Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / BooksOfSamuel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** TropeNamer. Goliath was more or less ancient history's Wrestling/AndreTheGiant -- some translations put him at ''nine feet tall!'' David, meanwhile, was hammered home as the runt of his family, the youngest of ten siblings and not much older than 18 when Goliath bellowed his challenge to Saul's army.

to:

** TropeNamer. Goliath was more or less ancient history's BibleTimes' Wrestling/AndreTheGiant -- some translations put him at ''nine ''over nine feet tall!'' tall!''[[note]]This incredible size is likely just a [[EitherWorldDominationOrSomethingAboutBananas very particular mistranslation by the Masoretic Text]] of the measurements given in earlier tellings of the Book of Samuel, however; the Dead Sea Scrolls list his height as "four cubits and a span", or about 6'9"--impressively tall, especially for a time when people were considerably shorter than they are today, but not outright preternatural. Thus, him later being said to be six cubits and a span was either an error or embellishment made over the centuries of translation (though even the original measurement itself is speculated to be a metaphorical allusion to the height of the walls surrounding Gath, the Philistines' capital).[[/note]] David, meanwhile, was hammered home as the runt of his family, the youngest of ten siblings and not much older than 18 when Goliath bellowed his challenge to Saul's army.

Added: 729

Removed: 716

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: David loses three of his children to death -- his unnamed infant son whom Bathsheba bore for him when David got her pregnant, his first son Amnon to his other son Absalom, and then later Absalom to David's general Joab when Absalom had led most of the nation of Israel to war against his own father. Absalom's death was so heartbreaking to David that his mourning made his own troops retreat from the battle in shame.
** And that's the bare minimum. There's a theory that David and Abigail's son Chileab also died young, given that he's second-eldest after Amnon and yet is never mentioned when it comes to the struggle over succession - David's assumed heir skips first to Absalom and then to Adonijah.


Added DiffLines:

* OutlivingOnesOffspring: David loses three of his children to death -- his unnamed infant son whom Bathsheba bore for him when David got her pregnant, his first son Amnon to his other son Absalom, and then later Absalom to David's general Joab when Absalom had led most of the nation of Israel to war against his own father. Absalom's death was so heartbreaking to David that his mourning made his own troops retreat from the battle in shame.
** And that's the bare minimum. There's a theory that David and Abigail's son Chileab also died young, given that he's second-eldest after Amnon and yet is never mentioned when it comes to the struggle over succession - David's assumed heir skips first to Absalom and then to Adonijah.

Changed: 166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Books of Samuel are followed by the Literature/BooksOfKings.

to:

The Books of Samuel are followed by the Literature/BooksOfKings. In some old Catholic and Orthodox bibles, the books are sometimes confusingly called 1 Kings and 2 Kings, with the later Books of Kings being 3 and 4 Kings in suit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnusualEuphemism: Many English translations have Saul swear at Jonathan along the lines of, "You son of a ''[[ThisIsForEmphasisBitch perverse and rebellious woman]]''!" There is indeed a [[SonOfAWhore closer English equivalent]] to the Hebrew original, but apparently most translators prefer to use an [[TactfulTranslation equally accurate but not so precise translation]] for Literature/TheBible. (''The Living Bible'' is a notable exception.)

to:

* UnusualEuphemism: Many English translations have Saul swear at Jonathan along the lines of, "You son of a ''[[ThisIsForEmphasisBitch perverse and rebellious woman]]''!" There is indeed a [[SonOfAWhore closer English equivalent]] to the Hebrew original, but apparently most translators prefer to use an [[TactfulTranslation equally accurate but not so precise translation]] ("perverse and rebellious" is a very literal translation of the exact words) for Literature/TheBible. (''The Living Bible'' is a notable exception.)

Added: 598

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtifactTitle: Samuel only played a significant role in the beginning of the first book, then died in the middle and is not mentioned in the second. Those books focus more on the King David.

to:

* ArtifactTitle: Samuel only played a significant role in the beginning of the first book, then died in the middle and is not mentioned in the second. Those books focus more on the King David.


