Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / ThePatriot

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: Tavington burning the Martin's farm and killing the wounded Americans. The militia killing surrendering redcoats, much to Gabriel's protests. Later the church burning by the British with Patriot townsfolk inside.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Later on, Benjamin and his militia massacre a British patrol, cutting down even those redcoats trying to surrender, much to Gabriel's [[WhatTheHellHero horror]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhyDontYouJustShootHim: For some reason, Tavington insists on taking Gabriel Martin back to British headquarters to be hanged instead of just shooting him on the spot. This is odd, seeing as he orders all the other continental soldiers he finds at the Martin farm to be to shot right then and there.

to:

* WhyDontYouJustShootHim: For some reason, Tavington insists on taking Gabriel Martin back to British headquarters to be hanged instead of just shooting him on the spot. This is odd, seeing as he orders all the other continental soldiers he finds at the Martin farm to be to shot right then and there. Justified though, as he considers Gabriel to be a spy for carrying colonial dispatches and wants to use the execution [[MakeAnExampleOfThem to set an example]] to dissuade others from doing likewise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving cut Critical Research Failure entry.

Added DiffLines:

* writtenByTheWinners: While the atrocities showed in the movie often did have basis as real events (the war in the South WAS a very barbaric conflict), the movie overemphasized the British atrocities grossly (which were often the result of the Loyalist Americans rather than the redcoats) and forgets many of the equally horrific atrocities committed by the Patriots. Generally, the war in the south was just a bunch of locals using the war as an excuse to settle old scores. And new scores.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrettyLittleHeadshots: John's suicide doesn't seem to leave an exit wound at ''all'' despite being fired right up against his head. Especially odd given this is an R-rated film, so lack of gore to keep the rating down wasn't really an issue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When Benjamin ambushes the patrol to save Gabriel, he shoots a Redcoat in the head while running and from the hip with a pistol from about 30 yards away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TokenEvilTeammate: While the British are inarguably the antagonists of the movie and are portrayed as arrogant snobs, they're also honorable, PunchClockVillain soldiers just fulfilling their duty. Tavington is the exception; his cruelty is repeatedly reprimanded by Cornwallis, and it earns him the scorn and horror of everybody around him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gideon Ploy: Inverted. Benjamin Martin and his men dress up scarecrows as Redcoat officers and hold them at gunpoint within full view of General Cornwallis' camp, specifically to convince Cornwallis that they held a large number of English officers captive so they could exchange the "officers" for Colonial prisoners Cornwallis had. It works, much to Cornwallis' later consternation.

to:

* Gideon Ploy: GideonPloy: Inverted. Benjamin Martin and his men dress up scarecrows as Redcoat officers and hold them at gunpoint within full view of General Cornwallis' camp, specifically to convince Cornwallis that they held a large number of English officers captive so they could exchange the "officers" for Colonial prisoners Cornwallis had. It works, much to Cornwallis' later consternation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Gideon Ploy: Inverted. Benjamin Martin and his men dress up scarecrows as Redcoat officers and hold them at gunpoint within full view of General Cornwallis' camp, specifically to convince Cornwallis that they held a large number of English officers captive so they could exchange the "officers" for Colonial prisoners Cornwallis had. It works, much to Cornwallis' later consternation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EliteMook: The British Dragoon units led by Tavington, which leads the lesser Redcoats in battle, and can be identified by the green stripes on their uniform and headgear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhyDontYouJustShootHim: For some reason, Tavington insists on taking Gabriel Martin back to British headquarters to be hanged instead of just shooting him on the spot. This is odd, seeing as he orders all the other continental soldiers he finds at the Martin farm to be to shot right then and there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Direct link


* UnderlingWithAnFInPR: Colonel Tavington, the field commander of the British dragoons, adopts extremely harsh policies towards the Americans, having wounded enemy soldiers gunned down and setting fire to the homes of non-combatants who sheltered them. General Cornwallis berates Tavington for his savagery, calling it unbecoming of AnOfficerAndAGentleman and reminding him of the King's wishes that there will be a reconciliation with the colonists (their fellow countrymen) after the rebellion is put down. He later rightfully points out that [[CreateYourOwnHero Tavington's cruelty has directly motivated men like Benjamin Martin to take up arms]].

to:

