Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / JonathanStrangeAndMrNorrell

Go To

OR

Added: 748

Removed: 745

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllMythsAreTrue: An interesting variation - only some myths are true, Merlin was explicitly stated to be true while magic mirrors are false (any mirror will do). The characters themselves aren't sure which myths are true. Beings from Christian theology and ancient religions also show up in this universe; the Raven King is said to have been on good terms with most angels and demons, but quarrelled with Zadkiel and Alrinach. Also in a footnote, Merlin is described as being half-demon. Hermes (Trismegistus, specifically) also has a passing mention near the end as the "God of all magicians" implying that while Christian theology is focused on, there may be other realms that Christians are unaware of, ignore or simply lump in with Faerie.


Added DiffLines:

* CrossoverCosmology: An interesting variation - only some myths are true, Merlin was explicitly stated to be true while magic mirrors are false (any mirror will do). The characters themselves aren't sure which myths are true. Beings from Christian theology and ancient religions also show up in this universe; the Raven King is said to have been on good terms with most angels and demons, but quarrelled with Zadkiel and Alrinach. Also in a footnote, Merlin is described as being half-demon. Hermes (Trismegistus, specifically) also has a passing mention near the end as the "God of all magicians" implying that while Christian theology is focused on, there may be other realms that Christians are unaware of, ignore or simply lump in with Faerie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadlyDecadentCourt: Lost-hope, and most of Faerie by extension.

to:

* DeadlyDecadentCourt: DecadentCourt: Lost-hope, and most of Faerie by extension.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GhostlyWail: The undead soldiers that Mr. Strange [[{{Necromancer}} conjures up]] can only speak in a ghastly unintelligble shriek, which he eventually identifies as the BlackSpeech of {{Hell}}.

to:

* GhostlyWail: The undead soldiers that Mr. Strange [[{{Necromancer}} conjures up]] can only speak in a ghastly unintelligble unintelligible shriek, which he eventually identifies as the BlackSpeech of {{Hell}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking from Ghostly Wail

Added DiffLines:

* GhostlyWail: The undead soldiers that Mr. Strange [[{{Necromancer}} conjures up]] can only speak in a ghastly unintelligble shriek, which he eventually identifies as the BlackSpeech of {{Hell}}.

Added: 197

Removed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EssentialMadness: The eponymous Strange must drink a bottle of distilled madness (causing him to lose his mind) in order to be able to see and interact with TheFairFolk on their own terms.


Added DiffLines:

* SuccessThroughInsanity: The eponymous Strange must drink a bottle of distilled madness (causing him to lose his mind) in order to be able to see and interact with TheFairFolk on their own terms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 252

Changed: 897

Removed: 1040

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlueAndOrangeMorality:
** The gentleman with the thistle-down hair seems entirely unable to comprehend regular human morality, love or ethics, and seems to lack any kind of empathy. At his worst he kills a dozen people in pursuit of Stephen's true name, simply because they were connected to those present at Stephen's mother's death, but cannot understand Stephen's horror. He's casually sadistic, yet also cannot comprehend racism. He shows a genuine liking for King George, yet is more than happy to murder him.
** The gentleman finds it even more difficult to understand human society than humans do to discern fairy culture. He cannot comprehend why if he kills George III that Stephen Black would not be immediately crowned due to his attractiveness and charm.
** TheFairFolk also consider Christianity to be this -- a footnote mentions that centuries ago, someone left a pair of boots in a fairy's castle, and they were regarded as objects of dread for fear that in some inscrutable way, Christian morality might hold the fairies responsible for their theft.

to:

* BlueAndOrangeMorality:
**
BlueAndOrangeMorality: The moralities of fairies and humans are entirely incomprehensible to each other. The gentleman with the thistle-down thistledown hair seems entirely unable is guided by values that are utterly opaque to comprehend regular human morality, love or ethics, and seems to lack any kind of empathy. At his worst he the humans around him. He kills a dozen number of people in pursuit of to find Stephen's true name, simply because they were connected name and is perfectly willing to those present at kill King George even though he likes him. The gentleman is also charmed by Stephen's mother's death, but cannot beauty and doesn't understand Stephen's horror. He's casually sadistic, yet also cannot comprehend racism. He shows a genuine liking for why he can't be King George, yet is more than happy to murder him.
**
of England. The gentleman finds it even more difficult to understand human society than footnotes mention this trend as well, relating how fairies were terrified that humans do to discern fairy culture. He cannot comprehend why if he kills George III that Stephen Black would not be immediately crowned due to his attractiveness and charm.
** TheFairFolk also consider Christianity to be this -- a footnote mentions that centuries ago, someone left a pair of boots in a fairy's castle, and they were regarded as objects of dread
would, for fear that in some inscrutable way, Christian morality might hold the fairies responsible for reason, accuse them of stealing a pair of boots that someone left in one of their theft.castles.



