Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / RobinHoodPrinceOfThieves

Go To




to:

*** And it mostly seems to be the ambush, it's not like she's busting out kung-fu moves in her fight with Robin, she's just got a knife held on him at first, manages to wrestle around with him a bit since she's already at close range, then cheap shots him because she's conveniently in position to do so.

Added DiffLines:

*** Had not considered this, honestly. I suspect his comment about 'seeing it done on horses' was meant to confirm a C-section. But can confirm that a repositioning (external cephalic version) is possible and could certainly work.


*** There's nothing to say he actually used the needle and thread - he could have just been asking for it in case there was a tear around the womb and she started bleeding heavily.

to:

*** There's nothing to say he actually used the needle and thread - he could have just been asking for it in case there was a tear around the womb cervix and she started bleeding heavily.

Added DiffLines:

*** There's nothing to say he actually used the needle and thread - he could have just been asking for it in case there was a tear around the womb and she started bleeding heavily.


How does Marian fight Robin to a standstill in her first scene, then turn into a NeutralFemale when captured by the Sheriff? That inconsistency always bothered me.
* It seems pretty simple to me. Against Robin, she's armed, armored, and attacks him from ambush. With the Sheriff, she's unarmed, and wearing no more armor than a nice dress.

to:

* How does Marian fight Robin to a standstill in her first scene, then turn into a NeutralFemale when captured by the Sheriff? That inconsistency always bothered me.
* ** It seems pretty simple to me. Against Robin, she's armed, armored, and attacks him from ambush. With the Sheriff, she's unarmed, and wearing no more armor than a nice dress.


Added DiffLines:

** If all he did was reposition the kid, why would he have asked Marian for needle and thread?

Added DiffLines:

**Fanny was far too spry in the days afterward to have had any sort of surgery. Far more likely Azeem manually repositioned the child or, less likely, he gave Fanny an episiotomy.

Added DiffLines:

** What was done to Macduff's mother to make Macduff a man not of woman born? It was a C-section! A medieval C-section!

Added DiffLines:


* What did Azeem do to Fanny?



to:

* It seems pretty simple to me. Against Robin, she's armed, armored, and attacks him from ambush. With the Sheriff, she's unarmed, and wearing no more armor than a nice dress.


How does Marian fight Robin to a standstill in her first scene, then turn into a NeutralFemale when captured by the Sheriff? That inconsistency always bothered me.

to:

How does Marian fight Robin to a standstill in her first scene, then turn into a NeutralFemale when captured by the Sheriff? That inconsistency always bothered me.me.

----

Added DiffLines:

How does Marian fight Robin to a standstill in her first scene, then turn into a NeutralFemale when captured by the Sheriff? That inconsistency always bothered me.

Showing 12 edit(s) of 12

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report