Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / TheRiseOfSkywalker

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* We see Rey, and later Ben, using the Force to heal others. Palpatine can do the same trick, except he doesn't ''give'' of his life force, he ''takes'' it from others to sustain himself, not unlike one fan theory as to how Darth Vader ended up surviving his injuries while Padme "lost the will to live."

to:

* We see Rey, and later Ben, using the Force to heal others. Palpatine can do the same trick, except he doesn't ''give'' of his life force, he ''takes'' it from others to sustain himself, not unlike one fan theory as to how Darth Vader ended up surviving his injuries while Padme "lost the will to live."
live".



* The death of General Hux is constantly criticized as one of the most silly and corniest from the saga and a disservice for who could have been a great villain in the sequel trilogy, first appearing in ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' as a serious bad guy and then reduced to a comic relief ButtMonkey in ''Film/TheLastJedi''. However, this was a fitting and well-deserved way to finish Hux's story arc from a certain point of view: for someone who had high ambitions for powers and believing himself to be destined to greatness, no matter how many should have to die to achieve his goals, Hux ended up suffering an indignant and ridiculous death.

to:

* The death of General Hux is constantly criticized as one of the most silly and corniest from the saga and a disservice for who could have been a great villain in the sequel trilogy, first appearing in ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' as a serious bad guy and then reduced to a comic relief ButtMonkey in ''Film/TheLastJedi''. However, this was a fitting and well-deserved way to finish Hux's story arc from a certain point of view: for someone who had high ambitions for powers and believing himself to be destined to greatness, no matter how many should have to die to achieve his goals, Hux ended up suffering an indignant indignant, undignified and ridiculous death.



* Palpatine's return gets only a HandWave explanation in the film but makes sense: Force users can retain individual consciousness within the Force, and even manifest as Force Ghosts. Only Jedi have been seen to do so, perhaps because an existence of enlightenment and wisdom within the Force is one only a Jedi would want. If a Sith achieved that power, motivated by hate and anger and ambition, would his Force Ghost content itself with acting as a mentor to others? No, the first thing a Sith Ghost would do is go to its followers and tell them to start cloning a replacement body immediately. Palpatine always seemed a level above the few other Sith seen in the films, willing to study both sides of the Force, it's in character that he would be prepared to ensure his immortality in that way, and then following up with the GrandTheftMe he intends for Rey.

to:

* Palpatine's return gets only a HandWave explanation in the film but makes sense: Force users can retain individual consciousness within the Force, and even manifest as Force Ghosts. Only Jedi have been seen to do so, perhaps because an existence of enlightenment and wisdom within the Force is one only a Jedi would want. If a Sith achieved that power, motivated by hate and hate, anger and ambition, would his Force Ghost content itself with acting as a mentor to others? No, the first thing a Sith Ghost would do is go to its followers and tell them to start cloning a replacement body immediately. Palpatine always seemed a level above the few other Sith seen in the films, willing to study both sides of the Force, it's in character that he would be prepared to ensure his immortality in that way, and then following up with the GrandTheftMe he intends for Rey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Why did Finn shoot his leg? He wanted the man who took him and so many other people from their families dead.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!FridgeBrilliance :

to:

!!FridgeBrilliance :!!FridgeBrilliance:



** 'Luke' comes from 'Lucius', meaning 'bright one,' and 'Rey' is an alternate spelling of 'ray', as in 'ray of light', continuing the [[MeaningfulName MeaningfulNames]] ''Star Wars'' characters are sometimes given.

to:

** 'Luke' comes from 'Lucius', meaning 'bright one,' and 'Rey' is an alternate spelling of 'ray', as in 'ray of light', continuing the [[MeaningfulName MeaningfulNames]] {{Meaningful Name}}s ''Star Wars'' characters are sometimes given.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In some of the books, such as ''From A Certain Point of View'', it is mentioned that many of the Rebel forces are Imperial defectors, [[NotWhatISignedOnFor particularly after the destruction of Alderaan.]] Indeed, we've seen Imperial defectors in the OT as well, with [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi General Crix Madine]] being a former Imperial officer and Princess Leia herself being a member of the Imperial Senate until it was dissolved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Finn defected from the First Order, not Poe.


