Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / JediAcademyTrilogy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetCon:

to:

* RetCon:{{Retcon}}:



** ''I, Jedi'' itself had to be retconned by Creator/DavidSherman and Creator/DanCragg's ''Literature/JediTrial'' after the prequels contradicted some of the timing in the Halcyon/Horn family tree, a common problem for pre-''[[Film/ThePhantomMenace Phantom Menace]]'' novels. Creator/TimothyZahn's [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy Thrawn trilogy]] ran into this, too.

to:

** ''I, Jedi'' itself had to be retconned by Creator/DavidSherman and Creator/DanCragg's ''Literature/JediTrial'' after the prequels contradicted some of the timing in the Halcyon/Horn family tree, a common problem for pre-''[[Film/ThePhantomMenace Phantom Menace]]'' novels. Creator/TimothyZahn's [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy Thrawn trilogy]] ran into this, too.novels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[WhoDares Who]] '''[[WhoDares DARES?!]]''':

to:

* [[WhoDares Who]] '''[[WhoDares DARES?!]]''': WhoDares:
Tabs MOD

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse of [[invoked]] tag


** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy [[DoylistVersusWatsonian because Stackpole hadn't even created the character yet]]). Later Legends material filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]][[invoked]] (there are are at least four possible candidates for the remaining two).

to:

** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy [[DoylistVersusWatsonian because Stackpole hadn't even created the character yet]]). Later Legends material filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]][[invoked]] Twelve (there are are at least four possible candidates for the remaining two).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompressedAdaptation: The first act of ''I, Jedi'' is a POVSequel covering the high points of Luke Skywalker's storyline in ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: Given how much of Yavin 4's sky Yavin fills, Four has to be tidally locked. So there should be only "Twi-night" on that side, and only ever "Truenight" on the far side.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: ArtisticLicenseSpace: Given how much of Yavin 4's sky Yavin fills, Four has to be tidally locked. So there should be only "Twi-night" on that side, and only ever "Truenight" on the far side.

Added: 321

Changed: 318

Removed: 330

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Edited due to duplication


* PragmaticVillainy: For obvious reasons, when Corran goes undercover with the Invids in ''I, Jedi'', he starts [[InvokedTrope encouraging the other pirates to practice this]] to promote cooperation in the future. While a few of the pirates are in it more ForTheEvulz, most of them recognize the potential of this racket [[spoiler:and end up accepting a legitimate security contract at the end of the novel.]] Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Navy, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.

to:

* PragmaticVillainy: For obvious reasons, when Corran goes undercover with the Invids in ''I, Jedi'', he starts [[InvokedTrope encouraging the other pirates to practice this]] to promote cooperation in the future. While a few of the pirates are in it more ForTheEvulz, most of them recognize the potential of this racket [[spoiler:and end up accepting a legitimate security contract at the end of the novel.]] ]]
**
Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Navy, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.



** Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Defense Force, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.

Added: 1097

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodFeelsGood: There's a couple of moments in ''I, Jedi'' where characters describe the Light Side of6 TheForce as feeling like every positive feeling they've ever experienced.

to:

* GoodFeelsGood: There's a couple of moments in ''I, Jedi'' where characters describe the Light Side of6 of TheForce as feeling like every positive feeling they've ever experienced.



* PragmaticVillainy: For obvious reasons, when Corran goes undercover with the Invids in ''I, Jedi'', he starts encouraging the other pirates to practice this to promote cooperation in the future. While a few of the pirates are in it more ForTheEvulz, most of them recognize the potential of this racket [[spoiler:and end up accepting a legitimate security contract at the end of the novel.]] Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Navy, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.

to:

* PragmaticVillainy: For obvious reasons, when Corran goes undercover with the Invids in ''I, Jedi'', he starts [[InvokedTrope encouraging the other pirates to practice this this]] to promote cooperation in the future. While a few of the pirates are in it more ForTheEvulz, most of them recognize the potential of this racket [[spoiler:and end up accepting a legitimate security contract at the end of the novel.]] Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Navy, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.


Added DiffLines:

** Later, when the pirate gang has to fight its way out of a confrontation with the New Republic Defense Force, Corran convinces the crew's leader that they should use ion cannons to disable the Republic fighters... because some forces will have to be diverted to rescue the pilots, distracting them from chasing after the Invids.


