Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Lost / TropesUToZ

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup

Added DiffLines:

* WhatIf: [[spoiler:The flash-sideways timeline is initially presented as this; the characters' lives had there been no plane crash, no Island, and no interference from Jacob. The series finale, however, shows that it's actually the afterlife]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, this trope was renamed, so moving it accordingly


* WeAllLiveInAmerica: In one particular episode, a woman is on life support and her doctor says that she will be well looked after, the which the patient's sister comments that they can't pay for that. The issue: The hospital is in New South Wales, Australia, where Medicare (or the SIRA, given that it was the result of a car accident) would take care of the bills.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rogue launched trope.


* VillainousExodusMotive: All The Man in Black wanted was to leave the Island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VillainousExodusMotive: All The Man in Black wanted was to leave the Island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Partway through season four "Kevin Johnson", the janitor on the freighter, turns to the camera to reveal he's actually Michael in disguise.

to:

** Partway through season four Towards the end of "Ji Yeon" the freighter's janitor "Kevin Johnson", the janitor on the freighter, turns to Johnson" walks towards the camera to reveal and into the light revealing that he's actually Michael in disguise.

Added: 739

Changed: 65

Removed: 1358

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamEpisode:
** All of the {{Season Finale}}s count in their own way.
*** Season 1: The Hatch has finally been opened, but there's no discernible way in. Michael, Jin, Sawyer, and Walt are attacked by the Others, Walt is kidnapped, Sawyer is shot, and the raft is destroyed.
*** Season 2: Michael betrays the survivors and has Jack, Kate, and Sawyer captured. Locke and Desmond accidentally blow up the Hatch.
*** Season 3: The survivors manage to send a distress call despite [[spoiler:Charlie's]] death, [[spoiler:but the FlashForward reveals that while Jack and Kate managed to escape, Jack's convinced they need to return]].
*** Season 4: [[spoiler:The freighter explodes. Ben moves the Island. The Oceanic Six finally manage to escape the Island]].
*** Season 5: [[spoiler:The survivors in the past accidentally cause The Incident, setting the stage for the own plane crash 27 years later. In the present, Ben murders Jacob]].
*** Season 6: [[spoiler:The true nature of the flash sideways is revealed. Jack manages to kill the Man in Black, passing the title of Island Protector off to Hurley before dying. The survivors move on to the afterlife]].
** The Candidate: [[spoiler:The survivors are all candidates for the title of Protector of the Island, and Jacob has been monitoring and controlling their every move their entire lives. Jack takes on the role as Protector]].

to:

* WhamEpisode:
** All of the {{Season Finale}}s count in their own way.
*** Season 1:
WhamEpisode: The Hatch show has finally been opened, but there's no discernible way in. Michael, Jin, Sawyer, and Walt are attacked by the Others, Walt is kidnapped, Sawyer is shot, and the raft is destroyed.
*** Season 2: Michael betrays the survivors and has Jack, Kate, and Sawyer captured. Locke and Desmond accidentally blow up the Hatch.
*** Season 3: The survivors manage
a [[WhamEpisode/{{Lost}} subpage]] to send a distress call despite [[spoiler:Charlie's]] death, [[spoiler:but the FlashForward reveals that while Jack and Kate managed to escape, Jack's convinced they need to return]].
*** Season 4: [[spoiler:The freighter explodes. Ben moves the Island. The Oceanic Six finally manage to escape the Island]].
*** Season 5: [[spoiler:The survivors in the past accidentally cause The Incident, setting the stage for the own plane crash 27 years later. In the present, Ben murders Jacob]].
*** Season 6: [[spoiler:The true nature of the flash sideways is revealed. Jack manages to kill the Man in Black, passing the title of Island Protector off to Hurley before dying. The survivors move on to the afterlife]].
** The Candidate: [[spoiler:The survivors are all candidates for the title of Protector of the Island, and Jacob has been monitoring and controlling their every move their entire lives. Jack takes on the role as Protector]].
list them all.