Added DiffLines:

* BabyAsPayment: Samuel's mother Hannah prays to God for a son and promises that she will give him to the priests to raise when he's old enough. Sure enough, she gives birth to Samuel and keeps her promise. This is related to the Jewish practice of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pidyon_haben pidyon haben]], "redemption of the firstborn", in which a priest is paid 5 silver shekels (or an equivalent value) to symbolically redeem a firstborn male child (it is considered unnecessary if the boy is preceded by a girl or a miscarriage, born by caesarean section, or the father is himself a priest).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updating to have these crosswicked entries match.


* BirthDeathJuxtaposition: Soon after Phinehas and Hophni get killed in 1st Samuel chapter 5, Phinehas' widow gives birth to his son Ichabod even as she passes away.

to:

* BirthDeathJuxtaposition: Soon after Phinehas and Hophni get killed in 1st Samuel chapter 5, Phinehas' widow wife goes into labor when she heard that her father-in-law and husband were dead, and she gives birth to his son Ichabod even as she passes away.([[MeaningfulName meaning "The Glory is not"]]) around the time of her death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: Goliath, Absalom, King Saul, Joab ([[KarmaHoudiniWarranty eventually]]), the Philistines and the Amalekites.

to:

* AssholeVictim: Goliath, Absalom, Amnon, King Saul, Joab ([[KarmaHoudiniWarranty eventually]]), the Philistines and the Amalekites.

Added: 326

Changed: 143

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrivenToSuicide: Saul, eventually. And Ahithophel, when Absalom seeks advice as for what to do with King David, and prefer's Hushai's advice over Ahithophel's.

to:

* DrivenToSuicide: DrivenToSuicide:
**
Saul, eventually. And when the battle at Mount Gilboa turned against him and his sons, and he couldn't get his shield bearer to kill him so he wouldn't be abused by the Philistines.
**
Ahithophel, when Absalom seeks advice as for what to do with King David, David when he was driven from the kingdom, and prefer's prefers Hushai's advice over Ahithophel's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GriefSong: The Song of the Bow in 2nd Samuel chapter 1, where King David sings the loss of King Saul as well as his friend Jonathan, who both died in the battle at Mount Gilboa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DontMakeMeDestroyYou: In the Message translation, Abner tells Asahel when the latter wouldn't let up on chasing after the former, “Turn back. Don’t force me to kill you. How would I face your brother Joab?” (2nd Samuel 2:22)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The second book tells of the kingship of David, Israel's greatest king and ancestor of Jesus.

to:

The second book tells of the kingship of David, Israel's greatest king and (in the Christian tradition) ancestor of Jesus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Doeg the Edomite slaughters a village for aiding David, on Saul's orders. He is never mentioned again. (Although one Rabbinical tradition says that David personally kills him later.)

to:

** Doeg the Edomite slaughters a village for aiding David, on Saul's orders. He is never mentioned again. (Although one Rabbinical tradition says that David personally kills him later.later, and it can be assumed he goes to {{Hell}} when he dies.)

Added: 239

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UseTheirOwnWeaponAgainstThem: After knocking down Goliath, David finishes off the Philistine giant by using Goliath's own sword to decapitate him.

to:

* UseTheirOwnWeaponAgainstThem: UseTheirOwnWeaponAgainstThem:
**
After knocking down Goliath, David finishes off the Philistine giant by using Goliath's own sword to decapitate him.him.
** Benaiah son of Jehoiada killed an Egyptian warrior with the Egyptian's own spear, after wresting it out of his hands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UseTheirOwnWeaponAgainstThem: After knocking down Goliath, David finishes off the Philistine giant by using Goliath's own sword to decapitate him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IncestantAdmirer: Amnon was heavily attracted to his half-sister Tamar. When he managed to get her alone, he tried to coerce her into having sex with him. Tamar protested and he eventually raped her, which would later indirectly cause him to get murdered by Absalom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''“Now, therefore, thus you shall say to my servant David, ‘Thus says the LORD of hosts, I took you from the pasture, from following the sheep, that you should be prince over my people Israel. And I have been with you wherever you went and have cut off all your enemies before you. And I will make for you a great name, like the names of the great ones of the earth.’”''