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Back in ''[[Literature/XWingSeries X-Wing: The Bacta War]]'', smuggler chieftain Booster Terrik, Corran Horn's father-in-law, managed to capture an ''Imperial''-class star destroyer with a lot of subterfuge and a bit of luck, naming it the ''Errant Venture'' and turning it into a mobile trade port and casino (the New Republic agreed to let him keep it on condition that most of its armaments were removed). In ''I, Jedi'', Corran visits the ''Venture'' to get help returning to Corellia (where he has an active arrest warrant), and finds that the star destroyer has become something of [[TheAllegedCar The Alleged Starship]]: turns out Booster significantly underestimated how much it costs to keep a ship that size in proper repair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If Corran sleeps with Tavira, his ego (and other things) get stroked, she, the leader of the group he's infiltrating, won't be suspicious of him, and he can get closer to finding his wife. Ethically, it's just part of the deception; Mirax is the love of his life and he really would do anything to save her. Plus, Tavira really hates rejection and might well have him killed. But would he really be doing this out of a genuine desire to endure anything for Mirax, or would it be a matter of lust and pride? Eventually Corran [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]].

to:

** The above rant gets a CallBack later: If Corran sleeps with Tavira, his ego (and other things) get stroked, she, the leader of the group he's infiltrating, won't be suspicious of him, and he can get closer to finding his wife. [[HoneyTrap Ethically, it's just part of the deception; deception]]; Mirax is the love of his life and he really would do anything to save her. Plus, Tavira really hates rejection and might well have him killed. But would he really be doing this out of a genuine desire to endure anything for Mirax, or would it be a matter of lust {{lust}} and pride? Eventually {{pride}}? Corran [[TakeAThirdOption comes so close to going for it that he realizes Luke actually had a point: he's not nearly as invulnerable to the Dark Side as he previously thought. He ultimately [[TookAThirdOption takes a third option]].option]]: [[spoiler:embrace being a Jedi Knight and fight Tavira]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy). Later sourcebooks filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]].

to:

** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy). trilogy [[DoylistVersusWatsonian because Stackpole hadn't even created the character yet]]). Later sourcebooks Legends material filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]].Twelve]][[invoked]] (there are are at least four possible candidates for the remaining two).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TwoPartTrilogy: A nonstandard example: Stackpole wrote ''I, Jedi'' at the same time that Creator/TimothyZahn was writing ''The Literature/HandOfThrawn'', and collaborated to share characters and toss {{Call Forward}}s and {{Call Back}}s to each other, making ''Hand of Thrawn'' in effect a two-part DistantSequel to Stackpole's novel. In publication order, ''Specter of the Past'' came out first, then ''I, Jedi'', then ''Vision of the Future''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: When Kyp destroyed the Carida star system by causing its sun to go nova, he killed 25 million people. Even if Carida was the only inhabited body in the entire system, that's still a very small number for a planetary population above a bronze-age level. For comparison, New York state '''''alone''''' has a population of around 20 million. While Carida is described as being quite inhospitable (this being precisely why the Empire chose it for a Stormtrooper training facility), it ''also'' had a native non-human population who presumably would be well-adapted enough to their own planet's conditions to produce a larger population than that. Originally, it was "billions" who perished, which sounds more plausible. The lower number comes from sourcebook fluff, and may have been intended to mitigate the backlash against Kyp's actions.

to:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: When Kyp destroyed the Carida star system by causing its sun to go nova, he killed 25 million people. Even if Carida was the only inhabited body in the entire system, that's still a very small number for a planetary population above a bronze-age level. For comparison, as of 2019, New York state '''''alone''''' has had a population of around almost 20 million. While Carida is described as being quite inhospitable (this being precisely why the Empire chose it for a Stormtrooper training facility), it ''also'' had a native non-human population who presumably would be well-adapted enough to their own planet's conditions to produce a larger population than that. Originally, it was "billions" who perished, which sounds more plausible. The lower number comes from sourcebook fluff, and may have been intended to mitigate the backlash against Kyp's actions.

Added: 664

Changed: 231

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilCannotComprehendGood: Tavira's belief that Luke Skywalker ordered the destruction of Carida was because: 1, that's what she would have done to her foes had she a Sun Crusher; and 2, grace such as Durron was shown is completely outside her understanding.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: EvilCannotComprehendGood:
** As a Sith Lord, Exar Kun wields enormous power even 4,000 years after his death, enough that he was even able to defeat Luke Skywalker. However, it never occurs to him that while he might be far stronger than an individual Jedi, a group of them in harmony with each other can cumulatively wield a power that far surpasses his, even if many of those Jedi are still little more than students. [[spoiler:This proves his undoing.]]
**
Tavira's belief that Luke Skywalker ordered the destruction of Carida was because: 1, that's what she would have done to her foes had she a Sun Crusher; and 2, grace such as Durron was shown is completely outside her understanding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SafelySecludedScienceCenter: The Maw Installation, a top-secret Imperial research centre for the development of new Superweapons. It's a SpaceStation hidden in a black hole cluster, accessible only along classified safe routes; this also keeps the more naive scientists from learning what their research projects are really being used for.