Added DiffLines:

* WhamShot:
** At the end of the fourth episode, Locke in a wheelchair at the end of his last flashback. All previous flashbacks throughout it had him behind a desk or in bed.
** In the season 3 finale, the woman Jack is meeting with is actually Kate revealing that all of the "flashbacks" in the episode were actually flash ''forwards'' to after they leave the island.
** Partway through season four "Kevin Johnson", the janitor on the freighter, turns to the camera to reveal he's actually Michael in disguise.
** At the end of the season 4 finale, Jack has opened the coffin of "[[ClarkKenting Jeremy Bentham]]," though we can't see inside of it yet. Then the camera pans over so we can see who "Jeremy Bentham" really is...and it's Locke!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


** A non-bullet variant in the pilot. Jack initially refuses to remove the large piece of shrapnel stuck in the Marshall's stomach as he assumes rescue is coming and they'll be transferred to a sterile environment where the wound can be properly treated. After it becomes clear that help isn't coming, Jack removes the shrapnel and tries to treat the wound with the few antibiotics they were able to scrounge from the plane. It doesn't work and the Marshall is left in such pain the only option left is to [[MercyKill put him out of his misery]].

to:

** A non-bullet variant in the pilot. Jack initially refuses to remove the large piece of shrapnel stuck in the Marshall's Marshal's stomach as he assumes rescue is coming and they'll be transferred to a sterile environment where the wound can be properly treated. After it becomes clear that help isn't coming, Jack removes the shrapnel and tries to treat the wound with the few antibiotics they were able to scrounge from the plane. It doesn't work and the Marshall Marshal is left in such so much pain the only option left is to [[MercyKill put him out of his misery]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeHaveToGetTheBulletOut:
** A non-bullet variant in the pilot. Jack initially refuses to remove the large piece of shrapnel stuck in the Marshall's stomach as he assumes rescue is coming and they'll be transferred to a sterile environment where the wound can be properly treated. After it becomes clear that help isn't coming, Jack removes the shrapnel and tries to treat the wound with the few antibiotics they were able to scrounge from the plane. It doesn't work and the Marshall is left in such pain the only option left is to [[MercyKill put him out of his misery]].
** Early in the second season Sawyer digs a bullet out of his shoulder with his bare fingers. This proves to be a terrible idea as the wound gets infected and he nearly dies of sepsis. Jack is able to save him with some timely surgery and drugs from the Swan hatch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorldOfMysteries: The Island. Though some of its mysteries are resolved, many others (like Hurley's cursed numbers) are not; besides, in-universe, characters and organisations who devote themselves to unravelling the Island's mysteries '''always''' meet a bad end.

to:

* WorldOfMysteries: The Island. Though some of its mysteries are resolved, many others (like Hurley's cursed numbers) are not; besides, in-universe, characters and organisations organizations who devote themselves to unravelling the Island's mysteries '''always''' meet a bad end.



* YearZero: Season 2 Finale established that Oceanic 815 crashed and started the whole thing on September 22, 2004, the same day that ''The Pilot, Part 1'' episode was first aired and, you know, started the whole thing. Since then, fans were able to give all events of Seasons 1-4 an exact date based on the clues within the series. However, a TimeSkip followed and events on Seasons 5-6 can only be put down to the year they happen in, with no precise dating except in relation to each other.

to:

* YearZero: Season 2 Finale established that Oceanic 815 crashed and started the whole thing on September 22, 2004, the same day that ''The Pilot, Part 1'' episode was first aired and, you know, started the whole thing.aired. Since then, fans were able to give all events of Seasons 1-4 an exact date based on the clues within the series. However, a TimeSkip followed and events on Seasons 5-6 can only be put down to the year they happen in, with no precise dating except in relation to each other.other (the zero hour in these two seasons is [[spoiler:the Ajira 316 crash]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* WeAllLiveInAmerica: In one particular episode, a woman is on life support and her doctor says that she will be well looked after, the which the patient's sister comments that they can't pay for that. The issue: The hospital is in New South Wales, Australia, where Medicare (or the SIRA, given that it was the result of a car accident) would take care of the bills.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Hello Aaron."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnseenNoMore:
** The show once depicted its own [[StylisticSuck cheesy]] ShowWithinAShow called "''Exposé''", mostly via island survivor [[MauveShirt Nikki]]'s flashbacks to her time as an actress. In one such flashback, it had its supposedly long-running TheGhost BigBad turn out to be played by none other than Creator/BillyDeeWilliams.
** Jacob is first mentioned early in season 3, but doesn't appear until the season 5 finale.

Added: 1098

Changed: 739

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* TheUnsolvedMystery: Several.

to:

%%* * TheUnsolvedMystery: Several.While more of the Island's mysteries are solved than the series usually gets credit for, a fair amount of questions remain unanswered. The biggest one is likely involving Walt: in a series with characters having explicitly supernatural powers, does Walt indeed have some sort of power or are all the birds just a massive coincidence?



%%* WhamEpisode:
%%** The {{Season Finale}}s, with several in between.
%%** "The Candidate" is probably the biggest non-finale wham episode of the series.

to:

%%* * WhamEpisode:
%%** The ** All of the {{Season Finale}}s, with several Finale}}s count in between.
%%** "The Candidate" is probably
their own way.
*** Season 1: The Hatch has finally been opened, but there's no discernible way in. Michael, Jin, Sawyer, and Walt are attacked by
the biggest non-finale wham episode Others, Walt is kidnapped, Sawyer is shot, and the raft is destroyed.
*** Season 2: Michael betrays the survivors and has Jack, Kate, and Sawyer captured. Locke and Desmond accidentally blow up the Hatch.
*** Season 3: The survivors manage to send a distress call despite [[spoiler:Charlie's]] death, [[spoiler:but the FlashForward reveals that while Jack and Kate managed to escape, Jack's convinced they need to return]].
*** Season 4: [[spoiler:The freighter explodes. Ben moves the Island. The Oceanic Six finally manage to escape the Island]].
*** Season 5: [[spoiler:The survivors in the past accidentally cause The Incident, setting the stage for the own plane crash 27 years later. In the present, Ben murders Jacob]].
*** Season 6: [[spoiler:The true nature
of the series.flash sideways is revealed. Jack manages to kill the Man in Black, passing the title of Island Protector off to Hurley before dying. The survivors move on to the afterlife]].
** The Candidate: [[spoiler:The survivors are all candidates for the title of Protector of the Island, and Jacob has been monitoring and controlling their every move their entire lives. Jack takes on the role as Protector]].



%%* WorldOfBadass: The Island, and flash-sideways LA. %%(Not enough context in the entry.)%%

to:

%%* * WorldOfBadass: The Island, Everyone on the Island manages to kick their fair share of ass, even Jack the doctor and flash-sideways LA. %%(Not enough context Bernard the dentist. [[spoiler:LA in the entry.)%%flash sideways timeline is also one of these]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VillainsOutShopping: In the season 3 opening, the manipulative and murderous Others are seen cooking themselves lunch, attending book club, and giving out marriage advice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VerbedTitle: An irregular verb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed trope. Also removed Conversation In The Main Page.


* YouFailLogicForever: Miles' in-universe response to Hurley's attempts to understand time travel paradoxes. Nevertheless, they talk about it long enough that Hurley brings up what Miles concedes is a valid point: [[spoiler: why didn't Ben remember Sayid as the guy who shot him when he was a kid when they 'met' for the first time in Season 2?]]
** Which is explained later that episode when [[spoiler: Richard tells Kate and Sawyer that Ben will have no memory of what happened.]]
** Not even though, because Ben [[spoiler: lived with Sawyer, Juliet, Jin and Miles for three whole years in the 70s]], and yet he does not remember any of them. There weren't THAT many people in the Initiative.