* UnderlingWithAnFInPR: Colonel Tavington, the field commander of the British dragoons, adopts extremely harsh policies towards the Americans, having wounded enemy soldiers gunned down and setting fire to the homes of non-combatants who sheltered them. General Cornwallis berates Tavington for his savagery, calling it unbecoming of AnOfficerAndAGentleman an OfficerAndAGentleman and reminding him of the King's wishes that there will be a reconciliation with the colonists (their fellow countrymen) after the rebellion is put down. He later rightfully points out that [[CreateYourOwnHero Tavington's cruelty has directly motivated men like Benjamin Martin to take up arms]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheWhyWaitCombatant: Colonel Tavington responds with these exact words when Benjamin Martin tells him that he will kill him before the war is over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackFromTheDead/Blooper: John Billings is seen killed in the first Redcoat volley at the climactic Battle of Cowpens. This is several months after he committed suicide.

to:

* BackFromTheDead/Blooper: BackFromTheDead: John Billings is seen killed in the first Redcoat volley at the climactic Battle of Cowpens. This is several months after he committed suicide. Also counts as a {{Blooper}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


-->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' ''(after locking townspeople in a church)'' [[SaltTheEarth Ready to fire the town on your order, sir]].
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' ''(EvilLaugh)'' The town? [[KickTheDog Burn the church]].
-->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' [[EvenEvilHasStandards There's no honor in this]].
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' [[IronicEcho Didn't you say "All those who stand against England deserve to die a traitor's death"?]] Burn the church, Captain.

to:

-->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' ''(after locking townspeople in a church)'' [[SaltTheEarth Ready to fire the town on your order, sir]].
sir.
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' ''(EvilLaugh)'' The town? [[KickTheDog Burn the church]].
church.
-->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' [[EvenEvilHasStandards There's no honor in this]].
this.
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' [[IronicEcho Didn't you say "All those who stand against England deserve to die a traitor's death"?]] death"? Burn the church, Captain.



-->'''Col. Benjamin Martin:''' If [[AxeCrazy the conduct of your officers]] is the measure of a gentleman, I'll take that as a compliment.

to:

-->'''Col. Benjamin Martin:''' If [[AxeCrazy the conduct of your officers]] officers is the measure of a gentleman, I'll take that as a compliment.



** [[spoiler:Near the end of the Battle of Cowpens, a presumably-incapacitated Benjamin Martin watches the battle as he writhes in pain, having been slashed by Tavington's sword. Tavington, who is right behind him, insults Martin by declaring: "[[MeaningfulEcho Kill me before the war is over, will you?]] It appears that you are ''not'' the better man. " Just as Tavington is about to behead Martin, Martin dodges the killing blow and grabs a bayonet to stab Tavington in the stomach. As Tavington falls, Martin holds the bayonet on Tavington's neck responds to his insult by concurring with him, declaring that [[PreMortemOneLiner his]] ''[[PreMortemOneLiner sons]]'' [[PreMortemOneLiner were better men]], right before Martin delivers the killing blow to Tavington]].

to:

** [[spoiler:Near the end of the Battle of Cowpens, a presumably-incapacitated Benjamin Martin watches the battle as he writhes in pain, having been slashed by Tavington's sword. Tavington, who is right behind him, insults Martin by declaring: "[[MeaningfulEcho Kill me before the war is over, will you?]] It appears that you are ''not'' the better man. " Just as Tavington is about to behead Martin, Martin dodges the killing blow and grabs a bayonet to stab Tavington in the stomach. As Tavington falls, Martin holds the bayonet on Tavington's neck responds to his insult by concurring with him, declaring that [[PreMortemOneLiner his]] ''[[PreMortemOneLiner sons]]'' [[PreMortemOneLiner his ''sons'' were better men]], men, right before Martin delivers the killing blow to Tavington]].

Added: 165

Changed: 163

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: The roundshot fired by cannon actually was aimed toward the ground, and the cannonball actually does bounce repeatedly off the ground the way it does in the film.

to:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: AluminumChristmasTrees:
**
The roundshot fired by cannon actually was aimed toward the ground, and the cannonball actually does bounce repeatedly off the ground the way it does in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: No one in the British Army, not even his '''generals''', likes Tavington and were visibly relieved when [[spoiler:Benjamin does him in]].

to:

* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: No one Absolutely '''no one''' in the British Army, not even his '''generals''', likes Tavington and were visibly relieved Army has anything kind to say about Tavington. Cornwallis himself doesn't show any sympathy for him when [[spoiler:Benjamin does him in]].kills him]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The British in general get this, but BigBad Charles Cornwallis definitely does. While in the movie he is still portrayed as a NobleDemon in comparison to Tavington's plain demon, he still holds the colonists in open contempt and disdain. In reality Cornwallis was a Whig who was sympathetic to the colonials, and before the war was an MP who voted on their behalf several times (notably, he was one of only five MPs to vote against the Stamp Act, predicting exactly the hostile response it generated). He was also an effective governor of Ireland and India after the war, effecting major changes in both parts of the British Empire despite his defeat in the Revolution.