Added: 410

Changed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReassignedToAntarctica: One interpretation of Daala being given command of the Maw Installation is that it's legitimate recognition of her command abilities. [[SleepingTheirWayToTheTop Another is that Tarkin pulled strings to give his mistress a good assignment.]] A third is this trope, where Tarkin, having had his fun, shuffles his now ex-mistress off to the most secret and remote posting he can find.



* SleepingTheirWayToTheTop: Often taken as the reason why Daala became Admiral. It's kind of confirmed in ''Literature/DeathStar'', where she's Tarkin's lover and he privately believes that the boost he gave her career is just enough to get her past the difficulties female Imperials have in the military. She takes brain damage in that novel.

to:

* SleepingTheirWayToTheTop: Often taken as the reason why Daala became Admiral. It's kind of confirmed in ''Literature/DeathStar'', where she's Tarkin's lover and he privately believes that the boost he gave her career is just enough to get her past the difficulties female Imperials have in the military. She takes brain damage in that novel. Even in this trilogy, it's noted that Daala and Tarkin were having an affair, and that he gave her the Maw assignment personally, either as genuine recognition of her ability, a result of this trope, or [[ReassignedToAntarctica because he was done with her and wanted her as out-of-the-way as physically possible]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlbinosAreFreaks: In ''I, Jedi'' the albino [[WolfMan Shistavenen]] female Caet Shrovl relates that she was poorly treated by her people on their home world for her condition. As she believed the Empire caused this through an experiment which they performed on her mother, she grew to loathe them for it and joined a pirate group which despised Imperials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: Corran's plan for confronting Exar Kun hinges on Kun's seeming inability to interact with the physical world, and need to act through other agents. Corran forgot that Kun had managed to short out the Holocron by himself, and does the same with the device that Corran brings with him. [[OhCrap Only then does Corran realize his mistake.]]

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Corran's plan for confronting Exar Kun hinges on Kun's seeming inability to interact with the physical world, and need to act through other agents. Corran forgot that Kun had managed to short out the Holocron by himself, and does Kun proceeds to do the same with the explosive device that Corran brings with him. [[OhCrap Only then does Corran realize his mistake.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Corran's plan for confronting Exar Kun hinges on Kun's seeming inability to interact with the physical world, and need to act through other agents. Corran forgot that Kun had managed to short out the Holocron by himself, and does the same with the device that Corran brings with him. [[OhCrap Only then does Corran realize his mistake.]]

Added: 915

Removed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConspiracyTheorist: The fact that Luke ''doesn't'' suppress the knowledge of Kyp Durron's investiture gives the anti-Jedi crowd a huge propaganda coup. Daala's also convinced ''everyone'' she encounters is secretly with the Rebellion, no matter what.



* ConspiracyTheorist: The fact that Luke ''doesn't'' suppress the knowledge of Kyp Durron's investiture gives the anti-Jedi crowd a huge propaganda coup. Daala's also convinced ''everyone'' she encounters is secretly with the Rebellion, no matter what.


Added DiffLines:

* DesignerBabies: Done by the Khommites, who believed their society was perfect, and froze it by cloning themselves for a thousand years. This changed when the 81st clone of Dorsk was found to be Force-sensitive and left to become a Jedi, eventually bringing Khomm into the galactic war they had avoided up to that point due to their planet's isolation and lack of resources that anybody else cared about. Also they are described as being genderless, something they "forsook" when taking up cloning, though only referred to by male pronouns (it appears they mean Khommites have {{no biological sex}}, so this wouldn't preclude them identifying that way socially).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OnceDoneNeverForgotten:
** Kyp Durron, a powerful young Jedi who once got either possessed or heavily influenced by an ancient and very evil ghost, and who then fished out an indestructible superweapon that had been [[HurlItIntoTheSun dropped into the heart of a gas giant]] and proceeded to use it to cause a supernova that destroyed a rather populated planet. He was then very quickly and easily brought back into the light and put the superweapon into a black hole, then got off [[KarmaHoudini basically scot-free]] in the trilogy where he originally featured. Basically every book to feature him since then has called him on it, particularly ''I, Jedi'', a sort of FixFic trying to get the trilogy to make sense, where the main character leaves in disgust after this mass-murderer is welcomed back into the Jedi Academy for training. Other books paint Kyp as the perpetual [[TheAtoner Atoner]], having it and his lack of punishment constantly brought up.
** Sometimes (including in ''I, Jedi'') the death toll of Kyp's attack is vastly exaggerated, because apparently killing a few million people isn't bad enough; it's necessary to falsely claim he killed billions so that it can be put on the same level as the destruction of Alderaan (bonus fail points: said destruction is attributed to Darth Vader instead of the man who actually did it, Grand Moff Tarkin). The fact that the majority of the population were Imperial soldiers also tends to be ignored. Of course, Kyp himself doesn't consider that much of a comfort, given that many of those soldiers (including his own brother) were conscripts. And to make it worse, from ''Literature/NewJediOrder'' onward, Kyp is a {{Jerkass}} who's no longer interested in atoning for his sins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BodyguardCrush: Wedge Antilles was Qwi Xux's bodyguard. Yes, for some reason a general was the bodyguard of a high-ranking ex-Imperial scientist. In ''I, Jedi'' Corran was horrified to discover Wedge developing feelings for Qwi and Qwi returning them, since it was terribly unprofessional and he didn't think it would work out at ''all'' - actually, he shipped Wedge with his old partner Iella. Of course, when Kyp Durron decided to [[MindRape traumatically destroy Qwi's memories]], Wedge wasn't able to stop him. They break up at the start of Creator/AaronAllston's ''[[ComicBook/XWingSeries Starfighters of Adumar]]'', with Wedge later marrying Iella.