Changed: 158

Removed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhoWantsToLiveForever: Richard. [[spoiler:After Jacob's death, he desperately wants to die himself because he thinks his work for Jacob was all for nothing, but he can't.]]
** But subverted in the very last episode. When Richard learns that he [[spoiler:finally ages, he tells Miles that he now realizes he wants to live after all.]]

to:

* WhoWantsToLiveForever: Richard. [[spoiler:After Jacob's death, he desperately wants to die himself because he thinks his work for Jacob was all for nothing, but he can't.]]
** But subverted
]] Subverted in the very last episode. When episode, when Richard learns that he [[spoiler:finally ages, [[spoiler:is finally aging, he tells Miles that he now realizes he wants to live after all.]]

Added: 92

Changed: 383

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WithMyHandsTied: Sayid once killed an armed man ''with his ankles''.
* WindowLove: Kate and Jack through a glass barrier, in season 3.
* WomanScorned: Kate goes through this Jack after he gets addicted to pills and abandons her and Aaron. [[OfficialCouple She eventually forgives him, though.]]

to:

* WithMyHandsTied: In "Through the Looking Glass", Sayid once killed kills an armed man ''with his ankles''.
* %%* WindowLove: Kate and Jack through a glass barrier, in season 3.
3. %%(Not enough context in the entry.)%%
* WomanScorned: Kate goes through this Jack after he gets addicted to pills and abandons her and Aaron. [[OfficialCouple She eventually forgives him, though.]]WomanScorned:



* WorldOfBadass: The Island, and flash-sideways LA.

to:

* ** Kate goes through this with Jack after he gets addicted to pills and abandons her and Aaron. [[OfficialCouple She eventually forgives him, though.]]
%%*
WorldOfBadass: The Island, and flash-sideways LA.LA. %%(Not enough context in the entry.)%%
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Examples Are Not General, and also sort of comes off as needless complaining about the show.


* AWizardDidIt: Kind of ends up [[spoiler: being the explanation for the entire show]]. Everytime something happens that obviously relies on too much heavy ContrivedCoincidence or just plainly [[MindScrew doesn't seem to make any sense]], just [[MST3KMantra relax]] and repeat "The Island did it".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]]
* WorldOfMysteries: The Island. Though some of its mysteries are resolved, many others (like Hurley's cursed numbers) are not; besides, in-universe, characters and organisations who devote themselves to unravelling the Island's mysteries '''always''' meet a bad end.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ViewersAreGeniuses: You remember that cheeky shot of Ben reading {{Ulysses}}? Well, ''Lost'' might as well be called ''Intertextuality: The TV Show''. It '''does''' make sense, but if you want to understand it fully you better be prepared to do some Wikipedia legwork, because you're going to need a working knowledge of Hellenic and Buddhist philosophy, Jungian psychology, the principles of cultural clash and the process of "Othering", theories about the subjective nature of reality and the lack of absolute truth, et cetera, et cetera.

to:

* ViewersAreGeniuses: You remember that cheeky shot of Ben reading {{Ulysses}}? Literature/{{Ulysses}}? Well, ''Lost'' might as well be called ''Intertextuality: The TV Show''. It '''does''' make sense, but if you want to understand it fully you better be prepared to do some Wikipedia legwork, because you're going to need a working knowledge of Hellenic and Buddhist philosophy, Jungian psychology, the principles of cultural clash and the process of "Othering", theories about the subjective nature of reality and the lack of absolute truth, et cetera, et cetera.