to:

** The British in general get this, but BigBad Charles Cornwallis definitely does. While in the movie he is still portrayed as a NobleDemon in comparison to Tavington's plain demon, he still holds the colonists in open contempt and disdain. In reality Cornwallis was a Whig who was sympathetic to the colonials, and before the war was an MP who voted on their behalf several times (notably, he was one of only five MPs [=MP=]s to vote against the Stamp Act, predicting [[CassandraTruth exactly the hostile response it generated).generated]]). He was also an effective governor of Ireland and India after the war, effecting major changes in both parts of the British Empire despite his defeat in the Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The British in general get this, but BigBad Charles Cornwallis definitely does. While in the movie he is still portrayed as a NobleDemon in comparison to Tavington's plain demon, he still holds the colonists in open contempt and disdain. In reality Cornwallis was a Whig who was sympathetic to the colonials, and before the war was an MP who voted on their behalf several times. He was also an effective governor of Ireland and India after the war, effecting major changes in both parts of the British Empire despite his defeat in the Revolution.

to:

** The British in general get this, but BigBad Charles Cornwallis definitely does. While in the movie he is still portrayed as a NobleDemon in comparison to Tavington's plain demon, he still holds the colonists in open contempt and disdain. In reality Cornwallis was a Whig who was sympathetic to the colonials, and before the war was an MP who voted on their behalf several times.times (notably, he was one of only five MPs to vote against the Stamp Act, predicting exactly the hostile response it generated). He was also an effective governor of Ireland and India after the war, effecting major changes in both parts of the British Empire despite his defeat in the Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although Banastre Tarleton, the prototype for Tavington, was a rather nasty individual (to clarify, note his actions at the Waxhaws Massacre[[note]]and even then, it was arguably more his troops' fault than his own[[/note]] and his fervent support of the slave trade as an MP), he was not nearly as bad as the film would have you believe. Many of the things Tavington does, such as locking up villagers inside their church and then setting it and them on fire were based on German war crimes from UsefulNotes/WorldWarII like the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oradour-sur-Glane_massacre Oradour-sur-Glane massacre]] (though the English did do similar things to the Irish during the 1641 rebellion, even if more than 100 years beforehand).

to:

** Although Banastre Tarleton, the prototype for Tavington, was a rather nasty individual (to clarify, note his actions at the Waxhaws Massacre[[note]]and even then, it was arguably more his troops' fault than his own[[/note]] and his fervent support of the slave trade as an MP), he was not nearly as bad as the film would have you believe. Many of the things Tavington does, such as locking up villagers inside their church and then setting it and them on fire were based on German war crimes from UsefulNotes/WorldWarII like the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oradour-sur-Glane_massacre Oradour-sur-Glane massacre]] (though the English did do similar things to the Irish during the 1641 rebellion, rebellion [[note]] as did Irish rebels to English and Scottish settlers [[/note]], even if more than 100 years beforehand).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HonorBeforeReason: The redcoat segment who declares this is "the King's Road" and refuses to stand down despite being outnumbered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel William Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas (Gregory Smith), his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).

to:

This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel William Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas (Gregory Smith), (Creator/GregorySmith), his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Specifically, the timeline that the film tries to present doesn't jive with historical chronology, even though the film also presents these real events both on-screen and through monologue. The film opens in 1776 and conversation at the South Carolina Assembly indicates that the Continentals "expect a Declaration of Independence," so it can be safely assumed that it is June or early July by that point. After Gabriel enlists and parts ways with his family, the audience hears his monologue-by-letter which reveals that Charles Town (modern-day Charleston, SC) fell to the British (12 May 1780) and his best friend "fell at Elizabethtown (part of the Battle of Springfield (23 June 1780))". The following scene with Benjamin and Thomas has Thomas stating that "it's already been two (years)". It's unclear if he means two years since the start of the war or since the levy vote, but either explanation is historically inaccurate. This also makes it difficult to determine just how bad the film's [[NotAllowedToGrowUp Not Allowed To Grow Up]] sin really is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItsPersonalWithTheDragon: General Cornwallis is the highest-ranking British officer opposing the Southern rebels, but American Colonel Benjamin Martin respects Cornwallis' military genius and at one point negotiates his men's release with the General. Martin's real enemy is the vicious Colonel Tavington, the field commander of the Dragoons, who murdered Martin's son and burned down his home.

to:

* ItsPersonalWithTheDragon: General Cornwallis is the highest-ranking British officer opposing the Southern rebels, but American Colonel Benjamin Martin respects Cornwallis' military genius and at one point negotiates his men's release with the General. Martin's real enemy is the vicious Colonel Tavington, the field commander of the Dragoons, who murdered Martin's son and burned down his home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: After Anne Howard and Mrs. Howard sew Gabriel Martin into a bundling bag when he stays the night, Mr. Howard listens nervously at the door. Mrs. Howard says, "Don't worry, I'm a better seamstress than my mother was." Mr. Howard looks mortified and replies, "I hope so!"

to:

%% * GettingCrapPastTheRadar: After Anne Howard GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and Mrs. Howard sew Gabriel Martin into a bundling bag when he stays persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the night, Mr. Howard listens nervously at future, please check the door. Mrs. Howard says, "Don't worry, I'm a better seamstress than my mother was." Mr. Howard looks mortified and replies, "I hope so!"trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.

Added: 226

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Capt Wilkins:''' ''(after locking townspeople in a church)'' [[SaltTheEarth Ready to fire the town on your order, sir]].
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' ''(EvilLaugh)'' The town? Burn the church.

to:

-->'''Capt -->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' ''(after locking townspeople in a church)'' [[SaltTheEarth Ready to fire the town on your order, sir]].
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' ''(EvilLaugh)'' The town? [[KickTheDog Burn the church.church]].
-->'''Capt. Wilkins:''' [[EvenEvilHasStandards There's no honor in this]].
-->'''Col. Tavington:''' [[IronicEcho Didn't you say "All those who stand against England deserve to die a traitor's death"?]] Burn the church, Captain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel William Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).

to:

This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel William Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, Thomas (Gregory Smith), his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).

to:

This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel William Tavington]] (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).

Added: 233

Changed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding writer and actors.


A 2000 war epic set during UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution, directed by Creator/RolandEmmerich and starring Creator/MelGibson, Creator/HeathLedger and Creator/JasonIsaacs.

The movie isn't about the actual Founding Fathers, but is instead about some of the biggest and most brutal engagements that were waged in the Southern colonies, as seen through an [[CallToAgriculture Officer turned Farmer]] turned Officer again. Benjamin Martin (Gibson) is a [[OldShame veteran of the French And Indian War]] who was changed by the horrors he has seen (and committed). South Carolina has just voted to join the war, but Ben decides not to participate in the conflict. His eldest son Gabriel (Ledger) decides to go anyway; he isn't seen again until two years later, when he staggers home, wounded and carrying dispatches between two rebel leaders.

This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel Tavington]] (Isaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).

to:

A ''The Patriot'' is a 2000 war epic set during UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution, directed by Creator/RolandEmmerich and starring Creator/MelGibson, Creator/HeathLedger and Creator/JasonIsaacs.

written by Robert Rodat.

The movie isn't about the actual Founding Fathers, but is instead about some of the biggest and most brutal engagements that were waged in the Southern colonies, as seen through an [[CallToAgriculture Officer turned Farmer]] turned Officer again. Benjamin Martin (Gibson) (Creator/MelGibson) is a [[OldShame veteran of the French And Indian War]] who was changed by the horrors he has seen (and committed). South Carolina has just voted to join the war, but Ben decides not to participate in the conflict. His eldest son Gabriel (Ledger) (Creator/HeathLedger) decides to go anyway; he isn't seen again until two years later, when he staggers home, wounded and carrying dispatches between two rebel leaders.

This is where [[GeneralRipper Colonel Tavington]] (Isaacs) (Creator/JasonIsaacs) comes in. The commander of the elite Green Dragoon forces, Tavington orders the deaths of the rebel wounded, has the Martins' house burned down, and takes Gabriel in as a spy to be hanged. Thomas, his next oldest son, tries to intervene, and gets a bullet in the back for his trouble. This sparks Benjamin Martin's decision to join the Revolution to fight the Redcoats (and to ambush and slaughter the British detachment).


Added DiffLines:

The film also stars Creator/JoelyRichardson as Charlotte Selton, Creator/ChrisCooper as Harry Burwell, Creator/TchekyKaryo as Jean Villeneuve, Creator/ReneAuberjonois as Reverend Oliver and Creator/TomWilkinson as Charles Cornwallis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PsychoSmirk: Tavington's perpetual expression varies between this or a [[PerpetualFrowner snarling grimace]].


Added DiffLines:

-->'''Tavington''': ''[shouting at Martin]'' I remember you, that farm and that stupid little boy! [[RelativeButton Did he die?]] ''(Martin stops in his tracks)'' It's an ugly business, doing one's duty, but just occasionally, it's a real pleasure.

Top