to:

->''“Now, therefore, ->''“Further, say thus you shall say to my My servant David, ‘Thus says David: 'Thus said the LORD of hosts, Hosts: I took you from the pasture, from following the sheep, that you should flock, to be prince over my ruler of My people Israel. And Israel, and I have been with you wherever you went went, and have cut off down all your enemies before you. And Moreover, I will make for give you a great name, renown like the names that of the great ones of the greatest men on earth.’”''



* ImprobableWeaponUser: The Philistines had a monopoly on weapons so the Israelites (with the exception of Saul & Jonathan) had to weaponise their farm tools. The Philistines promised that they would not go to war with Israel if the Jews destroyed all of their weapons. The Jews, being TooDumbToLive, complied. Needless to say, [[DidNotThinkThisThrough they regretted their decision almost immediately]].

to:

* ImprobableWeaponUser: The Philistines had a monopoly on weapons so the Israelites (with the exception of Saul & Jonathan) had to weaponise their farm tools. The Philistines promised that they would not to go to war with Israel if the Jews they destroyed all of their weapons. The Jews, Israelites, being TooDumbToLive, complied. Needless to say, [[DidNotThinkThisThrough they They regretted their decision almost immediately]].



* MercyKill: In 2nd Samuel chapter 1, an Amalekite tells David that he had given King Saul this when he met him still alive after being mortally wounded and literally begging to be put out of his misery. David ended up killing the Amalekite for this claim, stating that he had said with his mouth he had killed the Lord's anointed.

to:

* MercyKill: In 2nd Samuel chapter 1, an Amalekite tells David that he had given King Saul this when he met him still alive after being mortally wounded and literally begging to be put out of his misery. David ended up killing the Amalekite for this claim, stating that he had said with his mouth he had killed the Lord's anointed.



** While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no? Note that when Nathan castigates David for his actions, he has nothing as bad to say about Bathsheba, instead comparing her to a lamb.

to:

** While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no? Note that when When Nathan castigates David for his actions, he has nothing as bad to say about Bathsheba, instead comparing her to a lamb.



* UnusualEuphemism: Many English translations have Saul swear at Jonathan along the lines of, "You son of a ''[[ThisIsForEmphasisBitch perverse and rebellious woman]]''!" Needless to say, there is indeed a [[SonOfAWhore closer English equivalent]] to the Hebrew original, but apparently most translators prefer to use an [[TactfulTranslation equally accurate but not so precise translation]] for Literature/TheBible. (''The Living Bible'' is a notable exception.)

to:

* UnusualEuphemism: Many English translations have Saul swear at Jonathan along the lines of, "You son of a ''[[ThisIsForEmphasisBitch perverse and rebellious woman]]''!" Needless to say, there There is indeed a [[SonOfAWhore closer English equivalent]] to the Hebrew original, but apparently most translators prefer to use an [[TactfulTranslation equally accurate but not so precise translation]] for Literature/TheBible. (''The Living Bible'' is a notable exception.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EmpathicEnvironment: Invoked by Samuel, who calls for rain at Saul’s inauguration as a sign that God is unhappy that Israel has chosen a human king over their heavenly King.

to:

* EmpathicEnvironment: Invoked by Samuel, who calls for rain a storm at Saul’s inauguration as a sign that God is unhappy that Israel has chosen a human king over their heavenly King.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And that's the bare minimum. There's a theory that David and Abigail's son Chileab also died young, given that he's second-eldest after Amnon and yet is never mentioned when it comes to the struggle over succession - David's assumed heir skips first to Absalom and then to Adonijah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no?

to:

** While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no?no? Note that when Nathan castigates David for his actions, he has nothing as bad to say about Bathsheba, instead comparing her to a lamb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadAnimalWarning: Saul cuts an oxen apart and has its dismembered bodies part sent to all the cities of Israel, a warning that the same dismemberment will happen to the livestock of any who do not fight against Nahash the Ammonite. Three hundred thousand soldiers answer the call.

to:

* DeadAnimalWarning: Saul cuts an oxen apart and has its dismembered bodies part body parts sent to all the cities of Israel, a warning that the same dismemberment will happen to the livestock of any who do not fight against Nahash the Ammonite. Three hundred thousand soldiers answer the call.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope.