* DarkIsNotEvil: the Raven King is mysterious and a bit alien, but seems ultimately benevolent. (Certainly compared to other natives of Faerie.) Similarly Childermass is enigmatic in his loyalties and purposes, but also one of the morally better people in the story.

to:

* DarkIsNotEvil: the DarkIsNotEvil:
** The
Raven King is mysterious and a bit alien, but seems ultimately benevolent. (Certainly compared to other natives of Faerie.) Similarly Childermass is enigmatic in his loyalties and purposes, but also one of the morally better people in the story.



* GentlemanWizard: See the page quote. The titular characters, as well as the magic societies, if you consider them wizards despite their not actually ''doing'' any magic. Magic is considered the realm of the idle gentry, and Mr Norrell is not pleased to learn that Strange intends to teach a Jew.

to:

* GentlemanWizard: See the page quote. The titular characters, as well as the magic societies, if you consider them wizards despite their not actually ''doing'' any magic. Magic is considered the realm of the idle gentry, and Mr Norrell is not pleased to learn that Strange intends to teach a Jew.

Added: 584

Changed: 135

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceGuy: Childermass often tries to encourage Norrell's better nature, and acts only in the interests of English magic with zero self-interest.

to:

* NiceGuy: NiceGuy:
**
Childermass often tries to encourage Norrell's better nature, and acts only in the interests of English magic with zero self-interest.self-interest.
** Mr Segundus is such a nice guy that it's even called out by the Narrator, and spends most of his page-time prioritising English magic and Lady Pole's welfare over his own interests.
--->'''Narrator:''' For who can remain angry with Mr Segundus? I dare say there are people in the world who are able to resent goodness and amiability, whose spirits are irritated by gentleness - but I am glad to say that Jonathan Strange was not of their number.

Added: 1808

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExactWords: [[spoiler:When the gentleman with thistle-down hair predicts that Stephen will become the king of a kingdom he has already been to, he assumes that means England. It doesn't appear to occur to him that Stephen has been to one other kingdom: Lost-Hope.]]



* HypocriticalHumor: The gentleman with thistle-down hair once tells Stephen, about Strange, "I have never heard anyone talk so much! He is quite the most conceited person I have ever met. People like that who must be continually talking themselves and have no time to listen to any one else are quite disgusting to me." This, of course, describes the gentleman precisely.



* MobileMaze: Norrell's house has one, particularly when one is attempting to reach the library.



%%* NobilityMarriesMoney: Sir Walter Pole's marriage to Emma Wintertowne.

to:

%%* * NobilityMarriesMoney: Sir Walter Pole's Pole is a politician, but doesn't have much money. His marriage to the wealthy Emma Wintertowne.Wintertowne solves that.


Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: English magical history has a number of occurrences that no one in the Nineteenth Century really understands, such as the time the Raven King "quarreled with Winter and banished it from his kingdom, so that for four years Northern England enjoyed continual Summer."


Added DiffLines:

* OhMyGods: Fairies have little understanding of Christianity, but they did tend to venerate the saints, thinking they must be powerful magicians whose aid it would be useful to have. They therefore would randomly sprinkle various saints' names into their spells, which came to be called "florilegia." They taught these spells to English magicians, too, but when Catholicism was supplanted by Protestantism florilegia degenerated further into meaningless phrases that magicians would throw in, hoping to give their spells a little extra kick. (Norell finds florilegia worthless and tends to eliminate them from his spells.)


Added DiffLines:

* SuicideByCop: [[spoiler:When Lascelles fights the Champion of the Castle of the Plucked Eye and Heart, it seems to Lascelles that the Champion deliberately missed.]]

Added: 712

Removed: 491

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheIngenue: Both Emma and Arabella already have shades of this, but Flora Greysteel ''breathes'' the trope.



* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, Francisco Goya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.
* TheIngenue: Both Emma and Arabella already have shades of this, but Flora Greysteel ''breathes'' the trope.


Added DiffLines:

* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, Francisco Goya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.
* InternalReveal: After the muffle enchantment is lifted, [[spoiler:Lady Pole]] is able to reveal the backstory of the majority of the book's events to two key participants... almost ten years after the inciting incident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyCatLady: Mrs Delgado. [[spoiler: Strange gives her what she wants most in exchange for the key to madness - he transforms her into a cat]].

to:

* CrazyCatLady: Mrs Delgado. [[spoiler: Strange [[spoiler:Strange gives her what she wants most in exchange for the key to madness - he transforms her into a cat]].



* MushroomSamba: Strange's experiences after drinking [[spoiler:distilled madness]] read as nothing so much as someone's first trip on acid.



* PsychoSerum: Strange deliberately drinks essentially [[spoiler: "distilled madness"]] out of the logic that since lunatics can see fairies without relying on the fairies revealing themselves, he needs to [[spoiler: become insane to be able to see the gentleman with thistle-down hair.]] (Strange's summoning spells worked, as the gentleman himself admits to Stephen, but since the gentleman did not wish to speak to Strange he remained invisible to him. [[spoiler: The madness allows Strange to see past the glamour, to the gentleman's great shock.]])

to:

* PsychoSerum: Strange deliberately drinks essentially [[spoiler: "distilled [[spoiler:"distilled madness"]] out of the logic that since lunatics can see fairies without relying on the fairies revealing themselves, he needs to [[spoiler: become [[spoiler:become insane to be able to see the gentleman with thistle-down hair.]] (Strange's summoning spells worked, as the gentleman himself admits to Stephen, but since the gentleman did not wish to speak to Strange he remained invisible to him. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The madness allows Strange to see past the glamour, to the gentleman's great shock.]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Osprey Games publish a TabletopGame called ''Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell: A Board Game of English Magic''.

to:

Osprey Games publish published a TabletopGame called ''Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell: A Board Game of English Magic''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Osprey Games publish a TabletopGame called ''Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell: A Board Game of English Magic''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Submissive Badass is only meant to be an index, not a trope on its own.


* SubmissiveBadass: Childermass can out-think pretty much all of the characters in the novel, and out-magic the majority of them. He is determined to serve Mr Norrell until it is disadvantageous for magic in England to do so. Indeed his submissiveness is one reason he is badass: in over 23 years of service to Norrell, he has learnt various spells, making him the secret third magician in Britain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MuggleWithADegreeInMagic: Until the revelation of the titular characters, ''all'' magic scholars are muggles, and have been for hundreds of years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TongueTied: Arabella Strange and Stephen Black are cursed by the Gentleman with the Thistle-down Hair to be unable to speak of their enslavement. If they try to tell anyone, they end up telling nonsensical fairy tales instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Arabella, Lady Pole and Stephen are released from their enchantment, Stephen kills the Gentleman with the thistle down hair, and magic is fully restored to England. But Stephen is utterly disillusioned with his life in England and leaves to become the new king of Losthope, and Strange and Norrell are trapped in eternal darkness for the foreseeable future. While this doesn't bother Norrell so much, Jonathan and Arabella are separated and uncertain of when they will meet again. But until then Norrell and Strange can happily practice magic and explore realms.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Arabella, Lady Pole and Stephen are released from their enchantment, Stephen kills the Gentleman with the thistle down thistle-down hair, and magic is fully restored to England. But Stephen is utterly disillusioned with his life in England and leaves to become the new king of Losthope, Lost-hope, and Strange and Norrell are trapped in eternal darkness for the foreseeable future. While this doesn't bother Norrell so much, Jonathan and Arabella are separated and uncertain of when they will meet again. But until then Norrell and Strange can happily practice magic and explore realms.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mr. Norrell himself, who is unmarried, and seemingly obsessed with Strange at their first meeting, jealous of his wife, and deeply frustrated at the thought of him leaving to help with the war effort. An aside in a footnote about an old magician's love letters to his unisex-named lover mentions that Mr Norrell is much more comfortable with the idea of a gay magician than a woman.

to:

** Mr. Norrell himself, who is unmarried, and seemingly obsessed with Strange at their first meeting, jealous of his wife, and deeply frustrated at the thought of him leaving to help with the war effort. An aside in a footnote about an old magician's love letters to his unisex-named lover mentions that Mr Norrell is much more comfortable with the idea of a gay magician than a woman.female magician.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: One of Norrel's objections to Vinculus's prophecy is that fortune-telling tends to be unreliable. Of course, some of his other objections are that it invokes the Raven King, that prophecies in general don't align with his idea of respectable English magic, and that Vinculus broke into his house to recite it to him, so that claim might come off as dubious. However, in this case he's entirely right: [[spoiler: it's not a prophecy at all. It's the Raven King's to-do list.]]

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: One of Norrel's objections to Vinculus's prophecy is that fortune-telling tends to be unreliable. Of course, some of his other objections are that it invokes the Raven King, that prophecies in general don't align with his idea of respectable English magic, and that Vinculus broke into his house to recite it to him, so that claim might come off as dubious. However, in this case he's entirely right: [[spoiler: it comes true because it's not a prophecy at all. It's the Raven King's [[TheChessmaster to-do list.list]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: One of Norrel's objections to Vinculus's prophecy is that fortune-telling tends to be unreliable. Of course, some of his other objections are that it invokes the Raven King, that prophecies in general don't align with his idea of respectable English magic, and that Vinculus broke into his house to recite it to him, so that claim might come off as dubious. However, in this case he's entirely right: [[spoiler: it's not a prophecy at all. It's the Raven King's to-do list.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChemicallyInducedInsanity: Mr. Strange {{Invoke|dTrope}}s this on himself: realizing that TheFairFolk are [[ByTheEyesOfTheBlind visible to madmen]] even when they're making themselves InvisibleToNormals, he creates an {{alchem|yIsMagic}}ical distillation of insanity and spends a few days wandering around Venice in a hallucinatory stupor. It even lets him find the [[BigBad Gentleman with Thistledown Hair]], to the Gentleman's considerable surprise, though he's too loopy to realize it until after the fact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IHaveManyNames: The Raven King, aka John Uskglass, aka the Black King of the North, aka the nameless slave (from his changeling childhood, though rarely used and [[spoiler: key to the climax of the novel]]), etc. This actually figures into the plot when [[spoiler: Strange and Norrell try to magically locate the Raven King but can't figure out which name to use in the spell. Norrell speculates that The Raven King did this on purpose, because names are such an important part of magic. Without his true name, it gets difficult to do anything related to the person you're trying to target.]]

to:

* IHaveManyNames: The Raven King, aka John Uskglass, aka the Black King of the North, aka the nameless slave (from his changeling childhood, though rarely used and [[spoiler: key to the climax of the novel]]), etc. This actually figures into the plot when [[spoiler: Strange and Norrell try to magically locate the Raven King but can't figure out which name to use in the spell. Norrell speculates that The Raven King did this on purpose, because names are such an important part of magic. Without his true name, it gets difficult to do anything related to the person you're trying to target. In the end, they just cast a spell asking for "the king", using as many items with connections to The Raven King as possible as ritual components, as a way of specifying which king they're talking about.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeCarefulWhatYouSay: The trope is invoked twice near the ending. Firstly, the gentleman with the thistle-down hair [[spoiler: places a curse of Darkness]] on Strange, naming him as "the English magician". Since he failed to be more specific, [[spoiler: the Darkness also begins to affects Norrell once Strange reaches him, and the two are bound together until the curse can be broken.]] The second instance is of major importance to the fate of England and its English Magic: [[spoiler: Norrell and Strange address "the nameless slave" in their spell, hoping to reach the Raven King. The spell finds Stephen Black instead.]]

to:

* BeCarefulWhatYouSay: The trope is invoked twice near So, so much. Mr Norrell resurrects Ms Wintertowne by [[spoiler: summoning a fairy, namely, the ending. Firstly, gentleman with the thistledown hair,]] and offering him [[spoiler: half her life. Mr Norrell thinks this means she'll die in her 40s, but instead the gentleman takes her to a fairy ball every night, forcing her to dance all night instead of sleeping.]] Later, the gentleman with the thistle-down hair [[spoiler: places a curse of Darkness]] on Strange, naming him as "the English magician". Since he failed to be more specific, [[spoiler: the Darkness also begins to affects Norrell once Strange reaches him, and the two are bound together until the curse can be broken.]] The second instance is of major importance to the fate of England and its English Magic: [[spoiler: Norrell and Strange address "the nameless slave" in their spell, hoping to reach the Raven King. The spell finds Stephen Black instead.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlcoholInducedStupidity: Vinculus's late father tended to suffer from this, the most notable incident being when he accepted a drunken wager to [[spoiler:eat a priceless book of magic allegedly written by the Raven King himself, which resulted in the contents of the book being indelibly marked on the skin of the child he fathered a few days later.]]