* The existence of Jannah and her team help answer the question of whether it is right for our heroes to have killed countless Imperials who were only doing their jobs. Like Poe, Jannah defected, showing that other Imperials had the same choice. (This is a gross simplification but at least it advances the discussion.)

to:

* The existence of Jannah and her team help answer the question of whether it is right for our heroes to have killed countless Imperials who were only doing their jobs. Like Poe, Finn, Jannah defected, showing that other Imperials had the same choice. (This is a gross simplification but at least it advances the discussion.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** WordOfGod is the page in ComicBook/DarthVaderDarkLordOfTheSith interpreted as confirmation [[https://screenrant.com/star-wars-anakin-father-emperor/2/ "Palpatine is Anakin's father"]] did not depict a direct connection between [[https://mobile.twitter.com/missingwords/status/1208973509134671872?s=19 Palpatine and Anakin's birth]] and that "the Dark Side is not a reliable narrator." Maybe nobody has to worry about accidental incest? GodNeverSaidThat Palpatine definitively did not create Anakin (and not that he did, either). Anakin's conception remains a StarWars mystery.

to:

** WordOfGod is the page in ComicBook/DarthVaderDarkLordOfTheSith interpreted as confirmation [[https://screenrant.com/star-wars-anakin-father-emperor/2/ "Palpatine is Anakin's father"]] did not depict a direct connection between [[https://mobile.twitter.com/missingwords/status/1208973509134671872?s=19 Palpatine and Anakin's birth]] and that "the Dark Side is not a reliable narrator." Maybe nobody has to worry about accidental incest? GodNeverSaidThat Palpatine definitively did not create Anakin (and not that he did, either). Anakin's conception remains a StarWars Franchise/StarWars mystery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The title "The Rise of Skywalker" is a subtle callback to ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' - after all, in that movie, Anakin Skywalker's original personality and light-side allegiance returned from decades of being Darth Vader, so one might easily say that Skywalker rose within Vader. Also, the title of the film [[ThemeNaming follows the traditional]] "R of the X" pattern the previous trilogy-enders used -- ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'', ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' and finally ''Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker''. Only the "the" has changed place.

to:

* The title "The Rise of Skywalker" "Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker" is a subtle callback to ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' - after all, in that movie, Anakin Skywalker's original personality and light-side allegiance returned from decades of being Darth Vader, so one might easily say that Skywalker rose within Vader. Also, the title of the film [[ThemeNaming follows the traditional]] "R of the X" pattern the previous trilogy-enders used -- ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'', ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' and finally ''Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker''. Only the "the" has changed place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The idea that Palpatine's mental state has been compromised may also be reflected in his reliance on Sith lightning in the final fight; despite boasting that he is "all the Sith", his body is currently so damaged that he can't focus on his full range of abilities, and is focusing on maintaining a reasonably stable mental state so that he isn't reduced to a drooling heap on the floor as his brain shuts down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Anakin could still be the Chosen One for three reasons:

to:

** Anakin could still be the Chosen One for three four reasons:




to:

### Even Anakin himself admitted as much as he passed the mantle on to Rey ("Bring balance to the Force, as I did.").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* R2 just so happening to have a perfect copy of C-3P0's memory seems like a bit of an AssPull until you remember poor R2 already lost his best friend once before. While it was PlayedForLaughs at the end of ''Revenge of the Sith'', C-3P0 having his entire memory wiped means the person who R2 had been closest with for several years was effectively dead. While it's clear they were eventually able to reforge a bond, he was likely horrified at the thought that his best friend could be taken away at anytime just by the whim of someone ordering his memory wiped clean yet again. He probably records a copy of C-3P0's memory any moment they have some downtime to [[CrazyPrepared be prepared]] for just such a situation as what happens in the movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Palpatine had succeeded in stealing Rey's body, then he would have ended up with a womb. And if he had a womb, that means that he now has the ability to impregnate himself every time he is close to death and just transfer his mind to his newborn child. And if this is true then logically, if he just used genetic engineering to ensure that the child was female, then he would effectively have immortality as he could just repeat the trick ad-infinitum.

to:

* If Palpatine had succeeded in stealing Rey's body, then he would have ended up with a womb. And if he had a womb, that means that he now has the ability to impregnate himself every time he is close to death and just transfer his mind to his newborn child. And if this is true then logically, if he just used genetic engineering to ensure that the child was female, then he would effectively have immortality as he could just repeat the trick ad-infinitum.ad-infinitum.