** David [[YourCheatingHeart commits adultery with Bathsheba]] and then pulls off his infamous UriahGambit. As a punishment, the son of that adultery dies, but later they have another son: Solomon. David is also cursed with war and public shame, which results in the deaths of two of his other sons. (And though they probably [[EvilPrince deserved it]], David is still [[HeroicBSOD crushed]].)

to:

** David [[YourCheatingHeart commits adultery with Bathsheba]] Bathsheba and then pulls off his infamous UriahGambit. As a punishment, the son of that adultery dies, but later they have another son: Solomon. David is also cursed with war and public shame, which results in the deaths of two of his other sons. (And though they probably [[EvilPrince deserved it]], David is still [[HeroicBSOD crushed]].)

Added: 902

Changed: 544

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadGuyOnDisplay: Saul, after he was killed in 1st Samuel chapter 31, had his head cut off and his body put on display by the Philistines gloating over their victory in their battle with the Israelites. The people of Jabesh Gilead, when they heard of the desecration of Saul's body, stole it from Beth Shan and buried it under a tamarisk tree in Jabesh, and fasted for seven days.

to:

* DeadGuyOnDisplay: DeadGuyOnDisplay:
**
Saul, after he was killed in 1st Samuel chapter 31, had his head cut off and his body put on display by the Philistines gloating over their victory in their battle with the Israelites. The people of Jabesh Gilead, when they heard of the desecration of Saul's body, stole it from Beth Shan and buried it under a tamarisk tree in Jabesh, and fasted for seven days.days.
** The seven grandsons and sons of Saul who are sent to Gibeon to be killed and left to hang. Rizpah, the mother of two of them, guards the bodies from scavengers until David has them taken down.



* KarmaHoudini: Doeg the Edomite slaughters a village for aiding David, on Saul's orders. He is never mentioned again. (Although one Rabbinical tradition says that David personally kills him later.)

to:

* KarmaHoudini: KarmaHoudini:
**
Doeg the Edomite slaughters a village for aiding David, on Saul's orders. He is never mentioned again. (Although one Rabbinical tradition says that David personally kills him later.))
** Jonadab, who gives Amnon advice on committing incestuous rape, and only turns up later to let David know that Absalom didn't kill ''all'' of his brothers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not actually an example of the trope. If it doesn't fit, take it out rather than adding a note.


* AllCrimesAreEqual: In part of Samuel's harsh rebuke to Saul's incomplete genocide and rejection as King of Israel, he states in I Samuel 15:23 that rebellion is just as sinful as witchcraft, and stubbornness is just as evil as idolatry. [[note]]However, Saul ''did'' consult a witch after rebelling against God, and stubbornness against God is putting yourself over Him, ergo idolatry.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedemptionEqualsAffliction: David repents of pulling the UriahGambit as well as committing adultery. Although God forgave him, He allowed David and Bathsheba's child to die in infancy and David's life got quite complicate afterwards.

to:

* RedemptionEqualsAffliction: David repents of pulling the UriahGambit as well as committing adultery. Although God forgave him, He allowed David and Bathsheba's child to die in infancy and David's life got quite complicate complicated afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdultFear: David loses three of his children to death -- his unnamed infant son whom Bathsheba bore for him when David got her pregnant, his first son Amnon to his other son Absalom, and then later Absalom to David's general Joab when Absalom had led most of the nation of Israel to war against his own father. Absalom's death was so heartbreaking to David that his mourning made his own troops retreat from the battle in shame.

