Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / WeirdAlYankovic

Go To

OR

Removed: 3207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
These are just people complaining, not asking about Fridge Logic in the songs.


* Angry White Boy Polka. I usually love his Polka medleys, but whose idea was it to include [[Music/SystemOfADown an Armenian band]] singing about Arab suicide bombers and a band of... Uh... [[Music/RageAgainstTheMachine mixed ethnicity]] fronted by a Mexican ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3dab1jiSiyU covering an Afrika Bambaataa song name checking civil rights leaders?]]'' Isn't that... A bit misleading? That's as unwhite as [[{{Dissimile}} white rice covered by something very unwhite.]]
** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late '90s / early '00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who [[FirstWorldProblems didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about.]] The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included some acts that didn't quite fit the description.
** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' the Suburbs," which was a direct attack at Music/{{Korn}}.
* Music/PaulMcCartney disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!
** For one, Al wasn't yet a vegetarian when he first wrote the song. Also, Paul (well-known for his social crusades) is one of ''those'' vegetarians. In fact, I'm pretty sure he went full-on vegan after Linda died.



** Actually, in Japanese culture the rude thing to do is to leave a tip, for some reason. So [[FridgeBrilliance it actually becomes smart]] once you know this. It seems to me that Al was just writing the lyrics off the top of his head for the sake of funny.
* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/ThreeDoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.
** Because the thought never crossed his mind?
** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?
** Because they (or their record label) said "No thanks" when he asked if he could?
** Because his best vocal range isn't low-pitched enough to sound much like their lead singer?
* What is it with the internet's obsession of attributing every single parody song to Weird Al?
** Weird Al has become so synonymous with parody songs (ignoring the fact that he's actually done quite a large number of original songs that aren't outright parodies) that people online subconsciously associate all parody songs with Weird Al. Either that, or some people out there are claiming their own parodies were created by Weird Al in order to piggyback on his popularity.
** It most likely was something that came to light during the birth of online music sharing, and the mp3 format. Back when music sharing was more hand to hand, via mix tapes - artist/track info was seldom written down. However, early file sharing (Napster et.al.) depended on mp3 tag info, so people were pretty much forced to add such info, regardless of whether it was accurate or not. While Weird Al was likely the most notable artist who had songs misattributed to him, it was a fairly common thing where even non-parodies, by lesser known artists, were attributed to more famous artists at the time. Resulting in songs like "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks, commonly being attributed to Alanis Morissette, and "Teenage Dirtbag" by Wheatus, being attributed to Weezer.

to:

** Actually, in Japanese culture the rude thing to do is to leave a tip, for some reason. So [[FridgeBrilliance it actually becomes smart]] once you know this. It seems to me that Al was just writing the lyrics off the top of his head for the sake of funny.
* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/ThreeDoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.
** Because the thought never crossed his mind?
** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?
** Because they (or their record label) said "No thanks" when he asked if he could?
** Because his best vocal range isn't low-pitched enough to sound much like their lead singer?
* What is it with the internet's obsession of attributing every single parody song to Weird Al?
** Weird Al has become so synonymous with parody songs (ignoring the fact that he's actually done quite a large number of original songs that aren't outright parodies) that people online subconsciously associate all parody songs with Weird Al. Either that, or some people out there are claiming their own parodies were created by Weird Al in order to piggyback on his popularity.
** It most likely was something that came to light during the birth of online music sharing, and the mp3 format. Back when music sharing was more hand to hand, via mix tapes - artist/track info was seldom written down. However, early file sharing (Napster et.al.) depended on mp3 tag info, so people were pretty much forced to add such info, regardless of whether it was accurate or not. While Weird Al was likely the most notable artist who had songs misattributed to him, it was a fairly common thing where even non-parodies, by lesser known artists, were attributed to more famous artists at the time. Resulting in songs like "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks, commonly being attributed to Alanis Morissette, and "Teenage Dirtbag" by Wheatus, being attributed to Weezer.
funny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Weird Al has become so synonymous with parody songs (ignoring the fact that he's actually done quite a large number of original songs that aren't outright parodies) that people online subconsciously associate all parody songs with Weird Al. Either that, or some people out there are claiming their own parodies were created by Weird Al in order to piggyback on his popularity.