Added: 12577

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Lost/{{Tropes A to E}} | Lost/{{Tropes F to J}} | Lost/{{Tropes K to O}} | Lost/{{Tropes P to T}} | '''Tropes U to Z'''
----
[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder:U]]
* UnderwaterBase: The Looking Glass and part of The Hydra.
* UnexplainedRecovery: The show is usually very good about keeping characters' wounds consistent from episode to episode, or strongly suggesting that the island was involved when a character heals faster than expected or has a sudden, miraculous full recovery. Which makes it incredibly glaring when Ben gets pinned beneath a tree in the series finale, and this is played for drama as other characters frantically trying to dig him loose, then a few scenes later he catches up to the rest of the heroes like nothing had even happened.
* UnfazedEveryman: Most of the characters with no history in the MythArc, but it's most noticeable with Frank Lapidus, especially in Season Five. [[spoiler:Yet he's also the one who gets everyone off the island; ''both times'']].
* UnreliableExpositor: Anytime we get any exposition, it comes with a side order of this.
* UnreliableNarrator: It turns out that Jack omitted something fairly important from his surgery story in the pilot. It says in the enhanced version of the episode on abc.go.com as the reason for the unreliable narrating: "but Jack was angry with his father and had a complicated relationship with him."
* TheUnreveal: For every major reveal of the series, there's one of these as well.
%%* TheUnsolvedMystery: Several.
* UnstoppableRage:
** Hurley after Sawyer jokes about [[spoiler: being able to see Hurley's imaginary friend, giving him hope about not being crazy for half a second and then taking it away]].
** [[spoiler: Jacob after his brother killed the Mother. That's how we got our Monster]]
** Ben, after [[spoiler:Keamy taunts him about his murder of Alex. He beats him to the ground, and then proceeds to repeatedly stab him. Made even more awesome / terrifying by the fact that Keamy is a muscled mercenary, and Ben is much shorter and slimmer, and you'd usually expect Keamy to overpower Ben.]]
* UnstuckInTime: Several characters, and throughout the first half of season 5 the ''entire Island''.
* UnusualEuphemism: Sayid's former job title in the Revolutionary Guard? "Communications Officer". Because, see, his specialty was "communicating" with prisoners. Regardless of whether or not they ''wanted'' to communicate.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:V]]
* ViewersAreGeniuses: You remember that cheeky shot of Ben reading {{Ulysses}}? Well, ''Lost'' might as well be called ''Intertextuality: The TV Show''. It '''does''' make sense, but if you want to understand it fully you better be prepared to do some Wikipedia legwork, because you're going to need a working knowledge of Hellenic and Buddhist philosophy, Jungian psychology, the principles of cultural clash and the process of "Othering", theories about the subjective nature of reality and the lack of absolute truth, et cetera, et cetera.
* VillainDecay: As of the end of Season 5, [[TheChessmaster Ben]] has been reduced to just another pawn in The Man in Black's extended chess match against Jacob. He knows it too, and isn't the least bit happy about it. It should be noted that only a few episodes after we learned Ben led the Others we found out Jacob gave the orders (the list for instance), so we should have seen this one coming.
** Though it's implied that Ben's mere existence and free will is the "loophole" that Jacob's nemesis needed to kill Jacob, making him the most important character in the show... let's just say this: Ben in early seasons: Leader of the Others and MagnificentBastard. Ben at the end of the series:[[spoiler: Hurley's sidekick]]
* VillainousBSOD: Ben gets one of these for about ten seconds after Keamy kills Alex.
* TheVirus: [[spoiler:The Sickness, as revealed in Season 6.]]
* VomitIndiscretionShot: Used at least a couple of times. Sawyer, after he [[spoiler:kills Anthony Cooper]] and Locke, when he [[spoiler:teleports to Africa and breaks that poor, poor leg]].
[[/folder]]