to:

* BodyguardCrush: Wedge Antilles was Qwi Xux's bodyguard. Yes, for some reason a general was the bodyguard of a high-ranking ex-Imperial scientist. In ''I, Jedi'' Corran was horrified to discover Wedge developing feelings for Qwi and Qwi returning them, since it was terribly unprofessional and he didn't think it would work out at ''all'' - actually, he shipped Wedge with his old partner Iella. Of course, when Kyp Durron decided to [[MindRape traumatically destroy Qwi's memories]], Wedge wasn't able to stop him. They break up at the start of Creator/AaronAllston's ''[[ComicBook/XWingSeries ''[[Literature/XWingSeries Starfighters of Adumar]]'', with Wedge later marrying Iella.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stackpole's 2014 post denies that he was taking swipes at Anderson: http://www.michaelastackpole.com/?p=3429


* TakeThat: Stackpole does this to Anderson. Repeatedly. Particularly regarding Kyp Durron getting away with ''genocide'' through destroying a planet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FixFic: Stackpole uses ''I, Jedi'' to make the ''Jedi Academy'' trilogy more palatable. Note that ''I, Jedi'' also has lots of crossover with the ''Literature/HandOfThrawn'' books by Creator/TimothyZahn, which are even more of a FixFic for the whole EU.

to:

* FixFic: Stackpole uses ''I, Jedi'' is often assumed to make the ''Jedi Academy'' trilogy more palatable. Note be this, though in a [[http://www.michaelastackpole.com/?p=3429 blog post]] from 2014 Stackpole denied this, noting that ''I, Jedi'' also has lots of crossover with he and Kevin J. Anderson were good friends and that the ''Literature/HandOfThrawn'' books by Creator/TimothyZahn, which are even more of book wasn't intended as a FixFic for the whole EU."jab" against what Kevin had written.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntSeeThatComing: An in-universe example becomes a plot-point in ''I, Jedi''. The New Republic is at a loss as to how Tavira and the Invids have managed to avoid every trap the Republic has set to catch them, not knowing Tavira has the Jensaari advising her by using the Force to see the future. But when Tavira leads her fleet in a raid on a shipyard, to their surprise they run into a New Republic task force (including Rogue Squadron) who just happened to be there on other unrelated business. This clues Corran into a weakness in the Jensaari's foresight; they can't predict a threat that isn't directed at them.

Added: 514

Changed: 1569

Removed: 457

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: When Kyp destroyed the Carida star system by causing its sun to go nova, he killed 25 million people. Even if Carida was the only inhabited body in the entire system, that's still a very small number for a planetary population above a bronze-age level. For comparison, New York state '''''alone''''' has a population of around 20 million. While Carida is described as being quite inhospitable (this being precisely why the Empire chose it for a Stormtrooper training facility), it ''also'' had a native non-human population who presumably would be well-adapted enough to their own planet's conditions to produce a larger population than that.
** Originally, it was "billions" who perished, which sounds more plausible. The lower number comes from sourcebook fluff, and may have been intended to mitigate the backlash against Kyp's actions.

to:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: When Kyp destroyed the Carida star system by causing its sun to go nova, he killed 25 million people. Even if Carida was the only inhabited body in the entire system, that's still a very small number for a planetary population above a bronze-age level. For comparison, New York state '''''alone''''' has a population of around 20 million. While Carida is described as being quite inhospitable (this being precisely why the Empire chose it for a Stormtrooper training facility), it ''also'' had a native non-human population who presumably would be well-adapted enough to their own planet's conditions to produce a larger population than that.
**
that. Originally, it was "billions" who perished, which sounds more plausible. The lower number comes from sourcebook fluff, and may have been intended to mitigate the backlash against Kyp's actions.