Added: 666

Changed: 181

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Curse}}: Although not outrightly stated as a curse, when David's first wife Michal criticizes David for his "unholy" dancing, the text says that she had no children to the day of her death.

to:

* {{Curse}}: {{Curse}}:
** In 1st Samuel chapter 14, King Saul calls a curse on the man who eats food before the evening comes and the king gets his revenge on his enemies, the Philistines. Saul's son Jonathan, who hasn't heard the curse, defies it by eating a bit of honey that he found on the ground. Although Jonathan accepts the responsibility for the curse when his father found out what had happened, the Israelites protected Jonathan from death because he had helped them bring about a great victory.
**
Although not outrightly stated as a curse, when David's first wife Michal criticizes David for his "unholy" dancing, the text says that she had no children to the day of her death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CivilWar: First between Saul and David, and then between Ish-Bosheth and David.

to:

* CivilWar: First between Saul and David, and then between Ish-Bosheth and David.David, and later between David and his son Absalom.



* SelfDisposingVillain: Nabal, who, after David is prevented from [[DisproportionateRetribution slaughtering him and his servants]] by Abigail, ends up dying soon after, likely from a combination of a VillainousBSOD his [[TheAlcoholic his alcoholism]].

to:

* SelfDisposingVillain: Nabal, who, after David is prevented from [[DisproportionateRetribution slaughtering him and his servants]] by Abigail, ends up dying soon after, likely from a combination of a VillainousBSOD his and [[TheAlcoholic his alcoholism]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SelfDisposingVillain: Nabal, who, after David is prevented from [[DisproportionateRetribution slaughtering him and his servants]] by Abigail, ends up dying from a VillainousBSOD.

to:

* SelfDisposingVillain: Nabal, who, after David is prevented from [[DisproportionateRetribution slaughtering him and his servants]] by Abigail, ends up dying soon after, likely from a VillainousBSOD.combination of a VillainousBSOD his [[TheAlcoholic his alcoholism]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SelfDisposingVillain: Nabal, who, after David is prevented from [[DisproportionateRetribution slaughtering him and his servants]] by Abigail, ends up dying from a VillainousBSOD.

Added: 422

Changed: 192

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LetsWaitAWhile: Since soldiers are not allowed to have sex during war time, Uriah refuses to have sex with Bathsheba. David tries to manipulate him into doing so to cover his adultery up, but fails and decides to send him to a certain death.



* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: The Witch of Endor calls up the spirit of Samuel from the grave, and he speaks in a disembodied voice, revealing the disguised Saul's identity and prophesying his defeat. Or did she? Some scholars have observed that the apparition as described would be very easy to fake with the help of a bit of clever ventriloquism [[note]]The Septuagint translation from the 2nd century BC goes so far as to translate "witch" with the Greek word for "ventriloquist"[[/note]], and it wouldn't exactly take supernatural aid to deduce that the disguised man was in fact the king known for being the tallest of all the Israelites. When read with that in mind, the text is actually rather cagey on the point of whether a spirit genuinely appeared. [[BrokenBase Interpreters are divided]] as to what might have really happened.

to:

* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: The Witch of Endor calls up the spirit of Samuel from the grave, and he speaks in a disembodied voice, revealing the disguised Saul's identity and prophesying his defeat. Or did she? Some scholars have observed that the apparition as described would be very easy to fake with the help of a bit of clever ventriloquism [[note]]The Septuagint translation from the 2nd century BC goes so far as to translate "witch" with the Greek word for "ventriloquist"[[/note]], and it wouldn't exactly take supernatural aid to deduce that the disguised man was in fact the king known for being the tallest of all the Israelites. When read with that in mind, the text is actually rather cagey on the point of whether a spirit genuinely appeared. [[BrokenBase Interpreters are divided]] divided as to what might have really happened.



* QuestionableConsent: While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no?

to:

* QuestionableConsent: QuestionableConsent:
**
While David clearly wanted to sleep with Bathsheba, her interest in him is less clear. When the king asks you to come over (and your husband is away at war), how do you say no?

Top