*The existence of the Xyston-Class means that weapons capable of making an EarthShatteringKaboom are no longer giant space stations and star-sucking planet-structures. It is entirely possible to make a massive fleet of ships capable of killing planets. Knowledge that such a thing is possible will spread, and Xyston-Class equivalent ships will be sought by any warlike power with resources to spare. And nobody seems willing or able to try and stop or at least regulate the oncoming proliferation. The nature of warfare in the Galaxy is irrevocably changed, more terrible than ever before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Or "All the Jedi" was literal and every one that existed came to support Rey with their power, whether they were dead or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Star Destroyers with planet destroying lasers finally get rid of most of the Impractical of the AwesomeButImpractical of the Death Stars and Starkiller Base. By miniaturizing to such an extent the weapon is far more mobile than the old Death Stars while Starkiller Base can't move at all. The superweapon reaches the point where they can be mass produced and thus are plentiful. The weapon also is a planet destroyer, but only is powerful enough to destroy the crust of the target planet. This is far more than enough to kill any life on it, but unlike it's predecessors which obliterates planets completely it leaves the planet itself intact and thus still able to be strip mined for resources. Since they're mounted on Star Destroyers they also possess the ability for more surgical strikes if need be. Wherever it goes from here on out, the future of the Star Wars galaxy better hope nobody with the means ever locates the designs for these weapons and they are never recreated, because that means any power mad lunatic with the bank can blow up planets now.

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While Rey being a Palpatine might be a ShockingSwerve, keep in mind that her life story is still part of ''Skywalker Saga''. So, imagine if her being a nobody remains unchanged, imagine that you watch Skywalker Saga chronologically from Anakin's childhood, Palpatine's manipulation of him, Anakin being redeemed by his son and died, his son and daughter got old and died, and then their family saga is finished by some random girl whose only connection to the Skywalkers is being Luke and Leia's apprentice. That could be somewhat of a letdown, from a certain point of view. On the other hand, making Rey a Palpatine got the saga to end in the most unexpected way because... who would've thought that the Skywalker Saga would be finished by a grandchild of the ''BigBad''?

to:

* While Rey being a Palpatine might be a ShockingSwerve, shocker, keep in mind that her life story is still part of ''Skywalker Saga''. So, imagine if her being a nobody remains unchanged, imagine that you watch Skywalker Saga chronologically from Anakin's childhood, Palpatine's manipulation of him, Anakin being redeemed by his son and died, his son and daughter got old and died, and then their family saga is finished by some random girl whose only connection to the Skywalkers is being Luke and Leia's apprentice. That could be somewhat of a letdown, from a certain point of view. On the other hand, making Rey a Palpatine got the saga to end in the most unexpected way because... who would've thought that the Skywalker Saga would be finished by a grandchild of the ''BigBad''?



* Much was made in the fandom about Rey "copying" Force abilities used on her by Kylo Ren in ''Film/TheForceAwakens''. He tries to Mind Probe her, she learns the JediMindTrick; he tries to pull Anakin's lightsaber to his hand, she pulls it to hers; he channels the Force to drive her back with his lightsaber, she channels the Force to drive him back with her lightsaber. Now, come this film, Rey uses the Force to heal and revive Kylo Ren. . . then Ben Solo later uses the Force to revive and heal Rey. Kylo Ren inadvertently taught Rey her first Force tricks, she inadvertently teaches Ben Solo his last.

to:

* Much was made in the fandom about Rey "copying" Force abilities used on her by Kylo Ren in ''Film/TheForceAwakens''. He tries to Mind Probe her, she learns the JediMindTrick; he tries to pull Anakin's lightsaber to his hand, she pulls it to hers; he channels the Force to drive her back with his lightsaber, she channels the Force to drive him back with her lightsaber. Now, come this film, Rey uses the Force to heal and revive Kylo Ren. . .Ren... then Ben Solo later uses the Force to revive and heal Rey. Kylo Ren inadvertently taught Rey her first Force tricks, she inadvertently teaches Ben Solo his last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Leia realising Rey's lineage but keeping it a secret makes perfect sense: she knows exactly what it would do to Rey if the truth were discovered, but it's exactly what happened to ''her''. ''Literature/StarWarsBloodline'', a prequel nove to the Sequel Trilogy, shows that when Leia's relation to Darth Vader became public knowledge, it not only ruined ''her'' life, but her family's lives as well. As far as Leia knew, Palpatine was dead and staying that way, so what point would there be in forcing that AwfulTruth upon the girl?