* SleepingTheirWayToTheTop: Often taken as the reason why Daala became Admiral.
** Kind of confirmed in ''Literature/DeathStar'', where she's Tarkin's lover and he privately believes that the boost he gave her career is just enough to get her past the difficulties female Imperials have in the military. She takes brain damage in that novel.

to:

* SleepingTheirWayToTheTop: Often taken as the reason why Daala became Admiral.
** Kind
Admiral. It's kind of confirmed in ''Literature/DeathStar'', where she's Tarkin's lover and he privately believes that the boost he gave her career is just enough to get her past the difficulties female Imperials have in the military. She takes brain damage in that novel.



* SwordAndFist: Corran challenges Luke to a lightsabre duel prior to leaving the academy. Thanks to his prior hand-to-hand experience, [[CombatPragmatist he is able to use other techniques against Luke to turn the fight to his advantage]]. Luke actually picks up on this and makes use of such techniques upon [[BigDamnHeroes later coming to Corran's aid]].
* TakeThat: Stackpole does this to Anderson. Repeatedly.

to:

* SwordAndFist: Corran challenges Luke to a lightsabre lightsaber duel prior to leaving the academy. Thanks to his prior hand-to-hand experience, [[CombatPragmatist he is able to use other techniques against Luke to turn the fight to his advantage]]. Luke actually picks up on this and makes use of such techniques upon [[BigDamnHeroes later coming to Corran's aid]].
* TakeThat: Stackpole does this to Anderson. Repeatedly. Particularly regarding Kyp Durron getting away with ''genocide'' through destroying a planet.



* WeWillNotUseStageMakeupInTheFuture: Averted. Disguising his identity, Corran grows a beard and uses hair dye. Hair dye which he initially misuses, making all of his hair green and forcing him to call his old partner for help.

to:

* WeWillNotUseStageMakeupInTheFuture: WeWillNotUseStageMakeupInTheFuture:
**
Averted. Disguising his identity, Corran grows a beard and uses hair dye. Hair dye which he initially misuses, making all of his hair green and forcing him to call his old partner for help.



* WhatTheHellHero: Corran gives Luke a spectacular TheReasonYouSuckSpeech and quits the academy for forgiving Kyp Durron for... what prefix, exactly, do you use before "-cide" to describe blowing up an inhabited solar system?
** "Stellar"-cide?

to:

* WhatTheHellHero: WhatTheHellHero:
**
Corran gives Luke a spectacular TheReasonYouSuckSpeech and quits the academy for forgiving Kyp Durron for... what prefix, exactly, do you use before "-cide" to describe blowing up an inhabited solar system?
**
system? "Stellar"-cide?



*** Investigating a [[Series/AdamTwelve 415 family disturbance]], he found a {{Domestic Abuse}}r had battered his wife severely, and he was so furious that he was sorely tempted to employ PoliceBrutality, to let the abuser know what it felt like. But he held back.

to:

*** Investigating Responding to a [[Series/AdamTwelve 415 family disturbance]], he found a {{Domestic Abuse}}r {{domestic abuse}}r had battered his wife severely, and he was so furious that he was sorely tempted to employ PoliceBrutality, to let the abuser know what it felt like. But he held back.



** If Corran sleeps with Tavira, his ego (and other things) get stroked, she, the leader of the group he's infiltrating, won't be suspicious of him, and he can get closer to finding his wife. Ethically, it's just part of the deception; Mirax is the love of his life and he really would do anything to save her. Plus, Tavira really hates rejection and might well have him killed. But would he really be doing this out of a genuine desire to endure anything for Mirax, or would it be a matter of pride? Eventually Corran [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]].
* [[WhoDares Who]] '''[[WhoDares DARES?!]]''': Exar Kun, the ''Franchise/StarWars'' equivalent of a Sith DastardlyWhiplash, says it word-for-word to a thoroughly unimpressed Mara Jade, who goes on to [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech describe how poorly he stacks up to the Sith Lords that she personally knew]] (not to mention Ysanne Isard, who wasn't even Force-sensitive).

to:

** If Corran sleeps with Tavira, his ego (and other things) get stroked, she, the leader of the group he's infiltrating, won't be suspicious of him, and he can get closer to finding his wife. Ethically, it's just part of the deception; Mirax is the love of his life and he really would do anything to save her. Plus, Tavira really hates rejection and might well have him killed. But would he really be doing this out of a genuine desire to endure anything for Mirax, or would it be a matter of lust and pride? Eventually Corran [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]].
* [[WhoDares Who]] '''[[WhoDares DARES?!]]''': DARES?!]]''':
**
Exar Kun, the ''Franchise/StarWars'' equivalent of a Sith DastardlyWhiplash, says it word-for-word to a thoroughly unimpressed Mara Jade, who goes on to [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech describe how poorly he stacks up to the Sith Lords that she personally knew]] (not to mention Ysanne Isard, who wasn't even Force-sensitive).