to:

** Weird Al has become so synonymous with parody songs (ignoring the fact that he's actually done quite a large number of original songs that aren't outright parodies) that people online subconsciously associate all parody songs with Weird Al. Either that, or some people out there are claiming their own parodies were created by Weird Al in order to piggyback on his popularity.popularity.
**It most likely was something that came to light during the birth of online music sharing, and the mp3 format. Back when music sharing was more hand to hand, via mix tapes - artist/track info was seldom written down. However, early file sharing (Napster et.al.) depended on mp3 tag info, so people were pretty much forced to add such info, regardless of whether it was accurate or not. While Weird Al was likely the most notable artist who had songs misattributed to him, it was a fairly common thing where even non-parodies, by lesser known artists, were attributed to more famous artists at the time. Resulting in songs like "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks, commonly being attributed to Alanis Morissette, and "Teenage Dirtbag" by Wheatus, being attributed to Weezer.

Added: 177

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?

to:

*** ** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?songs?
** Because they (or their record label) said "No thanks" when he asked if he could?
** Because his best vocal range isn't low-pitched enough to sound much like their lead singer?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What is it with the internet's obsession of attributing every single parody song to Weird Al?

to:

* What is it with the internet's obsession of attributing every single parody song to Weird Al?Al?
** Weird Al has become so synonymous with parody songs (ignoring the fact that he's actually done quite a large number of original songs that aren't outright parodies) that people online subconsciously associate all parody songs with Weird Al. Either that, or some people out there are claiming their own parodies were created by Weird Al in order to piggyback on his popularity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?

to:

*** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?songs?
* What is it with the internet's obsession of attributing every single parody song to Weird Al?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Angry White Boy Polka. I usually love his Polka medleys, but whose idea was it to include [[SystemOfADown an Armenian band]] singing about Arab suicide bombers and a band of... uh... [[RageAgainstTheMachine mixed ethnicity]] fronted by a Mexican ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3dab1jiSiyU covering an Afrika Bambaataa song namechecking civil rights leaders?]]'' Isn't that... a bit misleading? That's as unwhite as [[DisSimile white rice covered by something very unwhite]].
** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who [[FirstWorldProblems didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about]]. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included some acts that didn't quite fit the description.
** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs," which was a direct attack at Music/{{Korn}}.
* Paul [=McCartney=] disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!

to:

* Angry White Boy Polka. I usually love his Polka medleys, but whose idea was it to include [[SystemOfADown [[Music/SystemOfADown an Armenian band]] singing about Arab suicide bombers and a band of... uh... [[RageAgainstTheMachine Uh... [[Music/RageAgainstTheMachine mixed ethnicity]] fronted by a Mexican ''[[http://www.''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3dab1jiSiyU covering an Afrika Bambaataa song namechecking name checking civil rights leaders?]]'' Isn't that... a A bit misleading? That's as unwhite as [[DisSimile [[{{Dissimile}} white rice covered by something very unwhite]].
unwhite.]]
** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s '90s / early '00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who [[FirstWorldProblems didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about]]. about.]] The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included some acts that didn't quite fit the description.
** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The the Suburbs," which was a direct attack at Music/{{Korn}}.
* Paul [=McCartney=] Music/PaulMcCartney disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!



* Why does "Dare to be Stupid" have the line "You can eat a bunch of sushi and forget to leave a tip"? That would be rude, to be certain, but not really stupid.

to:

* Why does "Dare to be Be Stupid" have the line line: "You can eat a bunch of sushi and forget to leave a tip"? tip?" That would be rude, to be certain, but not really stupid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because the thought never crossed his mind?

to:

** Because the thought never crossed his mind?mind?
*** Because he couldn't come up with a good way to either parody or adapt one of their songs?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, in Japanese culture the rude thing to do is to leave a tip, for some reason. So [[FridgeBrilliance it actually becomes smart]] once you know this. It seems to me that Al was just writing the lyrics off the top of his head for the sake of funny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/ThreeDoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.