to:

* Leia realising Rey's lineage but keeping it a secret makes perfect sense: she knows exactly what it would do to Rey if the truth were discovered, but it's exactly what happened to ''her''. ''Literature/StarWarsBloodline'', a prequel nove novel to the Sequel Trilogy, shows that when Leia's relation to Darth Vader became public knowledge, it not only ruined ''her'' life, but her family's lives as well. As far as Leia knew, Palpatine was dead and staying that way, so what point would there be in forcing that AwfulTruth upon the girl?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In their final fight, Rey starts unknowingly shifting into the Dark Side by fighting in blind rage, while Ben starts unknowingly shifting into the Light Side by fighting composedly and calmly and ''not'' out of rage for the first time in the series. It takes Rey stabbing Ben to realize she has fallen to the Dark Side, and it takes Ben getting stabbed to realize he can return to the Light Side.

to:

* In their final fight, Rey starts unknowingly shifting into the Dark Side by fighting in blind rage, while Ben starts unknowingly shifting into the Light Side by fighting composedly and calmly and ''not'' out of rage for the first time in the series. It takes Rey stabbing Ben to realize she has fallen she's falling to the Dark Side, and it takes Ben getting stabbed to realize he can return to the Light Side.




to:

* Kylo has his mask repaired -- but it's still noticeably fractured. Kinda like how Kylo himself is fracturing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* One of the main reasons why Anakin joined the dark side is to prevent people from dying. Ben Solo's last act was to revive Rey, so it could be said that he finished what Darth Vader started.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This may also be a CallBack to ''Revenge of the Sith'' when Mace Windu reflected Palpatine's Force lightning and disfigured the Sith Lord and severely weakening him. This was the first real moment where Palpatine was truly at someone else's mercy and would have died by Windu's blade had Anakin not intervened. Rey makes sure with her time it sticks.

Changed: 532

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Leia realising Rey's lineage but keeping it a secret makes perfect sense: she knows exactly what it would do to Rey if the truth were discovered, but it's exactly what happened to ''her''. ''Literature/StarWarsBloodline'', a prequel nove to the Sequel Trilogy, shows that when Leia's relation to Darth Vader became public knowledge, it not only ruined ''her'' life, but her family's lives as well. As far as Leia knew, Palpatine was dead and staying that way, so what point would there be in forcing that AwfulTruth upon the girl?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For that matter, their final battle in this film is reminiscent in tone to Anakin Skywalker versus Obi-Wan Kenobi in ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith''. Anakin went all-out on Obi-Wan, demonstrating improved skill and a deeper connection to the Force (the Dark Side) than ever before, and Obi-Wan continuously fell back before him... not because he was outmatched, but because he was more in tune with the Force and letting it decide when, where, and how it would all end. Now, Rey is going all-out, demonstrating vastly improved skill and a deeper connection to the Force than ever before, and Kylo Ren is letting the battle flow towards its ultimate conclusion. The symbols are the same, the meanings reversed, as happens all the time in ''Star Wars''.

to:

* For that matter, their final battle in this film is reminiscent in tone to Anakin Skywalker versus Obi-Wan Kenobi in ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith''. Anakin went all-out on Obi-Wan, demonstrating improved skill and a deeper connection to the Force (the Dark Side) than ever before, and Obi-Wan continuously fell back before him... not because he was outmatched, but because he was more in tune with the Force and letting it decide when, where, and how it would all end. Now, Rey is going all-out, demonstrating vastly improved skill and a deeper connection to the Force than ever before, and Kylo Ren is letting the battle flow towards its ultimate conclusion. The symbols are the same, the meanings reversed, as happens all the time in ''Star Wars''.
Wars''. (Meaning it's likely no conicidence the Mustafar duel is surrounded by fire, while the Kef Bir duel is surrounded by water.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Palpatine's Plan: It seems odd that Palpatine "created" Snoke when some of Snoke's actions in the previous films seem counter to Palpatine's goals in this film. But Palpatine was a master at four things: long-term planning, farseeing, BatmanGambit and XanatosSpeedChess. Snoke's insistence that Ren kill Rey in the ''The Last Jedi''. Snoke had been pressing Ren's buttons all movie, but in Palpatine's endgame this wasn't to secure his loyalty, it was to encourage his betrayal. By constantly belittling Ren as basically "a Darth Vader wannabe fanboy," Snoke actually pushes Ren into thinking that maybe just being the next Darth Vader is aiming too low, so Ren does what Vader never did: kill his master and take power for himself. Driving Ren deeper into the Dark Side and setting him up as a more powerful and capable Dragon when Palpatine chooses to reveal himself. Setting up the connection between Ren and Rey (assuming Snoke[=/=]Palpatine wasn't lying about that and Palpatine was surprised by the ''strength'' of their bond, not its existence) forged an ''attachment'' between Ren and Rey that meant Rey was never really in danger of being killed by him (learned that one from Anakin Skywalker, he did). And the possible outcomes of ''The Last Jedi''[='=]s Throne Room Scene: Best Case Scenario (for Palpatine) is that Ren turns Rey to the Dark Side, making her someone who wouldn't hesitate to kill Palpatine for the promise of unlimited power (thus letting Palpatine possess her as was his plan all along). Worst case, Rey leaves an emotionally-compromised, powerful young Force-sensitive with limited options for training and discipline, leaving her vulnerable to the seduction of the Dark Side. . . basically exactly where she is when we meet her in ''Rise''. Someone who wouldn't hesistate to strike down Palpatine in righteous anger -- but still anger, letting Palpatine possess her, again exactly as he planned all along. Really, things only go off the rails for Palpatine's plan because of the unexpected double-team of Leia and Rey redeeming Ben Solo. . . and Palpatine explaining his plan to Rey, where if he'd kept his mouth shut she would have killed him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The death of General Hux is constantly criticized as one of the most silly and corniest from the saga and a disservice for who could have been a great villain in the sequel trilogy, first appearing in ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' as a serious bad guy and then reduced to a comic relief ButtMonkey in ''Film/TheLastJedi''. However, this was a fitting and well-deserved way to finish Hux's story arc: for someone who had high ambitions for powers and believing himself to be destined to greatness, no matter how many should have to die to achieve his goals, Hux ended up suffering an indignant and ridiculous death.

to:

* The death of General Hux is constantly criticized as one of the most silly and corniest from the saga and a disservice for who could have been a great villain in the sequel trilogy, first appearing in ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' as a serious bad guy and then reduced to a comic relief ButtMonkey in ''Film/TheLastJedi''. However, this was a fitting and well-deserved way to finish Hux's story arc: arc from a certain point of view: for someone who had high ambitions for powers and believing himself to be destined to greatness, no matter how many should have to die to achieve his goals, Hux ended up suffering an indignant and ridiculous death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The death of General Hux is constantly criticized as one of the most silly and corniest from the saga and a disservice for who could have been a great villain in the sequel trilogy, first appearing in ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' as a serious bad guy and then reduced to a comic relief ButtMonkey in ''Film/TheLastJedi''. However, this was a fitting and well-deserved way to finish Hux's story arc: for someone who had high ambitions for powers and believing himself to be destined to greatness, no matter how many should have to die to achieve his goals, Hux ended up suffering an indignant and ridiculous death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Building on that point, it's been noted that it was rather stupid of him to announce his return to the entire galaxy, when he could have easily won the entire saga just by keeping quiet and launching his attack, thus catching everyone off guard. But as Luke had said in Return of the Jedi, "Your overconfidence is your weakness." Given he's proven himself to be a skilled manipulator and strategist who successfully played the entire galaxy for chumps multiple times, he thinks he's already won no matter the outcome. After all, "Everything that has transpired has gone according to MY design." As far as he's concerned, the odds are in his favor and no one can stand to them. Too bad he didn't learn that lesson the first time around...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* By the time Ben makes it to Palpatine's throne room, he's already pretty badly injured--the crash-landing into the pit alone would have been enough to kill an ordinary human, and he takes a good beating from the Knights of Ren before Rey gets him a lightsaber. Then Palpatine literally tosses him away, and we see him brutally slam into the edge of the cliff before falling down a ravine. He would have horrific internal injuries at minimum by the time he was climbing out of the ravine--which, from the looks of it, he did with a broken leg on top of everything else. By the time he made it to Rey, most likely the Force was the only thing holding him together. It's a wonder he survived as long as he did.