** Mirax later has a similar reaction to Admiral Tavira saying much the same thing. After that, Luke decides that Corran's earlier comment about making sure that Mirax and Mara never meet is good advice.

to:

** Mirax later has a similar reaction to Admiral Tavira saying much the same thing. After that, Luke decides that Corran's earlier comment about making sure that Mirax and Mara never meet is good advice. They do though, and hit it off massively, becoming fast friends.

Added: 270

Changed: 618

Removed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[Literature/TheCallistaTrilogy Another backup of the Death Star plans is stored deep in the archives of the Imperial Palace on Coruscant, and the original lead designer had been reassigned away from the Maw years earlier so he's still at large.]]
*** Daala also escapes to the Imperial Remnant with a portion of the data, and some of it gets used to build weapons in later series. ''Literature/HandOfThrawn'' initially declares it all AwesomeButImpractical, but Daala returns in ''Literature/LegacyOfTheForce'' with other, field-ready weapons built to Maw specs.

to:

*** ** [[Literature/TheCallistaTrilogy Another backup of the Death Star plans is stored deep in the archives of the Imperial Palace on Coruscant, and the original lead designer had been reassigned away from the Maw years earlier so he's still at large.]]
*** ** Daala also escapes to the Imperial Remnant with a portion of the data, and some of it gets used to build weapons in later series. ''Literature/HandOfThrawn'' initially declares it all AwesomeButImpractical, but Daala returns in ''Literature/LegacyOfTheForce'' with other, field-ready weapons built to Maw specs.



* OrbitalBombardment: In ''Dark Apprentice'' Daala uses her three remaining [=ISDs=] for a terror attack on Mon Calamari before a gambit by Admiral Ackbar costs her a second star destroyer and forces her to retreat.
** In ''I, Jedi'', Corran tells Tycho that if the Jedi apprentices are defeated, to convince Ackbar to order orbital bombarment of Exar Kun's temple, as that would the only way to destroy it while staying far enough way to be safe from mental influence by Kun's spirit.

to:

* OrbitalBombardment: OrbitalBombardment:
**
In ''Dark Apprentice'' Daala uses her three remaining [=ISDs=] for a terror attack on Mon Calamari before a gambit by Admiral Ackbar costs her a second star destroyer and forces her to retreat.
** In ''I, Jedi'', Corran tells Tycho that if the Jedi apprentices are defeated, to convince Ackbar to order orbital bombarment bombardment of Exar Kun's temple, as that would the only way to destroy it while staying far enough way to be safe from mental influence by Kun's spirit.



** The way used by Han Solo, once he has stolen the Sun Crusher, to deal with one of Daala's Imperial Star Destroyers, that is blocking their escape path of the Maw.

to:

** The way method used by Han Solo, once he has stolen the Sun Crusher, to deal with one of Daala's Imperial Star Destroyers, that is blocking their escape path of the Maw.



** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy).
*** Later sourcebooks filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]].

to:

** ''I, Jedi'' was the first novel in the modern EU to directly retcon events of an earlier novel, mainly by establishing that Corran Horn studied at Yavin IV under Luke over the course of ''Dark Apprentice'' and ''Champions of the Force'' (neither he nor his alias Kieran Halcyon was ever mentioned in the earlier trilogy).
***
trilogy). Later sourcebooks filled in all but two of Luke's [[FanNickname Original Twelve]].

Added: 841

Changed: 2007

Removed: 387

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: Oddly, ''I, Jedi'' has the lightsabre colours backwards - the Dark Jedi use blue ones and the Light side Jedi seem to use any colour ''but'' blue. Part of that might be an example of [[CharacterizationMarchesOn continuity marching on]]: until Episode I, the idea that all Dark Jedi and Sith used exclusively red lightsabers was WordOfDante, and many fans (apparently including Stackpole) found the idea silly and arbitrary given the rainbow of colors used by light-side Jedi (and ironic considering that the Sith are treacherous and individualist, while the Jedi are so effective because of their ability to work together harmoniously).

to:

* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: Oddly, ''I, Jedi'' has the lightsabre colours lightsaber colors backwards - the Dark Jedi use blue ones and the Light side Jedi seem to use any colour color ''but'' blue. Part of that might be an example of [[CharacterizationMarchesOn continuity marching on]]: until Episode I, the idea that all Dark Jedi and Sith used exclusively red lightsabers was WordOfDante, and many fans (apparently including Stackpole) found the idea silly and arbitrary given the rainbow of colors used by light-side Jedi (and ironic considering that the Sith are treacherous and individualist, while the Jedi are so effective because of their ability to work together harmoniously).