[[folder:W]]
%%* WastelandElder: Jack
* {{Webisode}}: 13 "Missing Pieces", which were released for mobile phones and later online between Seasons 3 and 4. Also available on Season 4 Bonus DVD.
* WeJustNeedToWaitForRescue: Season 1 has a sub-plot where Jack insists that the survivors don't need to make a life on the island, they just need to wait for rescue. Measures such as keeping a signal fire going, trying to give a radio signal, and staying on the beach are implemented. In the end, of course, no one ever rescues them and weirdness ensues.
* WellIntentionedExtremist: The Others, who's main priority is to protect The Island at all costs. [[spoiler:If they had a bit more direct contact with Jacob, their war with the survivors may not have gotten so bad.]]
** [[spoiler:Michael, who killed two fellow survivors and led four more into an ambush, to save his son.]]
** Jack and Locke have shown shades of this at times, too.
** Season 6 implies that [[spoiler:Charles Widmore]] may be this.
%%* WhamEpisode:
%%** The {{Season Finale}}s, with several in between.
%%** "The Candidate" is probably the biggest non-finale wham episode of the series.
* WhamLine: "Because I want it to crash, Kate."
** In the season six premiere: "Sorry you had to see me like that."
** The following exchange from the SeriesFinale:
---> '''Jack:''' But...[[spoiler: you're dead]]. How are you here?\\
[[spoiler:'''Christian''']]: [[spoiler:[[DeadAllAlong How are YOU here]]]]?
** "My name is Sayid Jarrah, and I am a torturer."
** "This time... you have to die."
** "They're coming tonight... they're coming RIGHT NOW!"
** "Always nice talking to you [[spoiler:Jacob]]."
** We're gonna have to take the boy."
* WhatHappenedToTheMouse:
** Cindy Chandler and the kids she was kidnapped by the Others to protect, disappeared after the mortar attack on the Others by Charles Widmore. Apparently, they "scattered into the jungle" along with the few surviving Others.
** What happened to Annie, Ben's only childhood friend? We were told in Series 3 and 4, she'd be very important to the finale, and Ben's fascination with Juliet was hinted at because she "looks just like her". But she was never mentioned again after Series 4. Did she survive the Purge? Was she merely just his girlfriend, who'd gotten pregnant and died, explaining his over the top reaction to Alex and Carl? She seemed to have been "Eaten by the Cat" to coin a phrase.
** Walt. The Epilogue thankfully gave his character arc some much needed closure.
* WhoWantsToLiveForever: Richard. [[spoiler:After Jacob's death, he desperately wants to die himself because he thinks his work for Jacob was all for nothing, but he can't.]]
** But subverted in the very last episode. When Richard learns that he [[spoiler:finally ages, he tells Miles that he now realizes he wants to live after all.]]
* WholeEpisodeFlashback:
** "The Other 48 Days", telling season one from The Tailies' perspective.
** "Ab Aeterno", almost--it took six extra minutes to fit in the present-day part of the plot.
** "Across The Sea", [[spoiler:the Jacob/MIB origin story, which has one minute of non-flashback material-- which is ''also'' a flashback to a scene from season one.]]
%%* WistfulAmnesia: The flash sideways.
* WithMyHandsTied: Sayid once killed an armed man ''with his ankles''.
* WindowLove: Kate and Jack through a glass barrier, in season 3.
* AWizardDidIt: Kind of ends up [[spoiler: being the explanation for the entire show]]. Everytime something happens that obviously relies on too much heavy ContrivedCoincidence or just plainly [[MindScrew doesn't seem to make any sense]], just [[MST3KMantra relax]] and repeat "The Island did it".
* WomanScorned: Kate goes through this Jack after he gets addicted to pills and abandons her and Aaron. [[OfficialCouple She eventually forgives him, though.]]
** Sawyer's old girlfriend Cassidy after he runs a long con on her and dumps her.
* WorldOfBadass: The Island, and flash-sideways LA.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:X-Y-Z]]
* XanatosSpeedChess:
** Michael Emerson pretty much said himself (in layman's terms) that Ben is doing this throughout Season Five:
-->"I think Ben has a lot of layers of plans, but I think we're way off the main stem of anything that works for him. I mean, Ben's doing like moment-to-moment scrambling now."