to:

* By the time Ben makes it to Palpatine's throne room, he's already pretty badly injured--the crash-landing into the pit alone would have been enough to kill an ordinary human, and he takes a good beating from the Knights of Ren before Rey gets him a lightsaber. Then Palpatine literally tosses him away, and we see him brutally slam into the edge of the cliff before falling down a ravine. He would have horrific internal injuries at minimum by the time he was climbing out of the ravine--which, from the looks of it, he did with a broken leg on top of everything else. By the time he made it to Rey, most likely the Force was the only thing holding him together. It's a wonder he survived as long as he did.did.

* If Palpatine had succeeded in stealing Rey's body, then he would have ended up with a womb. And if he had a womb, that means that he now has the ability to impregnate himself every time he is close to death and just transfer his mind to his newborn child. And if this is true then logically, if he just used genetic engineering to ensure that the child was female, then he would effectively have immortality as he could just repeat the trick ad-infinitum.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rey’s Father could be an unaltered clone of Palpatine. We know Palpatine has Dooku visit Kamino. Who's say as Chancellor, he paid for an unaltered clone of himself.

to:

** Rey’s Father could be an unaltered clone of Palpatine. We know Palpatine has had Dooku visit Kamino. Who's say as Chancellor, he paid for an unaltered clone of himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Note that Palpatine did the same thing in ROTJ: he kept telling Luke that giving into hate and trying to kill him (or later killing Vader ) would cause him to fall to the Dark Side, which kept reminding Luke to reject that path whereas if he'd just kept his mouth shut, the odds of Luke taking that step would have been far higher. In other words, when he has his primary opponent face to face and he's on the verge of total victory, Palpatine can't help gloating. And he doesn't learn from the first time that didn't work out for him.

to:

** Note that Palpatine did the same thing in ROTJ: he kept telling Luke that giving into hate and trying to kill him (or later killing Vader ) Vader) would cause him to fall to the Dark Side, which kept reminding Luke to reject that path whereas if he'd just kept his mouth shut, the odds of Luke taking that step would have been far higher. In other words, when he has his primary opponent face to face and he's on the verge of total victory, Palpatine can't help gloating. And he doesn't learn from the first time that didn't work out for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What happened to [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse the porgs]] aboard the ''Millennium Falcon''? There were several of them on the ship at the end of ''The Last Jedi'', but they're nowhere to be seen a year later. Considering that the few dozen Resistance survivors were low on supplies and on the run for some time until they established a new base...yeah, maybe those porgs started to look quite tasty...

to:

* What happened to [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse the porgs]] aboard the ''Millennium Falcon''? There were several of them on the ship at the end of ''The Last Jedi'', but they're nowhere to be seen a year later. Considering that the few dozen Resistance survivors were low on supplies and on the run for some time until they established a new base...yeah, maybe those porgs started to look quite tasty...tasty...
* By the time Ben makes it to Palpatine's throne room, he's already pretty badly injured--the crash-landing into the pit alone would have been enough to kill an ordinary human, and he takes a good beating from the Knights of Ren before Rey gets him a lightsaber. Then Palpatine literally tosses him away, and we see him brutally slam into the edge of the cliff before falling down a ravine. He would have horrific internal injuries at minimum by the time he was climbing out of the ravine--which, from the looks of it, he did with a broken leg on top of everything else. By the time he made it to Rey, most likely the Force was the only thing holding him together. It's a wonder he survived as long as he did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarly, for much of the film (and series), Ben Solo is an identity that Kylo Ren has abandoned as part of his past - he has "been Solo."

to:

** *** Similarly, for much of the film (and series), Ben Solo is an identity that Kylo Ren has abandoned as part of his past - he has "been Solo."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Similarly, for much of the film (and series), Ben Solo is an identity that Kylo Ren has abandoned as part of his past - he has "been Solo."

Top