to:

* AlcoholInducedStupidity: Vinculus's late father tended to suffer from this, the most notable incident being when he accepted a drunken wager to [[spoiler:eat a priceless book of magic allegedly written by the Raven King himself, which resulted in the contents of the book being indelibly marked on the skin of the child he fathered a few days later.]]later, as well as his own execution by hanging for "book murder."]]

Added: 599

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkIsNotEvil: the Raven King is mysterious and a bit alien, but seems ultimately benevolent. (Certainly compared to other natives of Faerie.) Similarly Childermass is enigmatic in his loyalties and purposes, but also one of the morally better people in the story.
** Dark is also morally ambiguous with regard to Strange's reanimating the dead Neapolitans; it's only Lascelles (not a magician, and intending to slander Strange) who calls it Black Magic, and when the Raven King did the same magic in the Middle Ages the only problem his friend had with it was how he treated the man he reanimated.



* NameAmnesia: The character called "Stephen Black" is apparently not actually named Stephen Black, or so it would seem according to the rules of magic, because 'Stephen' was a slave name and not his true name given to him by his mother at his birth, which has been lost. As such, Magic considers him to be "The Nameless King", which is problematic because there is also a historical figure prevalent in the story, the Raven King, who was also given a slave name that was not his real name, John Uskglass, and is also referred to as "The Nameless King". Spells meant to address the latter Nameless King accidentally affect the former Nameless King.

to:

* NameAmnesia: The character called "Stephen Black" is apparently not actually named Stephen Black, or so it would seem according to the rules of magic, because 'Stephen' was a slave name and not his true name given to him by his mother at his birth, which has been lost. As such, Magic considers him to be "The Nameless King", Slave", which is problematic because there is also a historical figure prevalent in the story, the Raven King, who was also given a slave name that was not his real name, John Uskglass, and is also referred to as "The Nameless King". Spells meant to address the latter Nameless King Slave accidentally affect the former Nameless King.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StealthPun: The general who dubs his right-hand magician "Merlin"? That [[ShroudedInMyth semi-mythical]] English leader, ''[[ArthurianLegend Arthur]]'' Wellesley.

to:

* StealthPun: The general who dubs his right-hand magician "Merlin"? That [[ShroudedInMyth semi-mythical]] English leader, ''[[ArthurianLegend ''[[Myth/ArthurianLegend Arthur]]'' Wellesley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiHero: Norrell is an old-fashioned example; Strange is a Byronic one.

to:

* AntiHero: Norrell is an old-fashioned example; Strange is a Byronic one. one (who is actually on good terms with Lord Byron.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's a joke about how everyone overlooks Wales. It very clearly still exists in the book (e.g. The Prince of Wales is still the title for the heir to the British Crown)


* ThrowAwayCountry: A footnote implies that the country of Wales has been magically [[RetGone erased from existence]], [[LostCommonKnowledge its language remaining only in the minds of the insane.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlcoholInducedStupidity: Vinculus' late father tended to suffer from this, the most notable incident being when he accepted a drunken wager to [[spoiler:eat a priceless book of magic allegedly written by the Raven King himself, which resulted in the contents of the book being indelibly marked on the skin of the child he fathered a few days later.]]

to:

* AlcoholInducedStupidity: Vinculus' Vinculus's late father tended to suffer from this, the most notable incident being when he accepted a drunken wager to [[spoiler:eat a priceless book of magic allegedly written by the Raven King himself, which resulted in the contents of the book being indelibly marked on the skin of the child he fathered a few days later.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to YMMV subpage as it's a subjective, Just For Fun wick


* XMeetsY: The book has been described as "J.R.R. Tolkien meets Creator/JaneAusten", "Literature/HarryPotter for Adults", or "Harry Potter for History Buffs".

Top