to:

* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/ThreeDoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.them.
** Because the thought never crossed his mind?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/3DoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.

to:

* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/3DoorsDown Music/ThreeDoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It could also be that the stupid part isn't the lack of a tip itself but instead the "forgetting" part.

to:

** It could also be that the stupid part isn't the lack of a tip itself but instead the "forgetting" part.part.
* Why, exactly, did Weird Al never do a parody of a Music/3DoorsDown song? Sure they're (relatively) obscure now, but from around 1999-2005ish you almost had to go out of your way to avoid them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later in the album.

to:

** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later in the album.Suburbs," which was a direct attack at Music/{{Korn}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More no-tip sushi


** Because next time you go in there, they might just remember you as a bad tipper, and not be quite so careful to give you fresh sushi, I'm guessing.

to:

** Because next time you go in there, they might just remember you as a bad tipper, and not be quite so careful to give you fresh sushi, I'm guessing.guessing.
** It could also be that the stupid part isn't the lack of a tip itself but instead the "forgetting" part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No-tip sushi


* Why does "Dare to be Stupid" have the line "You can eat a bunch of sushi and forget to leave a tip"? That would be rude, to be certain, but not really stupid.

to:

* Why does "Dare to be Stupid" have the line "You can eat a bunch of sushi and forget to leave a tip"? That would be rude, to be certain, but not really stupid.stupid.
** Because next time you go in there, they might just remember you as a bad tipper, and not be quite so careful to give you fresh sushi, I'm guessing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For one, Al wasn't yet a vegetarian when he first wrote the song. Also, Paul (well-known for his social crusades) is one of ''those'' vegetarians. In fact, I'm pretty sure he went full-on vegan after Linda died.

to:

** For one, Al wasn't yet a vegetarian when he first wrote the song. Also, Paul (well-known for his social crusades) is one of ''those'' vegetarians. In fact, I'm pretty sure he went full-on vegan after Linda died.died.
* Why does "Dare to be Stupid" have the line "You can eat a bunch of sushi and forget to leave a tip"? That would be rude, to be certain, but not really stupid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included some acts that didn't quite fit the description.

to:

** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who [[FirstWorldProblems didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about.about]]. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included some acts that didn't quite fit the description.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included [[Music/SystemOfADown some acts]] [[Music/KORN of higher regard]].

to:

** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included [[Music/SystemOfADown some acts]] [[Music/KORN of higher regard]].acts that didn't quite fit the description.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included [[Music/SystemOfADown some acts]] [[Music/Korn of higher regard]].

to:

** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The title isn't so much a reference to the musicians as much as the fad, which, sadly included [[Music/SystemOfADown some acts]] [[Music/Korn [[Music/KORN of higher regard]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The point isn't the whiteness of the ''singers'', its the whiteness of the ''fans''.

to:

** "Angry White Boy" is a derogatory term for late 90s/early 00s nü metal generally referring to how the only people who liked it were privileged white kids who didn't really have anything to be genuinely mad about. The point title isn't so much a reference to the whiteness of musicians as much as the ''singers'', its the whiteness fad, which, sadly included [[Music/SystemOfADown some acts]] [[Music/Korn of the ''fans''.higher regard]].

Added: 214

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Paul McCartney disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because.... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!

to:

* Paul McCartney [=McCartney=] disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because.... because... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!too!
** For one, Al wasn't yet a vegetarian when he first wrote the song. Also, Paul (well-known for his social crusades) is one of ''those'' vegetarians. In fact, I'm pretty sure he went full-on vegan after Linda died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later in the album.

to:

** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later in the album.album.
* Paul McCartney disapproved of Weird Al's "Live and Let Die" spoof "Chicken Pot Pie" because.... Paul is a vegetarian? What sense does that make? Weird Al is a vegetarian too!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later on the album.

to:

** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later on in the album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later on the album.

to:

** It's worth pointing out that Al did this polka around the same time that he worked with BenFolds Music/BenFolds on "Rockin' The Suburbs". Indeed, his own Ben Folds-assisted style parody is three songs later on the album.

Top