** The Man in Black can now lay a good claim to being the ''master'' of Xanatos Speed Chess after the events of "The Candidate"; see The Chessmaster above.
* YearZero: Season 2 Finale established that Oceanic 815 crashed and started the whole thing on September 22, 2004, the same day that ''The Pilot, Part 1'' episode was first aired and, you know, started the whole thing. Since then, fans were able to give all events of Seasons 1-4 an exact date based on the clues within the series. However, a TimeSkip followed and events on Seasons 5-6 can only be put down to the year they happen in, with no precise dating except in relation to each other.
* YouAlreadyChangedThePast: Whatever happened, happened. Maybe.
** In a sense, this is double subverted. It appears to be the rule until the finale of season 5, when [[spoiler: the bomb creates an alternate reality. However, in the series finale, it is revealed that the "alternate reality" is really the afterlife and it wasn't actually caused by the bomb.]] So, in the end, the trope is used consistently.
* YouALLShareMyStory: Many of the characters have knowingly or unknowingly encountered each other before coming to the island.
* YouCalledMeXItMustBeSerious: At the end of season 3 of, Sawyer's in a funk after finally killing Cooper. Sawyer repeatedly addresses Kate by her name instead of "Freckles" or another nickname when she confronts him about what's wrong:
-->'''Kate:''' Ever since you got that tape from Locke it's like you've been sleepwalking. You don't care about our friends, fine, but it's like you don't care about anything anymore. And since when did you start calling me Kate?
** It's a sign that things are getting really serious when almost ''everyone'' begins referring to Sawyer and Hurley by their given names (James and Hugo, respectively) instead of their nicknames.
* YouCantFightFate: The debate of free will vs. fate is a recurring theme in the series, with Eloise explicitly telling Desmond that one's destiny cannot be avoided.
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: Once some of the survivors make it off the island, at least Jack and Hurley end up convinced they shouldn't have left in the first place.
** Also happens, from the other side, to Ben at the end of season four after he moves the island, meaning he can never return to it.
** Until he does. He admits that he broke the rules by doing so, and that there would be consequences (which he was ultimately spared from).
* YouFailLogicForever: Miles' in-universe response to Hurley's attempts to understand time travel paradoxes. Nevertheless, they talk about it long enough that Hurley brings up what Miles concedes is a valid point: [[spoiler: why didn't Ben remember Sayid as the guy who shot him when he was a kid when they 'met' for the first time in Season 2?]]
** Which is explained later that episode when [[spoiler: Richard tells Kate and Sawyer that Ben will have no memory of what happened.]]
** Not even though, because Ben [[spoiler: lived with Sawyer, Juliet, Jin and Miles for three whole years in the 70s]], and yet he does not remember any of them. There weren't THAT many people in the Initiative.
* YoureNotMyFather:
** Claire's response to her father.
** Walt's exact words to Michael when they're in the hotel.
* YouKilledMyFather: Averted. [[spoiler:Jacob]] isn't Ilana's biological father, but "the closest thing (she had) to a father." Nevertheless she didn't kill [[spoiler:Ben.]]
* YouWouldntShootMe:
** Subverted when Sawyer has [[spoiler: Tom at his mercy. After he surrenders, Sawyer (remembering his capture and threatening of Kate, as well as his involvement in kidnapping Walt, shooting Sawyer, and attempted murder of everybody on the raft)]] takes deliberate aim and kills him.
--> '''Hurley:''' Dude... he'd surrendered.\\
'''Sawyer:''' I didn't believe him.
** Also, Colleen and Sun in The Glass Ballerina.
** And Locke pulls an interesting subversion or twist on Sawyer: "If there were any bullets in that gun, why would you have held a knife to my throat?"
** Also subverted by Jack in the Season 4 premiere.
---> '''Locke:''' You're not gonna shoot me, Jack, any more than I was gonna shoot...\\
'''Jack:''' [''Click'']\\
'''Locke:''' It's not loaded, Jack.
** However, it works for the undercover cop when he tries it on Locke.
[[/folder]]
----

Top