gun into a nearby dumpster to prove he isn't joking, and flips a coin. Tails, and Schiff would die if Schiff didn't start talking. [[spoiler:Subverted. The [[spoiler:The coin was double-headed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Partially justified as this was just after [[spoiler:Gordon had been murdered]] and so Batman was out to cause pain just as much as he was to get information, as exemplified by his ruthless backhanding of a half dozen {{Mooks}} in the previous scene.
*** Also, as Maroni pointed out, he was a professional. Batman uses threats to get information when he can, but threats aren't enough against everyone. In this case, he had to prove that his threats were ''not empty.''
** Still an improvement to the Creator/TimBurton version, who had no aversion to casually murdering random {{Mooks}}.
** Film/TheDarkKnightSaga is also notable for deconstructing TortureAlwaysWorks. Batman uses torture twice in ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', the first time the guy tells him every thing he knows, but only because he wants Batman to know anyway. [[spoiler: The second time the Joker tells him where Dent and Rachel are being held, but switches the addresses and again only because he actually wants Batman to know anyway.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving to Jack Bauer Interrogation Technique, this example does not seem like it was too psychological


* A chilling, implied example happens in ''{{VideoGame/Homeworld}}'' after the "Return to Kharak" mission. During that mission, the crew of the Mothership witness the aftermath of genocide committed on their people and capture one of the enemy's rear-guard ships to question the crew on who and why had made it happen.
--> '''The Tactical Advisor''': The subject... [[DeadlyEuphemism did not survive the interrogation]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''BurnNotice'' episode "do no harm", Michael Westen comments on how torture doesn't work - then throws someone out a window to convince someone else to talk. (The thrown one is caught by a wire attached to the chair to which he's tied.)
** Michael ''frequently'' comments on how physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses long term methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.)

to:

* In the ''BurnNotice'' episode "do no harm", Michael Westen comments on how torture doesn't work - then throws someone out It's a window to convince someone else to talk. (The thrown one is caught by a wire attached to the chair to which he's tied.)
** Michael ''frequently'' comments on how
recurring ;point in ''Series/BurnNotice'' that physical torture doesn't work. The show mentions, and even sometimes uses long term uses, "non-violent" methods that ''do'' break someone such as prolonged isolation, being subjected to loud noise for long periods of time, sleep deprivation, etc. In the end most of those methods take too long, so Michael and company devise clever ways to make a target either trust them or become completely terrified of them, usually without ever laying a hand on the subject. (For example, in one case Sam breaks a con artist by cutting ''himself'' open, dripping the blood all over the con artist, all while talking about what he'll do to the guy. It completely freaks the con artist out.))
** In the episode "Do No Harm", Michael throws one uncooperative captive out of a window to convince another one to talk. Unbeknownst to his partner, the first guy is perfectly safe -- he was attached to a wire and hauled in through the window below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Sam''': Lucky guess. You get to live. ''Now tell me something useful or we'll play another round.''

to:

'''Sam''': '''Fisher''': Lucky guess. You get to live. ''Now tell me something useful or we'll play another round.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Still an improvement to the TimBurton version, who had no aversion to casually murdering random {{Mooks}}.

to:

** Still an improvement to the TimBurton Creator/TimBurton version, who had no aversion to casually murdering random {{Mooks}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A chilling, implied example happens in ''{{VideoGame/Homeworld}}'' after the "Return to Kharak" mission. During that mission, the crew of the Mothership witness the aftermath of genocide committed on their people and capture one of the enemy's rear-guard ships to question the crew on who and why had made it happen.
--> '''The Tactical Advisor''': The subject... [[DeadlyEuphemism did not survive the interrogation]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', Harvey captures Thomas Schiff, one of the Honor Guard the Joker hired to help kill the Mayor, after seeing him wearing a name plate that reads Rachel Dawes. He takes Schiff to an alley, ties him to a chair, shoots a gun into a nearby dumpster to prove he isn't joking, and flips a coin. Tails, and Schiff would die if Schiff didn't start talking. [[spoiler:Subverted. The coin was double-headed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''JusticeLeague'' (with a crossover with ''WesternAnimation/BatmanBeyond'') the elderly Bruce Wayne pulls the captive Ghoul away from Batman (his younger self), who had been dangling the villain over the side of a building. "I can't believe I was ever that green," he scoffs. "''This'' is how you interrogate a suspect." Wayne hefts his cane and advances toward Ghoul. One fade-to-black later, the villain has confessed not only to the organization and capabilities of the Jokerz, but to being a bed-wetter until he was fourteen.

to:

* In ''JusticeLeague'' (with a crossover with ''WesternAnimation/BatmanBeyond'') the elderly Bruce Wayne pulls the captive Ghoul away from Batman (his younger self), who had been dangling the villain over the side of a building. "I can't believe I was ever that green," he scoffs. "''This'' is how you interrogate a suspect.someone." Wayne hefts his cane and advances toward Ghoul. One fade-to-black later, the villain has confessed not only to the organization and capabilities of the Jokerz, but to being a bed-wetter until he was fourteen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/XCOMEnemyUnknown'', like the original, allows you to interrogate captured aliens. Unlike the original, the "interrogated" aliens don't survive the process. One of the characters later comments that he's shocked that [[BewareTheNiceOnes the seemingly-benign Dr. Vahlen would go to these lengths]] (though everyone admits that, ghoulish and inhumane though the methods may be, they are necessary in the face of possible extinction).

to:

* In ''VideoGame/XCOMEnemyUnknown'', like the original, allows you to interrogate captured aliens. Unlike the original, the "interrogated" aliens don't survive the process. One of the characters later comments that he's shocked that [[BewareTheNiceOnes the seemingly-benign Dr. Vahlen would go to these lengths]] (though everyone admits that, ghoulish and inhumane though the methods may be, they are necessary in the face of possible extinction). Although it's implied that the interrogations are less a series of questions but more painful stimulation to read the alien's brain waves.

Top