* ConspiracyTheorist: The fact that Luke ''doesn't'' suppress the knowledge of Kyp Durron's investiture gives the pro-Order-66 crowd a huge propaganda coup.

to:

* ConspiracyTheorist: The fact that Luke ''doesn't'' suppress the knowledge of Kyp Durron's investiture gives the pro-Order-66 anti-Jedi crowd a huge propaganda coup.coup. Daala's also convinced ''everyone'' she encounters is secretly with the Rebellion, no matter what.



* GeneralRipper: Daala is a sort of hybrid of this and ColonelKilgore. She's ''both'' a paranoid fanatic who lashes out at every little starship or planet she runs into (Because they're ''[[ConspiracyTheorist obviously]]'' part of the Rebellion!), ''and'' a crazy sadist who just loves blowing things up.

to:

* GeneralRipper: Daala is a sort of hybrid of this and ColonelKilgore. She's ''both'' a paranoid fanatic who lashes out at every little starship or planet she runs into (Because (because they're ''[[ConspiracyTheorist obviously]]'' part of the Rebellion!), ''and'' a crazy sadist who just loves blowing things up.



'''Corran:''' Think Hutt, but with eyebrows.
* GoodFeelsGood: There's a couple of moments in ''I, Jedi'' where characters describe TheForce as feeling like every positive feeling they've ever experienced.

to:

'''Corran:''' Think Hutt, but with eyebrows.
eyebrows.\\
'''Luke:''' Got it.
* GoodFeelsGood: There's a couple of moments in ''I, Jedi'' where characters describe the Light Side of6 TheForce as feeling like every positive feeling they've ever experienced.



* HurlItIntoTheSun: What the New Republic decides to do with the Sun Crusher, although they picked a gas giant instead of a sun. At the end of the trilogy, Kyp hurls it into a black hole, where it cannot be retrieved from.
** The fairly lame suggestion by the New Republic Council that a gas giant would be good enough seemed to be deliberately implying that at least some of them were ''hoping'' that someday they'd be able to retrieve the Sun Crusher and use it against the Empire once political opposition to using an Imperial superweapon died down.

to:

* HurlItIntoTheSun: What the New Republic decides to do with the Sun Crusher, although they picked a gas giant instead of a sun. At the end of the trilogy, Kyp hurls it into a black hole, where it cannot be retrieved from.
**
from. The fairly lame suggestion by the New Republic Council that a gas giant would be good enough seemed to be deliberately implying that at least some of them were ''hoping'' that someday they'd be able to retrieve the Sun Crusher and use it against the Empire once political opposition to using an Imperial superweapon died down.



* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Luke has about a dozen students. While the others will get characterization in future works, only about four or five actually have a personality right now. Some of them weren't even ''named'' in the trilogy.
** To this day, some of them ''still'' haven't been named.

to:

* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Luke has about a dozen students. While the others will get characterization in future works, only about four or five actually have a personality right now. Some of them weren't even ''named'' in the trilogy.
**
trilogy. To this day, some of them ''still'' haven't been named.named. It's what made it easy to add Corran in ''I, Jedi''.



* AMillionIsAStatistic: Kyp Durron used the Sun Crusher to kill a ''lot'' of people. But one of those was his brother, he feels bad about that, Han talked him out of being evil, and he almost died sticking the Sun Crusher into a black hole, so... let's bring him back to the Jedi Academy and work on that temper! In ''I, Jedi'', this is what finally drives Corran Horn to quit. Pretty much every other book in the EU to have Kyp has his KarmaHoudini brought up, and Kyp himself becomes TheAtoner.
** Since Carida was an Imperial planet and a major Stormtrooper training center, it explains why many in the New Republic weren't all that dismayed by its destruction. Particularly given that the [[AssInAmbassador Caridan ambassador]] had just shortly before attempted to assassinate the New Republic Chief of State (though they did not know that at the time). However, since the Jedi '''''felt''''' the deaths of the planet's millions of inhabitants in excruciating detail, including all the civilian population, some of them were less inclined to be so forgiving.

to:

* AMillionIsAStatistic: AMillionIsAStatistic:
**
Kyp Durron used the Sun Crusher to kill a ''lot'' of people. But one of those was his brother, he feels bad about that, Han talked him out of being evil, and he almost died sticking the Sun Crusher into a black hole, so... let's bring him back to the Jedi Academy and work on that temper! In ''I, Jedi'', this is what finally drives Corran Horn to quit. Pretty much every other book in the EU to have Kyp has his KarmaHoudini brought up, and Kyp himself becomes TheAtoner.
** Since Carida was an Imperial planet and a major Stormtrooper training center, it explains why many in the New Republic weren't all that dismayed by its destruction. Particularly given that the [[AssInAmbassador Caridan ambassador]] had just shortly before attempted to assassinate the New Republic Chief of State (though they did not know that at the time). However, since the Jedi '''''felt''''' the deaths of the planet's millions of inhabitants in excruciating detail, including all the civilian population, some of them were less inclined to be so forgiving. It isn't like everyone on an entire ''planet'' is involved with stormtrooper training, after all.



** Exar Kun wasn't ''dormant'', precisely, since he bred monsters, but an academy of semitrained Jedi was exactly what the pharmacist prescribed to get him back into intergalactic affairs.

to:

** Exar Kun wasn't ''dormant'', precisely, since he bred monsters, but an academy of semitrained semi-trained Jedi was exactly what the pharmacist prescribed to get him back into intergalactic affairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: Oddly, ''I, Jedi'' has the lightsabre colours backwards - the Dark Jedi use blue ones and the lightside Jedi seem to use any colour ''but'' blue. Part of that might be an example of [[CharacterizationMarchesOn continuity marching on]]: Until Episode I, the idea that all dark Jedi and Sith used exclusively red lightsabers was WordOfDante, and many fans (apparently including Stackpole) found the idea silly and arbitrary given the rainbow of colors used by light-side Jedi (and ironic considering that the Sith are treacherous and individualist, while the Jedi are so effective because of their ability to work together harmoniously).

to:

* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: Oddly, ''I, Jedi'' has the lightsabre colours backwards - the Dark Jedi use blue ones and the lightside Light side Jedi seem to use any colour ''but'' blue. Part of that might be an example of [[CharacterizationMarchesOn continuity marching on]]: Until until Episode I, the idea that all dark Dark Jedi and Sith used exclusively red lightsabers was WordOfDante, and many fans (apparently including Stackpole) found the idea silly and arbitrary given the rainbow of colors used by light-side Jedi (and ironic considering that the Sith are treacherous and individualist, while the Jedi are so effective because of their ability to work together harmoniously).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''I, Jedi'' has two references to Tatooine being Obi-Wan Kenobi's homeworld. While this was a reasonable inference at the time (especially given that the novelization of the first Star Wars movie identified Owen Lars as Obi-Wan's brother), unfortunately for Stackpole ''The Phantom Menace'' was released only one year later and contradicted it. One of the references was indirect (Kenobi wasn't actually mentioned by name, it was just clearly implied to be him) and the other could be written off as in-universe records having mistakenly said Kenobi was a Tatooine native (the original records showing him being born on Coruscant could have been lost in the destruction of the Jedi Temple).

to:

** ''I, Jedi'' has two references to Tatooine being Obi-Wan Kenobi's homeworld. While this was a reasonable inference at the time (especially given that the novelization of the first Star Wars movie identified Owen Lars as Obi-Wan's brother), brother[[note]]Later [[RetCon changed]] into Obi-Wan having a vision of him he mistakenly thought was his brother.[[/note]]), unfortunately for Stackpole ''The Phantom Menace'' ''Film/ThePhantomMenace'' was released only one year later and contradicted it. One of the references was indirect (Kenobi wasn't actually mentioned by name, it was just clearly implied to be him) and the other could be written off as in-universe records having mistakenly said Kenobi was a Tatooine native (the original records showing him being born on Coruscant Stewjon could have been lost in the destruction of the Jedi Temple).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Investigating a [[Series/AdamTwelve 415 family disturbance]], he found a DomesticAbuser had battered his wife severely, and he was so furious that he was sorely tempted to employ PoliceBrutality, to let the abuser know what it felt like. But he held back.

to:

*** Investigating a [[Series/AdamTwelve 415 family disturbance]], he found a DomesticAbuser {{Domestic Abuse}}r had battered his wife severely, and he was so furious that he was sorely tempted to employ PoliceBrutality, to let the abuser know what it felt like. But he held back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AMillionIsAStatistic: Kyp Durron used the Sun Crusher to kill a ''lot'' of people. But one of those was his brother, he feels bad about that, Han talked him out of being evil, and he almost died sticking the Sun Crusher into a black hole, so ... let's bring him back to the Jedi Academy and work on that temper! In ''I, Jedi'', this is what finally drives Corran Horn to quit. Pretty much every other book in the EU to have Kyp has his KarmaHoudini brought up, and Kyp himself becomes TheAtoner.

to:

* AMillionIsAStatistic: Kyp Durron used the Sun Crusher to kill a ''lot'' of people. But one of those was his brother, he feels bad about that, Han talked him out of being evil, and he almost died sticking the Sun Crusher into a black hole, so ...so... let's bring him back to the Jedi Academy and work on that temper! In ''I, Jedi'', this is what finally drives Corran Horn to quit. Pretty much every other book in the EU to have Kyp has his KarmaHoudini brought up, and Kyp himself becomes TheAtoner.

Top